| Whole Cake Island Arc is one of the worst arcs in One Piece. Just boring. The only good think is fight between Luffy and Katakuri. |
| Nothing else comes to my mind when I think about best fight, so i guess Katakuri vs Luffy top it! tho i don't like the end of it .. Well, we have to wait another masterpiece "fight" from Oda at some point, maybe Wano? anyway, Whole Cake Island Arc is one of the best arcs for sure! |
| What was so special about Luffy vs Katakuri? Katakuri was just another stepping stone for Luffy. Nothing special in that. Even Luffy vs Rob Lucci was much better than Luffy vs Katakuri. The only really good fights that One Piece had were the Sanji's fights, and just until his fight with Jabura. The first time that he used the Diable Jumbe was cool. But after that his fights were just boring. |
| “Right is right even if no one is doing it; wrong is wrong even if everyone is doing it.” ― Saint Augustine |
| only if the pace aren't horrible and letdown resolve... |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
| I can't really agree with the Dogtooth fight being the best. I prefer a fight that has more dramatic tension. Many readers complained about how long and drawn out the Dressrosa arc was. However, the fact that Doflamingo was caging all these powerhouses and shortening it while fighting Luffy was intense. Also, the dramatic tension between Law and Dofi, Kyros and Doffy, everyone had a slightly different reason to hate Doffy lol. Yes, Doffy was a rather one sided villain, I won't argue with that. But Dog-tooth pretty much bent over backwards just because he saw Luffy improve. For his character, I felt like Dogtooth should have prioritized eliminating the threat over waking Luffy up when he becomes unconscious, reminding him that he promised to end it with his next move. Don't get me wrong, I like the character Dogtooth, I just felt it was a bit inconsistent. Yes, Dogtooth apparently hasn't faced someone like Luffy (which in the New World, I find hard to believe) but I feel like his own character was altered just to accommodate Luffy. |
| It wasn't even the best fight in One Piece... There are many fights that are much better than this. |
| It was boring if you ask me. |
| Fight was great and i like how Katakuri overwhelmed most time and pushed Luffy to improve his haki. In my opinion it's better than Luffy vs Rob Lucci. My favorite fight is still Zoro vs Ryuma. Was short but great and made hype on Wano Kuni. We've seen how Zoro got Shusui there and imo first ittoryu hiryu kaen was badass. |
  |
| not even close mate |
| it's pretty much, -luffy gets beaten -luffy gets powerup -luffy defeats enemy it's not reinventing the wheel and the choreography is pretty standard so it's pretty much just like every one piece encounter so far, the war arc has more interesting battle. |
 |
| I didn’t like Whole Cake Island all that much but yes, Luffy Vs Katakuri is absolutely irrefutably one of the greatest fights in all of Manga. Anyone thinks otherwise is just trying to be an edgelord contrarian. The art, the choreography, the sheer will and honour between the two characters, the use of Genius Loci in establishing a mirror match in a mirror world setting - everything from the moment Luffy broke that glass all the way to Snakeman, it is one of the greatest segments in all of One Piece! |
| I found this battle to be boring and drawn out, but not as bad as the Doflamingo vs Luffy fight. I couldn't wait to move on from this fight. That being said, I did like the short scenes of Katakuri telling off his annoying sister and when Luffy covered Katakuri's face with his hat so others wouldn't know his secret. Other than that, this fight was not interesting and felt like most other Luffy vs villain battles. |
Akhdas said: it's pretty much, -luffy gets beaten -luffy gets powerup -luffy defeats enemy it's not reinventing the wheel and the choreography is pretty standard so it's pretty much just like every one piece encounter so far, the war arc has more interesting battle. Did we read the same arc? every single fight in MF was a small skirmish that lasted for 1-3 pages before switching to another character or Luffy running to Ace. Chapter 895 alone is a better written and drawn fight scene than anything in MF. |
SuperRed said: Akhdas said: it's pretty much, -luffy gets beaten -luffy gets powerup -luffy defeats enemy it's not reinventing the wheel and the choreography is pretty standard so it's pretty much just like every one piece encounter so far, the war arc has more interesting battle. Did we read the same arc? every single fight in MF was a small skirmish that lasted for 1-3 pages before switching to another character or Luffy running to Ace. Chapter 895 alone is a better written and drawn fight scene than anything in MF. a glimpse of one piece character displaying their ability and powers is all enough considering how unique their ability are than the standard powerup battle. powerup is pretty common in most shounen and its too often believe it or not, honestly that's all i could ask for in one piece battle. the characters are unique and they show the full extent of how capable they are with their power. |
|
| It's not even a real fight, katakuri was holding back half way through to let luffy get stronger. He even fell on purpose to make luffy believe he won. It's a farce of a fight. |
 |
ichii_1 said: It's not even a real fight, katakuri was holding back half way through to let luffy get stronger. He even fell on purpose to make luffy believe he won. It's a farce of a fight. The only way One Piece detractors can even attempt to try diminish the fight is to straight up LIE about it. Lmfao, you’re pathetic. |
M0nkeyD_Luffy said: ichii_1 said: It's not even a real fight, katakuri was holding back half way through to let luffy get stronger. He even fell on purpose to make luffy believe he won. It's a farce of a fight. The only way One Piece detractors can even attempt to try diminish the fight is to straight up LIE about it. Lmfao, you’re pathetic. Sorry you didn't get the point of the battle. Katakuri put his faith in luffy and also used it to make his siblings stop looking at him like an unbeatable god. |
|
| From a character standpoint, dogtooth is probably one of my favorite antagonists in one piece. His development really was great. |
  come, you sweet hour of death |
| Nope. Luffy asspull power ups are over the top now. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Nah, never. I bet it will look like shit in the anime. |
 |
| Didnt seem anything special to me, every single fight in hxh tops it easily. |
| Katakuri was really fleshed out as a character. He might be the best character in the entire series. |
| damn I'm not reading/watching OP at the moment since I don't like to read/watch when it's airing but when it will end I sure will have content to look forward to. (I will probably read since the anime is garbage) (this is probably a bait but who knwows) |
| It was ok i guess............ |
| Most underated anime on mal: https://myanimelist.net/anime/4651/Yume_no_Crayon_Oukoku?q=Yume%20ni%20crayon |
| luffy vs doflamingo canon version < one pace luffy vs doflamingo filler version < one piece the same would be for katakuri fake crap and animation |
| Hm, I thought it was one of the worst. I know OP isn't a stranger to ass pulls, but the amount in this fight was too noticeable. Especially towards the end where Katakuri quite severely injures himself, doesn't use his spear (which he's very proficient with and luffy was having a very hard time dealing with), and stops using his awakened (which was also dominating luffy) in favor of brawling (luffy's specialty). Quite disappointing. |
╮ (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.) ╭ |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1161 DiscussionFMmatron - Sep 23 |
20 |
by MusaoMAL
»»
6 hours ago |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1159 Discussion ( 1 2 )FMmatron - Sep 2 |
61 |
by 9vash
»»
Today, 3:03 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1160 Discussion ( 1 2 )28012001 - Sep 9 |
53 |
by Asylum0741
»»
Sep 25, 2:44 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1135 DiscussionEoussama - Dec 27, 2024 |
37 |
by mrhamsterman
»»
Sep 22, 4:29 AM |
|
» Editor statement about God Valley (manga spoiler)FMmatron - Sep 19 |
4 |
by Abzy1239
»»
Sep 20, 11:50 PM |