DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads. DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material. DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters. DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
it’s hard to grasp how I feel about this anime overall
it was a creepy fever dream with weird pacing and a weirder storyline
oddly enough I was engaged the whole time and while the animation quality drop was disappointing it didn’t take away from the horror vibes which I enjoyed coming up to Halloween
the thing is I can’t say it’s good—and in a lot of major ways it was actually kind of bad lol
but it kept me interested which is among the most important qualities something to watch can offer
I’m torn but suppose I’ll give it a 5/10 and call it a day
I liked a lot the visual style but it is a shame the actual animation couldn't keep up with it, I'm a chicken with anything remotely scary and even I felt nothing, I can see the appeal of the visuals, much like with the Aliens / xenomorph franchise which I forgot how it is called, from H.R. Giger , but this adaptation didn't translate well.
I've seen all Ito adaptations and this was one was the best. My only complaint was the music, a good eerie soundtrack could have elevated the series. not sure why the low score, for a modern anime the execution and quality was excellent. it will probably age a lot better than its current reception now
Man... Junji Ito really is cursed to never have a truly good adaptation of his work. I re-read the manga before watching this show and that is still easily the best way to experience it. The show definitely had some good moments and showed serious potential, but overall it is still a big letdown. One of my biggest issues was the pacing. They really speedran the story trying to cram as much in as quick as possible. The huge drop in quality, the changing of plot points in the story, and having several story arcs going on simultaneously also heavily detracted from the show for me.
I didn't hate this. Was this the adaptation that Uzumaki deserved? No, but it wasn't the trainwreck I was fearing after seeing second episode. Even if the second episode was actually fine, this would still be hard to recommend to someone who hasn't read the manga, due to them having to rush and cut thing's, but the part's that worked, did work pretty well.
I guess I'm satisfied with just that.
Shame that they had to add that little narration to the end, because the ending would have been better without it.
This could've been better, but it was good. It's a very different anime compared your average stuff. More contemplative, weird and artistic. Too bad they decided to destroy the animation, but the art style still has it's own grace.
it has a good artsyle an good animation during its first episode but it goes downhill after that, that being said a good story doesnt need to be carried by visuals an Uzumaki doesnt have a good story or interesting characters and at points its more like unintentional comedy which makes it somewhat enjoyable, it had some cool looking momsters but thats about it
this episode fixed the pacing issues that ruined the previous three. you can't really do uzumaki in four episodes, but you can do the last act in one pretty well.
Man, if the quality kept up from the first episode, and this had double the episodes, this could have been phenomenal. It’s such a shame because there is some really interesting ideas, but the production and pacing just destroyed this show.
But here’s the thing: it was pretty bad, but I still enjoyed it!
This is a 4/10 for me, but it’s probably my favorite 4/10 ever lol!!!!!
Omfg, when the guy fell down the spiral, it was legit a static PNG that slowly shrank to make it look like he's falling.
People who worked on this should be embarrassed.
Average MAL user's media literacy:
Marinate1016 said: Not reading allat cause I don’t care. Tensura peak. Have a good one tho
This show was such a disappointment. The pacing was its biggest flaw, while the music stood out as its greatest strength. I’d rate it a 4/10 overall, though I enjoyed some moments. I’ll probably check out the manga at some point.
I think that overall I still found it scary and I like to see some of these horror elements animated like the snails etc but it's clearly underwhelming compared to the manga, not only for the animation but pacing and direction, I would just treat it as a bonus adaptation for being reminded of the manga but I'm sad that I waited years and got hyped just for it to have this result, anyway it is what it is...
I don't remember those two characters at the end and the time loop in the original, but other than that it was a pretty faithful adaptation, only changing the episodic narrative in the beginning by having the stories playing out at the same time.
Visually it was great on the first episode, and got a lot worse since then, but nowhere near as bad as I expected it to be from the viral clips I've seen.
