DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- So the pupil couldn't surpass the teacher after all. Shinku's fight against Bara Suishou was great, I enjoyed it. The end is good too, but this season is not really better than the first one. 7/10 |
cyruzJul 17, 2008 4:50 AM
 staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| The ending was meh. The fight was good but could of been a lot better imo. |
 |
| It is a shame that nothing got resolved. |
 |
| Confusion, why do Kanaria, Suigin-Tou and Suisei-Seki come back yet Sousei-seki and Hina Ichigo dont? Did rabbit dude just decide to keep their Roza Mysticas and let the others go? |
 |
Heart_of_Storm said: Confusion, why do Kanaria, Suigin-Tou and Suisei-Seki come back yet Sousei-seki and Hina Ichigo dont? Did rabbit dude just decide to keep their Roza Mysticas and let the others go? Barasuishou isn't a real Rozen Maiden. Thus Kanaria, Suigintou, and Suiseiseki unofficially removed from the Alice Game, as it was Barasuishou who defeated them. Souseiseki was defeated by Suigintou. And Hina Ichigo gave her Rosa Mystica to Shinku after no longer having a medium and the Alice Game officially starting with Souseiseki's defeat. |
Asrialys said: Heart_of_Storm said: Confusion, why do Kanaria, Suigin-Tou and Suisei-Seki come back yet Sousei-seki and Hina Ichigo dont? Did rabbit dude just decide to keep their Roza Mysticas and let the others go? Barasuishou isn't a real Rozen Maiden. Thus Kanaria, Suigintou, and Suiseiseki unofficially removed from the Alice Game, as it was Barasuishou who defeated them. Souseiseki was defeated by Suigintou. And Hina Ichigo gave her Rosa Mystica to Shinku after no longer having a medium and the Alice Game officially starting with Souseiseki's defeat. Cool, answered the first question, but now Ive got another :-D Since Barasuisho is a fake, how come the Alice Game started? doesnt it need all 7 Maidens together, or is that not the case? (im guessing not since Sougintou and Hina are out of the picture..) |
| |
Heart_of_Storm said: Asrialys said: Heart_of_Storm said: Confusion, why do Kanaria, Suigin-Tou and Suisei-Seki come back yet Sousei-seki and Hina Ichigo dont? Did rabbit dude just decide to keep their Roza Mysticas and let the others go? Barasuishou isn't a real Rozen Maiden. Thus Kanaria, Suigintou, and Suiseiseki unofficially removed from the Alice Game, as it was Barasuishou who defeated them. Souseiseki was defeated by Suigintou. And Hina Ichigo gave her Rosa Mystica to Shinku after no longer having a medium and the Alice Game officially starting with Souseiseki's defeat. Cool, answered the first question, but now Ive got another :-D Since Barasuisho is a fake, how come the Alice Game started? doesnt it need all 7 Maidens together, or is that not the case? (im guessing not since Sougintou and Hina are out of the picture..) I really don't have a definite answer. Either the producers were making stuff up as they went along (did not follow manga) or Laplace was just screwing with everyone. Laplace was with Barasuishou's creator the whole season. Maybe it was an experiment to see if Rozen's dolls could overcome one that wasn't made by him? I don't know. |
Asrialys said: Heart_of_Storm said: Asrialys said: Heart_of_Storm said: Confusion, why do Kanaria, Suigin-Tou and Suisei-Seki come back yet Sousei-seki and Hina Ichigo dont? Did rabbit dude just decide to keep their Roza Mysticas and let the others go? Barasuishou isn't a real Rozen Maiden. Thus Kanaria, Suigintou, and Suiseiseki unofficially removed from the Alice Game, as it was Barasuishou who defeated them. Souseiseki was defeated by Suigintou. And Hina Ichigo gave her Rosa Mystica to Shinku after no longer having a medium and the Alice Game officially starting with Souseiseki's defeat. Cool, answered the first question, but now Ive got another :-D Since Barasuisho is a fake, how come the Alice Game started? doesnt it need all 7 Maidens together, or is that not the case? (im guessing not since Sougintou and Hina are out of the picture..) I really don't have a definite answer. Either the producers were making stuff up as they went along (did not follow manga) or Laplace was just screwing with everyone. Laplace was with Barasuishou's creator the whole season. Maybe it was an experiment to see if Rozen's dolls could overcome one that wasn't made by him? I don't know. Fair enough, guess I need to read the manga :-D |
