Final Rank on MAL
Number 1
14.2%
63
Top 3
14.2%
63
Top 5
21.0%
93
Top 10
34.3%
152
Top 15
9.0%
40
Top 20
3.2%
14
Top 25
4.1%
18
443 votes
BlueXRam said: You are so cruel despite has same avatar.-- Wait, you two are the same person aren't you??--IntroverTurtle said: I don't see it breaking past rank 10. The 1/5 rule really isn't going to help it much. Ha. |
jayss said: Fantasee said: The difference is that SnK had short momentary hype and little content. Hunter x Hunter has grown steadily, score and popularity wise. It's better to compare it to another highly praised long running series like Gintama which has kept its place in top 10 for years nowYeah, HxH's rating will drop. I remember SnK being in the top 10 after it finished. Now it's 24th. Disagree entirely with this. Snk being popular is the main reason why it drop so much. It being popular means that everyone will give it a watch even people that are not interested in this genre. Look at gintama and look on the amount of members in it. it's doesn't have that many members compare to popular series like snk. So I know for a fact that the people that completed Gintama are fans of the series. Same goes for hxh look at the members not that many compare to popular anime, plus it has over 100+ episodes anyone completing that will most likely like the series. 25 episode is a easier task to finish than series with 100+. And that "momentary hype" that you said is complete bullshit! There is a lot of people that are looking forward to snk season 2. Looking at snk stats. over 90 thousand people gave it a 10/10, that's more members that's actually watching hxh at the moment which is around 84 thousand. I'll advice you to shut up and wait a few months to see if this series will maintain this high score or will it drop score. |
keragammingSep 23, 2014 6:09 PM
jayss said: Fantasee said: The difference is that SnK had short momentary hype and little content. Hunter x Hunter has grown steadily, score and popularity wise. It's better to compare it to another highly praised long running series like Gintama which has kept its place in top 10 for years nowYeah, HxH's rating will drop. I remember SnK being in the top 10 after it finished. Now it's 24th. HxH has had quite some hype around it as well for a while now. Also has much less members than SnK, and the more members that join, the lower the score goes typically. After a few months it may very well drop down to barely top 20. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
keragamming said: Disagree entirely with this. Snk being popular is the main reason why it drop so much. It being popular means that everyone will give it a watch even people that are not interested in this genre. Look at gintama and look on the amount of members in it. it's doesn't have that many members compare to popular series like snk. So I know for a fact that the people that completed Gintama are fans of the series. Same goes for hxh look at the members not that many compare to popular anime, plus it has over 100+ episodes anyone completing that will most likely like the series. 25 episode is a easier task to finish than series with 100+. And that "momentary hype" that you said is complete bullshit! There is a lot of people that are looking forward to snk season 2. Looking at snk stats. over 90 thousand people gave it a 10/10. I'll advice you to shut up and wait a few months to see if this series will maintain this high score or will it drop score. No. Attack on Titan is entirely hype no substance or quality. I know a lot of people who liked the show when they first watched it, and then after it was done said they were disappointed. That is why Attack on Titan keeps on going down lower and lower, because people realize it is not that good after you spend a minimal amount of time thinking about the show. That is also why the manga score keeps going down as well. |
| I don't think HxH will drop that much. It's still long and people will less likely start watching it solely because of that. SnK is a lot easier to hate as well, with its obvious flaws in the show even if it does other things very well. |
| It'll probably make it to 5 for a little while but dropped somewhere in the top 10. |
  |
PoeticJustice said: keragamming said: Disagree entirely with this. Snk being popular is the main reason why it drop so much. It being popular means that everyone will give it a watch even people that are not interested in this genre. Look at gintama and look on the amount of members in it. it's doesn't have that many members compare to popular series like snk. So I know for a fact that the people that completed Gintama are fans of the series. Same goes for hxh look at the members not that many compare to popular anime, plus it has over 100+ episodes anyone completing that will most likely like the series. 25 episode is a easier task to finish than series with 100+. And that "momentary hype" that you said is complete bullshit! There is a lot of people that are looking forward to snk season 2. Looking at snk stats. over 90 thousand people gave it a 10/10. I'll advice you to shut up and wait a few months to see if this series will maintain this high score or will it drop score. No. Attack on Titan is entirely hype no substance or quality. I know a lot of people who liked the show when they first watched it, and then after it was done said they were disappointed. That is why Attack on Titan keeps on going down lower and lower, because people realize it is not that good after you spend a minimal amount of time thinking about the show. That is also why the manga score keeps going down as well. The manga score is actually going down, because people want action! which snk at the moment is providing character development and world building atm. Which you don't know since you haven't read the manga. When season 2 comes around we will see how right you're. mayukachan said: I don't think HxH will drop that much. It's still long and people will less likely start watching it solely because of that. SnK is a lot easier to hate as well, with its obvious flaws in the show even if it does other things very well. HxH wont drop since 1, it's not that popular, 2. it's has over 100+ episodes anyone not interested in it will likely just drop it, which will not affect the overall score. If you're talking about obvious flaws which are not getting answers that's not a flaw. |
