Toaru Majutsu no Index III Episode 24 Discussion

Offline

Nov 2018

47

The whole Fiamma LPSaD and Touma IT/Dragon were butchered... Wow fuck off

Mar 22, 2019 6:40 AM

#4

ap1001

Offline

Apr 2014

306

LPSaD and IT had the impact of a wet fart.

And look at who showed up.

Birdway: do you have time to talk about the great Samuel Liddel Gregers Mathers? Let me tell you how great Golden Dawn is.

Ah birdway as much as I love seeing you, I pray to heaven that NT anime never get made. Plus they cut Stiyl SS anyway.

"You had no free will, you chased your vices along the same path as all of the others." - Shikieiki Yamaxanadu, Diamond in the rough

Mar 22, 2019 6:55 AM

#5

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:
The whole Fiamma LPSaD and Touma IT/Dragon were butchered... Wow fuck off

I thought it was done well

Mar 22, 2019 7:13 AM

#6

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:
The whole Fiamma LPSaD and Touma IT/Dragon were butchered... Wow fuck off

I thought it was done well

Absolutely not. Not even close. Read OT22 scene again the whole scene was totally wrong.
it was rushed it had no tension. Even worse, it seems they had a terrible misunderstanding about the IT and the "thing" that crushed it which Touma was able to communicate with it, instead they interpret it as IB which is wrong.

Mar 22, 2019 7:14 AM

#7

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:

Tiau said:

I thought it was done well

Absolutely not. Not even close. Read OT22 scene again the whole scene was totally wrong.
it was rushed it had no tension. Even worse, it seems they had a terrible misunderstanding about the IT and the "thing" that crushed it which Touma was able to communicate with it, instead they interpret it as IB which is wrong.

Oh man, that means you don’t know, I can’t even tell you since you haven’t read.

Mar 22, 2019 7:19 AM

#8

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Absolutely not. Not even close. Read OT22 scene again the whole scene was totally wrong.
it was rushed it had no tension. Even worse, it seems they had a terrible misunderstanding about the IT and the "thing" that crushed it which Touma was able to communicate with it, instead they interpret it as IB which is wrong.

Oh man, that means you don’t know, I can’t even tell you since you haven’t read.

Haven't read what? NT22? Or are you implying that I didn't read OT22?

Mar 22, 2019 7:22 AM

#9

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:

Tiau said:

Oh man, that means you don’t know, I can’t even tell you since you haven’t read.

Haven't read what? NT22? Or are you implying that I didn't read OT22?

If I told you here it’d be a spoiler

Mar 22, 2019 7:29 AM

#10

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Haven't read what? NT22? Or are you implying that I didn't read OT22?

If I told you here it’d be a spoiler

Mate, just say what volume are you talking about you don't have to spoil anything.
If not, I will explain every context that happened in that scene.

Mar 22, 2019 7:33 AM

#11

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:

Tiau said:

If I told you here it’d be a spoiler

Mate, just say what volume are you talking about you don't have to spoil anything.
If not, I will explain every context that happened in that scene.

If I told you why you're wrong based off of new information then that would be spoiling no matter what.

Mar 22, 2019 7:42 AM

#12

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Mate, just say what volume are you talking about you don't have to spoil anything.
If not, I will explain every context that happened in that scene.

If I told you why you're wrong based off of new information then that would be spoiling no matter what.

Honestly, it seems you have some fundamental misunderstanding here. Either way, the new information is irrelevant here in this episode and OT22. The context wasn't the same and that's the truth.
IT/and Dragon had different context throughout many volumes and Railgun manga. Since NT22 translation is not completed yet using OT22 as basis still stands out.

Mar 22, 2019 7:44 AM

#13

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:

Tiau said:

If I told you why you're wrong based off of new information then that would be spoiling no matter what.

Honestly, it seems you have some fundamental misunderstanding here. Either way, the new information is irrelevant here in this episode and OT22. The context wasn't the same and that's the truth.
IT/and Dragon had different context throughout many volumes and Railgun manga. Since NT22 translation is not completed yet using OT22 as basis still stands out.

There's actually again, a reason for that and its a reason I can't tell you, the misunderstanding here is really you assuming you know what is or isn't IT when its been a mystery since then, and the dragons(which you SHOULDN'T mention appearing there in this forum) is apart of that has been debated since then, so anything you use really wouldn't answer anything here.

