SunfushinoKana15 said: Hey I got curious, but what's the deal with Madoka Magica and Cardcaptor Sakura? Other than magical girls, any similarities/tied with the same universe? I got really curious cause I found they have similar or the same themes OPs and EDs It's the same shit for weeaboo in lack of love like this : |
 |
| Nothing and they are not related in any way, except for some genres. |
   |
| that's cause all mahou shoujos are the same lol |
 |
SunfushinoKana15 said: Hey I got curious, but what's the deal with Madoka Magica and Cardcaptor Sakura? Other than magical girls, any similarities/tied with the same universe? I got really curious cause I found they have similar or the same themes OPs and EDs the fuck? they have absolutely nothing in common except the vague genre pass the blunt |
 |
| I'm a magical girl fan, but I'm not a fan of Cardcaptor Sakura or Madoka Magica. One's a psychological seinen, and the other contains a disturbing age gap. |
 |
I was referring to Cardcaptor Sakura on that. |
|
| Card captor sakura is the cutesy type except that she doesn't transform and her friend makes her costumes to wear. while madoka ehmm guess its a bit dark? |
     © 花巻 花郎 @ pixiv.net |
Isterio said: You´re refering on Sakura´s crush on her brothers best friend? What´s the deal with it. As far as I´m aware it never grows beyond that. No, I'm referring to some little girl named Rika Sasaki, who falls in love with her teacher. Ruined the whole thing for me. |
|
| TBH, I'm currently watching Sailor Moon and trying to find her relationship with Tuxedo Kamen normal and not creepy... But it's really hard (^: |
 |
Isterio said: Seiya said: No, I'm referring to some little girl named Rika Sasaki, who falls in love with her teacher. Ruined the whole thing for me. Ok, excuse my lack of knowledge, because I´ve seen Cardcaptor Sakura only sporadically. What i remember was her BFF whose cosplay obsession had lesbian undertones, the magical boy with the cool windpowers, her overly sweet single father, her big bro and his BF who she had a crush on. Can fully understand your distaste for such a display, but Clamp always had an "aquired" taste. I've only seen a couple episodes of CCS. The only reason I know about the disturbing age gap, is because I read somewhere about it. But yeah, Clamp really isn't my cup of tea. Clebardman said: TBH, I'm currently watching Sailor Moon and trying to find her relationship with Tuxedo Kamen normal and not creepy... But it's really hard (^: At least with Sailor Moon and Tuxedo Kamen, the age gap is only 3 years. With CCS, you have a 10 year old girl with her 20-something year old teacher. |
|
| There are only two things in common: 1. Both are Magical Girl anime. 2. Both are considered two of the greatest anime of all time. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
shanimebib said: 2. Both are considered two of the greatest anime of all time. Nope, sorry. That is absolutely not true. |
|
Seiya said: shanimebib said: 2. Both are considered two of the greatest anime of all time. Nope, sorry. That is absolutely not true. Like I was the one who voted in NHK and TBS polls last year, the biggest polls conducted ever. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
shanimebib said: Like I was the one who voted in NHK and TBS polls last year, the biggest polls conducted ever. So, you think that your opinion speaks for everyone else's? Lol. |
|
Clebardman said: TBH, I'm currently watching Sailor Moon and trying to find her relationship with Tuxedo Kamen normal and not creepy... But it's really hard (^: But it's normal for 13-14 yo girls to have crushes for 17-18 yo guys. I mean... that is what I saw all the time in my high-school years. I would say Naru's ("Molly") almost-relationship with Nephrite was the more "creepy" one, since he was way older than Mamoru. |
velvetPhos said: Seiya said: One's a psychological seinen, and the other contains a disturbing age gap. I mean aimed demographic is shoujo, so… It’s easy for adults to realize it’s kind of creepy relationship, but for young girls, it’s surprisingly hard to realize. Many CCS fans I know didn’t think it was somewhat odd relationship until they have grown up to adults. To be fair, when Cardcaptor Sakura aired on TV in North America years ago, it was edited/censored, and all hints of the Sasaki relationship were removed. |
|
Seiya said: shanimebib said: Like I was the one who voted in NHK and TBS polls last year, the biggest polls conducted ever. So, you think that your opinion speaks for everyone else's? Lol. Read what I said "carefully" again and you'll "probably" realize how "stupid" and "irrelevant" your remark was. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
shanimebib said: Read what I said "carefully" again and you'll "probably" realize how "stupid" and "irrelevant" your remark was. Who cares if you voted in polls. That means nothing to me. |
|
velvetPhos said: Seiya said: To be fair, when Cardcaptor Sakura aired on TV in North America years ago, it was edited/censored, and all hints of the Sasaki relationship were removed. That is pretty interesting fact, but do you really think giving example of censoring in the continent that censors everything because of large number of oversensitive people add anything to your argument? Don’t forget the infamous “4 kids” is in North America, too. Personally, I don't really care what you think. This conversation is over. |
