Attack on Titan
| Went from a 9 to 8/10 might go down to 7 after the new pages or maybe 6, really though the manga had peaked in RTS so the ending isn't the nly thing that degraded it. |
__kami said: "but with the chapters after 131," also I'm talking about the arc, not the entire series. The series for me is a 7-8/10.hayzi said: Witnessing the rumbling arc degrade to what it is today has probably been the saddest shit I've seen in awhile. It's very disappointing to see just how bad Isayama fumbled the bag. This arc could've been an easy 10/10, but with the chapters after 131, I can't rate it higher than a 3/10. The extra pages in 139 haven't changed my rating since they're not that bad, but definitely not good either. i still don’t understand how your rating can drop that low just from one chapter |
| for me it went from a 10 to a 9. i still love aot and rating it low just because of a bad ending would be dumb |
 # of bans: 4@NoLiferSoul is an S+ tier MAL Staff member @anime-prime and @AlexPaulLEWZ are S tier Rest are mid |
| I now have it at a 5. My old score was a 7 and I already didn't like it so the ending just made it drop to a 5. |
| Sakura Matou is best girl in all anime and its not even close |
JohnySins100 said: Eren’s character was literally retconned and destroyed by Isayama. Hail Eren? Slave to Ymir’s “plan”, never achieved his own goals and actually went again his core beliefs multiple times, accepted death at the hands of his friends and refused to kill either his friends or the traitors from the alliance, never acted on his romantic feelings for Mikasa until his dying breath. Not sure how anyone can rate Eren highly after that last arc. Pathetic MC which is not technically his fault but Isayama’s dogshit writing.From 10/10 to 9/10 Leaks:8/10 The ending left some underanswered questions but for the story of Eren who is mc is good ending. Hail Eren |
 |
reallythatbad said: I also think the only deserved 10/10 rating is RtS/S3P2. I also think the ones like yourself that are hating on WFP as much as they are right now is mostly because the events that occurred were rendered useless by the following chapters (correct me if I’m wrong). Isayama retconning characters and story elements made the sci fi twist with paths a bad decision when you think back on it and Ymir is just wasted potential. But at the time, that twist and WFP in general was seen as a top tier arc in AOT by pretty much 99% of manga readers. I still think that WFP on its own is a top 3 arc of AOT, but with the ending it makes most of what happens a complete waste of time and lives.it's pretty weird that so many people give 10/10s to season 1-3. the only part of the story that I thought was close to a 10 was probably just season 3 part 2. if season 4 part 1 had a better adaptation it could've been close too but we got stuck with MAPPA. and everything after sasha died was as garbage as it was in the manga chapters 107-139 really shat on 9 years worth of solid storytelling. |
|
| After rereading the pages and look at some analysis the ending is starting to grow on me. And personally, this was the only logical ending to AOT I loved it. Though we can all agree it is rushed. |
| If you think Eren sacrificed for nothing, you're smoking |
| Went from a 10 to a 3. The ending was so shit that it literally made the whole manga pointless and i can't even, for example, rewatch the first season of the anime without thinking about the dumb and stupid 'plot twists' that should have stayed in the draft. |
 |
| Changed from an absolute 10/10 to a very generous 9.0/10 (8.50/10). In fact, an 8.0/10 would probably be more accurate but the series is too good and memorable to fall into the 8.0 category for me. |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni  |
yaegerist-15 said: Eren erased all titan powers, gave his friends 60+ years in peace (seen with Granny Mikasa) The time war broke out there were skyscrapers meaning 50+ more years have passed. There is no such thing as internal peace for humanity lolOmniScience5 said: why is this the only logical ending and what did Eren accomplish?After rereading the pages and look at some analysis the ending is starting to grow on me. And personally, this was the only logical ending to AOT I loved it. Though we can all agree it is rushed. Why logical? one word resources |
| If you think Eren sacrificed for nothing, you're smoking |
| It was a 10/10 before the ending. And is still a 10/10 after the ending. I wonder how on earth people can lower the score that much after only one chapter. Even though the ending obviously matters a lot its legit less then 1% of the story. |
 |
| Went from 6 before the extra pages to a 3 once the extra pages were revealed. Way to many retcons and character assassinations to me. Before the rumbling arc, overall I'd give it a 9 but now a masterpiece has been destroyed. |
 |
| It went from a 10 to a 9 to a 6 then 7 then 8 and now it sits comfortably at a 1. My ratings for this manga have been really weird, I know lol. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Honestly saw the extra pages and I changed my original score from an 8 to like a 6 idc what people say the ending does play a key factor into the story and this ending was bad but the extra pages made it worse. It might be a 5 honestly if I read it again. |
| Still 10/10. This is a manga in which I laughed and cried, in which I fell in love with so many great characters. |
| marley arc-135 is the peak,i give it a 10,then it went downhill,i did not score it,i always change it from 9>8>6then repeat,then decide to not score it final score:2/10 |
 |
| After reading the 139th chapter, I gave it a rating of 9/10 because atleast it was bearable but then Isayama had to drop the extra panels bomb for god knows what reason and after reading that unnecessary piece of shit, I felt so pissed off like never before while reading some manga and gave it a rating of 1/10. |
 |
| It was 9/10 until chapter 123 after that till chapter 130 /131 it was 7/10 after those chapters it be became 8.5/10 but after the ending 7.5/10 I rounded it to 8/10 |
 |
| For me the whole story 7/10 can enjoy the journey untill the hero turn to villain lol |
| 7/10 After that ending. I dont think so by any means it deserves under 5 score. 1 chapter can't change that all hype, excitement of past chapters. |
 |
| I didn't read complete manga from start, so I will rate from Uprising: - Uprising: 9/10 - pretty slow but I enjoyed manga ver. more than anime - RTS (including basement): 10/10 - Best arc imo - Marley: 9.5/10 - Really good but some chapters were a bit boring to read. - Wfp (ch 106-119): 9/10 - Enjoyed it a lot but felt like a lot of stuff was handled poorly - Paths (ch 120-123): 11/10 - kino chapters probably no one hates them - Rumbling (ch 124 -139): 3/10 - Really badly written, feel nonsensical, a lot of chapters were cringe and nothing made actual sense by the end. The only saving grace were 2 kino chapters 131 and 130. Overall it went from 10/10 (during kino chs) to 4/10 by the end |
| Chapters 1-131: mid to high 8 Chapters 132-138: low to mid 6 Chapter 139+new leaks: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ It was a low 8 for the first few arcs then peaked at a high 8 to low 9 between the Shinganshina and Paths arcs but is now sitting comfortably at a low to mid 7 past the Rumbling. |
| well, from a 10/10 to a 6/10. the ending is like the icing on the cake. if the interior of the cake is good, then you'll enjoy it, but if the frosting isn't to your liking, it ruins the whole perception and your idea of the cake. some people may enjoy it, but for me it left a bad taste in my mouth so idk. at least that levi scene was good. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 138 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )deg - Mar 5, 2021 |
1128 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 25, 11:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 139 / Ending Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )NextUniverse - Apr 7, 2021 |
1874 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 25, 10:48 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 4 DiscussionMagEarwhig - Sep 11, 2011 |
25 |
by HenryDanger
»»
Apr 24, 6:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 141 Discussionventi_e - Sep 30, 2022 |
32 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Apr 20, 1:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 77 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 7, 2016 |
137 |
by Berry-Vodka
»»
Mar 31, 12:03 AM |