RazielZero said: Also, yes...please give more sh1t to Yoshida so that we may see that annoying whiny little brat more... >_>
Interesting enough, it was Shana who had tears in her eyes, not Yoshida. I don't get all that Yoshida-hate. Shana will get Yuji, if someone will it, but only because she is the main character.
When you focus on the story of them, Yoshida was in love with Yuji long before Shana appeared, she just didn't know how to express herself. If you see it this way, it is Shana who is there to speed up things in the relationship between Yoshida and Yuji, not the other way round. And Yoshida would be a better fit, as Shana is busy fighting and stuff.
Even if you ignore this, Shana wouldn't be anywhere where she is without Yoshida.
Also, all three flame haze stood there in awe and stared when Pheles first captured Yuji. Yes, that includes Shana (who, as i said, was also the one with tears in her eyes later), the one who is totally different from the whiny, useless brat Yoshida.
Yoshida might not be able to do much, but the impact Shana has during situations like this is literally the same - none. She's just waiting, at a loss at what to do, even if she gets her act together (she's been a flame haze for at least several years, being trained for it since she was a small child), she does some stupid attacks (if she doesn't stop because the enemy is threatening to do something to Yuji, which they usually do even if she stops, as thats the perfect time for it) which don't accomplish anything, and someone else has to point her in the right direction, often enough it's Yuji who saves the situation.
Just look at the fight here.
Yuji gets captured by Pheles - Shana does nothing (no, shouting doesn't coun)
Pheles starts doing stuff to Yuji - Shan does nothing.
A huge silver arm coming from inside Yuji pierces Pheles - Shana does nothing.
The arm is draining Pheles power - Shana does nothing
The arm retracts - Shana does nothing
Wilhemina catches Pheles with her ribbons, Shana finally starts doing something.
Margery casts some spells on the silver arm - Shana is worried and doesn't know what to do
Margery tells Shana not to get in the way - Shana doesn't get in the way -> Shana does nothing
Yuji catches the spells for Margery - Shana is worried and doesn't know what to do
Konoe flies towards Yuji, Shana only wonders about it.
Konoe summons her staff and hits the spells, Shana draws her sword
Konoe notices it, shoots something after Shana - Shana dodges, but isn't able to do anything else.
Konoe makes the silver arm disappear and stabs Yuji - Shana is worried, repeatedely tries to fly to Yuji, but to no avail.
Hekate appears - Shana does nothing
Hekate fuses with Konoe - Shana does nothing
Hekate attempts to disassemble Yuji - Shana clashes with Hekate, but Hekate manages to fight her off and to cast a spell on Yuji. Shana notices only now that Yuji is falling.
While falling, Yuji changes into Johan, who promptly flies away with Pheles. Shana only manages to follow Pheles and Johan with quite a delay, gets blast away, falls down, and would have crashed into the ground if not for Alastor, who woke her up, or Margery (!!), who would have catched her. While she is falling, Hecate disappears again, having accomplish nearly all objectives.
After regaining consciousnes, Shana is at a loss again, until Johan, who dropped from Pheles arms, changes into Yuji again. She pursues only then, even though she knew that Johan was inside the Reija Maigo, and even though she saw Yuji change into Johan.
She catches Yuji, hugs him so hard it hurts and has tears in her eyes.
After the short scene where Pheles hands Yoshida the Hougo, theres a small timeskip, so lets see what Shana accomplished compared to Yoshida:
Uh..she was at a loss several times, lost a melee fight with Hekate, who isn't exactly the best fighter for all we know, lost her conscious, nearly crashed into the ground even though she can fly, started several fruitless attempts to get near Yuji, endangered herself despite Alastors warning not to fly too long in the "Magnesia" cast by Fecor..and she finally catched Yuji, getting tears in the eyes because of it, who only was falling down because she failed all the time before. And that wasn't even really needed, i mean, Wilhemina could have used her ribbons to catch him, and Margery was still in the air, too.
And what did Yoshida accomplish? She wished for being able to do something and followed the fight from the ground, staying relatively calm. And then she got distracted by Pheles landing next to her.
So..Yoshida did..nothing. Out of nothing she could have done.
And Shana did..nothing, out of who knows what she could have done. Maybe killing Hecate and Fecor, then helping Margery with scanning the silver, even drawing him out, so Margery could have dealt with it, which also would have let to a "normal" Reiji Maigo, which could even have lead to a conclusion to the story of Pheles/Johan.
I don't know, looks like a 0:0 for me. Now, Yoshida was interested in Yuji long before Shana, makes it a 1:0. If you count that Shana is the main character, it:s 1:1. Seeing that Shana is always fighting, can't cook, insulted Yuji at first etc., while Yoshida is a friendly girl, bringing him and the others bento and other stuff, it could even be a 2:1. It certainly isn't that clear cut, and it's slightly in favor of Yoshida.
Unless you decide to ignore *everything* and simply hate her because she is "disturbing" Shana and Yuji.
And the best thing is, Yuji didn't even acknowledge yet that he knows that they love him, as long as he doesn't notice that, it's moot anyways.
If you watch Fairy Tail, it's like with Gray and Juvia. Juvia is hopelessly in love with Gray, but Gray got no clue and doesn't seem that interested anyways.
I do not hate Shana, and i would totally accept Yuji ending up with Shana and Yoshida just being a friend/her ending up with Ike (though she isn't interested in him right now..), i simply do not get that Yoshida-hate.
Heck, it's worse then with most idiotic main characters, it seems like there are more people who liked Shinji or Shu (Guilty Crown) then Yoshida. |