| Yes thank you for the rec too ^^ |
Fuzarca said: Holy crap, formatting my post took much more time than I thought it would, and I have no idea why I chose watermelons as a theme, lol. Gonna use grapes for the anime one because why not. Anyway, can someone recommend me a (very) good finished manhua? I always only read japanese manga, guess I got a bit of, I dunno, 'prejudice' against manga from other countries... but I need one for challenge 22 so there's nowhere to run. Only manhua, please, not manhwa. Also, where can I search this? "43 Read a manga with a cast mostly of one gender" You are allowed to change one item from the list for another as long as it's from the same tier to comply with difficulty requirements ^^ Rayyken said: I'm not sure if I can or not, but can I still read things if they aren't on the MAL database? Yes, you can as long as it's considered manga/manhwa or manhua. Webtoons count as well, just link to its page on another site like baka-updates for example so I can check it counts. |
| 2025 Manga Reading Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion 2025 Anime Watching Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion Discord server for MRC/AWC |
| @MRC_mod What counts as an online magazine? It's never specifically stated... Edit: Do you know a good place to find out what has drama CDs? Yes I tried Google |
ScarletCelestialJan 6, 2018 9:08 AM
 |
MRC_mod said: You are allowed to change one item from the list for another as long as it's from the same tier to comply with difficulty requirements ^^ I see, thank you! I actually changed one on my anime challenge list (one that said I had to watch a dropped anime, I only have dropped one and don't want to watch it), but I'll keep the manga list as is, as getting out of our comfort zone is one of the points of this. :) |
  โโโโโโโโโโโโใตใใตใใโโโโโโโโโโโ โโโโโโโโโโโใตใใตใใโโโโโโโโโโโโ โโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโ |
ScarletCelestial said: @MRC_mod What counts as an online magazine? It's never specifically stated... Edit: Do you know a good place to find out what has drama CDs? Yes I tried Google All right, I'll add a note to it soon. It's a magazines that publishes manga in digital format Examples https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/419/Gangan_Online https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/1139/Web_Comic_Zenyon As for where to find what has been adapted to drama CDs, you can use https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?category=Adapted+to+Drama+CD |
| 2025 Manga Reading Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion 2025 Anime Watching Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion Discord server for MRC/AWC |
MRC_mod said: ScarletCelestial said: @MRC_mod What counts as an online magazine? It's never specifically stated... Edit: Do you know a good place to find out what has drama CDs? Yes I tried Google All right, I'll add a note to it soon. It's a magazines that publishes manga in digital format Examples https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/419/Gangan_Online https://myanimelist.net/manga/magazine/1139/Web_Comic_Zenyon As for where to find what has been adapted to drama CDs, you can use https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?category=Adapted+to+Drama+CD Thank You for this! |
|
| @omakase Can you rec something for 78.Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member ? |
| @omakase could you please give me a recommendation for this challenge? "(78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member" |
| @Melt_meltdown Hoshi no Samidare |
ๅฏๅฎคๆฎบไบบใฏใชใ็พใใใฎใใ |
| Dumb question but I want to make sure I do this right. I've finished a couple things already this year and am starting my challenge going from January 1st. For the "Completed manga at sign-up" part do I put what the number was on the 1st instead of what it is today? Also could I get a rec from a staff member and another participant please? Would prefer something in the 3-7 volume range but I'm up for anything. |
  |
letsgomeisei said: Dumb question but I want to make sure I do this right. I've finished a couple things already this year and am starting my challenge going from January 1st. For the "Completed manga at sign-up" part do I put what the number was on the 1st instead of what it is today? Also could I get a rec from a staff member and another participant please? Would prefer something in the 3-7 volume range but I'm up for anything. Let's see. If you're starting your challenge from January 1st, then all the manga you finished before that counts as completed manga at sign-up. :) I feel like recommending Isshuukan Friends. to you, hope you like it. |
