| Whenever tensai staff come together. |
| Well, let's see... 2013: Shingeki no Kyojin 2012: None( hopefully this changes after watching Psycho Pass and Shinsekai Yori) 2011: Steins Gate 2010: Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 2009: Hajime no Ippo New Challenger 2008: None 2007: Code Geass R2 2006: Code Geass, Death Note 2005: Mushishi 2004: None 2003: Fullmetal Alchemist So, I'd say for me on average there's about 1 masterpiece per year which is actually pretty good. |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
| How often do a mastermind come out? |
Shuhan said: True storyDepends on how big of a faggot an individual is. The biggest of faggots will probably find a "masterpiece" once or twice in a decade. Those who arent faggots will find one yearly. I feel like a lot of people here are denying the fact that certain anime are masterpieces simply because they don't suit them, I am completely open minded and new to this however so I can watch anime from any style and love it as long as it truly is a masterpiece, but in this discussion my question has sort of been answered as its one a year, this year I can say in my mind there may be 2. Kill LA Kill and monogatari second series. |
| "Okarin... Okarin... I don't know who that is, but when I say his name, I feel warm inside" - Mayuri "Mayushii" Shiina |
| Also there is only one LoGH |
| It is so dense. Every single image has so many things going on. |
| 1-2 one season, 0 the next. You never know how or when a masterpiece will come. Hell, it could even be disguised as plain shit. Then there are crap disguised as masterpieces. |
 |
shattereddreamzz said: Well, the last one I gave a 10/10 came in 2009. So, I am still waiting for a masterpiece for the past 4 years -_- Make it five years, but I doubt I'm going to be giving out any high votes to anime ever again. It's a waste of time to just wait something to happen. Better find the good stuff elsewhere. |
JustALEX said: Depends on your tastes. Some people give out 10s all the time. Others rarely if ever do it. So far this year, my only 10/10 is going to Monogatari Second Season (so far). Damn it i want to watch monogatari s2 even more now :/Can't wait until it finishes so i can marathon it. I agree whit you for someone that is easy to please can have a lot of masterpieces and some don't ever give an anime title masterpiece. |
 |
| Not often to never. It really depends on tastes in the end, though. An 'objective' masterpiece is something very very rare though. Something like that might never come out again. Also, what people consider a 'masterpiece' might be completely different from how someone else sees it. I haven't given out many 10s, and I can can say that it's mostly biased for me, not all of them are 'masterpieces'. A true masterpiece is phenomenal in all aspects it tries to accomplish, has depth, is engaging and unique, complexity, great characters, little to no use of common tropes, is devoid of any plot holes, has masterful trajectory, and a great exposition/resolution. They're aren't really many anime at all that have this, and I can't say any in past years have had all of this. This year being one of the worst in a long time, can't really hold up to any of these expectations. 'True masterpieces' are truly rare. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
samishime said: Not often to never. It really depends on tastes in the end, though. An 'critical'' masterpiece is something Fixed. OT: This year probably Monogatari second season. |
Arararraragi-kun said: Fixedsamishime said: Not often to never. It really depends on tastes in the end, though. A 'critical'' masterpiece is something Fixed. OT: This year probably Monogatari second season. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
Arararraragi-kun said: samishime said: Not often to never. It really depends on tastes in the end, though. An 'objective' masterpiece is something Fixed. OT: This year probably Monogatari second season. No, it is not "fixed", I meant objective. Also no, Monogatari will not be a masterpiece. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
IntroverTurtle said: Fixed It took me a minute to notice what you changed... samishime said: No, it is not "fixed", I meant objective. Also no, Monogatari will not be a masterpiece. There is no such thing as an objective masterpiece, unless you have your own defintion of ''objective''. No one asked for your opinion fool, not to mention that you didn't even watch anything Monogatari related.. |
