| Personally, it's not the edgy shit itself which annoys me. I loved Madoka Magica which was also edgy. The difference with Madoka is that there was depth in it. It made you think about things like sacrifice and that being a good person can actually be more negative than positive for oneself (like with Sayaka and Kyoko). It left a deep psycological impact on me. In contrast, MSS at first sight gave me the impression that it was being edgy for the sake of it, making the protagonist go through all bad things as possible in the episode time they had; I know though that with only one episode this impression could be mistaken. But I could go along with the edgy tone if it was not for another thing, which is what truly annoys me: This shit is real (the bullying, I mean). During all the bullying scenes I couldn't stop thinking that these kind of things happen. This show made me feel angry for real things and even though one could point that as a merit, to me it is not: I watch anime precisely to find some peace in contrast with the cruel world we live in. But in the end, it's a matter of preferences. I have no problem with other people liking it. |
| "The world appears wonderful in the eyes of wonderful people." (Alicia Florence, ARIA) |
| Maybe because the violence is so over the top that it is actually hilarious? Personally one of the first worst episodes I have personally seen. I honestly have nothing positive to say about it. |
 |
| It simple, the series lack deep character development and the story isn't anything special keep in mind this is jsut the first episode, so what most people see is a edge fest series with no substance. I enjoyed the first episode, it was entertaining and thats what matters the most to me. |
Calal-Chan said: Maybe because the violence is so over the top that it is actually hilarious? Personally one of the first worst episodes I have personally seen. I honestly have nothing positive to say about it. How is it over the top? There was a girl at my school that literally had the same shit happening to her daily. I guess some people can't relate to it maybe that's why they find it funny |
 |
Nevalopo said: Calal-Chan said: Maybe because the violence is so over the top that it is actually hilarious? Personally one of the first worst episodes I have personally seen. I honestly have nothing positive to say about it. How is it over the top? There was a girl at my school that literally had the same shit happening to her daily. I guess some people can't relate to it maybe that's why they find it funny That girl at your school is bullied by 3 girls who put tacks and razors in her shoe + destroys her desk + torture her in the bathroom, almost got raped, pet kitten got killed, and used as a punching bag by her brother when she gets home?? You should inform the police. |
Liddo-kunApr 12, 2018 6:13 PM
Liddo-kun said: Nevalopo said: How is it over the top? There was a girl at my school that literally had the same shit happening to her daily. I guess some people can't relate to it maybe that's why they find it funny That girl at your school is bullied by 3 girls who put tacks and razors in her shoe, almost got raped, pet kitten got killed, and used as a punching bag by her brother when she gets home?? Almost. She was beaten, stuffed in lockers, locked inside rooms, spit on, raped, always showed up to school with scars over her arms idk about her home life but bullying can get real intense |
|
Nevalopo said: Liddo-kun said: That girl at your school is bullied by 3 girls who put tacks and razors in her shoe, almost got raped, pet kitten got killed, and used as a punching bag by her brother when she gets home?? Almost. She was beaten, stuffed in lockers, locked inside rooms, spit on, raped, always showed up to school with scars over her arms idk about her home life but bullying can get real intense Well, you said the word "same" so I assumed it was the same as the show. And how would we know that you aren't just making things up? |
Liddo-kun said: Nevalopo said: Almost. She was beaten, stuffed in lockers, locked inside rooms, spit on, raped, always showed up to school with scars over her arms idk about her home life but bullying can get real intense Well, you said the word "same" so I assumed it was the same as the show. And how would we know that you aren't just making things up? nvm i get why people think its hilarous with bullying or say it's over the top trash show its because people can't relate to it or have ever experienced severe bullying |
|
It's a long standing MAL tradition to hate almost every new series that has been hyped before release. Don't worry. Fans will rank the series higher once all the eps have finished airing. |
  |
Nevalopo said: Liddo-kun said: That girl at your school is bullied by 3 girls who put tacks and razors in her shoe, almost got raped, pet kitten got killed, and used as a punching bag by her brother when she gets home?? Almost. She was beaten, stuffed in lockers, locked inside rooms, spit on, raped, always showed up to school with scars over her arms idk about her home life but bullying can get real intense Just from my own personal experience of being bullied I just didn't experience bullying of this degree or knew anyone who has/had. I am sorry to hear your friend (or I assume friend) experienced stuff like that. I still stand by what I said about this really over dramatizing most bullying. But again sorry to hear that. |
