Sapewloth said: I am already done preparing my pitchfork, this is just an early warning.Botato said: Not everyone read the VN.Lancer from Fate/Stay Night is criminally underrated. Incredibly badass and is a better bro than Broskandar himself. You better keep that for after UFOtable's UBW finished airing in case his number of favorites doesn't skyrocket (like it should). |
 |
AnarchicSloth said: Funny, you just described Light Yagami too.I think Lelouch is over-rated, he is often considered a "smart" character in anime and is often seen as the the rival of Light Yagami but all we know about his intelligence is that he's good at chess and can pull "plans" out of his ass. |
|
| The fact that Hisoka hasn't risen above Narutard and Ledouche is proof that He is an underloved character. Most misunderstood character in anime, people are just upset that he'll never schwing to them. |
 |
Ratohnhaketon said: Hisoka doesn't need a stupid top list on MAL.The fact that Hisoka hasn't risen above Narutard and Ledouche is proof that He is an underloved character. Most misunderstood character in anime, people are just upset that he'll never schwing to them. |
|
| Overrated: Lelouch, L, Haruhi, Aisaka taiga, Kanade Tachibana,Inori,etc |
  |
| Underrated: Tachikoma from GitS:SAC. Favorite character in the show. :D Overrated: Kirito - has over 11000 favorites... He is too overpowered for no reason, has 0 traits that makes him likeable and interesting, though every girl that sees him wants to hump him. Even little girls. |
 |
robis798 said: Underrated: Tachikoma from GitS:SAC. Favorite character in the show. :D 1 Million percent agreed. |
| Overrated: Lelouch from Code Geass Sebastian Michaelis from Black Butler Underrated: Elizabeth from Gintama |
FloatsBoats said: robis798 said: Underrated: Tachikoma from GitS:SAC. Favorite character in the show. :D 1 Million percent agreed. +1 Underrated: Ushio |
|
Ryukatsuka said: RedRoseFring said: Is that anything new for judals? Wait......this is another of his alts too? I gotta say, this one seems a cut below his usual fraudulent shams. It lacks.........subtlety? Do any of his alternates actually have subtlety though? |
crosx said: FloatsBoats said: 1 Million percent agreed. +1 Underrated: Ushio e.e don't act like i didn't see dat phantom edit. |
silversaint said: i wonder if A-1 ruined Alibaba, Magi fans tell me he is awesome but i thought he was very annoying in both anime seasons anyways underrated http://myanimelist.net/character/1610/Harry_MacDowel Not sure what A-1 did with him, but I quite like Alibaba in the manga so far Also agree with you on that underrated pick. Gungrave itself is underrated |
 |
laldonkaments said: Underrated (and misunderstood):  He's just an a-hole murderer what's there to understand |
|
| Makoto (School days) and Gendo (NGE) are underated. |
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| It would be nice if people state the name of the character instead of posting a picture...and a little reasoning behind the post would be nice too. |
 |
| It seems the word 'overrated' is used as liberally as possible to simply discredit characters people don't like in this thread. What's the point of it all? |
 |
JD2411 said: luffy is overrated as fuck. I really don't see how anyone could like him ichigo and naruto are overrated too but they are more likeable than luffy Likeable =/= good. Look at joffrey from GoT. Though i could not disagree with him beeing overated, because i haven't seen one piece. |
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
| Makoto Itou is extremly underrated, he is the best Harem MC. He act like a man of 15 years but his school has so much bitches (sekai). |
|
JumpinJackCrash said: Every named female character in Hunter x Hunter is underrated/underfavourited; they all have < 100 member favourites each, despite them all being well-written characters. You can't be serious. They don't even have enough focus to consider them as such, I can only agree with Pakunda, maybe. Temoze said: Likeable =/= good. Look at joffrey from GoT. That is true if the character is not supposed to be liked like Joffery. |
|
crosx said: Makoto Itou is extremly underrated, he is the best Harem MC. He act like a man of 15 years but his school has so much bitches (sekai). Agree. |
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
Ryukatsuka said: It seems the word 'overrated' is used as liberally as possible to simply discredit characters people don't like in this thread. What's the point of it all? You've got a point but the truth is that, on average, an anime is more likely to be overrated than not on MAL. So, it's easy to find overrated ones. |
| your waifu is shit |
| did you know that average can also be good? |
tsudecimo said: Temoze said: Likeable =/= good. Look at joffrey from GoT. That is true if the character is not supposed to be liked like Joffery. That's a good point, though as i meantioned before i have not seen even a little bit of OP and sometimes protagonist are not supposed to be liked. (Though knowing that OP is a shounen i suppose that's not the case.) Oh, and penguins from Mawaru Penguindrum are underated as fuck. |
| Signature was not removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Tulip & Flower Guidelines. |
