DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| I'm sorry to be the one who starts the topic but… what was the meaning of adapting this if there's nothing following it? This OVA adds little to the S3 ending. |
| Even as a Yui fan myself, from what I'm hearing, yeah this was bad on all fronts. They easily could have made this an hour, like I can't imagine how painful it would feel to wait 3 years, and get this |
Aramtheanimeman said: This was a disgrace. I have red the ln of this thankfully and The ln I really liked cause I wanted to see Yukino and Hachiman. When I heard this was getting animated I was Really happy. But Studio feels ruined My teen romantic comedy life they ruined season 2 and 3 they are the worst studio a blind man can direct better then him. I think the Studio is a flippin Yui fan {Not saying Yui is bad} They animated the Yui parts and Basically left all the Yukino parts. The OVA is a horrible adaptation of the first 4 OreGairu Shin novels, condensing 60,000 words into a mere 20 minutes of animation. A lot of content is either completely cut or rushed and the OVA ends on effectively on a cliffhanger. This is very, very bad, but if you want to know more details then read the spoiler section of this review. The studio being biased and having preferences is quite well-known within the community. It has come as no surprise to me anymore. WizardKnowsNoBou said: As if shin wasn’t bad enough, studio feel had to add original scenes to appeal yui fans... More self-inserts. Ironic given Oregairu is all about none of those shit. |
| Sure I have read parts of Shin along with some summaries which are problematic especially the early parts but this OVA is just bad. This is outrageous why it came out like this instead of adapting something like a mini series of OVAs for Shin where the Hachiyuki fluff moments don't get cut. Someone in feel must have been really salty that the source material and S3 made Yui cry so much to the point that they have to ruin it through this OVA. |
The studio being biased and having preferences is quite well-known within the community. It has come as no surprise to me anymore. I couldn't agree more with what you said there, the only reason why I decided to watch this OVA anyway is because I cared for this series a lot even if it means we have to suffer a lot from the Yui scenes and a lot of stuff which were cut from the original source. And so I gave this a 7/10 rating. |
 |
Aramtheanimeman said: lehuy0210 said: I'm not saying season 2 is bad I loved it if you check my list you will see I rated a 910. When adapting those Volumes studio feels kept All the Yui parts and cutted Any other part.I'm not a kid.season 2 bad ? lmao i know u hate .feel in some aspect but stop being dumb hater kid. Season 2 was only best quality they can produce lmao and u said bad lmao Pretty much. Generally, we still love the series for what it is---even more so if you're a fan of the original Light Novels. But one can't deny the obvious cut-outs that the anime have done. So, @lehuy0210, there's no need to get hostile and defensive about it. I'll say this: I accept the anime as what it is. I firmly believe the anime overall did an exceptional job of bringing out the core elements of the series. But I do have disappointments. That's why, even as a fan, when the obvious cuts that I and many others thought were important for some character, like, Yukino's perspectives in season 3 that should've been there, you can't help but feel some bias in the anime. Also, when certain perspectives and elements are cut, it leads to anime-only people forming false perceptions and conclusions. And in some cases, utter confusion from what I've seen. Which is frustrating in my eyes. The best advice I can give for anime only then is to rewatch the entire series in order to grasp the entire subtext, drama, characters' motives, and the goal of the series as a whole. But, that's just me. RaiYou said: The studio being biased and having preferences is quite well-known within the community. It has come as no surprise to me anymore. I couldn't agree more with what you said there, the only reason why I decided to watch this OVA anyway is because I cared for this series a lot even if it means we have to suffer a lot from the Yui scenes and a lot of stuff which were cut from the original source. And so I gave this a 7/10 rating. You've already seen the OVA? That's surprising since I couldn't find it anywhere. Mod Edit: Merged duplicated posts; please use the edit button. |
Koito91May 14, 2023 4:11 AM
You've already seen the OVA? That's surprising since I couldn't find it anywhere. Yeah, I have watched the OVA although it was in hard Japanese sub. Mod Edit: Removed Link to Copyright Material. |
Koito91May 14, 2023 4:10 AM
|
| A few days ago I read that this OVA focused more on Yui but I thought it wouldn't matter when I watched it, but it was the opposite. It's one of the few times I've been disappointed. I have fresh memories of how season 3 ended, since I saw her again recently, so I don't see the need for them to have focused so much on Yui, since it was quite clear what her position was that she would not give up . (I love the character but...) I translated my opinion into English, so most likely the sense of what I want to say is lost a bit. And something aside, am I the only one who thinks that Hikigaya's voice is different? This was bothering me throughout the episode, it's been 3 years since the 3rd season, but Eguchi is already an adult so there shouldn't be that much change in his voice. (Or did they change Seiyuu? I don't think it's the case, but since it's not in the MAL data yet, it makes me doubt a bit) I think it's the first time I've complained a lot about something I like. xd |
 |
| Yep, that sucked. What HansDevX said about Hachiman's voice was spot on, it was so off. I only liked Iroha insulting Yukino's mom because I still can't stand her and Hachiman's sister acting like a cat, rest of it was just meh to ughhh (mainly the scene with haruno, will forever hate her) |
| Can see where all the complaints were coming from, but I actually enjoyed it That version of Hello Alone worked well for Yui's scene Enjoyed the banter from all the girls, but no Hiratsuka sensei was a bit disappointing This itself made the watch worth it for me |
 |