|
| I guess this ep is trying to give you the feeling about the poor situation of the mahou shoujo suffering and the dark atmosphere,so I think this is pretty fine beginning. It makes you feel overwhelmed about the events happened,so that you'll be interested in this. Since, it's the first ep and it's already very edgy,so I believe that there'll be less edgy later on,I guess? |
 Life is empty without anime |
AbeldeMedici said: Personally, it's not the edgy shit itself which annoys me. I loved Madoka Magica which was also edgy. The difference with Madoka is that there was depth in it. It made you think about things like sacrifice and that being a good person can actually be more negative than positive for oneself (like with Sayaka and Kyoko). It left a deep psycological impact on me. In contrast, MSS at first sight gave me the impression that it was being edgy for the sake of it, making the protagonist go through all bad things as possible in the episode time they had; I know though that with only one episode this impression could be mistaken. But I could go along with the edgy tone if it was not for another thing, which is what truly annoys me: This shit is real (the bullying, I mean). During all the bullying scenes I couldn't stop thinking that these kind of things happen. This show made me feel angry for real things and even though one could point that as a merit, to me it is not: I watch anime precisely to find some peace in contrast with the cruel world we live in. But in the end, it's a matter of preferences. I have no problem with other people liking it. Those are the comments that should be made. Expressing one's opinion whilst being open about it, contemplating that maybe it's just not for them. But I think it's wrong to always compare things with other things that share the same bedrock. Madoka was meant to be felt that way, no one really has proof that Mahou Shoujo Site has the objective of throwing any philosophical stuff at you, not every dark anime HAS to portray life in a believable way or has the objective of putting some aspects of life in a philosophical outlook... It could be mindless and still be very dark. It just wants to tell a story, why do you always have to read pretentiousness and laugh at how impossible situations like those are in real life (I've read worse than this, so think twice about you say). Which is an absurd thought process to have watching a fictional media like anime is. |
| I feel it should have been rated higher, those brutal things happen in real life, maybe not all at once in the same day, but happen. 1 episode is not enough to judge a show...why is Steins Gate at 9.20 after 1 episode? Was it really a masterpiece episode? For those who liked the first episode I recommend the manga Life, it's centered around bullying all way through, then watch also the LIFE drama series, it's also good. https://myanimelist.net/manga/407/Life?q=life As for the rating, whatever, just watch if you liked the first episode, drop it if you didin't. Read reviews here or on blog sites, see what people think of the show also. |
| Yeah this show is pretty underrated |
 |
NostalgiaDrive94 said: AbeldeMedici said: Personally, it's not the edgy shit itself which annoys me. I loved Madoka Magica which was also edgy. The difference with Madoka is that there was depth in it. It made you think about things like sacrifice and that being a good person can actually be more negative than positive for oneself (like with Sayaka and Kyoko). It left a deep psycological impact on me. In contrast, MSS at first sight gave me the impression that it was being edgy for the sake of it, making the protagonist go through all bad things as possible in the episode time they had; I know though that with only one episode this impression could be mistaken. But I could go along with the edgy tone if it was not for another thing, which is what truly annoys me: This shit is real (the bullying, I mean). During all the bullying scenes I couldn't stop thinking that these kind of things happen. This show made me feel angry for real things and even though one could point that as a merit, to me it is not: I watch anime precisely to find some peace in contrast with the cruel world we live in. But in the end, it's a matter of preferences. I have no problem with other people liking it. Those are the comments that should be made. Expressing one's opinion whilst being open about it, contemplating that maybe it's just not for them. But I think it's wrong to always compare things with other things that share the same bedrock. Madoka was meant to be felt that way, no one really has proof that Mahou Shoujo Site has the objective of throwing any philosophical stuff at you, not every dark anime HAS to portray life in a believable way or has the objective of putting some aspects of life in a philosophical outlook... It could be mindless and still be very dark. It just wants to tell a story, why do you always have to read pretentiousness and laugh at how impossible situations like those are in real life (I've read worse than this, so think twice about you say). Which is an absurd thought process to have watching a fictional media like anime is. I know it may be unfair, but I can't help comparing series that are similar, specially when there's one that stands out as a masterpiece in a certain niche, like Madoka does in the "dark magical girls" subgenre. I had the same problem with Magical Girl Raising Project, which still wasn't as brutal as this one. But yeah, I understand they aren't trying to be deep and it is not really the show's fault that I had the wrong expectations about it. About the pretentiousness, I take that "you" as a general plural, not to me specifically, right? Since I precisely don't find the situations unbelievable, but the exact opposite, and that's the main issue I have with this show. |