| |
| The End was very good, extinguished Barasuishou being was very cool! XD But somebody has information on a continuation? (In anime, of course) |
 |
| I thought that it was an okay ending. I was a little depressed ~ desu. To see that souseiseki and hina didn't come back after the credits just for good spirits. but you win some and you lose some. I would rate this full anime an 8/10 (Rozen Maiden, Rozen Maiden - Traumend + Overature) |
| The ending was pretty good and in a sense emotionally relieving. I'm glad the apprentice wasn't Rozen because he was plain evil. よかった that it ended on a happier note, and that there are other ways to become Alice. And it seems now that Suigintou realizes Shinku isn't an enemy, and that the two have potential of becoming friends again. |
| dammit what happened to hina ichigo!!! so in the end we lost 2 dolls, this is a depressing 7/10 |
 |
| Will they continue it...? That's my question u.U |
// Hearts are wasted, lives are broken. |
| this is pretty much unrelated to Rozen Maiden but i was wondering if anybody has an idea of which anime was advertised at the end of this episode? |
 |
Dark_Valentine said: this is pretty much unrelated to Rozen Maiden but i was wondering if anybody has an idea of which anime was advertised at the end of this episode? It's Binchou tan and REC demo ne...still didn't get any clue..since I saw Laplace and Bara Shuishou together..and Bara's eye patch is reversed.. yea true..have to read the manga lol XD |
| I am gonna miss Rozen Maiden ... and hoping there is a continuing story. |
  |
| A depressing ending, I am sorry for Hina-Ichogi and Sousiseki. I am glad that the pupil wasn't Rozen, and that Shinku stayed to the end of the Alice game. I liked this season, like most second seasons it's a little different, I give it 9/10 |
 ~Vive La Miémorrina~ Play Lolita Caramel | Admire My Artworks Follow Me On Twitter | Read My Drawing Blog |
 Seriously. WTF IS THIS SHIT! GIVE ME MY 1 HOUR BACK! What did Jun did the whole episode? Nothing. Why did the dolls die? For no reason. Was the Alice decided? No. Did Bara Someshit die? No! She didn't die by Shinku's hands. So far thats okay, but she "died" just because of a plot device? She had everything planned, but she couldn't forsee that too many Roza Mystica would kill her? Are this writers really trying!? Why was Laplace's Demon helping those guys? So far he only seems like a plot device to me. Why did that blond f*g made them fight? Whats the point on making Bara thinggy get more Roza Mystica? Why did he... i dunno, evaporate along with Bara Someshit? (Yeah, i really hate her.) Why did the Rozen Maidens did not knew there was other way to become Alice? (Why would Rozen not tell them that? The only possible answer to me is: Plot Device) Why does the characters get underpowered/overpowered out of nowhere? I mean, Suiseiseki never got a Roza Mystica yet she resisted longer than when she last foght Sugintou, who at that time had none. Seriously. Jun was having a great character development, and the producers just defenestrated everything. There were a lot of good ways to use him, yet all he did was...... wait. He didn't do anything. How can people say the ending was good? It didn't change ANYTHING at all. The few last episodes were simply useless. Sure, i hate open endings, but this wasn't even near an open ending. It was screaming: I HAZ A SEQUEL! Yet no sequel was announced so far. Did this project get abandoned? |
RyushiJan 14, 2010 7:27 PM
| Bringing this thread back from the grave since I just finished the series. Bara bara was defeated. Yes, Jun is useless. (I thought Shinku, Suiseiseki, and Suigintou had already established this fact?) The doll that's with Laplace is the real 7th doll Kirakishou or w/e her name is. I enjoyed this series, and it looks like there won't be a 3rd season. However, I am looking forward to reading the manga. That is all. Desu. |
| nice ending, there still a lot of question but it was good. |
| Shinku was awesome when she pwned Barasuishou and Suigintou. It's a pity Souseiseki and Hinaichigo didn't come back. Oh well that's to be expected since they were defeated by real Rozen Maidens. |