I loved the first episode, but everything went downhill from there. A new production team came in, and pretty much the last 3 episodes were pretty bad
I haven't seen any of Ito's other works, or read the manga, but even I can tell something went wrong here. It reminds me of Wonder Egg Priority, in a way. Had an excellent start, to where it could turn out amazing, but nah, it was quite literally ruined 😭😭
Uzumaki kept it's scare factor and eerieness in the beginning, but their decision to make everything happen at the same time ruined that feel
Yes, the animation was pretty bad at times, but I still felt this was quite good. I didn't mind the ultrafast pacing because it just added to the fever dream atmosphere that this was already going for. I was never bored because there was always some creepy shit happening on screen.
Even though this adaptation should have been far better, it still manages to be among the best horror anime I've seen.
Everyone hating on it, just calm down, you cant appreciate the work of Junji Ito... how are you still here?
Manga may be better but, still the best adaptation
It was unique, thanks for the B/W, really weird and eerie, an experience, dont care about the animation, the horror aspect was there, sometimes goofy, pacing a little fast yes, but I liked it, perfect for this spooky month
In the end, its all a big spiral, the cycle and curse continues !
Alright guys calm tf down Jesus Christ like a 6.21??? You ppl are OVERREACTING like no tomorrow like yes this show had bad animation during the second episode but it wasn’t all that bad for episodes 3 and 4 in this episode there was one wonky part where shuichi fell but other than that this episode was greatly animated to me :D
Awww at least Shuichi got to figure out what the spiral was and at least him and Kirie got to be together for their last moments it was cute seeing them wrapped around each other it was kinda symbolic and romantic🥹🥰
Wow absolutely disgusting, they really eat those Snail people cooked and Raw LMAO
Shuichi x Kirie love story at the end, they ended up together forever in spiral.
Wow that after credits, history repeat itself.
Overall honestly i expected a lot from this adaptation since they spent years in the making but it was okay i guess.
Even though this was probably closest to be the best Junji Ito adaptation in Anime format compared to the previous one but still there is a lot of flaws.
6/10 for the terrifying and disturbing ride and just because i respect Junji Ito.
Was it scary? not really
Was it disturbing? hell yeah
I noticed that people said the animation quality dropped after ep 1 but I'm not that nitpicky to notice that much amount of detail lol, still good to get the horror aspect across.
How faithful is the ending to the original story? Was it really all because of some ruins and a recurring curse? In the film, everything ended much simpler, but I don’t know how true for the canon that was.
@TheRealRouges I'm having snobbery overload from your comment. Please warn me in the future.
this fell off just so badly. i loved the first episode but every other episode after that has just been boring af. it feels like there's no tension in the moments where there should be tension. the background art still looks great and thats about the only compliment i have tbh
This one is what I wanted from the series since it was announced. It was tense, the sound design was impeccable, and the animation was sharp and immersive. They really nailed the "doomed" atmosphere of the original, and it was by far the most nerve-wracking. I just wish the rest of the show was as good as this episode was.
Such a shame… The idea of creating a black and white adaptation in manga style was great, and the animation, though not quite up to expectations, was acceptable. The real problem was trying to adapt it in just four episodes, which completely killed the atmosphere, turning it into a bunch of creepy scenes glued together.
For me, it’s the best anime adaptation of a Junji Ito story, which makes me realize just how bad the others are. The curse struck again here too. :c
Decent Adaptation.
The story as a whole remains a 4/10 though.
... I can't recall the differences off memory, but I like the original epilogue of Shuichi and Kirie's genderswap reincarnation confirming to be stuck in the spiral for eternity.
I first read the manga in Sep 24, 2022.
I've read all of Junji Itou's work except for The Liminal Zone Volume 2, that new monthly manga, and his No Longer Human adaptation (all of his adaptations are bad).
I love his work for the most part. Big fan. But... Uzumaki is surprisingly his most overrated and most popular work.
It's too nonsensical to say the least.
Sure, the spiral is chaotic, but the plots individually aren't all great and don't compliment each other.
