DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Venomouspsycho said: I really hope the author really chooses another studio if a s4 comes Do manga authors even have any choice in studios and whatnot? I know they can basically hand pick VAs and request OPs/EDs but with studios, idk? |
 |
Reply to casilo
Nitpick lvl max, tons of good stuff this ep but yeah let’s pull a 1-second mistake lol
| @casilo You mean ton of good still frame shots? |
| Mhm, things are already starting to heat up. Garou is exactly what they call an Anti-Villain rn as he hasn't killed a single hero despite beating heroes and proclaiming that he's a monster. Overall, decent episode yet again. Pretty hyped for the next one knowing Garou is abt to fight for his life. Also, that whole dine and dash scene was pretty funny xD |
 |
Reply to 18927
This shit is beyond saving. Look at Garou
| @18927 As lame as this episode was, I have to say you need to touch grass. Seriously. Dude is effortlessly sliding down a slope of grass. There is nothing to animate here. For me, more than anything this doesn't FEEL like OPM. I know this story arc is just the monster association and garou, but the pacing and the atmosphere just feel off. |
Thank God I wasn't the only one who noticed this. This level of laziness is crazy, I don't know who thought this was passable. |
ktg said: That's not exactly a bad animation. They wanted Garou to slide down without moving. For that this is actually how you would do it. I’m not even an animation snob, but even I could tell you that an average quality animation would interact better. Make the grass move out of the way of the foot, add some particles from dust/dirt, have Garou slightly shifting his body around, slightly vary the speed of the descent to represent real physics acceleration/friction. He literally looks like he’s floating down like an angel 💀 |
| Some hope in the music. There was a good background score when Garou was talking to the other 2 monsters. But the score, itself while epic, seemed a bit out of place; I have some hope that it may redeem the anime a bit. As a person who enjoyed Kingdom season 1, animation doesn't bother me as much but I will countenance that when compared to previous seasons, this is a bit disappointing. Edit: Looking at the studio's other works, including their 3D works, but this is just dross. I can't blame a director who lacks experience but this is not a felicitous assignment. Let them work on smaller shows to prove themselves. |
HellindiuMOct 19, 10:47 PM
My candies:          +2 bonus candy |
Reply to FreedomFighter28
ktg said:
That's not exactly a bad animation. They wanted Garou to slide down without moving. For that this is actually how you would do it.
That's not exactly a bad animation. They wanted Garou to slide down without moving. For that this is actually how you would do it.
I’m not even an animation snob, but even I could tell you that an average quality animation would interact better. Make the grass move out of the way of the foot, add some particles from dust/dirt, have Garou slightly shifting his body around, slightly vary the speed of the descent to represent real physics acceleration/friction.
He literally looks like he’s floating down like an angel 💀
| @FreedomFighter28 That's less of an animation and more of a compositing/storyboarding issue. From this far, you won't be able to see how the grass moves, realistically there shouldn't be dust and small movements of his body couldn't be seen either. So, from this distance, that's a relatively okay-ish animation. Normally yes, this is not how you would do it, but this is far from being a bad shot or being the worst scene from this episode. I just wanted to point out that so far both episodes were okay, not something awful and not something great, but people keep complaining because they don't know anything about animation, they just follow the hate trend. Moist Critical also posted a video about this season and in the comment section people were talking about how this is THE worst adaptation, like Yakusoku no Nevetland S2 didn't exist. |
Reply to casilo
Nitpick lvl max, tons of good stuff this ep but yeah let’s pull a 1-second mistake lol
| @casilo What even is the point of animating it if it's just gonna look like this? I'd rather just read the manga if it's gonna look semi-animated with still images |