| "The world appears wonderful in the eyes of wonderful people." (Alicia Florence, ARIA) |
ToTheSky said: I haven't seen it but I heard enough to stay away. It sounds like the philosophy is... Shit life, here's a magical killing device, let's make everyone but the MC a complete shit, MC kills everyone. If it doesn't end up like that.. maybe it might be worth a look. Every Anime has fans, go talk to them about it if you enjoy the series. I don't see why people need some sort of vindication by the collective masses that it's good. As some one who read the manga, I can tell you that it doesn't go this way at all ^^ The school & the bullies aren't even important after the beginning xD |
There's no possible way you can steal my heart    I want to drown in this sweet Melancholy |
AbeldeMedici said: NostalgiaDrive94 said: Those are the comments that should be made. Expressing one's opinion whilst being open about it, contemplating that maybe it's just not for them. But I think it's wrong to always compare things with other things that share the same bedrock. Madoka was meant to be felt that way, no one really has proof that Mahou Shoujo Site has the objective of throwing any philosophical stuff at you, not every dark anime HAS to portray life in a believable way or has the objective of putting some aspects of life in a philosophical outlook... It could be mindless and still be very dark. It just wants to tell a story, why do you always have to read pretentiousness and laugh at how impossible situations like those are in real life (I've read worse than this, so think twice about you say). Which is an absurd thought process to have watching a fictional media like anime is. I know it may be unfair, but I can't help comparing series that are similar, specially when there's one that stands out as a masterpiece in a certain niche, like Madoka does in the "dark magical girls" subgenre. I had the same problem with Magical Girl Raising Project, which still wasn't as brutal as this one. But yeah, I understand they aren't trying to be deep and it is not really the show's fault that I had the wrong expectations about it. About the pretentiousness, I take that "you" as a general plural, not to me specifically, right? Since I precisely don't find the situations unbelievable, but the exact opposite, and that's the main issue I have with this show. Fair enough. Yeah that was not referred to you, I was talking in general, I got your point about that before. |
Ericonator said: I may have gone a bit overboard but it's the worst first episode to an anime I've ever seen. - Evangelion - Lucky Star - Guardian Hearts those have like the worsts 1st episodes ever. anyway, for me, with only this 1st episode, that looks more like death note than madoka. instead of having a genius that has the best life having a mass murder weapon (the death note) in hands, you have a hated girl that has the worst life possible having a mass murder weapon, kind of. I fail to see how this is bad for now, it looks promising enough. |
zebdalApr 13, 2018 12:40 PM
| Final Fantasy VII is a shitty game. |
zebdal said: Ericonator said: I may have gone a bit overboard but it's the worst first episode to an anime I've ever seen. - Evangelion - Lucky Star - Guardian Hearts those have like the worsts 1st episodes ever. anyway, for me, with only this 1st episode, that looks more like death note than madoka. instead of having a genius that has the best life having a mass murder weapon (the death note) in hands, you have a hated girl that has the worst life possible having a mass murder weapon, kind of. I fail to see how this is bad for now, it looks promising enough. Heh. Let me introduce you to... Divergence Eve. Episode 1 is actually episode 11 IIRC. :D While it is a sci-fi show, there aren't really any temporal gymnastics involved, like alternate timelines or time travel or anything like that which could be used to justify this episode order. They just vomited one of the last segments of the story up front. Did I mention that it's a disastrous pile of poorly made CGI and pointlessly and bizarrely large breasts? Not hot. Just... weird. All the hell that Aya goes thru in Ep1 falls squarely into "realistically plausible", and those who give off the scent of being prey animals would likely draw in potential tormentors just by being visible. The only surprising part is that the poor girl never intentionally hurt herself to get some peace and quiet in the hospital. |