Arararraragi-kun said: samishime said: No, it is not "fixed", I meant objective. Also no, Monogatari will not be a masterpiece. There is no such thing as an objective masterpiece, unless you have your own defintion of ''objective''. No one asked for your opinion fool, not to mention that you didn't even watch anything Monogatari related.. I have it's just not on my list. Also, I defined what a masterpiece is in the post, if you looked at it. If you're playing that card, who gives a shit about your opinion "fool"? |
nasliwnblOct 23, 2013 1:52 PM
| получить деньги моего друга |
| For me, I run into something I deem 10 worthy every 2-3 months now a days. You'd think I'd have higher standards by now, but I'm still at easy to please as ever. |
 |
Further questions can be directed towards this guy > I have it's just not on my list Lol, classic. |
| Varies on years, and ofcourse depends on opinion. I'd say about 2 each 3 years maybe? |
 |
| Depends. The amount of elitism you have is inversely proportional to how often you find masterpieces. |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
Arararraragi-kun said: Further questions can be directed towards this guy > I have it's just not on my list Lol, classic. Using someone else's thought process as your own, huh? And yes, I have seen it. It's not bad, but it's not great either, it's okay. Characters are good and well done in the first season, and animation is unique. However, in Nisemonogatari, I think they focused on the wrong things, and Hitagi takes a back seat (I don't like it). I doubt the new season does anything the others haven't, even if it is really good. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
j0x said: once a year agree. |
| There is no set figure since quality of shows vary widely, but I would estimate that I come across at least 1 or 2 in a year's time-frame of anime watching. That seems to be my average, although some years there are zero and in 2006 it went as high as ten titles. |
KruszerAug 2, 9:59 PM
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
| Rather than being worried about how often a masterpiece comes out, i'm worried with all the possible masterpieces out there that i never had a chance to watch yet :( Classifying a Masterpiece is hard to define, you could even say that this year there was a couple Masterpieces, but in a few years change your mind and say that afterall there was only one or even zero. |
 |
| I'd say at least one every 4-5 years personally. There aren't any "objective" masterpieces as far as I'm concerned. The conditions for the title of masterpiece varies from person to person. |
| Cowboy bebop is the newest anime that i would consider a masterpiece, and that was 15 years ago, before that was akira for me, so i wouldnt expect a masterpiece anymore sooner than maybe 18 years |
Anime_and_Dota said: The term masterpiece is ambiguous I guess because its based on opinion, but I'm a bit of a scrub when it comes to anime as I've only watched 5 days and everything I've ever seen has been a 9-10/10 except for guilty crown (though it was average at best). So, how often does a masterpiece come out? Movies included I mean something that will be top 100 Sorry, but even with your explanation, it is just too subjective. |
 |
samishime said: guys pls no h8 just aprecy8Arararraragi-kun said: samishime said: No, it is not "fixed", I meant objective. Also no, Monogatari will not be a masterpiece. There is no such thing as an objective masterpiece, unless you have your own defintion of ''objective''. No one asked for your opinion fool, not to mention that you didn't even watch anything Monogatari related.. I have it's just not on my list. Also, I defined what a masterpiece is in the post, if you looked at it. If you're playing that card, who gives a shit about your opinion "fool"? But still man how can you judge monogatari when it is still airing? I think its been a masterpiece so far anyways. |
| "Okarin... Okarin... I don't know who that is, but when I say his name, I feel warm inside" - Mayuri "Mayushii" Shiina |
| If we're going with the MAL ratings as a standard I think there are typically 1-2 very well received shows that come out each year. It gets complicated if we are considering personal masterpieces though since the standard for what qualifies as a masterpiece varies. The two shows I've seen that I would consider masterpieces both came out this decade, so I think that makes me more optimistic about the future of anime than some of the other posters here. |
