Dunning-kruger effect have ruined anime community.

No. a trash advice value nothing if you play soccer and someone advice you to play left foot where you're a right person , this advice is shit , and my advice could've been bad , as crazy it can seem.

I still thank you for sharing your work here , I sincerely appreciate reading it.

@Zakatsuki_

Why you so pessimistic all of a sudden, didnt you say you are 100% right tho? I think you advice is correct, not only you think that, but as the person who wrote it, I also think its a valid advice. Its not bad. Obviously I need to use my own brain to think if your advices are actually useful. Thats why on your second advice I don't think its as great as the first one.


I thank you for taking your time and reading.

@Zimmu that's why i've said "could've been bad" it's a possibility <.

🤝

@Zakatsuki_

lol I think you created a paradox here though. Because you said that you "might be right but only at 100%". So if you are actually 100% correct then there isnt the possibility of "couldve been bad". But yeah im gonna go to sleep lets end it here

@Zimmu when you say things like this , it show how you don't even understand a rating systeem ,yes there is good moment in jjk , yes there is characters with good or very good character development (Only Gojo , Geto ,Nanami and Toji the rest is pure ass character development) but the bad moments are so bad than good things are just not capable of facing sm shit , don't forgot that sukuna is the antagonist for no reason just bc he's a demon , absolutely just without reasons , my antagonist when i was playing with lego was having a way better character development than him , i will not even talking abt the CRAZY plagiarism of jjk on other animes

BRO IT'S THE SAME MOVES , LIKE EXACTLY THE SAME LMAOOOOO

funny to read this when i've actually said this in my post:
you just mix self-confidence and arrogance i'll give you an example:

If i say i'm the best basketball player in the world , i'm arrogant bc i'm not.
If Lebron James says this , it's self confidence and not arrogance because he actually is.
That's the same thing here , i'm not arrogant , i just know my capacities.
You comparing me to Geto actually worry me about your analyze and comprehension oF jutsu kaisen , because geto is pure racism , and i personally don't want to kill them or even make them suffer , i just want them to stop talking abt things they don't know.
i think that this thread can show like 55% of my level bc i was very limited by X.

Left - shounen-only normies
Middle - try-hard pseuds who care about "muh critical acclaim" and reviewers telling them something is "good"
Right - actual anime enjoyers who enjoy mecha, mahou shoujo, ecchi, harems etc. and don't care about the pseuds

Simple as.

@Zakatsuki_
I dunno man there are so many problems with what you said.

You literally just said you can analyze anime (and i assume manga) very well, and here you are claiming jjk manga is dogshit without anything to back up. You can say the ending flopped but giving it a 1 is like denying it ever had good moments, which just isnt the case my man. This proves you lack "OBJECTIVITY", which is the number 1 thing you need when you say you are good at analyzing. This is a red flag.


What even is your argument? You are just venting on the internet and posting some sort of effect to make it seem like you are being intellectual when all you are doing is complaining. Let me be honest here: You are just being arrogant. You think others can't analyze this media as good as you; and you think are good because you got good grades in literature classes. You say you arent arrogant but im sorry you are. You don't say you aren't arrogant immediately followed by "ik im crazy good at this" and calling ppl monkeys

Are you Geto from JJK? That dude is an actual villain and wanted to murder everyone for not being the same as him. Are you a villain too?

You aren't even over 18 from the way you talk

OP, I couldn't help but notice that you haven't written any reviews or blog posts on MAL yet. I'm always down for engaging with interesting media analysis, so could you please share a link to your off-site writing material, or perhaps some YouTube video essays you may have done, so that I may enjoy watching your "crazy good" analytical skills at work?

@RainyEvenings True, not all people are experts for example like your knowledge about modern anime but are you also experts in old anime like the 60s and 70s older anime fan would judge you if you knew about it

The Dunning Kruger effect is meant for you to analyze YOURSELF not others. If you try to use it against others you literally are potentially just falling into the same trap.



Is this post supposed to be a parody ?

Not sure what the OP is trying to say here.
Maybe that if you continue to be the hyped fanboy from your honeymoon period with the media it will be good for the community?
That would be definitely good for the industry, the studios will be able to sell any trash to the unambitious, but hungry for more content masses.

Is this good for you on a personal level, tho? Also the trick with the communities is that those should be mutually beneficial for the group and for the individuals. If there's some disbalance they will become a toxic environment.

Also there's the problem with the burnout. A lot of people simply quit the community at their first one (the case of "I watched all good/popular anime."). Some moderation and more diverse genre/theme choices will lead you to less burnouts and easier recovering from those. There are tons of great shows which aren't popular or lost popularity after fresher titles replaced those.

No matter how you slice it, a more experienced anime fen is a better anime fan...not as superior person or something stupid like that, but as one who is better at finding shows which they will enjoy.


"they think that the more anime you watch the more you're better at it"

In the general case this is true tho.
Depends on the what the OP implies with "better at". You will be definitely better at understanding the visual language, picking out the references and identifying the tropes. It's a good idea that "more" also would mean "more genre/theme diverse" too.


"just like your anime list show that "you know what you're talking abt" but no bro"

Actually "yes bro".
It was funny when tons of noobs reacted with "What is that?" to the ganguro girl from episode one of Dan Da Dan. It's just a weird teen fashion you can randomly learn about by watching anime.


"some peoples can have only 15 anime days and totally smash me in analyze"

Sorry, OP, that sounds like skill issue...but is it really important to analyze the way they do it? Isn't it more important to do it your way for the aspects you enjoy in anime?

You say you're not being arrogant but your quote on profile says otherwise

Shut up, Doctor Dummy xD
If anything, self proclaimed scholars like yourself, talking about themselfes more than anything else, is what's ruining online communitys, like MaL ...
It has become the outlet for every lonely, misunderstood, narcissist out there, who thinks that their thoughts are so very special.

It's a silly site for fans who like to talk about Anime.
It has nothing to do with "enlightenment" or "competence".... Of course you're diasppointed searching for these things, on here 🤡

Especially with the mindset that you're, most likely, the only one who actually is enlightened.

@Merve2Love No. but can you read? , i've literally said this:


I don't search those things here , but if i want to , i can find , bc people here are smart for the vast majority , not like other social media where they just want stats


your readings skills are worrying to say the least.

@Zakatsuki_

You're a dumbbell who's out here lecturing the public, AGAIN. Like every other Thread you're creating.
Shut up^^

Keep beeing enlightened and very, very smart. But for the love of god: Leave us out of it.
Please and thank you.

@Merve2Love most of them are actually good , but if you're so angry you can just mute me lmao , you will economize the best resource on earth: time

@Zakatsuki_

I say it with the words of every female you interacted with, ever:

"Not interested. You're weird. Stop it."

impossible , i would wanted it to be perfect so it will take me crazy time and it's not worth it , since review on mal give you nothing , even if they would be in top 5% reviews

you claim to be good at analyzing shows, yet you only have 11.5% affinity with me, curious.

How can you be sure that you're not at the peak of the dunning kruger yourself

@traed My posts have some sincerity in that the furthest right in the graph (which is the only correct thing in OP's post, btw) are also universally the best anime fans. But seriously, people who care about the popularity (or lack thereof) of an anime, or need some random "review" or YouTube essay to "verify" their opinion about an anime are the biggest loser. Not normie enough to just let the online hype carry them, not enlightened enough to just roll with what they like and not care about others.