the first 13 minutes are unwatchable, good thing we got a date with Yui, 8man will surely see how Yui is superior and will break up with that garbage and Yui said to the slut that she will not give up on 8man. Yui best. |
    |
| A clusterfuck all and all, yet this practical 23-minute-long adaptation of the phony outermost layer upon an overwrought and underwritten copy-pasta is always far greater than what the invaluable loss for the environment in six volumes and 180 pages of physical paperback could ever achieve. In addition, seeing Oregairu fans seething in review section was the greatest enjoyment this shit brought to me. And they said this franchise wasn't your average Fooling Around with Your Harem! Catalano said: the first 13 minutes are unwatchable, good thing we got a date with Yui, 8man will surely see how Yui is superior and will break up with that garbage and Yui said to the slut that she will not give up on 8man. Yui best. Man, I have absolutely nothing to go against you other than "Just cope harder".  |
SgtBateManMay 7, 2023 5:29 PM
Help! I need somebody. Help! Not just anybody. Help! You know I need someone. Helpppppp!  |
| Quite liked it, very fun OVA (made to help selling the VN). Btw, it was Watari himself that wrote the scrip for this one, deciding on the contents, first time he wrote the script for a Oregairu anime episode since the s1 OVA. |
I didn't suffer a lot since I'm not really into this shipping war, to begin with, but I find this OVA really suggestive, should it exist or not? From what's being shown is Yui trying to rebound(?) Well more like trying to steal 8man lol. I like both Yui and Yukino but Yui in particular, I felt like this OVA ruins her character, well not in the case for SOME Yui fans, but it feels very odd to see this route after what legit happened in S3. Another thing I can't help but notice and wonder whether certain moments between Yukino and 8man were omitted from the OVA that were present in the light novel? I haven't read the Shin light novel so kek call me clueless for this. The conversation between Yui, Komachi and Iroha was funny, wished there were more of these. |
"......If I told you that I was a real witch, would you believe it?"  |
TiagoCosta said: Quite liked it, very fun OVA (made to help selling the VN). Btw, it was Watari himself that wrote the scrip for this one, deciding on the contents, first time he wrote the script for a Oregairu anime episode since the s1 OVA. Now, that explains the witty dialogues, lol. |
| Tbh I didn't really like how they adapted the story which focuses more on HaciYui than HaciYuki as it should be like in novel. Well at least I got some lovely scene from Yukinon 💕   |
| these scores are yiiikes, there's only 1 torrent so far and it has weird subs, is this OVA really bad to the point where it's not worth waiting for better fansubs? |
Euroqean said: This OVA was embarrassing they're trying so hard to make Oregairu into a harem its hilarious. Not to mention the source novel oregairu SHIN has questionable writing anyway so of course FEEL./producers decided to add their "creative" take on it to add salt to the wound. The subs are not great. Overall the OVA is not worth watching. btw to all of y'all Yui is trash. these scores are yiiikes, there's only 1 torrent so far and it has weird subs, is this OVA really bad to the point where it's not worth waiting for better fansubs? |
| This OVA is a heartwarmer. I loved it. Hachiman is finally developing his bonds with Yukino and her family. Yui however won't give up easily... Well, they didn't adapt vol 14.5 as I was expecting; but I really liked this. So good to see Komachi and Isshiki together as well. |
 |
| what the hell was this all about ? lmao this was nothing i want my 30 mins back |
 |
| yukinon is garbage |
|
MAXproARYAN said: yaa.. right. I agree with youI really didn't like it. They ruined yui , iroha's and komachi's character |
| What the fk is this? Do they have dementia? Don't they know that the story is already complete? They think they are pleasing Yui fans? they are killing Yui fans, the whole development of Yui's character just all collapsed. From crying out all of her tears and admitting her loss to now stealing 8man?! oh my goodness, I can't even look at her face anymore, she is my favourite character in SNAFU, but now her character just fell apart and this whole thing just make no sense anymore. |
| Roxy Migurdia~ yes~ ahh~ |
| Hey... Does anyone still remember about the sensei? where is sensei? I know she's been transferred, but come on! Don't let the sensei ship reach the seabed, I know she's a submarine equipped with Dongfeng missile ready to sunk all ships... |
| Well, that does it for this franchise. Season 1 and its OVA = youll always be special to me. I look forward to rewatching you again in the future. Season 2 and its OVA, season 3 and its OVA = Nice knowing you, but ill never watch you again. |
oooo3333May 15, 2023 11:05 AM
| The drawings are actually not too bad in this episode and fairly consistent, solid for an OVA. The content and the way feel approached it was bizarre though. I'm not crazy into the main two girls in the series so my bias isn't quite there (only real character I loved in the rewatch was Hiratsuka by a lot), but there definitely seemed like an imbalance here in both the first and second halves respectively. The content with Iroha, Komachi and Yui could have easily been removed, that added nothing whatsoever and was a waste of time overall. Not great. |
Catalano said: yukinon is garbage This adaptation is a whole can of garbage. You want some wish fulfillment at the cost of the series' original premise, ideas, and characterizations? You got it. You want more of Yui? You got it. You want this to be ship war? You got it. I mean, you got it in Season 3, and now this OVA. Put your head in and indulge in it. |
More topics from this board
» Who wants a Yui route?saikyozero - Jul 2, 2023 |
27 |
by badabass
»»
Mar 14, 7:24 AM |
|
» What's the likelyhood of this getting dubbed?MrYandereFan26 - Aug 2, 2023 |
4 |
by Reversign
»»
Aug 3, 2023 5:39 PM |
|
» Is this after S3 Finished or its between some timeline?WomboComboLongo - Jan 22, 2021 |
37 |
by Asudox
»»
Jul 30, 2023 11:59 AM |
|
» How much does this OVA adapt?TsutanaiFuun - Jul 6, 2023 |
4 |
by GeoXsf9
»»
Jul 8, 2023 5:53 AM |
|
» Who opened the door at the end of the episode?SMERQY - May 29, 2023 |
9 |
by Ricky16
»»
Jun 20, 2023 8:46 AM |