wariowariowario said: @omakase could you please give me a recommendation for this challenge? "(78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member" Sure! What about Monster or if you want something shorter, Aku no Hana |
ๅฏๅฎคๆฎบไบบใฏใชใ็พใใใฎใใ |
omakase said: wariowariowario said: @omakase could you please give me a recommendation for this challenge? "(78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member" Sure! What about Monster or if you want something shorter, Aku no Hana Thank you! I'll have to go with Aku no Hana because I've already watched the anime adaptation for Monster. |
| Hi there! I want to start reading manga in 2.018, and this challenge is going to be a killer! Please, recommend me "(44) Read an active staff member's favorite manga" Thank you, and happy New Year :) |
 |
WhiteZuri said: Hi there! I want to start reading manga in 2.018, and this challenge is going to be a killer! Please, recommend me "(44) Read an active staff member's favorite manga" Thank you, and happy New Year :) In this case, it means from MAL's staff members, not the challenge. So you can go into any of the profiles here and choose a manga from their favorite to read. :) Either way, I'd recommend you Kineta's Tomodachi no Hanashi, or any one of Touka's favorites. :P |
HeNrYTG50 said: WhiteZuri said: Hi there! I want to start reading manga in 2.018, and this challenge is going to be a killer! Please, recommend me "(44) Read an active staff member's favorite manga" Thank you, and happy New Year :) In this case, it means from MAL's staff members, not the challenge. So you can go into any of the profiles here and choose a manga from their favorite to read. :) Either way, I'd recommend you Kineta's Tomodachi no Hanashi, or any one of Touka's favorites. :P Thank you for the tip!!! |
|
BrainpanSonata said: @MRC_Mod 8 sets of banners for use in the MRC. (The Ratman banners came out kinda murky... -_-) @MRC_Mod since I don't think editing in the ping in worked |
   |
Ressentiment Gon Kokou no Hito |
Thanks, I will certanly go with Ressentiment. BTW, is just a coincidence that they are all seinen, or somehow you knew that's the demographic I prefer? |
 |
Inujeck said: (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member If you can help me I would appreciate it very much @HeNrYTG50 :D Let me see.. Shaman King is a classic, Hoshi no Samidare is one of my favorites, although I do recommend it to anyone that seems like they will appreciate it, maybe something like RRR. |
Punkero said: Thanks, I will certanly go with Ressentiment. BTW, is just a coincidence that they are all seinen, or somehow you knew that's the demographic I prefer? i just assume everyone on mal is a dude in their 20s |
Works for me. ¯\_(ใ)_/¯ |
| @AudioTsunami Eyy, could I get a rec for 78 / recommended by a challenge staff member? Ideally something that can be read online + is completed. I'm trying to do all finished manga as a sort of self-challenge! If it helps any, I end up reading a lot of seinen, which you seem to as well. |
  |
Romiress said: @AudioTsunami Eyy, could I get a rec for 78 / recommended by a challenge staff member? Ideally something that can be read online + is completed. I'm trying to do all finished manga as a sort of self-challenge! If it helps any, I end up reading a lot of seinen, which you seem to as well. Kokou No Hito Kanojo wo Mamoru 51 no Houhou |
Eyyy, thanks a ton. Hadn't heard either, but going for Kanojo, since it looks like my kind of thing! |
|
@MRC_mod some random words to satisfy the character limit[img]https://i.imgur.com/z9KtCor.jpg[/img] [img]https://i.imgur.com/s7g5XsT.jpg[/img] [img]https://i.imgur.com/zy3YXuN.jpg[/img] [img]https://i.imgur.com/aWy0BpD.jpg[/img] [img]https://i.imgur.com/BR1qQLl.jpg[/img] [img]https://i.imgur.com/UbOFSyf.jpg[/img] |
xYuuJan 6, 2018 11:13 PM
 |
| Hello! Can someone please help me with (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member please? (Sorry if you're busy!) @omakase @AudioTsunami @HeNrYTG50 I don't mind the genre, but preferably I would like it to be 4-7 volumes (or even shorter) since I'm doing expert mode and I'm going to be short on time this year. Really looking forward to participating in the challenge for my third year in a row, thank you staff members for all your hard work! |
| @omakase need a rec for (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member. im not fussy on a genre or length of series ^^ thanks |