Anime_and_Dota said: samishime said: guys pls no h8 just aprecy8Arararraragi-kun said: samishime said: No, it is not "fixed", I meant objective. Also no, Monogatari will not be a masterpiece. There is no such thing as an objective masterpiece, unless you have your own defintion of ''objective''. No one asked for your opinion fool, not to mention that you didn't even watch anything Monogatari related.. I have it's just not on my list. Also, I defined what a masterpiece is in the post, if you looked at it. If you're playing that card, who gives a shit about your opinion "fool"? But still man how can you judge monogatari when it is still airing? I think its been a masterpiece so far anyways. "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
| Once a week. |
CRadu said: samishime said: "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. *Unable to grasp the concept of personal taste, the hater continues his mocking campaign.* See you in next chapter! The war on "melodrama" got old ages ago, despite so these people just won't stop beating on a dead horse. You'd think that after so long they'd have gotten tired of it, but nope. |
 |
| IDK & IDC |
 |
| OT: Gintama': Enchousen Alternative Titles Synonyms: Gintama' (2012), Gintama' Overdrive, Kintama Japanese: 銀魂' 延長戦 Information Type: TV Episodes: 13 Status: Finished Airing Aired: Oct 4, 2012 to Mar 28, 2013 ---------------------------- There you go. Inb4 objectivity |
|
| Masterpiece are a myth, everything is subjective. |
Xinil said: Thanks for joining MAL. JOIN MAH CLUB http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=38595 |
Maria_Sama said: Masterpiece are a myth, everything is subjective. Inferno Cop. He surpasses a masterpiece. He and the show are on their own level, a level above that which is consider a masterpiece. |
mbac said: samishime said: "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. based on your replies and MAL list (fellow eva fan), i'd humbly suggest you give LotGH a shot I have, but sadly it was deleted when my old hard drive died... I intend to finish it when I feel like downloading it again haha. CRadu said: samishime said: "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. *Unable to grasp the concept of personal taste, the hater continues his mocking campaign.* See you in next chapter! Personal taste or shit taste? You decide. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
CRadu said: samishime said: CRadu said: samishime said: "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. *Unable to grasp the concept of personal taste, the hater continues his mocking campaign.* See you in next chapter! Personal taste or shit taste? You decide. And on what basis do you get to decide who has shit taste and good taste ? It's god damn subjective. Grasp the concept, Watch your use of that word, Mr. shit-taste. |
| получить деньги моего друга |
| Masterpieces can happen anytime. Maybe 3-4 per year? |
| > Has Texhnolyze in his favorites > Dares to say other people have shit taste .... |
Arararraragi-kun said: > Has Texhnolyze in his favorites > Dares to say other people have shit taste .... Let's agree that everyone who watches anime should not talk about shit taste. It's easier and saves time. Now go back to exchanging 'factual' arguments guys. What was the discussion about again? |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
Ventose said: There is only one Cowboy Bebop Not counting movies, then this. FMA/Brotherhood come very close. |
 |
| i reckon about 2-3 every five years or something, maybe 4 if you are lucky? shattereddreamzz said: Well, the last one I gave a 10/10 came in 2009. So, I am still waiting for a masterpiece for the past 4 years -_- It came out and it was called Steins;Gate you just failed to realize it. |
CRadu said: true storysamishime said: "Masterpiece," says the guy with Angel Beats and Clannad in his favorites. *Unable to grasp the concept of personal taste, the hater continues his mocking campaign.* See you in next chapter! |
| "Okarin... Okarin... I don't know who that is, but when I say his name, I feel warm inside" - Mayuri "Mayushii" Shiina |
| My last 10/10 was FMA:Bro, which ended in 2010. Nichibros was a masterpiece if not for some miss the mark jokes. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Why do girls like making boys cross-dress?BlueMaho - Today |
28 |
by Zarutaku
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» What are the best series that you think scare Anime Tourists away?IpreferEcchi - 52 minutes ago |
11 |
by traed
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» What do you prefer the English title or the Japanese title of an anime ?internetguy214 - 11 hours ago |
31 |
by thewiru
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » The One Piece—are you hyped about it? ( 1 2 )All_Knowing - Yesterday |
58 |
by Fatephile
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Rick and Morty: The Anime Episode 1 DiscussionAshuAmbrose - 7 hours ago |
18 |
by RainyEvenings
»»
17 minutes ago |