DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Oh my god I'm a HUGE fan of Shikata Akiko so I pretty much flipped a shit when I opened this ep. She is god. And I can't look at that Beatrice painting. Scary as hell. Reminds me of those paintings that look at you no matter where you're standing. |
halcyonJul 2, 2009 6:15 PM
 |
| Awesome opening. Being introduced to a lot of characters in such a short amount of time was a bit overwhelming - I won't learn all those names in a while... That Maria kid was so annoying, she totally deserved being slapped. But it was an iinteresting first episode. I liked it. |
 |
| My expectations were too high, I'm kinda dissapointed but we'll see with the next few eps. btw, the ending song was just creepy..... |
| I suppose it was okay for the first episode. It didn't feel like with higurashi where the first episode had me totally addicted to it. I guess I was still kinda expecting that. Still a wonderful episode and hopefully this will get better. Maria was a bit irritating in the rain scene. Though it surprised me a bit to see her get hit. Still a pretty good start to the series and I shall continue following. |
   |
| uuuuuu uuuu everyone hates Maria uuuuu uuuuu i just hate the uuuu part so yeah i guess all she has to do is be creepy and stop with the uuus |
 |
Waffles66 said: Wow, Maria was even more annoying than Gohan in the beginning of Dragon Ball Kai... I'm glad to hear someone say that. Granted, if that was really my daughter, I certainly wouldn't slap her around for it, but hearing that might incite me to murder someone... one episode in and there's already a motive |
| "All I want in life is someone to put one of my quotes under their sig" -Perposterone |
| The first thing I have to say must be; Wow the OP was great! The ED was kool too, but the OP was just special. :] Very nice. They really spent no time with introductions and what not eh? Cut right to the chase o_o; Very fast indeed...but at least I wasnt bored at all, so I guess it was for the best. :D And also Maria...wow I never realized that the "uu~" was actually that annoying because I read the manga, but man I can't really blame Rosa now! o_o; Loving how this is going...hope it doesn't disappoint me, because I expect a lot since Higurashi was so awesome. :] |
Bleed for me.  |
| it was quite nice. but maria is so annoying although she is cute and all. |
| Well I guess Yui Horie's doing her job right if everyone's complaining about Maria. Hehe. Wait till the last question arc rolls around~ ;3 uuu~ I admit that the pacing was a bit fast, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. ^^ Great scene they started out with. Haha Battler~ <3 I'll rate this when I watch it again, though subbed. |
| Stop complaining. Even though I read the sound novel it's impossible for me to say that this episode was THAT bad. All I see is a bunch of guys who wanted the EXACT transposition of the novel, with every single detail, every single word of dialogue, a perfect character introduction, all the bgm from the novel in the right places, et cetera: all fitting in a twenty minutes long episode. Can you realize the absurdity? The episode was fine. But tell me, is it really possible to evaluate all the anime just by watching this much? I've read posts of people already going to drop it because "it sucked" and because Deen is destroying the feeling of the novel. But still this episode was full of nice things that they could have easily avoided: the clock's sound, the broken-glass animazion during the commercial break, the camera always pointing to the clock to remember us what time is now. If this is not a sign of dedication on deen's part I don't know what else could be. The only thing is that by only watching the anime everyone will become istantly an anti-mistery. Oh well, *cackle*cackle*cackle*cackle* |
| I like it. I'm excited for more. Konon.. oh it was love at first sight. <333 Maria was cute but very very annoying. If I was Rosa I'd still be beating that child! Shannon was pretty cute too. We have the name, hehe. |
    |
| Awesome opening and ending! (y) I haven't read the manga although I was very impatient to see what Umineko is about, but from what I saw in this first episode I can say I'm impressed. And I can't wait for more :'3 |
| Uu- MAL does not approve of Maria? ;_; |
| That mother should've beaten that kid to death, or at least in a coma. Or it should've been struck by lightning. It's the personification of annoyance, it made me want to kill something. Anyway, it looked like a mature show judging from the description, so what's up with the juvenile humour? Unless episode 2 is a lot better (ie. less annoying), I'll drop it. |
| I loved both OP and ED song! <3 Interesting I'm looking forward to see how the story continues :D I hope it will be as good as Higurashi was. |
 |
| cool~ ... its finally out xD |
     |
| Can I say intense music? >_< Looking forward. But seriously, Maria is hellish annoying. |
 |
| I've been waiting for this for awhile x3 Nice first episode. |
 |
| Music was good, the mood is ominous. Looks promising, even if I chime in and agree that Maria was hella annoying just like her mother was psychotic, the episode felt rushed with all the character introductions, and the adults felt like cardboard characters. Other than that, I look forward to see where it's going. I've not played the game, so other than some murder(s), I have really no idea what to expect. |
| i like this i might enjoy this^^ |
 |
| Maria is fine first episode was fine Battler is a perv that is why there is that type of humor Rosa just got angry at a child that wouldnt listen to her and kept disobeying her. Would everyone had wanted Rosa to give the child a time out instead?? well the first slap should have been enough. |