| >(10) Read a manga series you can finish in one day: as long i finish it in 1 day, any chapter count is accepted right? >(45) Read a manga that was recently reviewed: since i cant really cheat with this, 1.how do i turn on recent manga reviews 2. as long as i start on the day it was reviewed, not completely that days works right? >(51) Read a gekiga manga: yea no idea wot is dis >(53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group: same, no idea >(62) Read a manga that started serialization the year you joined MAL: ok so most if not all of the manga im interested in fom 2015 are still publishing, how does that work > (74) Read a manga based on real event or person: just needs to say based on right? it doesnt need to be historiccally accurate? >(78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member: so @omakase >(83) Read a manga that is related to something you have previously read: one shots count? >(85) Re-read a manga: do i have to mark it as reread or no , cause when i reread i just set count to zero and start adding again |
| It's good that Slop leveling won the CR awards with such a power gap, Gaijin Weebs don't deserve good anime. Not after what they did to frieren, kusuriya, and many others |
| (17) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Can someone please give me a rec? I would be glad to read something not very long and not depressing (Slice of Life, Comedy, Romance, etc.). |
| Could someone give me a recommendation for item 17, please? :3 Preferably something not very long (10 volumes max). |
 |
| Can I get uhh (17) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread and (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member Would appreciate |
| Are novels not allowed? Also, does reread counts? For example, reading a manga I've completed already. |
 |
VongolaTempesta said: Hello! Can someone please help me with (78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member please? (Sorry if you're busy!) @omakase @AudioTsunami @HeNrYTG50 I don't mind the genre, but preferably I would like it to be 4-7 volumes (or even shorter) since I'm doing expert mode and I'm going to be short on time this year. Really looking forward to participating in the challenge for my third year in a row, thank you staff members for all your hard work! densha otoko suiiki |
oberstein said: I need two recs. One is for: (17) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. The other is from the challenge staff, please @omakase @AudioTsunami @HeNrYTG50 rec me something! As a heads up, it should be a completed manga and I'd prefer if it's not longer than 5-8 volumes, thanks! glaucos gon suikii |
Scarlett_ryuken said: >(10) Read a manga series you can finish in one day: as long i finish it in 1 day, any chapter count is accepted right? >(45) Read a manga that was recently reviewed: since i cant really cheat with this, 1.how do i turn on recent manga reviews 2. as long as i start on the day it was reviewed, not completely that days works right? >(51) Read a gekiga manga: yea no idea wot is dis >(53) Read a manga written by someone from the Year 24 Group: same, no idea >(62) Read a manga that started serialization the year you joined MAL: ok so most if not all of the manga im interested in fom 2015 are still publishing, how does that work > (74) Read a manga based on real event or person: just needs to say based on right? it doesnt need to be historiccally accurate? >(78) Read a manga recommended to you by a challenge staff member: so @omakase >(83) Read a manga that is related to something you have previously read: one shots count? >(85) Re-read a manga: do i have to mark it as reread or no , cause when i reread i just set count to zero and start adding again (10) Yes, any chapter count works for this, even one-shot >(45) You just have to start it on the same day, not finish. Recently reviewed manga are here https://myanimelist.net/reviews.php?t=manga >(51) There's a list of authors in the FAQ under the spoiler tag in the first post of this discussion >(53) Same as above, ask lady_freyja for recs since she knows a lot about this >(62) Nobody said you cannot use on-going haha > (74) It doesn't matter if it's historically accurate, no >(83) Yes, one-shots count >No, you don't have to mark it as re-read, I will trust you on your word xD Shineee_ said: Are novels not allowed? Also, does reread counts? For example, reading a manga I've completed already. Light novels only count for the tier 3 item that requires the light novel type, they cannot be used for any other item. Re-reading counts for anything, yeah. |