| Yay ! I knew there was something fishy about Barasuishou ! Too bad Hina and Souseiseki didn't get revived TwT .. |
| Wow, I was fooled by Barasuisho's creator and Laplace. This was a good series; very fun to watch. I'm pretty bummed Souseiseki and Hinaichigo never came back. Now it's time for the OVAs. =] |
Ryushi said: Seriously. WTF IS THIS SHIT! GIVE ME MY 1 HOUR BACK! What did Jun did the whole episode? Nothing. Why did the dolls die? For no reason. Was the Alice decided? No. Did Bara Someshit die? No! She didn't die by Shinku's hands. So far thats okay, but she "died" just because of a plot device? She had everything planned, but she couldn't forsee that too many Roza Mystica would kill her? Are this writers really trying!? Why was Laplace's Demon helping those guys? So far he only seems like a plot device to me. Why did that blond f*g made them fight? Whats the point on making Bara thinggy get more Roza Mystica? Why did he... i dunno, evaporate along with Bara Someshit? (Yeah, i really hate her.) Why did the Rozen Maidens did not knew there was other way to become Alice? (Why would Rozen not tell them that? The only possible answer to me is: Plot Device) Why does the characters get underpowered/overpowered out of nowhere? I mean, Suiseiseki never got a Roza Mystica yet she resisted longer than when she last foght Sugintou, who at that time had none. Seriously. Jun was having a great character development, and the producers just defenestrated everything. There were a lot of good ways to use him, yet all he did was...... wait. He didn't do anything. How can people say the ending was good? It didn't change ANYTHING at all. The few last episodes were simply useless. Sure, i hate open endings, but this wasn't even near an open ending. It was screaming: I HAZ A SEQUEL! Yet no sequel was announced so far. Did this project get abandoned? All this. I'm really disappointed by this season, especially this crappy finale. It threw away all the good things first season had. |
| What!? aww now full happy ending :[ that bunny guy is just creepy and why is bara still alive? |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| The ending could have been better. Overall the battle scenes were poor though. |
| Sometimes with such series which differ from manga at some point I'm uncomfortable. They seem alike but may be totaly different in how they feel and the meaning. I'm not familiar with the manga. As for anime I'm glad the ending was not shallow and is actualy quite deep. I'm sad for Souseiseki and Chibichigo but it can't be helped at that point. I'm just glad it didn't end in ruin. And we have sort of a resolution for Alice's game too. At least for sisters they lost other dolls became wiser. Even Suigintou developed a touch of compassion and sense. In the beginning she was exactly like Bara Suishou. Alice's game is from those which if you win you loose and if you loose you are lost, so even being sad I consider it's fitting for both Sousei and Hina as they were too willing to start it. Reasons doesn't count. They might if it was a matter of forgiveness but this game is unforgiving and it plays it's pieces once started. But now the pieces have developed into something more free to choose their fate. |
Hell is empty and all the devils are here. |
| The mystery is how did sugintou have 2 rosa mysitca when bara bara have kanaria and suiseiseki's rosa mystica while shinku has hina ichigo's rosa and sugintou only have souseiseki? Hina ichigo back so 7/10 |
XxshizxX said: The mystery is how did sugintou have 2 rosa mysitca when bara bara have kanaria and suiseiseki's rosa mystica while shinku has hina ichigo's rosa and sugintou only have souseiseki? She is a Rozen Maiden herself - so obviously it's her own Roza Mystica. |
 |
| End. |
| There is like 2 weeks delay in my recent reading list I randomly bought discount/second hand manga with cute/mysterious cover.  Use Personal Blacklist extension in Chrome if you just want to Google for a series synopsis, without google slapping MAL score in it. 3/1 |