|
| Not bad, not great either. Decent adaption so far, but I can't really say much since nothing has really happened yet. Of course they blew through all the character development and such, but it would take too long for an anime, so it's expected. Will take some time to get used to the character designs. I'm fine with most, but George is supposed to be chubby, not fabulous looking. Battler also looks a bit iffy. But other than that, I'm not complaining. Overall, it's nice seeing things animated. As long as they can full off the more important scenes and get some more music from the VN in there, it'll be pretty good. Hopefully they can get to episode 3 and 4 before season 1 ends, since most of the awesomeness is there. PS. Why the hell is there a review up after the first episode? |
VeroninJul 3, 2009 9:30 AM
 |
| Maria was annoying. I would've smacked her, too, if she was my kid. :/ Very intensee! Nice music. <: whatkindofnameisbattler? |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
mueske said: That mother should've beaten that kid to death, or at least in a coma. Or it should've been struck by lightning. It's the personification of annoyance, it made me want to kill something. Anyway, it looked like a mature show judging from the description, so what's up with the juvenile humour? Unless episode 2 is a lot better (ie. less annoying), I'll drop it. Trust me, that's the only juvenile humor your gonna get from this series. Even the first half of the VN is a little boring. It gets infinitely better. ^^ |
DrZedJul 3, 2009 10:06 AM
| Rosa reminded me of Horo, lol. Also, Kanon is loev~ |
逃げちゃ駄目だ。 |
| I didn't expect this show to be good. But I still feel somewhat disappointed. I neither read the sound novel nor manga, so I can't really complain about the rushed pacing. Besides, it was just a single episode afterall. But for the first episode it was EXTREMELY LAME!! I forced myself to watch till the end. And the only thing I remember from these 20 minutes are characters' names and Maria's uu~uu~. I understand there must be a reason to pack all of the events into a limited anime show. But seriously, I'd prefer this ep to be split into two eps. They'd better cut the totally mismatching fanservice than some extra character development. By the way, to those who felt annoyed and woud like to hit Maria themselves: PLEASE NEVER DO THIS TO YOUR CHILDREN! They cry as annoying as Maria or even worse. So better embrace them, love them, kiss them, and calm them. While it's really hard for yourselves, it's for the kids sake. There's always a reason for their crying afterall. All in all, looks like I'll keep watching the next few eps just for the sake of Kyouko-chan Marina Inoue and Taiga Kugimiya Rie. If these get killed then I'll really have no motivation left for the show. Unless it really improves in comparison to the first eppy. |
| Bleh... They cut off the best scenes like this during dinner or on the boat ;/ I'm disappointed |
Ukyo9 said: Stop complaining. Even though I read the sound novel it's impossible for me to say that this episode was THAT bad. You must be a genius if you can read sound. Also anybody who says they would beat her is scum. |
Drunk_Samurai said: Ukyo9 said: Stop complaining. Even though I read the sound novel it's impossible for me to say that this episode was THAT bad. You must be a genius if you can read sound. Also anybody who says they would beat her is scum. I'd murder her... |
soulelle said: I didn't expect this show to be good. But I still feel somewhat disappointed. I neither read the sound novel nor manga, so I can't really complain about the rushed pacing. Besides, it was just a single episode afterall. But for the first episode it was EXTREMELY LAME!! I forced myself to watch till the end. And the only thing I remember from these 20 minutes are characters' names and Maria's uu~uu~. I understand there must be a reason to pack all of the events into a limited anime show. But seriously, I'd prefer this ep to be split into two eps. They'd better cut the totally mismatching fanservice than some extra character development. By the way, to those who felt annoyed and woud like to hit Maria themselves: PLEASE NEVER DO THIS TO YOUR CHILDREN! They cry as annoying as Maria or even worse. So better embrace them, love them, kiss them, and calm them. While it's really hard for yourselves, it's for the kids sake. There's always a reason for their crying afterall. All in all, looks like I'll keep watching the next few eps just for the sake of Kyouko-chan Marina Inoue and Taiga Kugimiya Rie. If these get killed then I'll really have no motivation left for the show. Unless it really improves in comparison to the first eppy. Agreed. |
| Interesting first episode. Maria is annoying and creepy, but much more annoying than creepy. |
 |
| Scary and Maria seems a bit... weird. |
| LET JUSTICE BE DONE; THOUGH THE HEAVENS MAY FALL |
| Maria deserved that slap. I thought she would be really cute but she was just annoying. I will keep watching, I don't see a reason to drop it. The show was just wasn't what I was expecting and it may have been because my hopes were held up too high. I really want to meet Ange though. ugh |
 |
| Oh it's just a opening episode.I am going to continue to watch this show.It has a lot of potential. |
 |