deadman80Apr 13, 2018 4:41 PM
 |
| TBH the 6.66 rating is quite funny for a horror |
| Slice of Life Anime about the everyday life of a German Philosopher: Nietzschijou. |
kidomaro said: So I actually was quite fond of this episode, which then shocked me that so many people are rating it so lowly because I don't feel like this show is as bad as some of the other shows this season who have a higher score than this show. That makes me think what are people feeling about this show/are making them rate it so lowly? I feel the same, because I really like this anime too |
ThreadFazer said: bastek66 said: because tokyo ghoul has interesting plots, development etc..while this one is just weak, all i can see is that this anime is all edgy edgy content with no good plots and good characters.Probably they watched video of certain 23-years-old kid who said it's edgy and bad despite the same manchild is huge fan of Tokyo Ghoul. Tokyo Ghoul was meh. |
Nevalopo said: Liddo-kun said: Well, you said the word "same" so I assumed it was the same as the show. And how would we know that you aren't just making things up? nvm i get why people think its hilarous with bullying or say it's over the top trash show its because people can't relate to it or have ever experienced severe bullying This I can agree with. Most "critical thinkers" or "critics" base on their own experiences on how "realistic" some scenarios can be in stories. They forgot that just because they don''t experience it, it doesn't mean it's not happening to someone else. Juunko Furuta is an example, she actually experienced way worse than the MC in this anime. |
| [quote=newazurilllolwut? Evangelion's first episode wasn't bad.[/quote] yeah my bad, the entire series was bad. |
| Final Fantasy VII is a shitty game. |
| It is so underrated Even a trash like Caligula is rated higher !!! |
| This will give Ashita no Joe a run for its money when it comes to funny humor. @zebdal BnHA has the worst first episode. |
| Yeah right there is no way a doujin about vomit exists. Good song https://soundcloud.com/yeungkakit33/op4-hekireki-last-alliance Tsumino account is BigMaraIppo Another Good Song Listen to テスト by mukami #np on #SoundCloud https://soundcloud.com/mukami/77a Ashita no Joe and Megalo box are disappointing anime. My reviews:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Botan-Chan45/reviews Best Naruto Op: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByCNZxOBVWM&list=RDByCNZxOBVWM&index=1 discord name: Chitoge Kirisaki#9564 https://discord.gg/nGKu6zx my discord server for plebs |
Blarey said: I found it more comedic than serious.Botan-Chan45 said: This will give Ashita no Joe a run for its money when it comes to funny humor. @zebdal BnHA has the worst first episode. Why are you always calling Ashita no Joe a comedy? You do know it’s a drama right? There is almost no comedy in it at all and you would know that too if you watched more than the first episode.. |
| Yeah right there is no way a doujin about vomit exists. Good song https://soundcloud.com/yeungkakit33/op4-hekireki-last-alliance Tsumino account is BigMaraIppo Another Good Song Listen to テスト by mukami #np on #SoundCloud https://soundcloud.com/mukami/77a Ashita no Joe and Megalo box are disappointing anime. My reviews:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Botan-Chan45/reviews Best Naruto Op: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByCNZxOBVWM&list=RDByCNZxOBVWM&index=1 discord name: Chitoge Kirisaki#9564 https://discord.gg/nGKu6zx my discord server for plebs |
Nevalopo said: Liddo-kun said: Well, you said the word "same" so I assumed it was the same as the show. And how would we know that you aren't just making things up? nvm i get why people think its hilarous with bullying or say it's over the top trash show its because people can't relate to it or have ever experienced severe bullying dude ur really funny u should try shitposting more u have like 50 posts please post more |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
newazurill said: your taking his tastes too seriously so every argument you just made is now moot.zebdal said: [quote=newazurilllolwut? Evangelion's first episode wasn't bad. yeah my bad, the entire series was bad. Sorry but hating on NGE and liking shows like madoka and site is the definition of shit taste. |
| Yeah right there is no way a doujin about vomit exists. Good song https://soundcloud.com/yeungkakit33/op4-hekireki-last-alliance Tsumino account is BigMaraIppo Another Good Song Listen to テスト by mukami #np on #SoundCloud https://soundcloud.com/mukami/77a Ashita no Joe and Megalo box are disappointing anime. My reviews:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Botan-Chan45/reviews Best Naruto Op: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByCNZxOBVWM&list=RDByCNZxOBVWM&index=1 discord name: Chitoge Kirisaki#9564 https://discord.gg/nGKu6zx my discord server for plebs |
Sonal1988 said: It's a long standing MAL tradition to hate almost every new series that has been hyped before release. Don't worry. Fans will rank the series higher once all the eps have finished airing. If it ain't popular and have some controversy about similiar tittle then it probably suffer with low score.. |
