One Piece Film: Red Episode 1 Discussion

What did you think of this episode?

DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.

Nov 16, 2022 2:52 PM

#151

mangalicker94

Offline

May 2014

2391

VolKur said:

BigBoya said:

that means they shown shanks fighting

Yeah, we will see Shanks and his crew members fighting in the movie.

Without revealing anything, he will fight, but it's very brief. Nothing special new if you read the manga. If you only watch the anime, however,....

Nov 16, 2022 4:59 PM

#152

curvedtree

Offline

Feb 2014

2027

mangalicker94 said:
I wonder if I was the only one who noticed. But when we saw Uta's flashbacks, we saw a brief moment of Shanks's past where he looked directly at Roger and Rayleigh. This is only speculation from my side, but I think Shanks was adopted similarly to Uta by Roger's crew, which makes him special and one of the longest crew members of Roger's pirates. So, Roger was like a godfather to Shanks, similar to what Shanks was to Uta/Luffy.

Search for "Volume 4000000000"

Nov 16, 2022 6:59 PM

#153

Madonis

Offline

Dec 2008

curvedtree said:
Disappointed with the writing, too many characters that didn't need to be there, we have three people with the "same power" (Law, Brulée, Bruno, ie moving people around) and a Fujitora that was okay with the Marines killing civilians by Kizaru's orders.

I actually thought it was nice to see such a niche set of powers prove to be useful. Not a writing issue either way. In fact, I'd call it a net positive.

Cast size is also a matter of personal preference. I don't feel strongly in favor or against. Again, not a writing issue.

Although his part in the movie was rather limited, I think a few folks are losing track of the situation when they criticize Fujitora. What exactly was he going to do as a response? It makes sense to protest when there is clearly another alternative and the stakes are rather easy to handle. If such an alternative isn't present and 3/4s of the world population could still die if the enemy's plan is allowed to succeed...that's a whole other order of magnitude. He still tried to minimize the damage in a couple of moments, but it's not like he had another option to offer which would resolve everything without fighting.

galicker94 said:

Without revealing anything, he will fight, but it's very brief. Nothing special new if you read the manga. If you only watch the anime, however,....

I'd say that's...inaccurate and an understatement. Shanks hasn't done much fighting in the manga either way. In fact, this is the most we've seen him fight so far. I'm sure that will eventually change in the future, when the manga makes more progress, but that's speculation.

Nov 16, 2022 9:30 PM

#154

AhriTheS3xyFox

Offline

Sep 2015

2661

Goddamn forgot to post here, anyway, Just finished my 20th watch on November 15th. Best of all I got the greatest camera angle for my picture taken for the One Piece Film Red poster. So i'm happy. This is a memorable moment, and especially people were quiet 95% of the time. Great stuff! I will miss this film! still feel like I didn't get enough of it !

August 6th 2023: Biggest upset ever, deception, selfishness, or scammed, manipulated. Heavy damage costs, and more. Days since: 15 Last updated: 8/21/2023

One Piece Episode 1041 & 1042 & 1047 & 1048 & 95.75%/1049 & 1053 were a mistake and Uta brought the salvation -AhriTheS3xyFox

Nov 17, 2022 6:22 PM

#155

yvsei

Offline

Apr 2019

1295

Watched it with my g in the theatres. Never watched one piece before so caught me off guard at first with the music-centered story, but i liked it more and more as it went on. thought the animation would b better considering it's a 2022 movie but ig not enough budget.

it was aight, 5/10.

Nov 18, 2022 12:47 PM

#156

elmingamerr

Offline

Dec 2021

me flipa todo, no entiendo a la gente que se queja de las canciones y todo eso cuando a mi me encanto. SEGUN ODA UTA SIGUE VIVA

Nov 20, 2022 2:24 AM

#157

mikzflava

Offline

Nov 2009

1503

I love One Piece but this is probably the most overrated one piece movie. Probably because I've never been fond of musicals even though the music scores were great. Just a ton of cameos and unnatural reactions from the main characters. The fight scenes felt cluttered with special effects and the final villain looking like it came straight from Madoka Magica. Still a good movie though 7/10, just not the best like most people here seem to think.

Nov 20, 2022 7:12 AM

#158

Madonis

Offline

Dec 2008

mikzflava said:
I love One Piece but this is probably the most overrated one piece movie. Probably because I've never been fond of musicals even though the music scores were great. Just a ton of cameos and unnatural reactions from the main characters. The fight scenes felt cluttered with special effects and the final villain looking like it came straight from Madoka Magica. Still a good movie though 7/10, just not the best like most people here seem to think.

People appreciate the music and other elements more than others. I don't know what "unnatural" reaction you're talking about. If you're talking about Luffy, then Oda himself made it that way.

Nov 22, 2022 3:07 AM

#159

UncleSev

Offline

May 2021

Yes, just yes, yes and yes

Nov 22, 2022 3:34 AM

#160

x2kill4

Offline

Jan 2017

704

so what happen to Uta, is she died at the end? i may miss the scene but i cannot see her anywhere after Luffy wake up..

