Attack on Titan
keragamming said: chiearlymorning said: it was great when the episode focused on the trenches but it got worse towards the end when all the fights were cgi. Was the blur bad for you? Because I didn't notice I only saw one person mention the blur. That person may no even watched the episode.Can you tag the person please?I would like to have a word with him. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| some of you are remembering Wit with some ridiculous colored tinted glasses. Go watch S3P2 again, this was not worse than the average episode. Will have to wait for the adaptation of the important chapters (99-105) to compare them with Perfect Game & Hero. |
kisuke_dono said: How sad is your life man? You made an account just to trash on AOT? Do your parents not love you? Don't you have any friends? I actually feel bad for you. Hope you can turn your life around. Lol you're not much better tbh. Are people this offensive in MAL like seriously? |
* |
| Except for Beast Titan CG other titans looked cool. So I dun see any reason to complain. |
 |
| I'm actually surprised that Twitter is clean without all the toxicity lol.I think mal has now become the new twitter.Many are saying cgi was clean.The users who are saying cgi is bad are just shit heads who haven't even watched the episode |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
wakenowakane said: Boi can we just agree that the CGI was comically shit and that the story (once again) will have to carry this season? Also why tf is everyone rating this a 10/10 and shitting on people rating it a 1/10? That's just peak hypocrisy lmao.MAL seriously needs to remove ratings when a sequel is airing ffs. It was a decent enough episode and it will get better, otherwise I'll go and riot on twitter lmao. When people rate a season a 1 without even watching is also bad you know. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Scordolo said: I'm actually surprised that Twitter is clean without all the toxicity lol.I think mal has now become the new twitter.Many are saying cgi was clean.The users who are saying cgi is bad are just shit heads who haven't even watched the episode Everywhere I've seen, like forums from my country, have been almost pure positivity, it's here where it's forming a circlejerk of negativity. |
| guys don't you see it... The studio change was made deliberately to show how brutal Wit fans and Mappa appreciators can be to each other in the comment war. AoT is breaking the media boundaries, what a masterpiece |
Scordolo said: I'm actually surprised that Twitter is clean without all the toxicity lol.I think mal has now become the new twitter.Many are saying cgi was clean.The users who are saying cgi is bad are just shit heads who haven't even watched the episode You realize that social media users that follow SNK are mostly fans, right? If this was the first season of a new anime, there wouldnt be that many positive reviews they are biased. its not like the CGI makes this season a 1/10 but for me it ruins the rating. Instead of rating 10/10 I am going to give it 9/10 Its not perfect but its still good. The plot saves it. I am not into this action filler battles |
Funseco said: bruh the fans are the ones that are the most toxic about everything being perfect lmao, the circlejerk negativity in MAL is insane. it's always the same complaints all over again each season.Scordolo said: I'm actually surprised that Twitter is clean without all the toxicity lol.I think mal has now become the new twitter.Many are saying cgi was clean.The users who are saying cgi is bad are just shit heads who haven't even watched the episode You realize that social media users that follow SNK are mostly fans, right? If this was the first season of a new anime you wouldnt get that many positive reviews they are biased. its not like the CGI makes this season a 1/10 but for me it ruins the rating. Instead of rating 10/10 I am going to give it 9/10 Its not perfect it's been around since s1, always the same complaints and magically seeing the previous season's animation with rose-tinted glasses when it's not as "perfect" as you might have remembered it to be. like seriously, the over-exaggeration of the cgi being shit is completely overblown especially if you've seen the colossal titan on s3 lmao |
EGOISTDec 6, 2020 8:30 PM
Funseco said: Scordolo said: I'm actually surprised that Twitter is clean without all the toxicity lol.I think mal has now become the new twitter.Many are saying cgi was clean.The users who are saying cgi is bad are just shit heads who haven't even watched the episode You realize that social media users that follow SNK are mostly fans, right? If this was the first season of a new anime, there wouldnt be that many positive reviews they are biased. its not like the CGI makes this season a 1/10 but for me it ruins the rating. Instead of rating 10/10 I am going to give it 9/10 Its not perfect but its still good. The plot saves it. I am not into this action filler battles I actually feel that some of the past seasons hardcore fans are the ones being more negative/critical right now. Sure, there are the typical haters that come and go, the series could have Demon Slayer animation quality and they still would drop their hot take and go, but are the hardcore, Wit fans, the ones that are being more exaggerated with the complains and will stay week after week. They're just looking at everything to compare with the best aspects of Wit. I repeat that I think that many are remembering Wit with colored tinted glasses, Wit of S2 was peak animation quality, but the average S3 quality wasn't particulary better than this, but the thing about Wit is that they ALWAYS knocked the important scenes out of the park, their highs, like "Hero" are untouchable, I just can hope that Mappa does something similar with the adaptation of chapters 99-105. |
cAbaddonDec 6, 2020 7:52 PM