| 2025 Manga Reading Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion 2025 Anime Watching Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion Discord server for MRC/AWC |
| I've started reading Kokou no Hito and would like to know if it fits challenge no. 74, Read a manga based on real event or person It says in Wikipedia that it is "partially based on real-life mountain climber Buntarล Katล". So I wonder if it is okay for it to be only loosely based? |
BLOODYRAIN10001 said: @BrainpanSonata could you give me a recommendation for the challenge? Decided to split between manga/anime. Rookies because baseball and good art Kozure Ookami or Blade of the Immortal for excellent samurai action Homunculus if you want good horror in a mundane setting Soil if you want something Twin Peaks freaky I'd say Mushishi, but half the volumes were scanned in the Slap It On The Scanner and Pray method. |
|
| @VongolaTempesta Ashita no Ousama might be right up your alley considering your interest in playwriting? @starfishalliance Terra e... or 11-nin iru! @minzie Hikaru no Go or Sayonara Sorcier @Scarlett_ryuken Doumu or Kanojo wo Mamoru 51 no Houhou @kyleinfinity Nozoki Ana @oberstein Otaku no Musume-san har har |
ๅฏๅฎคๆฎบไบบใฏใชใ็พใใใฎใใ |
| #17 Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Could I get a recommendation from someone? I tend to read only shoujo-type manga and would prefer to change that up. |
 |
| Where are featured manga found for (46) Read a featured manga? |
mewygirl said: #17 Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Could I get a recommendation from someone? I tend to read only shoujo-type manga and would prefer to change that up. I saw you rated the Cross Game anime highly, so I would be incredibly remiss to not recommend Touch, by the same artist and my favorite manga of all time. Since that one is kind of long, however, and I saw Koe no Katachi on your plan to read list I would recommend that 1000%. I haven't finished Monster but I often see it recommended alongside MW, which I have read and enjoyed and if you're looking for something on the more adult-oriented side I'd recommend that as well. |
|
kyleinfinity said: Where are featured manga found for (46) Read a featured manga? It's linked in the explanations list in the signup thread, but you can also find the articles in question in the drop down menu Industry -> Featured Articles. Any manga listed in a given article counts. You'll also need to link the article where the manga was mentioned in your signup form. mewygirl said: #17 Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Could I get a recommendation from someone? I tend to read only shoujo-type manga and would prefer to change that up. Billy Bat and 20th Century Boys are by the same author as Monster. Judge is the sequel to Doubt. Aria and Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou some nice SoLs if you don't want to go full on battle manga with your shounen or seinen. And if you do want to go full on battle manga, Tokyo ESP and Fullmetal Alchemist are good reads. |
BrainpanSonataJan 7, 2018 2:18 PM
|
xAzaelx said: (01) Read a collection of short stories: So, I actually dont know how to find or identify a Manga as a "collection of short stories" everything from this list is an collection of shorts. But it's better to go with some mangaka you like xAzaelx said: (02) Read an award-winning manga Same here, dont really know which manga did win an award. Everything from this list you just have to go here and type what you're looking for |
| ""#17 Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread"" Looking for a recommendation! Fine with any genre, but preferably completed and under 50 chapters. |
1000rosesJan 8, 2018 5:31 AM
 |
More topics from this board
Sticky: » 2025 Manga Reading Challenge - Sign-Up ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MRC_mod - Mar 8 |
339 |
by meowrrs
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Webtoons vs. MangaWisecatmao07 - May 6 |
23 |
by Alex004Alex
»»
57 minutes ago |
|
» Weekly shonen jump issue #42 (table of contests)jacobPOL - 1 hour ago |
1 |
by jacobPOL
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» Occasional manga reader, what's stopping you from reading more of them?fleurbleue - Aug 18 |
14 |
by Exhumatika
»»
Yesterday, 10:23 PM |
|
» What is your favorite manga that got axes (not a rush ending )mistguy23 - Jul 10 |
13 |
by Sondo
»»
Sep 12, 2:52 PM |