AnimageNeby said: I have mixed feelings about the ending. In a way, they ended it in a rather realistic and mature way, nothing too fancy, not an 'all good' Hollywoodian style, nor the complete opposite neither. It's been a decent and coherent series, with some episodes being really exceptional. All in all, definitely one of the better seinen of this season (or even the last 2-3 years), together with Shin Sekai Yori.
that said, on a more personal level, I still feel a bit frustrating by a sort of...anticlimax. Maybe it's just because I expected to much of it, something like a 'bossfight' in the end, or something drastic, like the Sybil system finally getting it's ass kicked (or at least having to sweat it out). Or even one of the main character (like akane) dying in the end. I dunno. Something really surprising and special. And while it remained realistic, in some respect it also made the ending rather trivial and mundane.
We see Makishima, the main antagonist, go in a rather meek way, simply shot without putting up any fight. In fact, even with all his earlier talk about changing the system and being a psychopathic revolutionary and what not, and all his intelligent plans to make society crumble...he turns out to be a two-time loser, getting shot at a cornfield. His first plan to expose the truth about the Sybil System failed (btw; when he had that talk on the airship with the cyberwoman/guy, he was shown the vid-recording of it...so why the heck didn't he take it with him and exposed it through the Net or some other means??) and now his other master plan to destroy the food-chain was a complete waste of time too. For fucks' sake, I had expected a bit more result of/from the guy. With all his intellectual air and judging others inferior, he didn't do too well neither, in the end.
And the Sybil system didn't brake a sweat. Never was in any bind. And when Akane says 'the people are smarter than you think, they will not put up with this" it sounds wholly unconvincing. I mean: SHE herself abides by the system, and she accepts it. So what is she saying: that she's mùore stupid than the masses around her? That the hoi palloi will rise and disobey or destroy the Sybil system, when she doesn't? Makes little sense. She is, in effect, contradicting herself her own stance.
Yes, there are some things that irked me.
Which is not to say it wasn't a great show. It's just...for me, most anime really end unsatisfactory, I've noted. Do I simply expect too much. It's like there is all this huge building up, but in the end, it never actually delivers in full. I've only known 1-2 anime who actually ended in a satisfactory way.
Could be I'm just difficult. :-)
But make no mistake: I still think this anime was a pearl. It's much, much better than 90% out there.
Yeah, what I love about this ending, is that it isn't much of a conclusion. Personally, I don't see it as an ending at all, and I'm not saying there's going to be a movie or a second season or anything, although if there is I welcome it wholly.
Regarding Makishima, his plan largely counted on him not getting caught. The fact that it ended this way means Kougami won, he outsmarted him. And if Akane hadn't recklessly jumped onto the truck and destroyed its tire, he definitely would have got away, so that's also an extra accomplishment to Akane's character, Kougami isn't the only one who can do field work. Although I definitely agree that he could have done more to secure his success, but at the same time it seems like him to count on his skill and intellect to overcome the situations that confront him. But from the very start of the episode where he says "you never learn" when he has Kougami pinned down, we were shown that the they had already over come him, surpassed him. That's probably why Kougami didn't put up a fight at the hill, he knew he had been defeated. There's definitely a lot more to it than that, but it's barely been a day since the episode aired I doubt everyone will have figure out everything there is to it. But for what it's done, I don't think this episode could have been done better.
As for Akane, this argument probably seems a bit cheap, but right now she's in a position where she is forced to abide by the Sibyl System. What she says, as much as she might not want to abide by the Sibyl System, she knows she has to for the sake of society as it is now. If Sibyl were to disappear over night, the society wouldn't be able to cope with that, I'm sure I don't need to explain why, but it's like if our/your current governing system was suddenly striped of their control overnight, everything would be in chaos. Just like in zombie movies/games, at the start, society is in complete chaos because there is nothing to control it, apart from the fact that there are zombies eating people. If someone were to take charge and work it's way around the situation and organise everything, then maybe society can be reformed and calmed. I might not have explained it very well, but if you watch/read Shingeki no Kyojin (the anime's airing pretty soon, I'd definitely recommend it), which is pretty much set in a world not too different from a zombie apocolypse, it definitely shows what I mean by society taking control of itself and managing its situation, in a way. The point there is that society isn't ready to live without the sibyl system, and Akane knows it. Whether or not it'll happen in her life time, unless they decide to take the more interesting approach and continue the series (because I'm sure they'll do it well), is probably up to us I guess. That's what I like about this ending, it's a win-win whether or not they decide to continue it or not. |