Mar 22, 2019 7:51 AM

#14

Cainthazar

Offline

Aug 2013

1481

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Honestly, it seems you have some fundamental misunderstanding here. Either way, the new information is irrelevant here in this episode and OT22. The context wasn't the same and that's the truth.
IT/and Dragon had different context throughout many volumes and Railgun manga. Since NT22 translation is not completed yet using OT22 as basis still stands out.

There's actually again, a reason for that and its a reason I can't tell you, the misunderstanding here is really you assuming you know what is or isn't IT when its been a mystery since then, and the dragons(which you SHOULDN'T mention appearing there in this forum) is apart of that has been debated since then, so anything you use really wouldn't answer anything here.

Stop being such a tryhard sourcefag and explain your point already. Spoiler tag exists for a reason.

Mar 22, 2019 7:54 AM

#15

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Honestly, it seems you have some fundamental misunderstanding here. Either way, the new information is irrelevant here in this episode and OT22. The context wasn't the same and that's the truth.
IT/and Dragon had different context throughout many volumes and Railgun manga. Since NT22 translation is not completed yet using OT22 as basis still stands out.

There's actually again, a reason for that and its a reason I can't tell you, the misunderstanding here is really you assuming you know what is or isn't IT when its been a mystery since then, and the dragons(which you SHOULDN'T mention appearing there in this forum) is apart of that has been debated since then, so anything you use really wouldn't answer anything here.

I DID not say or assume what is "IT" the narration implied that two different things that had appeared. Do not drag this and genuinely read the context in OT2, OT22, Railgun manga, NT4, NT15, NT18. You will see the different contexts that happened.

Mar 22, 2019 7:54 AM

#16

ap1001

Offline

Apr 2014

306

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

Honestly, it seems you have some fundamental misunderstanding here. Either way, the new information is irrelevant here in this episode and OT22. The context wasn't the same and that's the truth.
IT/and Dragon had different context throughout many volumes and Railgun manga. Since NT22 translation is not completed yet using OT22 as basis still stands out.

There's actually again, a reason for that and its a reason I can't tell you, the misunderstanding here is really you assuming you know what is or isn't IT when its been a mystery since then, and the dragons(which you SHOULDN'T mention appearing there in this forum) is apart of that has been debated since then, so anything you use really wouldn't answer anything here.

Again Tiau, stop with this stupid, “it’s spoiler stuff” the only people still talking in this forum are source readers anyway, just say the volume and part. Also I agree with Tom, it’s not IB that crushed IT.

"You had no free will, you chased your vices along the same path as all of the others." - Shikieiki Yamaxanadu, Diamond in the rough

Mar 22, 2019 8:15 AM

#17

MahiaErebeaNegi

Offline

Jul 2016

1467

loli_a_ravioli said:
Oh fucking fuck, did they just fucking confirmed NT adaptation?

Stop it you fucking pieces of shit, don't touch the sequel FFS.

Do they? If so, then fuck it. Better hope it's not release at 2020 or late 2019, and that Nishikiori didn't direct the show again so we won't be suffers on bad direction and bad arts/animations.

Haven't watch the episode yet so I don't know how badly they handled IT here and I won't talk about it now.

Mar 22, 2019 8:40 AM

#18

Congintive

Offline

Jan 2018

3149

So, they are going to introduce Birdway next episode but why there isn't even her name mentioned in the entire OT but they are still going for that so does that mean they are going for NT oh God please just don't let JC ruin NT because both DAL and Index has been a really huge disappointment so far and seems like they are gonna fuck the last episode of DAL I just don't know what to expect from them anymore.

Mar 22, 2019 8:42 AM

#19

allenjke

Offline

Jul 2012

1785

Didn't think we'll see Birdway this season, surprised. Don't know if it's a good or a bad thing, but she is one of my favorite characters so i guess i'll take it.
Not the best way how it should be adapted, but at this point i was expecting worse so it was pretty decent, a bit anticlimatic with IT. Animation was pretty good this time.
I think Hamazura's scene for one time was decently done, not just random running everywhere ...
For some reason thought Mikoto had more action/time for this season, little bit this time and a bit more =/

Mar 22, 2019 9:14 AM

#20

-Stray

Offline

Jul 2014

2850

I have no idea what happened that confirmed an NT adaptation but if that is the case, FUCK.OFF! I don't want any more torture, its hard not to watch something that you started from season 1 up to this point so staying out of it is a no go.

