| welp the title says all ... any memories of it? |
| All of them are absolutely ridiculous. |
| My argument was on Gakuen Babysitters as the other one was saying that it is not that good despite watching only few episodes and not having on his list lmao it was later solved |
| "Fear is necessary for evolution. The fear that one could be destroyed at any moment" -Aizen Sousuke |
| There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) |
 |
| that chihayafuru was boted on purpose with low scores to promote the series, it was a 300 IQ move. but there were other gems |
    |
| A lot of morality arguments. People really turning here to take the high ground lol V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) While you might not agree with it, this is what peak fiction looks like: |
 |
| AOT fans saying that FMA:B lovers are being unfair since they're giving their beloved show a 1, Like do they think that AOT lovers aren't doing the same ? Both FMA:B fans and AOT fans were unfairly giving 10s AND 1s, So people who point fingers and try to argue with the other side look ridiculous imo |
| I don't speak English that much, so please cut me some slack |
| The current FMAB vs AoT is really annoying to me. Why tf do they argue about a fcking rating anyway? Anime cannot be judged by a goddamn rating that anyone knows is forced by a hard-headed fanbases. |
  "ꜱᴛʀᴇɴɢᴛʜ ᴏꜰ ʜᴇᴀʀᴛ, ᴡʜᴇɴ ᴜɴɪᴛᴇᴅ, ɪᴛ'ꜱ ʙᴀʀʀᴇᴅ ʙʏ ɴᴏ ᴅᴏᴏʀ..." -Aigis |
| currently I am having a war with this user that fell into mad love with Nino Nakano. I stated that Yotsuba Nakano is better and he began shitting on me, sigh... |
  [Violet X Amy] [VioletteloiV X squished_lemon] |
Ex-Arm Try to fight that argument... |
| Fma:b tards vs Aot tards. I lost brain cells |
V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction" Fuck idk why i feel insulted People saying they don't like Aot because the story is dull |
| Shinzou Sasageyo!!! |
SaberHotMikasa said: V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) Name a anime better than AoT then 🤔 There are a lot of shows I think are better but if I take those name it will be biased so I am going to say only those ones I truly believe are better Try Ginga Eiyuu Denstsu or Legend of the Galactic Heroes if you're asking for English name Monster is another Plot based Anime which has a great story In Manga try reading Kingdom I would have said Vinland Saga and Berserk as well but I dont know how good those Manga are as I havent read them so you can try yourself. Also they are not Shounen all of them are Seinen so remember that Well these are all in my mind right now |
|
Attackonfiller said: A lot of morality arguments. People really turning here to take the high ground lol V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) While you might not agree with it, this is what peak fiction looks like: I don't think I can argue with that because deep down I believe that's true |
|
SaberHotMikasa said: V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) Name a anime better than AoT then 🤔 Legend of the Galactic Heroes, March Comes in Like a Lion, Mushishi, Bebop, etc. We all have different opinions. Plus yeah I mean if you want to take in all media books, films and shows I think at most only LOTGH and maybe March would even fit in a top 25 list for me. There is a lot out there. As for me will agree on the morality arguments they tend to be pretty bad on here. Also speaking of AOT the nitpicking going on before the series came out like getting upset over the trench backgrounds having certain details especially when AOT as a premise would fail any basic realism regarding warfare from the get go since 3D maneuver gears wouldn't work. That's probably the most recent case of dumb stuff I can remember on here. The amount of nitpicking one photo for like 10-15 pages of comments was kinda insane. |
BilboBaggins365Jan 14, 2021 1:30 AM
| Iirc there was someone posting in SNK related forum/review/an episode discussion that SNK is perfectly depicting diversity (there are complete race representation) and LGBT-stuff and took an example of Zoe Hange and Yelena and bringing Hajime Isayama is literal mangaka-god. I was like "ok calm your tits or whatever it is bro" but I didn't wrote that down. |
 |
ErwinDanchou said: V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction" Fuck idk why i feel insulted People saying they don't like Aot because the story is dull All I want to say is that calling it a Peak Fiction just destroys the Anime itself as there is so much hate just because of that. Every show has flaws and no show is perfect. And if you dont remember it is created by a Normal Human like every other Anime. However just ignore those who think the story is dull as in my opinion story is fine. |
|
manamasta said: It's just idiots who argue against others Well this is to be expected being mentioned in a topic about "most ridiculous arguments". It even is producing some fresh ones. |
| Idk how but i always seen people saying bullshit so im gonna follow this rule by saying this.... OP BESTO SHONEN |
 |