keragamming said: If you're talking about obvious flaws which are not getting answers that's not a flaw. Well, the main things I've heard (won't disagree or agree) are: - Pacing - Bad characterization/weak characters - "Edgy!!!!11" - Over hyped |
Flashoftheback said: BlueXRam said: You are so cruel despite has same avatar.-- Wait, you two are the same person aren't you??--Ha. *had |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
mayukachan said: keragamming said: If you're talking about obvious flaws which are not getting answers that's not a flaw. Well, the main things I've heard (won't disagree or agree) are: - Pacing - Bad characterization/weak characters - "Edgy!!!!11" - Over hyped -pacing which hxh also has. I wont argue with the characterization part, because the first season really didn't give the characters especially the side characters that much development. Edgy? What the fuck does this mean???? *Goes on google* Doesn't hxh has plenty of that as well? Especially with Gon?? I don't know how a series being hype can be a flaw. Well it can be flaw because it bring all sort of haters to the series as well. That's the disadvantage with seasonal series, they don't get enough content to show the viewers the overall quality of the series. Just imagine hxh having 25 episodes? I would say the characters are one dimmensional, because they really never develop until later arcs. |
| I'm just saying, there's lots more shit people can say about SnK compared to HxH. |
BlueXRam said: IntroverTurtle said: I don't see it breaking past rank 10. The 1/5 rule really isn't going to help it much. Ha. 1/5 responds: "You know nothing of my rule's infinite potential for rank-bumping!" 1/5-sensei too OP, please nerf. It has gone up from 9.09 this evening to 9.11. Could be post-ending hype or not, we'll see for sure in the next few months. |
YunoleffSep 23, 2014 6:35 PM
mayukachan said: I'm just saying, there's lots more shit people can say about SnK compared to HxH. And that's because snk only has 25 episodes while hxh has 148 episodes to show how good it really is. hxh wouldn't be that good if the first season had ended on 25 episodes. That's the point I'm making. The more content a series has the better. Snk ended when it was just ready to start giving characters, character development and world building. |
mayukachan said: I'm just saying, there's lots more shit people can say about SnK compared to HxH. That is mostly just because most have actually watched SnK, and few would be willing to watch HxH. Stupid complaints can be made for any anime. A few I have seen though are: - Gon looks so stupid - So much homo stuff - boring - where are the explosions? - just for kids. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| ^ Oh wow. That's hilarious xD And yeah, I wouldn't have watched HxH but I did, because of the hype people gave it on MAL and I'm up for any special shounen anime. keragamming said: mayukachan said: I'm just saying, there's lots more shit people can say about SnK compared to HxH. And that's because snk only has 25 episodes and hxh has 148 episodes to show how good it really is. hxh wouldn't be that good if the first season had ended on 25 episodes. That's the point I'm making. That's definitely true. If HxH only had it's Hunter Exam arc, it would only be in the low 8s. |
keragamming said: mayukachan said: Well, the main things I've heard (won't disagree or agree) are: - Pacing - Bad characterization/weak characters - "Edgy!!!!11" - Over hyped -pacing which hxh also has. I wont argue with the characterization part, because the first season really didn't give the characters especially the side characters that much development. Edgy? What the fuck does this mean???? *Goes on google* Doesn't hxh has plenty of that as well? Especially with Gon?? I don't know how a series being hype can be a flaw. Well it can be flaw because it bring all sort of haters to the series as well. Gon is hardly edgy, he is probably one of the least edgy shounen mc's. Other than for a short period of time he is mostly calm and composed.. Hunter x Hunter has no major pacing issues, other than Chimera Ant Arc you can't argue any of the arcs were slow because in comparison with other Battle Shounen arcs they're much smaller. SNK has just about no pacing issues at all, whether you claim the recent arc to be world building and character development it just seems slow and dull in comparison to the rest of the manga. Eren is extremely irritable and ill-tempered, so he is pretty edgy as an MC. |
