Thanks for the effort, you put up a nice list. BUT, it doesn't really make much sense.
Let me explain... Do explainI'm saying that I liked a show, and you (and others) say that it's really bad. So I say: if this one is bad, give me examples of good ones. I'm not trolling, I really mean it, if you guys find this one bad and I like it, maybe you show me even better animes. They are better, so what's the problem?But then you come up with a list and I check them out and....
We are discussing an action/horror anime and when I check your suggestions I see:
1. Psychological romance
2. Comedy drama
3. Comedy psychological drama
4. romance drama
5. action (will check this one out)
6. psychological sports
wth, I stoped checking here.
Sorry, but you are proving you just don't like the genre, not the anime. So instead of checking all of the titles that consists of 20 different anime you only check about six of them and then make stupid assumptions based on about 1/4 of the list's content. It never occurred to you that I might not have put all action/drama/horror/mystery/psychological/seinen/supernatural shows (because unlike you, I've actually taken into account all of the tags and not just two that might fit my agenda) at the beginning of the list? Because if you had decided to control all of the titles, you would have discovered that:
- 3 of the anime have the tag "horror" (Perfect Blue, Paprika, Shinsekai Yori)
- 6 of the shows have the tag "action" (Sennen Joyuu, Baccano!, Inferno Cop, Kara no Kyoukai, Ghost in The Shell, Psycho-Pass)
- 7 of the Chinese cartoons have the tag "psychological" (YST, Mawaru Penguindrum, Ping Pong, GiTS, Paprika, Perfect Blue, Psycho-Pass)
- 4 of the cancerous cartoons have the tag "seinen" (Baccano, KnK, GiTS, Ping Pong)
- 5 of the Japanimations have the tag "drama" (Cross Game, KnK, Mawaru Penguindrum, Nana, Perfect Blue, Sennen Joyuu)
- 7 of the animated TV series/movies have the tag "mystery" (Baccano, Kaiba, KnK, Mawaru Penguindrum, Paprika, Shinsekai Yori, YST)
- 3 of the animus have the tag "supernatural (Baccano, KnK, Shinsekai Yori)
Pretty much all of the anime on my list are tagged with at least one of the genres that TG belongs to. I'd even argue that some of the shows that don't share any tags with TG, like Steins;Gate, should be on that list since it's a thriller and there is a mystery to solve. If you check other anime (and manga!) that I've given a high score but didn't list you'll see that almost every one of them have one or more of these tags (Death Note, Durarara!!, SEL... The list goes on)
Next time I suggest you actually do your research when responding to criticism instead of just basing your arguments on the first six linesThanks again anyway, I appreciate that you took the time to put up that list. Clearly you don't since you didn't even take the time to read my post properly |