The start is great, and so is the finale, but some of the buildup and plots are dull and as a whole doesn't feel right and perfect. Most of it is too ridiculous and random. They don't fit.
Anyway, here's my incredibly lengthy original manga review;
After reading all of Junji Itou's collections, and finishing most of his work,
excluding No Longer Human, Gyo, and The Liminal Zone.
I decided to read his longest manga last, starting with The Spiral, which is praised as his best and most popular manga to date.
I am somewhat shocked at how mediocre, overrated and extremely disappointing it was, and regret buying it instead of reading the non-high quality scanlation.
Most, if not all of Itou's horror work are "great" in how they're fascinating, creative and intriguing with their concepts and how he displays the horror in his stories. Some better than others, while most are left inconclusive to the unknown in their finale.
The mystery is often "disappointing" for wanting to fully comprehend the story, but most of his horror stays entertaining regardless.
The problem that I dislike and is a legit flaw from The Spiral and possibly all of his long stories or rather bad works is how unstructured and awkward they can be.
I'm a fan who's fondly enjoyed and continue to enjoy reading his work as I'm close to finishing all of his work,
but unfortunately this one is one of the few bad ones.
So far out of his series of long stories that I enjoyed are; Tomie, Souichi, Fashion Model, The Bizarre Hikizuri Siblings, The Intersection Boy and, Remina.
None are perfect, and all are inconclusive... but at least they're intriguing and captivating,
while Tomie has sense with good plots to its trope, unlike The Spiral.
... The Spiral is mostly boring, and underwhelming in its depiction from most of the plots of what exactly the Spiral is and why it creates these specific phenomenoms.
The art and display of the horror is great as is common from Itou,
while the characters even though critisized as unsophisticated from fans, serve their purpose well in displaying a realistic attitude and interaction of people which I think is an overlooked talent from Itou that most people don't realize, even if his characters aren't extraordinary.
On the contrary, I think they're realistic in his own style, even if other mangaka have a different style of character interpretation that's arguably more realistic in other manners.
Anyway.
The timeline of events is somewhat interesting for the mystery of how the spiral affects the townspeople differently, but as a whole, the difference and lacking relation of sense to the phenomenoms together till the ending overall is unfulfilling and disappointing.
The main plot of the town's dragonfly pond with a spiral figure under it causing these phenomena and somehow causing the town to loop into a spiral of time is awesome!
Although, again, the events in relation to the main plot is underwhelming as a whole to the story.
Shuichi's father's obsession is what starts the story, which introduces a decent intrigue to this upcoming obscure mystery. Which surprisingly is never revealed how he first became affected, but no matter.
The bizarre attitude of his father while creeping out the characters is fairly good; from his eyes seperately rolling, his tongue curling, and unnaturally curling his body inside a round box as he dies, later haunting his wife with spirals from his death, with his ashes smoking into a spiral figure in the clouds- which is all good.
The issue afterwards is how random most of the events are with little to no logic to the spiral itself and its supposed meaning which I don't know what it is aside from a loop that enjoys to suck people in.
The girl with the scar who's attracted any boy ever since she's had it, ending up being sucked in by her own spiral in her forehead.
Shuichi's parents as spirits burning in Kirie's father's kiln... his father calling him to join him, while her mother screams to him for help, along with other spirit victims of the spiral who've died.
The couple intertwining together like snakes against their enemy neighboring family who don't accept each other.
Kirie's hair locks curling into spirals, with her friend gaining the same ability craving to show off and ending up dead by her living hair sucking out her life.
The boy who has a crush on Kirie, attempting to prove his love by having a car stop in front of him, causing him to die with the car's spring in his spine as he was curled on the front wheel, to then his undead corpse springing into to her after Shuichi tried to kill him before reanimating.
A classmate who comes to school turning into a snail from a spiral on his back which turns into his shell.
The lighthouse's burnt dysfunctional light somehow causing fire to spread inside whenever it starts, with the stairs almost being an endless loop.