cAbaddon said: Funseco said: You realize that social media users that follow SNK are mostly fans, right? If this was the first season of a new anime, there wouldnt be that many positive reviews they are biased. its not like the CGI makes this season a 1/10 but for me it ruins the rating. Instead of rating 10/10 I am going to give it 9/10 Its not perfect but its still good. The plot saves it. I am not into this action filler battles I actually feel that some of the past seasons hardcore fans are the ones being more negative/critical right now. Sure, there are the typical haters that come and go, the series could have Demon Slayer animation quality and they still would drop their hot take and go, but are the hardcore, Wit fans, the ones that are being more exaggerated with the complains and will stay week after week. They're just looking at everything to compare with the best aspects of Wit. I repeat that I think that many are remembering Wit with colored tinted glasses, Wit of S2 was peak animation quality, but the average S3 quality wasn't particulary better than this, but the thing about Wit is that they ALWAYS knocked the important scenes out of the park, their highs, like "Hero" are untouchable, I just can hope that Mappa does something similar with the adaptation of chapters 99-105. Nope.There are the ones who've hated Snk from the start. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| I thought yall liked Aot because of its solid writing, not animation. This literally revokes all of the elitism yall feel towards the show. |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
asukka said: I normally don't even comment on these kinds of posts bc they're all stupid, but come on dude. The CGI wasn't the best, but I'd say it is LEAGUES above what you normally get in anime; in fact, this entire episode is clearly evident that the final season is going to be a step above the quality of most anime, like the previous seasons. We are super lucky to have MAPPA taking on the project, as every studio knew it was going to be a hell production bc of time restraints, and most (like studio deen) couldn't handle the load. I don't understand how people can find the tiniest nitpicky and say the whole season is ruined (I know this is a vast minority that do this) - it barely looks different from other seasons. Yeah.We are lucky that Mappa took the final season instead of some third party studio with bad cg like Studio deen and Jc staff.We should be grateful that we are getting a full adaptation. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| I don't think a studio will prove the storytelling of an anime. As long as it shows tolerable animation, who cares? |
 |
| Lmao cap. MAPPA washing WIT |
 |
RickSuarez said: BurntOkita said: WIT wasn't making any money, Araki is a hack and S3P2 sold like shit because it looked like shit Lol I liked S3 XD but I'd like to see an official statement or behind the scenes why they changed studio, maybe some anime twitter guy has inside info or something. BurntOkita was right tbh but it's actually way deeper than you think. The production committee is looking for a studio that is willing to work with just the animation aspect of it rather than being directly involved with the committee's decisions -- and Production IG doesn't want to compromise that spot. Wit is having financial and staffing issues hence why the project has to go to another studio. Keep in mind that IG is still directly involved in the pipeline just as much as it did in the previous seasons. MAPPA has been in the talks for the last two years with the necessary preparations for the turnaround. They just have to hand this over to do damage control given how the last season before this went an all-time low in terms of quality that even Bluray releases can't fix it, and that Wit has been bleeding more than earning from it. https://blog.sakugabooru.com/2020/06/02/attack-on-titan-mappa-otp/ I still stand with my opinion about this. The pilot wasn't as bad as what others make it out to begin with. While there are some glaring issues regarding the tone, a little bit about the direction, and overall new aesthetic, it really didn't take away too much from the experience. Most of what was being complained about was the CGI which is actually above-average but is still a love-it-or-hate-it matter, and there are almost little to no complaints about the other aspects of it. Make no mistake, I do agree with some points of criticism about MAPPA' s first take on this out of 16 episodes but isn't it too early to decide to drop or cancel this just because of the stylistic differences between the two studios involved? I get everyone's separation anxiety from Wit but let this sink in: this is better than having nothing or having this completely butchered by another studio who wasn't up for the challenge. I don't get it why a lot has been overreacting on this as if Wit didn't mess up some of S2 and the entirety of S3. Both studios had their hits and misses on each of their takes and they're just as equally good as each other. Get over it and enjoy it for what it is. asukka said: I normally don't even comment on these kinds of posts bc they're all stupid, but come on dude. The CGI wasn't the best, but I'd say it is LEAGUES above what you normally get in anime; in fact, this entire episode is clearly evident that the final season is going to be a step above the quality of most anime, like the previous seasons. We are super lucky to have MAPPA taking on the project, as every studio knew it was going to be a hell production bc of time restraints, and most (like studio deen) couldn't handle the load. I don't understand how people can find the tiniest nitpicky and say the whole season is ruined (I know this is a vast minority that do this) - it barely looks different from other seasons. Well said. It'll take time for others to get used to the style though but I'd agree about the CGI. You won't see that kind of almost-seamless 2.5DCGI effort in a standard anime nowadays. Those are mostly used in movies or high budget OVAs. How the CGI was implemented just reminded me of Dorohedoro and some of Gundam Unicorn/Origins. |
ZnraDec 6, 2020 8:42 PM