That invisible thing that Touma was talking too barely had any impact at all, no eerie vibe or anything, its like.. just put in there... the direction was so flat I couldn't feel anything this episode, they did Touma V Accel better and thats not saying much.

Mar 22, 2019 9:52 AM

#21

Fede_5000

Offline

Dec 2018

346

allenjke said:
Didn't think we'll see Birdway this season, surprised. Don't know if it's a good or a bad thing, but she is one of my favorite characters so i guess i'll take it.
Not the best way how it should be adapted, but at this point i was expecting worse so it was pretty decent, a bit anticlimatic with IT. Animation was pretty good this time.
I think Hamazura's scene for one time was decently done, not just random running everywhere ...
For some reason thought Mikoto had more action/time for this season, little bit this time and a bit more =/

So she is the "famous" birdway, a name that sounds familiar to me because it's the one a user used to know, the one who insulted me every time I mentioned something bad about index, I wonder what happen to him? I suppose I would have enjoyed the anime like every good blind fan

Mar 22, 2019 10:04 AM

#22

Papa_Scorch

Offline

May 2018

3193

Boring episode. Too much talking.

Mar 22, 2019 10:18 AM

#23

-_entei_-

Offline

Aug 2015

44

allenjke said:
Didn't think we'll see Birdway this season, surprised. Don't know if it's a good or a bad thing, but she is one of my favorite characters so i guess i'll take it.
Not the best way how it should be adapted, but at this point i was expecting worse so it was pretty decent, a bit anticlimatic with IT. Animation was pretty good this time.
I think Hamazura's scene for one time was decently done, not just random running everywhere ...
For some reason thought Mikoto had more action/time for this season, little bit this time and a bit more =/

Sure that's Birdway? Thought we were supposed to be getting our first glimpses at

next.

Mar 22, 2019 10:28 AM

#24

BlaveBliss

Offline

Oct 2017

508

I'm sorry, I'm not feeling anything with this Touma vs Fiamma scenes.

Mar 22, 2019 10:43 AM

#25

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Wow just like that, and I thought the director did ok but it shows how foolish he is and the production team.

Mar 22, 2019 10:58 AM

#26

Ulquiorra

Offline

Feb 2013

24142

His arm grew back like it was nothing, cool.

Mar 22, 2019 11:15 AM

#27

Arjuna777

Offline

Jul 2015

1581

Welp they butchered the Invisible Thing(IT).It was so majestic in the LN.It completely overpowered Fiamma until Touma forced it back in his arm.

At least Misaka was in this episode.

NT anime possibly confirmed,maybe if they change the director and start from fresh they can do well.

Mar 22, 2019 11:33 AM

#28

deg

Offline

Jan 2009

101833

no explanation on how Touma's right hand regenerated instantly like that after being cut-off?

Mar 22, 2019 11:49 AM

#29

Offline

Oct 2018

289

deg said:
no explanation on how Touma's right hand regenerated instantly like that after being cut-off?

Nope. It’s the biggest mystery in the series.

Mar 22, 2019 12:04 PM

#30

deg

Offline

Jan 2009

101833

Tiau said:

deg said:
no explanation on how Touma's right hand regenerated instantly like that after being cut-off?

Nope. It’s the biggest mystery in the series.

i see

and another question i saw some light novel page where it shows there are dragons coming out of the cut-off right arm of Touma so did the anime did not show that or that scene will come out later?

Mar 22, 2019 12:27 PM

#31

Offline

Oct 2018

289

deg said:

Tiau said:

Nope. It’s the biggest mystery in the series.

i see

and another question i saw some light novel page where it shows there are dragons coming out of the cut-off right arm of Touma so did the anime did not show that or that scene will come out later?

Well, no the anime did this part right, that had happened in the second arc against the alchemist, if you’re thinking of something else that wasn’t in Index

But basically you’re supposed to be wondering what the heck is wrong with his arm

Mar 22, 2019 12:34 PM

#32

Offline

Nov 2018

47

deg said:

Tiau said:

Nope. It’s the biggest mystery in the series.

i see

and another question i saw some light novel page where it shows there are dragons coming out of the cut-off right arm of Touma so did the anime did not show that or that scene will come out later?

