This backstory seems to be adapted quite amazingly. The recap is tiny, the art and animation consistently great and it seems they continually adapt 1.5 chapters per episode? Like, I have not a single nitpick with these adaptation wise! It's crazy in a good way.
The big thing in the first half of the episode that I noticed was that it was amazing characterization for Luffy. This was done in two ways. He may have become less of a crybaby going forward but more than just loving his nakama and wanting to be Shanks a line he said this episode came off incredibly powerful. Ace said isn't it better to live than to die even if you're lonely, and even when he lacked strength he responded with the line:- "Being lonely is more painful than getting hurt."
I haven't looked at Luffy like that before, and I never saw it quite that way. He like Ace was alone in the world, he wasn't hated, perhaps he may have been if the father he was born to was well known, and he had no one but Garp. He loves his friends and even back in Arlong arc he said without them he was nothing, but that comes from a place of prioritizing friendship over his own life due to loneliness being more painful than being hurt. This doesn't change my understanding of Luffy's actions but it adds onto them in a meaningful way. Marineford made me see Luffy like a kid who couldn't deal with loss, where Jimbei and Whitebeard understood loss is inevitable, Luffy ran in time and time again fighting like an ant in a storm until he was blown away. Even back to Magellan where he practically suicided if not for Ivan. He appeared to me like a child which had absolute ideals he couldn't accept failing at times. It's why I think his arc will be one of understanding that he can fight with his all and live to his fullest but that alone won't make things work out for the better! So, I already saw his admirable side come off as childish, but now understanding the core of why Luffy fights so strong is to avoid being alone, to cherish his friends to avoid that pain, a belief he had even as a 7 year, it makes him appear even more childish. Not in a bad way, but in a impactful way. I love Luffy, 500 episodes down the line my understanding of him deepens.
The other bit of Luffy characterization that stood out to me was Luffy's fear. As a kid he had two major conflicting values. The desire to live and not be hurt, and the desire to have friends and not be lonely. Of course even as a child he prioritized friendship over his own well being, like he does now by willingly sacrificing tons of years of his life for his friends. Yet, now he doesn't show fear, at least when he does he's doing it because he's mimicking those around him like Buggy or Mr.3. He can smile in a guillotine and he can face imminent death with a strong resolve. The only time he cries in the current time line is when he loses a friend, which goes back to the last paragraph, or in other words when his impossible ideals start to shatter(Merry, Usopp, Ace). This is the Luffy we know, and this Luffy does not hold a desire to live that battles with his desire to fight for his friends, he does punch a Celestial Dragon and fight 3 of the strongest men in the world at once without a second thought and without a sign of fear. So I wondered, when did Luffy gain that conviction which left behind his tears for his own sake and his own life and his conflicting desire to live. And, I may be wrong, but if we look at Ace he is willing to recklessly fight to the death without showing fear for his own life akin to how Luffy ended up. So I think perhaps Luffy learned how to live to his fullest and casually state phrases like"everyone dies sometime" before risking his life through a mix of having role models like Shanks, and Ace, as well as habituation through trying to act that way...
I also adore the natural progression of this friendship. Sabo and Ace are in a world where they feel they need to be strong and on their own but when they saw the blood Luffy split for their own sake they ended up warming up to him a little and letting him tag along with them. Their dynamic really feels like 2 big brothers picking on their youngest brother, especially in scenes like when Sabo and Ace bully him and kick him like a soccer ball. Which only furthers that feeling because even if they bully him they love him and will risk their lives for him, as they did with the Crocodile and Porchemy. It feels so real and sweet and it's going to make the loss of Ace and Luffy's pain feel even more real. The dynamic of 13 year old Ace and 7 year old Luffy fighting and 10 year Sabo acting like the reasonable adult of the group is nice too.
Sabo is quite interesting. I am excited to see more of him and the natural way he moved in with the Dadan family is wonderful. The more I see the Dadan family the more I like them. They remind me of Tetra's pirate crew in Zelda: The Wind Waker. They may appear as bad people but they're really just a bunch of good hearted idiots. Kind of similar to how Sabo and Ace put up bad boy appearances at first before it obviously cracks. That said, Sabo isn't seen anymore in the current time line. We only heard about him as Ace was dying, and that makes me fear for how this backstory can turn out. With the Bluejam pirates hunting our three boys and even killing one of their own in cold blood and Sabo not playing a huge role in the story up until now, it's like, this could be bad. Mostly every backstory outside of Luffy's ended in tragedy and I think it's cool we get to see Luffy deal with the tragedy characters like Zoro did as a kid, or like Brook did when he lost his crew but in real time. Yet, this backstory arc could still get pretty dark with how it already started to with the death of Porchemy and Bluejam's crew swarming the areas... |