deg said: this is hindsight bias at work it happens in real life too It isn't. It is common sense. Tengen collapsed and Gyuutaro went out of his way to check whether his heart was beating or not instead of just slashing his head off? SparCy said: Tengen collapsed and gyutaro checked his breathing and saw he wasn’t so he assumed he was dead. So Gyuutaro checked whether Tengen's heart was beating. He had so much time and consideration but didn't just slice Tengen's head off to ensure he is dead? Eren_Cho said: Uzui's heart had stopped, he was supposedly dead. Why slicing a body?? Plus, he had to eliminate actual survivors like Tanjiro and Nezuko. Yes, he was short on time. So what does he do? Check Tengen's heartbeat to ensure he is dead lmao. Why not just slice Tengen's head off which will not only ensure that Tengen is dead but also save time? |
 |
SparCy said: Dude it’s an anime it’s not meant to be realistic if you want that go watch live action. It would of been stupid if tengen just got killed off screen and the viewers won’t feel anything towards his death. It was handled very well how people thought he was dead and then came back out of no where. It was badass as fck. You probably need to watch something else if you want realism cause this LITERALLY HAS DEMONS IN. It’s not meant to be realistic. It’s supposed to be fun So, lower my standards to accept sub-par story-telling? No. And just because it has demons in it doesn't mean anything works lol. So why not make Tanjiro fly? It has demons in it, right? It isn't realistic anyway. That will be stupid, won't it be? Because the demons are an established part of the show with defined rules like not being able to survive in the sun. So just because you insert a supernatural creature in a show doesn't mean you can throw away common sense. I never said Uzui should have died off screen. The author could have handled it differently. Why even create a difficult situation in the first place if you can't even get your characters out of it properly? The way the author handled it was stupid. |
|
| In action story, most of the creator prefers drama over logic, KnY is no different, if it were to follow irl logic or irl common sense, tanjirou would've been dead since season 1. |
| Go read 'Mediterranean Hegemon of Ancient Greece' If you like webnovel with historical, military and kingdom building genre. |
Eren_Cho said: That's so extra and morbid. Why would you behead a dead body? If the heart stops, the person is dead. It's a law of nature! The fact that he happened to bump into the only two exceptions is bad luck. On top of that, demons have a superiority complex, he wouldn't waste his time slicing heads of humans, even if they were alive, to appear like a coward. Demons would torture them like true predators. That isn't extra. Do you know what is extra? Checking the heartbeat of your enemy who has fallen down. It takes 5 to 10 seconds at least. While beheading him would have taken a single second. He would not have wasted time slicing his neck. It happens in an instant. He actually wasted his time checking his heart beat. |
|
SparCy said: I think it would of been worse if he dies cause then people would of got the impression that every arc another hashira is gonna die, which they don’t. As we also saw in this ep gyutaro likes to play with his prey. He could of killed tanjuro at any moment but he didn’t, he watched him run and squirm around. This could of also been the case for tengen. He though he was dead so he went for his next plaything. Also I looked at you ratings and i think you just don’t like demon slayer. you’ve rated alot of things higher than demons slayer, that the majority of people would say are on the same level as or lower then demon slayer. It’s your opinion so you do you but there isn’t really any issues with it. Demon slayers plot is average but it’s the aesthetic that draws people in. If your not enjoying it just drop it cause if your rating an anime a 4 theres so point to keep watching it even if it’s popular. Yes, I never wanted him to die. But the way Tengen "tricked" Gyuutaro was stupid. We also know Gyuutaro is jealous of Tengen. I don't understand why someone like Gyuutaro would check his opponent's pulse (which takes unnecessary time + you can be attacked) instead of just beheading them (which takes a single second) to make sure they are dead. It fits in line with Gyuutaro's chatacter and considering he doesn't like the way Tengen looks, it makes even more sense than Gyuutaro would have buried his weapon in Tengen's head there. The case with Tanjiro is different because Tanjiro was alive + Tanjiro's scar is ugly so he doesn't feel jealous + Tanjiro isn't a threat, the hashira was a threat. And on top of that, Tanjiro was a brother like him. So, it makes sense why he would play with him. I have read the manga for Demon Slayer and it is 7/10 in my opinion. Compared to that, I have rated the anime a lot less, right? :P I prefer the manga for Demon Slayer over the anime. There are a lot of problems with the way Ufotable has handled the anime. I won't go into details here though. I am just waiting for the last arc to be adapted. Also, can you tell me which ones from my list do you think are not as good as DS but I have rated them higher than DS? |