| Its over D'X im glad every1 is back... well except Hina and Souseiseki but im sure Shinku will be able 2 save them some how! and i loved it when his doll crumbled and he was sad... he deserved it! but it sucks how Bara's still alive with the bunny! The fighting was pretty epic... i thought Shinku actually died 4ever and everything was over i was like "... WHAT?!" haha im glad its continuing though! =D anyway this season was amazing!!! i loved it ^^ |
 |
| Miracle ending... hm... but not too bad. I think better than the first season (more fighting). 8/10 Time to go read the manga. :P |
| Well, I saw the 2 seasons.. and I expcting a better end ... WTF -.- ? I wanted to see Alice and in the end they gave us the same thing that we were watching the whole 2 seasons... THE HAPPY COMPANY WATCHING DETECTIVE KUN KUN! ..... i disliked the end for the reasons that Ryushi gave and I obviusly agree with him in this quote "GIVE ME MY 1 HOUR BACK" ... I am totaly disapointed for that ending.... :/ sorry guys :P |
 |
| "Let's go. Detective Kunkun will start without us." "Alright." The fact that those are the last lines of the series encapsulates everything wrong with this show. My final impression is that Rozen Maiden would've been better off as either a doll harem or a Highlander-esque action anime, not some awkward combination of the two. The second season was better in the sense that it tried to move the overarching story, but worse in the sense that it failed at doing so. What a mess. But I did love Shinku's fights with Suigintou and Barasuishou. Was half of the season's budget spent on that 15-minute sequence alone? |
| Saw this awhile ago in dubbed. ~Desudesudesu great series. |
 |
Stark700 said: ~Desudesudesu lol, thanks for reminding me that I can finally watch that Suiseiseki desu video on YT. She was probably the highlight of the series. |
| Ahh I really enjoyed this whole series! I honestly didn't think I would beause it's sort of a silly concept but it was really fun and super cute. I totally was sitting there at the end like I WANT THEM TO KISS AND HAVE A HAPPY LOVE RELATIONSHIP! Then I was like: Ohh wait... she's a doll......... Then I was fine with it the way it was. I half expected from the beginning that she would become Alice which somehow meant that she would be human and date Jun. Bwee hee hee. |
 |
Hakuromatsu said: "Let's go. Detective Kunkun will start without us." "Alright." The fact that those are the last lines of the series encapsulates everything wrong with this show. My final impression is that Rozen Maiden would've been better off as either a doll harem or a Highlander-esque action anime, not some awkward combination of the two. The second season was better in the sense that it tried to move the overarching story, but worse in the sense that it failed at doing so. What a mess. But I did love Shinku's fights with Suigintou and Barasuishou. Was half of the season's budget spent on that 15-minute sequence alone? I agree that the last words were picked TERRIBLY and hated them, so I prefer to just ignore them... >__>;; I think it did a reasonably good job of mixing the two, and having a relitively good plot. I agree that the second season was much better than the first, but overall I rated this show a 7. Pretty good, but not great. |
|
| I'm glad everybody came back, and as for Hina-Ichigo and Souseiseki, I'm sure Shinku will bring them back. Having the gang back together watching Detective Kun-Kun seemed like a good ending. Overall, this season impressed me more than season 1. Characters, hmm let's see.... Kanaria annoyed me. No complaints elsewhere. 7/10 |
 |
| This episode pissed me off so much. It's rare for me to get so angry at an anime. But damn, there was no development at all for Jun this season 7/10 |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Rozen Maiden: Träumend Episode 11 Discussioncyruz - Jun 26, 2008 |
27 |
by Pentagonion
»»
Aug 31, 2:13 PM |
|
Poll: » Rozen Maiden: Träumend Episode 10 Discussioncyruz - Jun 25, 2008 |
37 |
by Pentagonion
»»
Aug 29, 7:48 PM |
|
Poll: » Rozen Maiden: Träumend Episode 8 Discussioncyruz - Jun 24, 2008 |
21 |
by Pentagonion
»»
Aug 23, 7:50 PM |
|
Poll: » Rozen Maiden: Träumend Episode 7 Discussioncyruz - Jun 23, 2008 |
23 |
by Pentagonion
»»
Aug 19, 6:57 PM |
|
Poll: » Rozen Maiden: Träumend Episode 5 Discussioncyruz - Jun 22, 2008 |
26 |
by Pentagonion
»»
Aug 17, 12:00 PM |