katsucats said:Lesley_Roberta said:
Most of you WILL decide that anime is for kids and disappear.
You will have chosen wrong.
I love anime and may always do, but the more I watch it the more I realize there are some sensibilities of anime (or maybe Japanese culture in general) that absolutely grates on me, and these tropes are standing out to me more and more like Santa Claus in the middle of summer progressively wearing brighter shades of red until he ends up in bright pink -- which is just weird! From my interactions with those on MAL, it seems a very large segment of anime fans
like these aspects of anime for the very reason that I dislike them.
There are several reasons for this that I will accept:
- I'm jaded from experience and pessimism.
- Anime is for kids and I'm growing out of it, just maybe many of you haven't noticed yet.
- The majority of script writers (or manga artists) in anime, or perhaps any commercial media, just plain suck; they lack originality and prefer to lift tried-and-tested techniques from proven works, and eventually the trend becomes noticeable to people looking out for them -- but not to newer fans whom they are trying to attract.
#2 remains a possibility and I won't rule it out. There are exceptions to every rule: most adults would probably not read picture books since they are usually targeted at children, although undoubtedly mature ones might exist. This doesn't mean picture books --as the media in themselves-- are
for children, but in more practical usage the
state of the picture book media is targeted towards children. Just the same, there are some anime with very mature subject matters, but the aesthetics and sensibilities will usually be targeted at a younger audience who are more idealistic and haven't been worn down by the experience of the world.
Case in point, for anyone that has played the anime-like JRPG Star Ocean: The Last Hope, is it strange that I find Deputy Shimada (the fat guy in the beginning of the game who's neither a main protagonist or antagonist) the most sympathetic character in the entire game? He's the only person that cuts straight to the chase, instead of wasting time preaching and listening to other people preach about nakama power, justice, "natural" evolution, and a bunch of other nonsense. When Lightspeed Kenny tells him it's shameful that he put his own position ahead of the dreams of others, he retorts, "Is that all you have to say?" -- I thought that was the best line in the game. So unlike the MC, Edge, that gets easily flustered and emotional at every little event. Edge is like a carbon copy of 90% of shounen anime leads that just pisses me off nowadays. It didn't piss me off 5-10 years ago though. I've gradually found it to be more and more silly to the point of being completely unrealistic. Reimi is like a carbon copy of the ditzy airheaded insecure female leads that populate 60-75% of anime, right down to the running gag of her overreacting like a little 11 year old girl and slaps the MC. It must be just me... After 10+ years of the same joke, I can't be the only one that tires of it...