This is a piece from the LN after the invisible thing started to come out from his arm
"Kamijou Touma used his own power to crush that invisible something.
A different power appeared above that great power that had gathered around Kamijou’s
shoulder. That other power seemed to open up a large mouth and swallow up the first
power. As if this giant mouth was chewing, the air around the shoulder shook looked
like sugar water".
In the anime, they showed us IB crushing the IT which is wrong. So they fucked up here like they always do.

Mar 22, 2019 12:36 PM

#33

Meta_Yoshi

Offline

Feb 2014

3990

I was really, REALLY hoping that Hamazura would finish off Mugino for once and for all, but he just couldn't muster up the courage to follow through with it. Thankfully, for now at least, his words have finally gotten through to Mugino thick head and is now on his side. i just hope that they'll find Takitsubo soon... D=

The stand-off between Fiamma and Toma did feel intense and I certainly wasn't expecting Fiamma to cleaning chop Toma's right arm off completely, but his plan did backfire as Toma's arm went out of control before he got control over it again and had his arm grow back, imagine breaker still intact.

Sadly, Misaka and Misaka clone are still stuck with the end credits scene once again. On the plus side, they do have the means now to get to where Toma and Fiamma are fighting, so it'll be interesting to see if they do take part in the fight or not.

Sound direction wasn't good, but thankfully, the visuals and animation was much better than last week. I know this is asking a lot from the already inconsistent production team, but I just hope they keep this level of quality up for the last two episodes. Please...

Mar 22, 2019 12:49 PM

#34

Offline

Oct 2018

289

TomHazard said:

deg said:

i see

and another question i saw some light novel page where it shows there are dragons coming out of the cut-off right arm of Touma so did the anime did not show that or that scene will come out later?

This is a piece from the LN after the invisible thing started to come out from his arm
"Kamijou Touma used his own power to crush that invisible something.
A different power appeared above that great power that had gathered around Kamijou’s
shoulder. That other power seemed to open up a large mouth and swallow up the first
power. As if this giant mouth was chewing, the air around the shoulder shook looked
like sugar water".
In the anime, they showed us IB crushing the IT which is wrong. So they fucked up here like they always do.

If you’re implying the dragons ate IT then that’s wrong.

Mar 22, 2019 12:50 PM

#35

Leo

Offline

Aug 2013

5104

Mugino is back in this episode.

Touma's arm being cut off was brutal but it grew back.

Mar 22, 2019 12:56 PM

#36

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Tiau said:

TomHazard said:

This is a piece from the LN after the invisible thing started to come out from his arm
"Kamijou Touma used his own power to crush that invisible something.
A different power appeared above that great power that had gathered around Kamijou’s
shoulder. That other power seemed to open up a large mouth and swallow up the first
power. As if this giant mouth was chewing, the air around the shoulder shook looked
like sugar water".
In the anime, they showed us IB crushing the IT which is wrong. So they fucked up here like they always do.

If you’re implying the dragons ate IT then that’s wrong.

Maybe. Maybe not. They key word here is "His own power" And we saw what happened in Railgun manga.

Mar 22, 2019 1:21 PM

#37

Flexstyle

Offline

Jul 2017

352

So now Touma is magically able to regenerate his arm. This show has gotten more stupid each episode

Mar 22, 2019 1:30 PM

#38

Offline

Nov 2018

47

OG_Gattsu said:
So now Touma is magically able to regenerate his arm. This show has gotten more stupid each episode

No, Go back to season one. Heaven canceller questioned Touma if his arm is a piece of fantasy. Since Touma arm can also reattach itself if someone sliced it.

Mar 22, 2019 1:37 PM

#39

Offline

Oct 2018

289

OG_Gattsu said:
So now Touma is magically able to regenerate his arm. This show has gotten more stupid each episode

Touma's arm not being normal has been foreshadowed for over a decade now.

Mar 22, 2019 1:41 PM

#40

FMmatron

Offline

Nov 2016

32013

I'm glad that Mugino is staying around and damn, my man Touma with dem random powers.

