zer0Phi said:AkatsukiShinobi said: On a side note, the only way I can accept the shit idea of having that little uniform on her would have to be the fact that Gurren Lagann was over the top nuts because it was the deconstruction of mecha anime, and this one is the deconstruction of slice of life/school life anime which usually features heavy shameless fan service, making this over the top uniform an ironic slap in the face to those who use fan service as a way to draw in a fanbase as opposed to interesting story and development.
I'm sorry but how can KlK be a deconstruction of slice of life/school life anime if it's different genre? To deconstruct genre you must make anime in that specific genre which follows it's rules but changes some of it's elements that it become no longer typical example of that genre. In the end deconstructed anime is part of specific genre but breaks away from it's cliches and usual themes. If you use only one element of such genre in different genre (just like KlK do this with school as a story setting) and twist it it can only become some kind of parody of that former genre. If KlK would become a deconstruction of something it will be deconstruction of shonen anime because it belongs to this genre and is heavily inspired by other older shonen animes. If you look for deconstruction of slice of life/school life anime check out Aku no Hana. Yeah yeah I know that AnH is not so hot for most anime viewers and it's not cool to call it deconstruction (or even good anime) but in reality it is deconstruction of mentioned genres. Also TTGL wasn't deconstruction of mecha anime. It was it's reconstruction after deconstruction performed by Evangelion.
Something can be a deconstruction while being another genre, deconstruction is the sub genre of the main genre that it's deconstructing. While you say that a deconstruction has to occur in an anime of a specific genre which follows it's rules but changes some elements so that it no longer becomes that genre, can you really tell me that Kill la Kill's school theme isn't a deconstruction of the school life anime, with no changes done while following it's genres basic rules? It takes the elements of school being the most important thing in the students life, and makes it the literal top of the world, it takes the 1st year, 2nd year, and 3rd year superiority complex and turns it into uniform based superiority through single, double, and triple star uniforms, the common trope of the mysterious transfer student shaking things up, this time shaking the foundation of the ruling class in this society, and the fact that the head of the clubs, disciplinary council and student council are the heads of the society, as opposed to simply being the heads of the school. There's more than enough examples for you on how this is a deconstruction of school life anime according to your examples.
Now if you want a parody of school life anime, look to Nichijou, while it's a school life anime, the activities that take place are over the top and insane, but the world is still stable to say the least, the school's a school and the students are students, as opposed to Kill la Kill, which breaks down the not only the setting but the world as well, and rebuilds the genre as the world itself, school life literally becomes a life of school. I'll agree with you on the fact that it's pretty shonen, so why not a a deconstruction of shonen style school life anime? You've seen pages for anime on this site, most have more than a single genre. Just to clarify, something doesn't have to dark and messed up, or overly realistic to be a deconstruction genre, Evangelion while showing a prime example of a deconstruction, shouldn't be used a template for all deconstructions, they won't always be that dark, and they won't always have those kinds of characters, but they can still be deconstructions in the end.
As for me saying that Gurren Lagann was a deconstruction of the mecha anime, I'd have to stick to that, it does destroy tropes and changes cliches, taking them to a natural point, for example, what they did with Kamina, setting him up as the "Red Ranger", a natural born leader, and then doing what they did to his character, forcing not only the main character to take up the torch and thrust him in a position where he needs to grow up quickly, but also forcing Yoko, the main love interest at the time, to move on and give someone else, far from main character status, a try, which we know the result of, leaving her alone at the very end, as well as Simon. When an anime can take you on a trip in a strange new world, and lead you by the hand in a way where tropes and cliches will either catch you by surprise because of how they're either none-existent, destroyed before your eyes, or changed to take a natural course, then it can be seen as a deconstruction of the formula based and reliant on tropes and cliches staying true and unchanged.
Long story short, it not only follows the rules that you set up as definition of a deconstruction, but the actual rules as well. On a side note, I'll take a look Aku no hana, who gives a shit what reviewers say, they're just assholes like you and I, most with a stick up their ass because they think they're hot shit. Same thing with movies, screw reviewers, you watch whatever the hell you want to watch and if you like it, well then bravo my friend. |