|
| Cardcaptor Sakura is nothing like Madoka, which was sort of tragic in a way, but Sakura is more of a light hearted Shojo anime and manga crerated by CLAMP. CC Sakura is also hunting down Clow cards which escaped or are out there, and she can use captured cards, that is nothing like Madoka Magica. |
Clebardman said: TBH, I'm currently watching Sailor Moon and trying to find her relationship with Tuxedo Kamen normal and not creepy... But it's really hard (^: sailor moon isn't a very good mahou shoujo if you ask me, it's even worse than puta madoka tbh. drop it and embrace the greatness of carcaptor sakura. |
  "elles sont bien noires les pensées des nuits blanches"  |
S-quare22 said: sailor moon isn't a very good mahou shoujo if you ask me, it's even worse than puta madoka tbh. What exactly is so wrong with Sailor Moon? I'm curious. |
Glenfinnan said: S-quare22 said: sailor moon isn't a very good mahou shoujo if you ask me, it's even worse than puta madoka tbh. What exactly is so wrong with Sailor Moon? I'm curious. I was wondering the same thing. I saw Sailor Moon when it first aired in North America back in 1995, and I always enjoyed it. I'm not a fan of Cardcaptor Sakura at all. |
|
Glenfinnan said: What exactly is so wrong with Sailor Moon? I'm curious. It's not awful or anything, but the predominance of "monster of the week" episodes (where the monsters or their solutions aren't at all interesting.) and repeated footage are significant problems, and it frequently has problems giving its adversaries motivations beyond "evil". Madoka and CCS are both significantly better. |
Glenfinnan said: S-quare22 said: sailor moon isn't a very good mahou shoujo if you ask me, it's even worse than puta madoka tbh. What exactly is so wrong with Sailor Moon? I'm curious. I'm sure that you've heard about "generic shounens" before right? Well, sailor moon is just a generic shoujo. |
"elles sont bien noires les pensées des nuits blanches" |
S-quare22 said: I'm sure that you've heard about "generic shounens" before right? Well, sailor moon is just a generic shoujo. Hmm, I'm not sure you can call something which invented a subgenre "generic". |
logopolis said: S-quare22 said: I'm sure that you've heard about "generic shounens" before right? Well, sailor moon is just a generic shoujo. Hmm, I'm not sure you can call something which invented a subgenre "generic". May I ask why? I mean..it doesn't matter if it invented subgenre or not. |
"elles sont bien noires les pensées des nuits blanches" |
S-quare22 said: May I ask why? I mean..it doesn't matter if it invented subgenre or not. That means, at the time it was made, there was nothing else like it. Which is pretty much the opposite of what "generic" means. |
SunfushinoKana15 said: They're not even by the same folks. CCS is a CLAMP work, while MadoMagi is an Urobuchi work.Hey I got curious, but what's the deal with Madoka Magica and Cardcaptor Sakura? Other than magical girls, any similarities/tied with the same universe? I got really curious cause I found they have similar or the same themes OPs and EDs Their theme songs are also quite stylistically different. "Catch You Catch Me" and "Tobira wo Akete" are both like, peppy 90s pop, though I guess "Platinum" is somewhat closer to the more lyrical tone of "CONNECT". "Groovy!" and "Fruits Candy" are also peppy 90s pop, and "Honey" is somewhat less peppy but more comforting in its feel. "Mata Ashita" is somewhat closer to "Honey", except a lot more cutesy in its voice style. And CCS has nothing like "Magia" for any of its theme songs (not to mention its literary themes). Basically the only thing common between them is that they both use magical girl genre elements. If there's a lineage, it probably goes CCS -> Nanoha -> MadoMagi. Seiya said: I think @shanimebib is sarcastically remarking "like I was the one who decided their popularity? of course not; they actually had polls about this", but shanimebib didn't communicate that meaning clearly.shanimebib said: Read what I said "carefully" again and you'll "probably" realize how "stupid" and "irrelevant" your remark was. Who cares if you voted in polls. That means nothing to me. |
GlennMagusHarveyApr 2, 2018 2:03 PM
| Avatar character is Gabriel from Gabriel DropOut. |
More topics from this board
» Do you enjoy talking about anime you dislike?Catalano - 1 hour ago |
16 |
by Rhae
»»
36 seconds ago |
|
Poll: » Japanese Anime and its Relationship to the Source Material vs Western MediaLSSJ_Gaming - 23 minutes ago |
4 |
by Lucifrost
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» 3x3/Grid threadJohan420 - Apr 28 |
17 |
by -Kugeki-
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Do you pick new anime to watch thinking you probably will like it? Or just picking whatever is popular?Rinrinka - Yesterday |
35 |
by Nirinbo
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » anime is trash and so am ideg - 2 hours ago |
17 |
by deg
»»
14 minutes ago |