One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron

Mar 22, 2019 1:47 PM

#41

Flexstyle

Offline

Jul 2017

352

TomHazard said:

OG_Gattsu said:
So now Touma is magically able to regenerate his arm. This show has gotten more stupid each episode

No, Go back to season one. Heaven canceller questioned Touma if his arm is a piece of fantasy. Since Touma arm can also reattach itself if someone sliced it.

Well they’ve done a shit job of foreshadowing it then.

Mar 22, 2019 2:11 PM

#42

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

564054

The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got seiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

Mar 22, 2019 2:14 PM

#43

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Lolimancer said:
The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got seiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

No it's not. Pretty much it's still JC Staff and the same staff.

Mar 22, 2019 2:15 PM

#44

Offline

Oct 2018

289

Lolimancer said:
The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got seiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

It wasn’t a literal jaw, that’s why they say
“As if”, if they had did a literal dragon jaw not only would that be improper they’d be taking it too literal like you noted with KL having digital zeros

Mar 22, 2019 2:25 PM

#45

CeddyyBearr

Offline

Apr 2015

2619

Mugino is back and instantly going berserk again, damn the destruction she leaves behind. Hamazura handled that situation well.

Touma's right arm shows more mysteries now, I am legit more interested in Touma's arm now than the general plot, as this season has totally butchered it. I probably can say I regret not reading any source material at this point.

Mar 22, 2019 2:25 PM

#46

Offline

Nov 2018

47

Lolimancer said:
The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got ntseiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

it lacked intensity like the LN. In OT22 it felt that the IT definitely was something above LPSaD and can destroy the planet too. In addition, they fucked up big time when they didn't animate the thing that devoured it which has a Giant mouth and swallowed the IT.

Mar 22, 2019 2:36 PM

#47

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Tiau said:

Lolimancer said:
The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got seiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

It wasn’t a literal jaw, that’s why they say
“As if”, if they had did a literal dragon jaw not only would that be improper they’d be taking it too literal like you noted with KL having digital zeros

More of the explanation from the anime from the light novel are making more questions than answers. Japan light novel readers are not pleased with this kind of adaptation so deal with it. I just think the director and the studio just cannot make this series even good as the light novels even are. Remember this is rushed and not even one studio are interested with a series that is a sequel to a light novel series. The series subpar to the light novels which just qualifies it trash to everybody's opinion. Expect it gone Tiau or watch a series you like watching but don't expect this season is great because most of it was cut out which felt awkward. Doesn't matter if at least you are enjoying it but this series is rushed and complex for anime watchers which will never make this series popular or even like by anybody to start.

Mar 22, 2019 2:38 PM

#48

Offline

Dec 2018

196

TomHazard said:

Lolimancer said:
The Invisible Thing's reveal was horrible, this is on par with Accel smacking Kakine with his wings or Knight Leader having digital zeroes fly out of him. In other words, a completely horrible misinterpretation. Pretty much DEEN F/SN tier adaptation at this point, except a bit worse even. It looked like a hand crushed a cheap blob of energy, but it was supposed to be something (see: implied dragon jaw like from Deep Blood) chewing on it until it retreated into the arm socket. Well, you had one job, JC Staff. NT was all but confirmed a year ago when they got ntseiyuus for Othinus and Birdway so I can only pray it's a whole new staff.

it lacked intensity like the LN. In OT22 it felt that the IT definitely was something above LPSaD and can destroy the planet too. In addition, they fucked up big time when they didn't animate the thing that devoured it which has a Giant mouth and swallowed the IT.

Exactly tell Tiau that so that he can understand our language of light novel series for improvement.

Mar 22, 2019 2:41 PM

#49

Offline

Oct 2018

289

KiLLZONE15JYU said:

TomHazard said:

it lacked intensity like the LN. In OT22 it felt that the IT definitely was something above LPSaD and can destroy the planet too. In addition, they fucked up big time when they didn't animate the thing that devoured it which has a Giant mouth and swallowed the IT.

Exactly tell Tiau that so that he can understand our language of light novel series for improvement.

There's some heavy irony that you're agreeing with someone that mentions having KL do literal turn to zero is bad but the anime not doing a literal jaw is bad.

Mar 22, 2019 2:47 PM

#50