Xaelath said: Sonal1988 said: It's a long standing MAL tradition to hate almost every new series that has been hyped before release. Don't worry. Fans will rank the series higher once all the eps have finished airing. If it ain't popular and have some controversy about similiar tittle then it probably suffer with low score.. Possible. But I haven't witnessed that here. |
|
Sonal1988 said: Xaelath said: If it ain't popular and have some controversy about similiar tittle then it probably suffer with low score.. Possible. But I haven't witnessed that here. and likewise have been mentioned before lots people compare it with Madoka, literally every dark themed magical girl now compared to it. So its very unlikely to get 8 score above. |
| People just can't handle it and were probably disturbed. I honestly don't blame them. This goes beyond Madoka Magica in terms of being fucked up,and knowing that, I'm sure we are in for one hell of a (good) ride if it stays good throughout the whole series. In my opinion, they should make more fucked up shows like this. |
 |
Yuki_Nonaka said: People just can't handle it and were probably disturbed. I honestly don't blame them. This goes beyond Madoka Magica in terms of being fucked up,and knowing that, I'm sure we are in for one hell of a (good) ride if it stays good throughout the whole series. In my opinion, they should make more fucked up shows like this. Reminds me why shows like Kuzu no Honkai were actually well made and concluded except its kinda fucked up so people hated it. |
| typical shitty weebs, find out new mahou shoujo, watch 1st episode and they realized if this isn't madokami or nonoha they will rate <5. |
 |
| Don't know but somehow I enjoy watching this fellow magical girls killing each other. |
kidomaro said: Pnbn said: 'Cuz everybody try to be elitist shit I dunno why but most people here like dat shitting other opinions and popular mangas adaptation So just watch it if u like it and don't care about others It's just that rating it low might shy other's away from trying it and I don't feel that's fair considering so far I really don't think it's as bad as the score would show People doesn't like it, so they give it a low rating. That is all. Your personal feelings shouldn't affect others rating, you aren't that special. |
| I personally think it's a fine show, but I could have guessed why other people wouldn't like it. As long as something doesn't fit into their personal schema of what they think is good, they will give it a low rating. Even though their schema is not a one-size-fits-all, they lack the self-awareness to either change their judging criteria or realize that the show is simply not for them instead of calling it a "bad" show. They're just self-absorbed and closed-minded that way. That, or they like to feel superior to others using their arbitrary standards of taste. They will try to proselytize and chide you for liking something they don't. They're full of crap. Their fragile psyches cannot handle the fact that their opinions aren't fixed in stone because they will have an existential crisis otherwise. Critical thinking? They mean to say think like them. |
| All of you people need to stop being insecure and enjoy whatever you want |
Cross  AngeHey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste) |
Ligkonakos said: I've seen countlessGangsterCat said: All of you people need to stop being insecure and enjoy whatever you want It's not so much about insecurity as it is about the OP making a valid point. Generally every season there's atleast that one anime that just gets very bad ratings despite being atleast okay from a technical aspect. Because of that, many people shy away due to said bad score and the show remains unwatched; hence after a few years you have people talking about it as "hidden gem" and how people just "have" to watch it. "WAAH WHY THE SCORE SO HIGH?" "WAAAH WHY THE SCORE SO LOW?" It's all meaningless threads full of insecurities |
Cross AngeHey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste) |
| I personally won't give these series a high rating because of OVER THE TOP violence towards MC in ep 1. People she encounters are not just bullies, they're pedophile-rapists, mentally ill, sadistic, narcissist, unbelievably evil cruel and merciless. On top of it all - no one seems to notice or care about these things. I pity the girl and hate the bullies, but i can't really "take this story seriously" because anime is trying TOO MUCH to show us - how bad people are terrible and how sad it is to be this forsaken girl. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mahou Shoujo Site Episode 12 Discussionallenjke - Aug 8, 2018 |
43 |
by Lost_Viking
»»
Dec 11, 12:52 AM |
|
Poll: » Mahou Shoujo Site Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 6, 2018 |
390 |
by Lost_Viking
»»
Dec 7, 12:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Mahou Shoujo Site Episode 9 Discussionibraheem234 - Aug 21, 2018 |
19 |
by Lost_Viking
»»
Dec 7, 12:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Mahou Shoujo Site Episode 11 Discussionibraheem234 - Sep 5, 2018 |
13 |
by L01MK
»»
Sep 8, 2:44 PM |
|
Poll: » Mahou Shoujo Site Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Apr 27, 2018 |
114 |
by Ira_7
»»
Aug 27, 8:10 AM |