Female mosquitoes biting pregnant women and causing them to become blood-suckers to feed their babies, with the babies having the ability to talk and want to return in their mother's womb, and their umbilical chord turning into a mushroom-like spiral.
Typhoons, Whirlpools, Whirlwinds. A cursed house causing ones inside to gain horns throughout their body leading to death.
The townspeople gaining the ability to cause mini gust of tornados with any impactful movement or sound, with some having the skill to fly through a self-made tornado.
To finally people curling into themselves inside the built home extensions, curling together to the past of the town, eating snail people to survive, with time speeding for the main characters, and in the finale, the couple going down to the source of the spiral figure and intertwining together themselves after Kirie finds her parents turned into stone after years have passed seperate from their time together.
... There are kinda great plots and events in this story, but it's shamefully unstructured, illogical, and boring to some extent which is ultimately very disappointing.
Shuichi's sense of danger as the sole character who's noticed since the beginning for attending school elsewhere is great as the only medium who's aware of the spiral.
His wish to flea with his girlfriend together and constant failing to do so from her denial until its too late is well done.
I was mostly entertained after Chapter 10's Mosquitoes for how the horror started becoming grander in creativity, which got better in some form after the characters were struggling to survive and the town went into chaos.
I keep repeating myself, but even if some events are great individually, as a whole it just does not function.
A lot of it is greatly entertaining, but...
Azami, the girl with the scar spiral on her forehead arguably lacks explanation to her character's point of the story, exactly how and why she's the only one to get sucked in into herself, even though her demise of horror is fucking great. I think to the logic of the story, because (as Shuichi deduced) the spiral is in all of them, by becoming arrogant with ego to fail in charming Shuichi, the spiral sucked her in. Why though.
Shuichi's spirits and the other deceased. How are they trapped from passing away peacefully. The Twisted Souls Chapter of the couple intertwining is self-explanatory and a good introduction to the foreshadowing of the townspeople intertwining together later, even though the spiral affecting their family with hate unlike the couple is left a mystery to me.
Jack-in-the-Box is probably the stupidest event of the story. The boy's corpse reviving and springing to his crush Kirie was idiotic and meaningless to the story. The tornado being attracted to Kirie doesn't make sense at all either.
The Snail People is great to an extent. The way it's used to induce the plot of people eating them to survive is interesting... but I don't exactly understand the logic of how being slow or whatever causes specific people to turn into slugs. The tranformation itself is also fascinating.
The Black Lighthouse is bizarre in how it burns people to death, but, it's a decent introduction to travel having the occurence to be neverending causing one to be stuck in the same place.
The Mosquitoes' concept alone is great, but babies having the ability to talk and yearning to go back to their mother's womb doesn't make sense to me even if I feel there's probably a sense of loop in relation to the spiral, but I don't fully understand it's probable hidden meaning.
The cursed house is very random, and I don't understand why the old buildings are incable of being destroyed while stronger buildings are easily destroyed in comparison.
The last quarter of the story is fairly entertaining. The way in which practically everything in town is destroyed, with people trying to survive, kids previously being tied up, blowing things to destruction, with gangs flying, survivors eating snails, others intertwining in the safe buildings, Kirie and Shuichi attempting to keep her little brother safe before the cannibals attempt to eat him as he escapes as a snail and is saddenly never reunited with his sister in the finale.
That whole struggle, with others dying from being blown away by others is pretty good.
The finale itself though isn't bad. The doom that it's a bad ending is good, with the fact that The Spiral is a neverending loop, but I don't understand how it's a loop that could cause them to somehow repeat this cycle, or how time works in and out of the spiral from being in the hill out of the town for them to continue to travel time while in town afterwards, or even why some townspeople are turned into stones in face of Thee Spiral. I guess it's because they're stuck in time, to eventually revive later...
All in all... Flawed and Overrated. 4/10.
Although, if I completely neglect how the story and events lack logic, arguably 5-6/10.
I mean, This last episode was better than the previous two atleast. The first and last episodes were the best tbh. Oh well, Atleast the final scene and the drawings this episode were done really well.