soulelle said: I neither read the sound novel nor manga, so I can't really complain about the rushed pacing. Besides, it was just a single episode afterall. But for the first episode it was EXTREMELY LAME!! I forced myself to watch till the end. And the only thing I remember from these 20 minutes are characters' names and Maria's uu~uu~. And you expected what? Killer mackerels and Kanon's secret lazer-eyes? Kittenia said: Maria deserved that slap. |
ahhahahahahahahahahahaha. I hope this gif satisfies some of you. I seriously hope the annoyingness of Maria doesn't detract from how awesome this show should be. |
selective_yellow said: ahhahahahahahahahahahaha. I hope this gif satisfies some of you. I seriously hope the annoyingness of Maria doesn't detract from how awesome this show should be. Please go back to whatever Elfen Lied appreciation thread you came from. I don't even like Maria, yet I'm acting like her no. 1 MAL fanboy in this thread. For a good cause. |
| Quite surprised by the fact Kugimiya Rie sounds pretty good as Shanon. I wonder how many "Episode" are going to be animated, VN is up to Episode 4 atm right? OP and ED song were pretty good too. |
     |
Kitcha said: And you expected what? Killer mackerels and Kanon's secret lazer-eyes? I expected at least a well-told story introduction with properly built atmosphere and characters. What I got was a death note list with some boobs service. Or maybe I expected at least an opening as goog as Shimamiya Eiko's OP for Higurashi and/or Higurashi Chikai. Or perhaps I expected someting at least as fine as Higurashi no Naku Koro ni. It contained only five main charcters, and that's why its introduction looked far superior than Umineko's one - they basically had more space in a single episode to cover the characters personality properly and create/keep the light-hearted atmosphere until the very end of the eppy. That's why I wish Umineko's first episode was split into more episodes. That would definitely be for Umineko's sake. PS: please, keep the Kanon's Mikuru beams for the board administrators. All of the words above is nothing but my personal opinion afterall. Besides, neither have I tried to make anyone follow it nor had any intentions of that kind. |
| The episode was great in my opinion despite most people whining about it being too rushed. I felt that it was rushed too but I thought that that was inevitable. Higurashi only had ~ 6 major characters, whereas Umineko has like over 10, you can't easily squeeze the introduction of over 10 characters into 24 minutes AS WELL as introduce the story without rushing and losing detail. |
| After reading the 1. book, I think Maria has some sort of mild autism like asperger syndrom.( Of course the most have no babytalk problems but talking as kid too fast). But her character leads to this conclusion. (Antisocial, special interesst, less emotions,less face expressions, abnormal laugther etc.) So she is not anoying on purpose. Keep that in mind every one! But don't worry about the "uuuu" when Maria get's creepy she speak normaly. (But then she has a psychotic laugther)"kihihihi" |
ShogoKAWADAJul 3, 2009 4:06 PM
| The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear ist the fear of the unknown. H.P. Lovecraft |
| Uuuuu~ Maria is kinda scary. That was a nice first episode. I'm so looking forward to more. nihil said: Rosa reminded me of Horo, lol. Haha, yeah. Same here. XD |
ShogoKAWADA said: This lad is wise.After reading the 1. book, I think Maria has some sort of mild autism like asperger syndrom.( Of course the most have no babytalk problems but talking as kid too fast). But her character leads to this conclusion. (Antisocial, special interesst, less emotions,less face expressions, abnormal laugther etc.) So she is not anoying on purpose. Keep that in mind every one! But don't worry about the "uuuu" when Maria get's creepy she speak normaly. (But then she has a psychotic laugther)"kihihihi" spoilers for ep 4 which might be guesswork: |
How is the world ruled and how do wars start? Diplomats tell lies to journalists and then believe what they read. | Report rules abuse | Your Panel | Clubs | Messages | Forum | Recent <img src="http://img593.imageshack.us/img593/4672/stuhlbarg.png" /> |
| You can call me crazy, I just finished watching the first episode simultaneously in two players. One was playing the CoalGuys subbed version, whereas the second was playing the one by gg. I found out that CoalGuys failed completely with translating the part where the senior family members are having their little discussion. To be honest even before the gg subs I thought that something clearly did not make sense in the CoalGuys version, but now I'm sure of it. So, for those of you for whom this is the first encounter with Umineko no Naku Koro ni I strongly advise: DO NOT WATCH THE COALGUYS SUB! |
 |
| You're aware that the gg sub is the second version of the coalgg sub? |
| Yes, but that does not change the fact that the first one, might get the people unfimiliar with Umineko no Naku Koro Ni a bit confused... |
| |
| What was incorrect? They were fighting over the gold since their father has 3 months to live, and the 3 younger siblings were looking for their cut that they thought the heir had already found. Right? |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Sii_Kei - Jul 8, 2009 |
313 |
by luxarking7
»»
Dec 8, 4:42 AM |
|
» I want to watch it but...cvbnm07 - Oct 12 |
8 |
by Artorias-
»»
Nov 24, 1:07 AM |
|
» A(No-Other) Psychoanalytic Take on Umineko no Naku Koro niAerghlis - Oct 13 |
0 |
by Aerghlis
»»
Oct 13, 7:06 PM |
|
» What is this and why do people say this is a sequel to Higurashi?Asudox - Nov 26, 2023 |
13 |
by Asudox
»»
Oct 10, 12:57 PM |
|
Poll: » Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )antidentite - Jul 15, 2009 |
215 |
by BlackStar_24
»»
Sep 29, 4:25 PM |