 Those with dirty minds will find my Steam pic offensive |
Never mind me. My food has less salt, so I am here to pick the salt from this forum and eat my tasty food. |
DissapointmentA said: atleast with WIT only the colossal was CGI,now every titan will be CGI garbage(beast titan looks HORRIBLE). and the general animation is not better then WIT to justfiy it. i'd go with WIT any day. also the backgrounds and blur are still garbage. and this is supposed to be one of the best animated episodes (future episode will decrease in quality when its in tight production like this) Sad... should've have went to ufotable or something if anything,we can wait 2 years for quality WIT show god damn it. Yeah so basically bc theres CGI the anime adaptation is shit, is this how it works for people like you? |
 |
| stop posting troll threads. No one cares about your shitty opinions. Think positively and notice the good things in their animation and stop complaining like a fking 9yrs old. I seriously love how some of the toxic AOT fans do not know how to adopt to a new environment and survive. |
  [Violet X Amy] [VioletteloiV X squished_lemon] |
chiearlymorning said: Your pfp matches a lot with your post.I don't know what to say |
| Today they say you're crazy, tomorrow they will say you're a genious. |
| Did anyone not realize this is a bait thread? Okay |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| Eh, I think it's fine. The CGI wasn't that bad. Personally, I like MAPPA artstyle more than WIT overall because it's more faithful to the manga. I only watched Season 1 and 4 lol, so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I did follow the manga for years tho. Also, the opening is lit! |
| "As long as you're alive, something happy bound to happens" -What a Wonderful World |
| Great Miron joined the other debbie downer to complain every week, fun times ahead. He’s still trying his hardest to convince everyone whats good or bad and speak as if its fact, hilarious. But yeah, set absurd expectations for MAPPA while wearing rose tinted glasses talking about WIT which some of your - points apply to many WIT episodes. |
KneelBeforeMeDec 6, 2020 10:04 PM
 |
Pknoctis said: Nah you aren't the only one who thinks the CG was fine. It's either people that want to find something to complain about or people who just hate all CG no exceptions.? Am I the only one who thought the CGI and animation was fine? Not to mention, the direction and pacing of this first episode was fantastic. Can't wait for more. |
| the first episode of aot s4 was fine, the only thing that was disappointing was the opening, for now |
 |
| can you not be ungratefull and enjoy the series?? mappa was the only one that wanted to adapt it and the cg is the best i have seen so far on titan models |
_maruwu_Dec 6, 2020 10:17 PM
 |
| to be fair WIT would've had to use CG as well . . there is no way in hell they were going to animate all of this in 2D. animating these 4 titans only would've taken ages. as well as whenever the clash between all the 9 titans happens which is why I believe MAPPA is the better choice here. For the most part they looked very good. some people here are LOOKING for anything that looks remotely bad and ignoring the good parts. they're just ruining the show for themselves. |
| Why am I not surprised that MAL has the most toxic forum for AOT right now lmao. Twitter is giving credit where credit is due to MAPPA and so is reddit. Meanwhile, MAL—Pepega. |
 |
BourBon-7so said: some people here are LOOKING for anything that looks remotely bad and ignoring the good parts. they're just ruining the show for themselves. Lmao they don't care anything about the show.They are just haters of Mappa and the show as well. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Tyrel said: Why am I not surprised that MAL has the most toxic forum for AOT right now lmao. Twitter is giving credit where credit is due to MAPPA and so is reddit. Meanwhile, MAL—Pepega. Reddit is the most toxic after Twitter but Mal has taken the top spot now in terms of toxicity LMAO |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| My complaints so far is the opening and the CGI. I can definitely notice the bad animation on it, but I think it’s a little early to make harsh judgements. |
|
| Can you people just shut the fuck up for a second? Sure it's noticeable, but so what?? Compared to other CGI, this one already pretty good. You people praised Demon's Slayer CGI for being smooth and clear, yet sometimes the CGI is noticeable and weird, but I don't see you people complain about it. Is it because it's a big franchise and you expect more from it?? Just shut up, just be happy MAPPA didn't betray our expectation and gave us a decent first episode and didn't go One Punch Man S2 route. Besides, it's only the first episode. Who are you to decide the rest of the series just based on one episode? We waited long for this, just let us appreciate that it's finally here without you dumbass spouting bullshit. |
| If WIT had to do this episode, I'm guaranteeing you that they would have dropped dead and everyone would be on them lmao |
| Ok now you people are doing TOO much now I don't see what's so bad about S4 it's not shit or anything honestly really good and you really complaining about blurry backgrounds?? It's not even noticeable either. Honestly everything looked amazing for a war setting at least. |
| Speak for yourself. Episode was badass. Everything looked good. Weebs really out there crying over a little CGI smh. Also username checks out. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » If Eren was in avatar...TASM18 - Apr 17 |
18 |
by belugaanime
»»
Apr 19, 2:12 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 7, 2021 |
513 |
by JoestarEISH_020
»»
Apr 13, 8:01 AM |
|
» Isayama: The Perfect Architect ( 1 2 )Mikasa - Mar 29, 2021 |
65 |
by benisfroms
»»
Apr 10, 8:21 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 10, 2021 |
986 |
by Jasmin061011
»»
Apr 2, 8:12 AM |
|
» Falco and Gabi…Arddaa52 - Jul 25, 2021 |
20 |
by Adrena
»»
Mar 27, 6:50 AM |