|
Eren_Cho said: troilus_05s said: That isn't extra. Do you know what is extra? Checking the heartbeat of your enemy who has fallen down. It takes 5 to 10 seconds at least. While beheading him would have taken a single second. He would not have wasted time slicing his neck. It happens in an instant. He actually wasted his time checking his heart beat. First of all, we don't know how he checked the heartbeat. It could have been the hearing alone, as demon have enhanced senses. Secondly, even if he checked with his hand, it's a safe measure itself. Human are supposedly the most fragile creatures in this universe, they die very easily and don't regenerate. Why dicing them if you think it's over? Anyway, let's say that we have different opinions and end it here. Our interpretations are different, so there's no point to talk about it further. No one said dicing. A single hit is enough. Considering Gyuutaro hates Tengen because of how he looks, it makes all the more sense that Gyuutaro would cut his head. But anyway, let's stop here. Have a good day. |
|
| This is an issue with both demons and demon slayers, and things like this are my number one issue with the show, I think if you want to enjoy demon slayer you just have to give up on wanting a logical plot, and just watch for the fight scenes, and if you enjoy it, the humour. |
Call me Ren  |
Narukuke said: Fkyourmom said: and why do you think he is stupid? Any special reason.Yeah....all of them are stupid...or u ccan mangaka thinks we r stupid lol...but it's nothing compared to the stupidness of demon king muzan By he do you mean Muzan? If I answer that question, it will be spoiler territory. Have you read the manga? |
|
| Just your typical tropey villain behaviour. When on the cusp of victory, do whatever is necessary to give the protagonist(s) an avenue back into the fight. To be fair to anime, it isn't the only medium where this happens. |
| It's called generic writing. |
 |
deg said: troilus_05s said: It isn't. It is common sense. Tengen collapsed and Gyuutaro went out of his way to check whether his heart was beating or not instead of just slashing his head off? common sense is not so common even science says so maybe Gyutaro just wants to be more efficient so he goes to Tanjiro first that is more alive and able than the rest anyway we already know Demon Slayer is a classic simple story so if youre looking for more realism then this show is not it I mean...asking for the villains to have basic sense isn't realism, right? Gyuutaro's only problem was Tengen so when Tengen collapsed, he checked his heartbeat....? What? Why not just stab him? And Gyuutaro hates Tengen too because of the way he looks. He has so many reasons to bury his weapon in Tengen's head. Tanjiro was never a problem to him. He was playing with Tanjiro for so long. Anyway, I expected too much of KnY... Have a good day! |
|
deg said: troilus_05s said: I mean...asking for the villains to have basic sense isn't realism, right? Gyuutaro's only problem was Tengen so when Tengen collapsed, he checked his heartbeat....? What? Why not just stab him? And Gyuutaro hates Tengen too because of the way he looks. He has so many reasons to bury his weapon in Tengen's head. Tanjiro was never a problem to him. He was playing with Tanjiro for so long. Anyway, I expected too much of KnY... Have a good day! sure but there are anime that you should turn of your brain and just feel the hype and rule of cool and most battle shonen like Demon Slayer is one of those Yeah. Can't disagree with that. |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Xenocrisi - Dec 12, 2021 |
193 |
by Zadion
»»
Aug 30, 11:36 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 5, 2021 |
276 |
by Zadion
»»
Aug 27, 8:58 PM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Feb 13, 2022 |
481 |
by addictedtoliving
»»
Aug 14, 2:32 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 6, 2022 |
551 |
by Magpareddi
»»
Aug 14, 2:21 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba: Yuukaku-hen Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Xenocrisi - Jan 9, 2022 |
384 |
by addictedtoliving
»»
Aug 13, 8:45 PM |