@ae-i: Thanks! lol^.^
Monad said:
You say you ain't crazy enough to just throw a 10 simply because you see bishies on the screen. Well if that is true then what is your problem? You shouldn't feel offended like you seem to be since obviously my comment doesn't involve you. Right?
Then according to you, 6 and 7 is from guys who think it's yaoi or people who didn't enjoy it. I believe you need to go and check the MAL rating. If someone disliked it completely it gives 2 and 3 not 6 and 7. So the users that give 6 and 7 are users that saw flaws but definitely aren't in any hate spree just because of the bishies. So yes they are the most logical viewers.
Goes check own rating of "Highschool of the Dead".....oh look it's a 7. Yeah am a straight male that loves seeing female flesh but it seems i still wasn't blind enough to give it a 10 just for fanservice when it was a 6 or 7.
So you see the problem here isn't if you deserve your fangirl moments, it's about considering them as a masterpiece of 10 and if am not mistaken that's what we were talking about. The rating.
Since as you say this is an anime and not a yaoi show then it's score should reflect it's quality as an anime. I can understand a yaoi show getting a 10 for being full of awesome bishies and all that, since such a show it's judged by the levels of fun male fanservice it provides and the score it gets reflects a completely different way of scoring that a normal anime. But an anime that's supposed to not fall in the hentai category has to be compared with a normal scoring system that reflects other anime and getting a 10 simply for the bishies is ridiculous.
BTW before i close the post, you do realize that boys are physically incapable of being wet and getting multiple orgasms since it's strictly a girl thing, right? Was your brain shut off when you where writing that "girls are not like boys" comment?
First of al, i wasn't offended, i was simply sharing my thoughts the same way you shared yours. ofc, you could have been more gentle and not mention the part of the getting wet and orgasms. Like i said, (and u should read it again), i wouldn't give it a 10 just because im a yaoi fangirl, and i wont give it a 10 at the end, probably. It takes much more than hot bishies to give a 10 to a show, and like i said before, probably the persons who rated it 10, rated it because they also enjoyed the plot. i cant even rate it now, because i wont rate an anime in the first ep. and also, if someone decides to give it a 10 only for the bishies, that´s the persons opinion, we shouldnt CRITICIZE.
So, are we talking about anatomy now? because i dont need lessons about what a girl or a boy are able to do or not, i already know, thanks. Since you were talking about the reactions that a fangirl has, which are not quite like you described, i was referring to the fact that boys get much more carnal while watching a fanservice than us girls, otherwise there wouldn't be like 90 % of the animes with half naked girls running around, while there´s only about 10 % of shirtless guys in the animes. Im not against it, i dont criticize the fanservice, boys are actually lucky, for having so much of that, while girls have almost none, lol.
Anyway, now its my time to ask, why do you feel so offended? We are only sharing opinions, so you shared yours, i commented, that´s all, i wasnt offended, but there are hard yaoi fans out there who could have been, so it was not very nice of you to share your opinion in such a crude way. Anyway, its only my opinion, and i apologize if i made you mad.
My opinion will remain the same. and im here to enjoy the anime;D
P.S- This and my other posts are not made to offend anyone, in return, i hope to be respected too. |