mayukachan said: ^ Oh wow. That's hilarious xD And yeah, I wouldn't have watched HxH but I did, because of the hype people gave it on MAL and I'm up for any special shounen anime. keragamming said: And that's because snk only has 25 episodes and hxh has 148 episodes to show how good it really is. hxh wouldn't be that good if the first season had ended on 25 episodes. That's the point I'm making. That's definitely true. If HxH only had it's Hunter Exam arc, it would only be in the low 8s. Actually, I don't think the Hunter Exams would even warrant that much. It's one of the least liked arcs (check the poll). |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
RedRoseFring said: Actually, I don't think the Hunter Exams would even warrant that much. It's one of the least liked arcs (check the poll). The poll proves nothing because Yorknew and Chimera are stealing all the votes. lol From what I know, Hunter Exam is liked by most people. SNK has just about no pacing issues at all, whether you claim the recent arc to be world building and character development it just seems slow and dull in comparison to the rest of the manga. I'd rather not start a huge debate about this, but the anime definitely has pacing issues and I would only notice it if I watched it two times (which I did). It's definitely good as a show that you watch once per week, but it's quite slow if you watch it all at once. |
MrLief said: keragamming said: -pacing which hxh also has. I wont argue with the characterization part, because the first season really didn't give the characters especially the side characters that much development. Edgy? What the fuck does this mean???? *Goes on google* Doesn't hxh has plenty of that as well? Especially with Gon?? I don't know how a series being hype can be a flaw. Well it can be flaw because it bring all sort of haters to the series as well. Gon is hardly edgy, he is probably one of the least edgy shounen mc's. Other than for a short period of time he is mostly calm and composed.. Hunter x Hunter has no major pacing issues, other than Chimera Ant Arc you can't argue any of the arcs were slow because in comparison with other Battle Shounen arcs they're much smaller. SNK has just about no pacing issues at all, whether you claim the recent arc to be world building and character development it just seems slow and dull in comparison to the rest of the manga. Eren is extremely irritable and ill-tempered, so he is pretty edgy as an MC. Yea, I was talking about the chimera ant arc having slow pacing. Ok, maybe I don't understand the term "edgy" could you explain this term to me? is edgy suppose to mean it's bad or something? This is what I found on google, "tense, nervous, on edge, highly strung, anxious, apprehensive, uneasy, ill at ease, unsettled, unstable" ^ Doesn't these term apply to ever anime? |
keragammingSep 23, 2014 6:45 PM
keragamming said: MrLief said: Gon is hardly edgy, he is probably one of the least edgy shounen mc's. Other than for a short period of time he is mostly calm and composed.. Hunter x Hunter has no major pacing issues, other than Chimera Ant Arc you can't argue any of the arcs were slow because in comparison with other Battle Shounen arcs they're much smaller. SNK has just about no pacing issues at all, whether you claim the recent arc to be world building and character development it just seems slow and dull in comparison to the rest of the manga. Eren is extremely irritable and ill-tempered, so he is pretty edgy as an MC. Yea, I was talking about the chimera ant arc having slow pacing. Ok, maybe I don't understand what "edgy" could you explain this term to me? Who the hell even came up with this term, is edgy suppose to mean it's bad or something. This is the definition I found on google, " tense, nervous, on edge, highly strung, anxious, apprehensive, uneasy, ill at ease, unsettled, unstable" ^ Doesn't this apply to ever anime? I don't know what anime you watch, it doesn't apply to every* anime but it certainly applies to a lot of characters in anime. Gon was certainly acting edgy because he was quick to anger and unstable during the most of chimera ant but his personality overall is the total opposite. Edgy usually has a negative connotation to it, I certainly wouldn't want to be friends with someone who is always on edge. |
| ^Well to Eren defense, he only gets upset when facing titans. You've read the later chapters, you should know that eren is a cool guy when not facing titans that's. This can applies to Kurapika as well, when it comes to the phantom troupes. |
| gave a 10 cause it fully satisfied me and want more hisokas style |
| Cty Best mid |
mayukachan said: RedRoseFring said: Actually, I don't think the Hunter Exams would even warrant that much. It's one of the least liked arcs (check the poll). The poll proves nothing because Yorknew and Chimera are stealing all the votes. lol From what I know, Hunter Exam is liked by most people. Being 'liked' doesn't guarantee anything above a 7 though. I like all of the anime I gave a 7 too. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
BlueXRam said: Is that so? I though it was a present perfect.Flashoftheback said: You are so cruel despite has same avatar.-- Wait, you two are the same person aren't you??-- *had *nod *nod |
RedRoseFring said: Being 'liked' doesn't guarantee anything above a 7 though. It does on MAL. |
mayukachan said: RedRoseFring said: Being 'liked' doesn't guarantee anything above a 7 though. It does on MAL. The plebeian tastes of MAL shall not decide this matter! |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
mayukachan said: RedRoseFring said: Being 'liked' doesn't guarantee anything above a 7 though. It does on MAL. Too true. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