JumpinJackCrash said: Every named female character in Hunter x Hunter is underrated/underfavourited; they all have < 100 member favourites each, despite them all being well-written characters. I think a few favorites didn't always means overrated though. I want to add Bisky and Pakunoda as my favorites character, but if i do that then all of my favorites characters will be from HxH. Kinda weird. XD crosx said: Makoto Itou is extremly underrated, he is the best Harem MC. He act like a man of 15 years but his school has so much bitches (sekai). No he is not. The fact that he is dead is a big evidence that he is a suck man to be considered as a harem king. |
FlashofthebackAug 22, 2014 9:51 AM
IktIkn said: Ryukatsuka said: It seems the word 'overrated' is used as liberally as possible to simply discredit characters people don't like in this thread. What's the point of it all? You've got a point but the truth is that, on average, an anime is more likely to be overrated than not on MAL. So, it's easy to find overrated ones. That's more the fault of the flawed rating system of MAL though, instead of the anime itself being overrated, isn't it? Besides, this is the underrated character thread so that should be irrelevant. |
|
robis798 said: Well maybe, JUST MAYBE, he is liked and up-voted by LN readers because in the LN he's nothing like he is in the anime?Overrated: Kirito - has over 11000 favorites... He is too overpowered for no reason, has 0 traits that makes him likeable and interesting, though every girl that sees him wants to hump him. Even little girls. |
|
Botato said: robis798 said: Well maybe, JUST MAYBE, he is liked and up-voted by LN readers because in the LN he's nothing like he is in the anime?Overrated: Kirito - has over 11000 favorites... He is too overpowered for no reason, has 0 traits that makes him likeable and interesting, though every girl that sees him wants to hump him. Even little girls. he is awesome in the anime though |
AzuStar said: That's not the impression I got from reading that post; robis doesn't find him awesome.Botato said: Well maybe, JUST MAYBE, he is liked and up-voted by LN readers because in the LN he's nothing like he is in the anime? he is awesome in the anime though |
|
Botato said: AzuStar said: That's not the impression I got from reading that post; robis doesn't find him awesome.he is awesome in the anime though no, he obviously loves it. |
| Wut. |
|
| i need sleep |
laldonkaments said: gedata said: [/spoiler] He's just an a-hole murderer what's there to understand Nah he isn't, he just cares for humanity in his own way Yeah he does care and by care I mean likes to shoot them in the face |
|
| Akeno Himejima, best female character in my opinion. She just is sadistic, cute and overpowered at the same time. She is so epic!! :D |
 |
AzuStar said: Editing quote. Very classic.Botato said: That's not the impression I got from reading that post; robis doesn't find him awesome. no, he obviously loves it. |
 Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
This queen is underrated. *_*  |
 |
AzuStar said: Botato said: That's not the impression I got from reading that post; robis doesn't find him awesome. no, he obviously loves it. Maybe he is cool and awesome in light novels, haven't read them. But the fact that even little girls fall in love with him when he has no distinct personality is just ridiculous to me. That means anime is a very bad adaptation if they couldn't manage to show his inner side, which I guess is the best and deeper part of him. The way I see him in anime has no difference from typical harem main characters. |
|
| Levy (Shingeki no Kyojin) he doesn't do anything in the anime and everyone seems to love him |
 |
IzKir said: Levy (Shingeki no Kyojin) he doesn't do anything in the anime and everyone seems to love him What do you mean, just look at this. |
OkashiAug 23, 2014 3:35 AM
IzKir said: Um... did you even watch when he fought the female titan to get Eren back.Levy (Shingeki no Kyojin) he doesn't do anything in the anime and everyone seems to love him |
NeoAnkara said: Shit I JUST saw that XDAzuStar said: Editing quote. Very classic.no, he obviously loves it. I must have seriously needed sleep yesterday.. |
|
laldonkaments said: gedata said: Yeah he does care and by care I mean likes to shoot them in the face For the common pleb he's just a murderer who randomly shoots ppl. For the elitists he's an idealist who wants to purge an overpopulated world short on resources from ppl who just waste them - and therefore don't deserve to live. But yeah, I guess it's kewler to worship charismatic MCs like Lelouch (who killed millions for his vision of a better world) or Dexter I get where you're coming from, but man, that show ended up being such a trainwreck that it's hard to get enthused about any of it's positives (knowing how they all went to waste considering the crap writing) |
|
| shinpachi and kondo from gintama only 200 favorites. why. |
gedata said: laldonkaments said: Nah he isn't, he just cares for humanity in his own way who is he? Yeah he does care and by care I mean likes to shoot them in the face |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » How hard is watch old animes ?Henrique-Senpai - 1 hour ago |
15 |
by SimplyBrazen
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Why is Isekai Anime So Mainstreamdistrict_marvel - Yesterday |
26 |
by ST63LTH
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
» unpopular opinionsST63LTH - 2 hours ago |
20 |
by JoeChip
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
» How terrifying are your wimin?SgtBateMan - 30 minutes ago |
1 |
by tchitchouan
»»
26 minutes ago |
|
» Can someone explain Johan's perfect suicideMazukoChan - 45 minutes ago |
3 |
by tchitchouan
»»
40 minutes ago |