Manga DB - Post Modifications/Duplicates Here

MangaRocks said:
Please add the Horror and Tragedy tags to https://myanimelist.net/manga/3486/Shiki - thanks! :) (Proof if needed)

MangaRocks said:
Please add the Shounen-Ai tag to https://myanimelist.net/manga/40813/1001 . (Even M-U agrees. :P :) )

Thanks!

MangaRocks said:
.........Okay, since all of my recent (100% accurate and legitimate, BTW) attempted adds/edits have been summarily denied for some strange reason (despite me knowing what I'm talking about and genuinely trying to help improve MAL's database here), here's a list of edits and adds that need to be made, with explanations of why they need to be edited/added. (So please do, since I apparently can't? Thanks.)



* Yoake Tsugeru Lu no Uta should have have its Annecy award win listed in its 'Background Info' section, just like other entries have their award wins listed there. I did this, but the edit was denied without explanation (despite it being both accurately written and placed in the proper section). Here's some sample text for that field all set and ready for you, even, please just paste it in:

"Yoake Tsugeru Lu no Uta won the 2017 Annecy International Animated Film Festival's Cristal Award for Best Feature film.

(Source: Annecy)"



* 1001 needs to have "1001 Knights" as an English synonym title. (Seriously, it's both the ACTUAL English translation of the Japanese title AND it's even right in the freaking featured image! I don't know why on earth this edit was denied...)



* Silver Diamond Gaiden needs to have 2 chapters, not 'Unknown.' (And I read it, so I should know. If you really need to double-check, though, just look at the inside cover of the darn thing, it lists the number of chapters right there-- TWO {with the extra couple of page listings being omake}.)



* And, finally, I tried to add the Yuri!!! on ICE: Welcome to the Madness manga one-shot to the database, but it was denied with a note saying that it was a doujin (and thus invalid). HOWEVER, it was literally created by Mitsurou Kubo herself (who is not only an established manga author but is the actual creator of YOI in the first place), and this one-shot she made was 100% official, directly connected to the anime, AND was actually given out as a bonus for buying the official anime Blu-Rays/DVD's. And I can point to NUMEROUS examples of titles like this that were ALREADY PREVIOUSLY APPROVED in the database-- see Kaori Ozaki's official-but-independently-published side-story and sequel to her serialized Meteor Methuselah manga, and Ryohgo Narita's official Durarara!! bonus novellas which were released along with its anime DVD's (just like this also-official YOI chapter I tried to add was), as just a few immediate examples. You can't just not apply those same rules across the entire board, my dudes(/dudettes); if those other titles I mentioned and linked to were qualified for approval, then Kubo's YOI bonus manga sure as heck qualifies as well.

MangaRocks said:
Toukei Ibun needs to have the Tragedy genre tag added to it. (Proof if needed.)

Thanks.

MangaRocks said:
Please add both the Drama and Slice Of Life tags to Ao no Flag (proof if needed). Thanks.