Blu0 said: V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) As a fan of aot manga.. I will say that there are many mangas better than AOT in terms of plot.. like Berserk, Vagabond, Punpun, Real, Monster.. etc.. But the manga is ending soon and it may very well establish itself as one of the ALL TIME GREATS and someone saying its 'PEAK FICTION' is objective and not a BAD opinion unlike when someone calls DEMON SLAYER (for eg) a 'PEAK FICTION' anime wise.. lets see.. its top 5 for me!! I have yet to watch some shows like Legend of The Galactic Heroes Well I think calling it a Peak Fiction just overhypes the show and when others don't find the same enjoyment as the were supposed to they will just think it as a dumb show. And Calling a show a masterpiece and a peak fiction is different as if you call it a Peak Fiction you claim it as it is on the greatest height compared to other shows. |
|
Mayu_jamir said: We're not denying the quality of aot here, but it's a bit of a stretch to call it the peak of fiction or the greatest work of fiction in history. Makes us aot fans look dumb and ignorant of other works that are heralded as great or masterpieces. bro it's just a hyperbolic way to say "my favorite" calm down |
 |
| Oh, the classic "Too much ecchi". ON FUCKING SHOWS THAT HAVE THE ECCHI TAG. |
 |
| There was once a post that said people who like AoT are nazis or something lol (they discovered my secret) |
 |
| Tough. The number of ridiculous arguments on questions on this message board outweighs the one for all thoughtful and intelligent arguments and questions by a mile. |
| Yuri comments i miss them why people argue all in life Lets just all be good like a good comunity we are right ?????? (~￣³￣)~ |
| |
_Maneki-Neko_ said: V1D1T said: There are many of them but the most hilarious one is Attack on Titan is the "Peak Fiction"(Dont bite me Aot fans, I am an AOT fan as well and I consider the show to be great and even if you say its a masterpiece I dont mind but if you think its "Peak Fiction" then my friend you need to watch other shows) Good god yes. Everytime someone pretends like their favorite show is the peak of art in thousand years of human history, you know you got an obnoxious fanboy right there lol bro it's just a hyperbolic way to say "my favorite" calm down(1) |
|
| I was arguing and someome told me that all anime with snow are trash. Yes, the guy's reason for dislike something was snow. |
| If you're a fanboy, please don't waste my time. Watch more movies, please. Kafka, Fu Xuan, Jingliu, Topaz and Huohuo. |
| All of the ones concerning MAL ratings, people complaining about ratings, people complaining about people complaining about them. Has been worse lately but constant regardless. Also you get some crazies in here comparing people who like this or that anime to like murderers and other crazy shit. Sometimes blanket statements like anyone who hates so and so character is a simp etc as well. |
| There are many but these are my two proudest and first to mind honestly https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1642654  then there was that time a guy said Shana III had bad writing but only because he couldn't pay attention to save his own life https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1594380 |
 |
| Anti-pedo hypocrites vs lolicon. Anti-pedo hypocrtites vs Boku no Pico. Morality fags vs incest. |
 |
| People that just toss the term 'overrated' around like it's candy, which is basically 80% of the arguments I see in MAL |
 |
| That webtoon adaptations done by Japanese studios aren't anime and that if you like webtoons you cannot possibly be a real anime fan |
 |
V1D1T said: ErwinDanchou said: Fuck idk why i feel insulted People saying they don't like Aot because the story is dull All I want to say is that calling it a Peak Fiction just destroys the Anime itself as there is so much hate just because of that. Every show has flaws and no show is perfect. And if you dont remember it is created by a Normal Human like every other Anime. However just ignore those who think the story is dull as in my opinion story is fine. I feel like "perfect" anime do exist. Except its different for different people. Like my perfect anime's would be: A silent voice, Steins;gate, Attack on titan, Fate/zero. I know people can come up with flaws for the show. But I still wouldn't change shit and me myself can't find any flaws. |
| I gave up on character of the week since it takes too much thinking. I'll just change my forum pfp to whoever I want every week lol. |
| idk most arguments on myanimelist are ridiculous tbh. |
 |
| "Having a waifu is unhealthy" - I disagree, my waifu has brought me to another plane of existence. I'm not depressed, I swear. |
| this of course devolved into another aot thread lmaoooooo |
offcrack said: Lol recently this has been the case for every argument threadthis of course devolved into another aot thread lmaoooooo |
|
offcrack said: this of course devolved into another aot thread lmaoooooo aot debate is peak debate, that's a fact. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » do you want more emotional or more intelligent anime?deg - 8 minutes ago |
2 |
by Spunkert
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» What's your most controversial anime among your favorites? ( 1 2 3 )Kushna - Apr 5 |
105 |
by YeeYeeAss
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » whats the severity of social stigma for anime and its fans now a days?deg - 50 minutes ago |
4 |
by Otakupervert890
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» have you guys watched texhnolyze?brainburger - Apr 21 |
37 |
by vampirismsxc
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» Women tend to have superior anime preferences compared to men? ( 1 2 3 )Alpha_1_Zero - Apr 23 |
114 |
by vampirismsxc
»»
24 minutes ago |