Wojtini21 said: There is 10/10 in Myanimelist ranking scale for some reason. HxH (2011) is one of this reasons. Graphic, plot, music, action, drama. It gave me all of this in no 5000 episodes like shonens but in cool 148. Um...it is 'shonens' too. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| 9.12 holy balls |
insan3soldiern said: ThisI don't know, I don't give much thought to ratings on this site at all. HxH is my favorite shounen by far and one of my favorite anime. That's good enough for me. |
 |
TheRedOtaku said: ya holy fuck, last episode airs and it goes from 10 to 6. Man, is this series that good? I've been planning to watch this for quite some time now but that hype is getting me... y'know, hyped as well. =P It's a pretty good series, but don't hype it for yourself too much. That's like the perfect recipe for disappointment to what may otherwise have been a perfectly enjoyable show. Watching a show with too high expectations can, and most times will, work against its favor. Watch it with a positive outlook, but be realistic and don't expect it to be the greatest thing ever. |
Lynx_7 said: Watching a show with too high expectations can, and most times will, work against its favor. Watch it with a positive outlook, but be realistic and don't expect it to be the greatest thing ever. It's posts like these that you just wish everyone could see and learn from |
TheRedOtaku said: ya holy fuck, last episode airs and it goes from 10 to 6. Man, is this series that good? That's the 1/5 rule effect of MAL ranking. Basically once a series is finished, everyone who didn't watch more than 1/5 of the series, won't have their score counted. |
 |
tsudecimo said: TheRedOtaku said: ya holy fuck, last episode airs and it goes from 10 to 6. Man, is this series that good? That's the 1/5 rule effect of MAL ranking. Basically once a series is finished, everyone who didn't watch more than 1/5 of the series, won't have their score counted. Also most people like to wait at the last airing episode to rate their shows. |
 |
amga20d said: Hunter is # 5 on the ranking .... Awesome :) i like it as much as i love gintama, hunter deserves it |
Celestrial2 said: still doesn't feel entirely fair to me given how much more illegitimate downvotes Gintama (not to mention LotGH) has if you compare their statsamga20d said: Hunter is # 5 on the ranking .... Awesome :) i like it as much as i love gintama, hunter deserves it though on the other hand Gintama' has the advantage of the sequel effect of a 200+ ep prior season |
  |
HaXXspetten said: But you can't see who has more troll votes just by looking at the stats. Amount of 1s =/= amount of troll votes.still doesn't feel entirely fair to me given how much more illegitimate downvotes Gintama (not to mention LotGH) has if you compare their stats |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
IntroverTurtle said: yeah of course I knowHaXXspetten said: But you can't see who has more troll votes just by looking at the stats. Amount of 1s =/= amount of troll votes.still doesn't feel entirely fair to me given how much more illegitimate downvotes Gintama (not to mention LotGH) has if you compare their stats but I can make a logical assumption at least :> |
| |
HaXXspetten said: It's not that logical to assume that though.IntroverTurtle said: yeah of course I knowBut you can't see who has more troll votes just by looking at the stats. Amount of 1s =/= amount of troll votes. but I can make a logical assumption at least :> There's more reasons than just troll votes as to why one series might have more 1s than another. For example how polarizing the series is, how bad the start is, some sudden twist that turns a lot of people off, its popularity, its rank, its genre, its appeal, etc. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| Oh how wonderful, so it has reached the top 5, maybe it will go up a little more and surpass C:AS. |
| Wonder how many Gintama fan boys will make accounts to down vote it now |
Kreemy said: Or how many HxH fanboys have already made accounts to get it to this place in the first place.Wonder how many Gintama fan boys will make accounts to down vote it now |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| The conspiracies... |
jreginald said: I like conspiracies.The conspiracies... |
IntroverTurtle said: Kreemy said: Or how many HxH fanboys have already made accounts to get it to this place in the first place.Wonder how many Gintama fan boys will make accounts to down vote it now A 1/10 affects the score of a series in the 8.50-9.50 range much more than a 10/10. Mathematically each 1/10 is nullified by about 8 10/10s. That's why Lotgh and C;AS despite having 2.8 and 5% more 10/10s than Fmab versus 1% more 1/10s are significantly lower than it ( Not to mention that Lotgh should have a greater boost from 1/5th rule than Fmab due to more episodes.). That's why troll votes count more than fanboy votes. OT: It has already ended and is in the top 5. Though I think it will be #1 or 2 in a few weeks/months. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 18 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Amagai - Feb 4, 2012 |
102 |
by Irfansap01
»»
Oct 12, 5:29 PM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )fishergirl16 - Oct 22, 2011 |
174 |
by EMANZ3
»»
Oct 12, 2:50 PM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Kefkiroth - Jan 21, 2012 |
185 |
by Deebieweeniw
»»
Oct 10, 3:12 AM |
|
» Does “departure! -Opening Tokubetsu-hen-“ actually exist?ryanalexander - Oct 8 |
3 |
by Fusion8707
»»
Oct 9, 6:14 AM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 62 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )HybridMBL - Jan 12, 2013 |
139 |
by TheModerateSnack
»»
Oct 8, 7:07 AM |