ktg said: @FreedomFighter28 That's less of an animation and more of a compositing/storyboarding issue. From this far, you won't be able to see how the grass moves, realistically there shouldn't be dust and small movements of his body couldn't be seen either. So, from this distance, that's a relatively okay-ish animation. Normally yes, this is not how you would do it, but this is far from being a bad shot or being the worst scene from this episode. I just wanted to point out that so far both episodes were okay, not something awful and not something great, but people keep complaining because they don't know anything about animation, they just follow the hate trend. Moist Critical also posted a video about this season and in the comment section people were talking about how this is THE worst adaptation, like Yakusoku no Nevetland S2 didn't exist. Sorry but you would definitely see the friction causing movement in one’s body, and the body would accelerate at G. He is completely static and falls at a constant speed. You can call this “okay” animation all you want but what is the line of “bad” animation? I can’t think of anything worse besides improper positioning (including size, scaling, orientation, etc) and other complete animation failures. Again, animation is one of the last things I watch an Anime for, but this feels like a fan made or knock off production animation wise. |
| Oh my god... That was even worse than I could have ever imagined. And I was ambivalent going into this season because I didn't totally hate season 2. Hell, I gave it a 7. I even gave the season 2 specials a freaking 9. The opening scene with the protesters where they just panned across very low detail still images while the VAs shouted their lines. Garou's interaction with the drunk holding the knife. His slide down the hill. Just the character art in general was looking really weird in this episode. I was not impressed with the detail. THIS SHIT IS NOT EVEN SEASON 2 LEVEL. It's worse than season 2. It makes season 2 feel like it was season 1. |
Reply to RoyalDemon05
I just finished watching one punch man season 3 episode 2 on Musa Asia, they ended the episode before they had fight scene, seriously I was expecting they will use animation from trailer
This episode was huge disappointment
they had this animation from trailer , but they didn't show on this episode
This episode was huge disappointment
they had this animation from trailer , but they didn't show on this episode
| @RoyalDemon05 Probably, they have to save this precious frames for Episode 3. |
| Well after Episode 1 gave my quite a bad first impression, i was interested for episode 2. And hey hey, they are actually doing QUITE worse than the second Season. And here i thought so many years could make a difference. Or did they start animating it last year? Either way, this thing is a disgrace. And another argument for me to stop watching Anime. We always get those random garbage Isekai with 9/10 animation, but nobody wants to see this old reused recipe. And when a hyped Manga finally gets an adaption, it becomes seven deadly frames, two frame man or this .. what ever happend to this one King Isekai. |
Reply to casilo
Nitpick lvl max, tons of good stuff this ep but yeah let’s pull a 1-second mistake lol
| @casilo I respect you for watching this Episode with 3 bottles of vodka. I did it with one and it didnt help me to see it any better. Guess i had to drink more. :( |
| Maybe they are saving their budget for later in the season, but so far, it's Food Wars 2.0....... |
| "Genki is Life, Genki is Love" |
| aye the animation was nice this ep! was expecting worse better than first half of blue lock s2 so far, ya’ll crazy blue lock s2 still 10/10 tho despite it all 🤩 |
 |
hahaha amen glad you appreciate it |
|
Reply to HeroforFun23
Ain't nobody talks about Garou's motivation, how funny comedic scenes, and how well executed the build up towards the fight. This discussion or MAL tards are so cooked. Focused on a 2 second clip of bad animation rather than being objective and/or subjective over the entire run of the episode with actually a lot of movements compared to episode 1. I'm out, too many bandwagons
| @HeroforFun23 Good thing you're here to talk about the peak comedy scene that was Saitama dining and then dashing instead of whining about what others are talking about... Wait, whoops. Anyway most of us (probably) have already read the manga. What exactly in terms of character development occurred in this episode or the last? Everything to do with Garou was already established last season. There hasn't been any change in him yet. And there won't be for a while. We're just beginning this arc. Literally episode 2. You are behaving as if there was anything but the animation to talk about in here. There wasn't. Mod Edit: Removed baiting. |
CCOct 22, 2:02 PM
| This here too is something I've already seen on a fan animation on yt, still good to see it properly animated though |
 |
| I guess the comedy tag for this anime still holds up because that scene of garou sliding down the hill like a PNG was just hilarious. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Softhenic03 - Oct 26 |
271 |
by nahtanoj1150
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )IzanaSolos - Dec 7 |
150 |
by xZabuzax
»»
3 hours ago |
|
Poll: » One Punch Man 3 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Softhenic03 - Dec 14 |
191 |
by bloobs3301
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» Time to celebrateRajdeep1212 - Dec 13 |
18 |
by Fusion8707
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » will you watch the next anime season or sequels?deg - Dec 14 |
45 |
by FutoiOtaku
»»
8 hours ago |