Nov 22, 2022 9:04 AM

#161

Torofe

Offline

Oct 2014

wena wena muy wena

Nov 22, 2022 11:11 AM

#162

ssjokg

Offline

Aug 2009

20055

mangalicker94 said:

ssjokg said:

8/10

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Nov 25, 2022 10:27 PM

#163

135710

Offline

Aug 2020

LOVE AND PEACE IS ALAWAYS HEARTBREAK

Nov 28, 2022 9:24 PM

#164

DemonDomo360

Offline

Jun 2021

best one piece movie

Nov 30, 2022 11:57 PM

#165

LegendSalmon

Offline

Oct 2022

Best one piece movie in my opinion.

Dec 2, 2022 9:25 PM

#166

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

564074

mangalicker94 said:
It was an enormous privilege for me to watch the 15th One Piece movie at a cinema in Norway (Colosseum cinema). It was a premiere and I didn't even know. LOL. I loved it. Even the executive producer appeared and promoted the movie. The first OP movie showed in Scandinavia. Finally, it took them 23 years!

Wow this is amazing, you guys really went all out over there! 🤯 As your neighbor (from Stockholm, Sweden) I'm lowkey jealous!

Dec 3, 2022 7:18 AM

#167

28012001

Offline

Apr 2020

643

It’s like a One Piece version to the infinite tsukuyomi, kind of like Oda modified what Kishimoto wrote prior. The idea of a dream world where everyone can live together in peace. The twisted ideal of Uta is so similar to that of Madara’s.

Dec 4, 2022 1:45 AM

#168

tumtum1998

Offline

Jun 2020

Music so good ! Uta so pretty and adorable

Dec 5, 2022 4:04 PM

#169

Longeyes

Offline

Oct 2020

not enough shanks

Dec 13, 2022 2:02 AM

#170

CQLLIST

Offline

Jul 2021

9184

The movie overall is nothing that groundbreaking but the selling point for me is Uta's singing. I have Backlight as my fav song she performs.

Dec 17, 2022 1:47 PM

#171

GhostxRain

Offline

Oct 2021

Too much singing not enough fighting

Dec 20, 2022 8:33 AM

#172

beenny_janssen

Offline

Apr 2016

very good story but a bitter end for a friend from luffy again

Dec 22, 2022 7:59 AM

#173

XialTbd

Offline

Mar 2021

Ta buenaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
TvT

Dec 23, 2022 10:22 AM

#174

GALAXdu46

Offline

Dec 2022

very nice with ado

Dec 25, 2022 5:36 AM

#175

Ur_mum_yeah

Offline

Dec 2022

great must watch big w

Jan 4, 2023 1:26 PM

#176

The_Crescendo

Offline

Jan 2021

I loved ados singing, overall 10/10 movie

Jan 12, 2023 6:28 PM

#177

cosmere64

Offline

Sep 2018

it was pretty good, the voice acting of Uta was very good, as well as the music, and she really carried the film with her motivations and actions and even back.
the ending fight was a little disappointing and lacked weight in my opinion and the presence of Blueno and Bepo was kind of funny at first, but after the first joke with them, it got old.

Good movie but felt like it dragged a bit at the end

Jan 19, 2023 2:45 PM

#178

BigChoppa77

Offline

Sep 2020

Movie was amazing

Jan 21, 2023 6:14 PM

#179

gabrielo13

Offline

May 2020

loved it.loved it.loved it.loved it.loved it.loved it.loved it.

Jan 24, 2023 12:37 PM

#180

LODE-STAR

Offline

Feb 2015

I went in with no expectations and was still somewhat disappointed.

The pacing for the whole movie felt off, like there was this constant hurry to hit the next story beat. Some scenes focused way too much on telling and not showing or revealing a story beat that could have been introduced more organically beforehand. The jokes were a hit-or-miss but then again, that's how I feel about OP's humor in general so it's not a big deal to me. The animation overall was a mixed bag: while there were fight scenes and character animations that were animated gorgeously (especially towards the end), a lot of the action felt lackluster and like the characters were punching and slicing air instead of solid matter with no real weight behind them. The soundtrack was definitely a highlight of the movie and the voice-over work and the audio design in general were high quality. I really liked the costume design for the characters (as usual) and the island's visual design too.

If I'm being honest, the movie felt like a fanfiction and not the good kind. All in all, I'm just glad Shanks got more than 8 seconds of screen time this time around lol

LODE-STARJan 25, 2023 12:35 AM

Feb 18, 2023 12:12 AM

#181

StrawhatVasiqo

Offline

Jan 2022

It sucks. Could have done a better job,

Feb 23, 2023 11:30 AM

#182

Rip_aqua

Offline

Apr 2021

Another masterpiece from the writer and director of this wonderful anime. I suggest you see this work

Mar 3, 2023 8:22 AM

#183

Sunny_Sun

Offline

May 2021

love Ado's songs~

Mar 7, 2023 8:36 AM

#184

MugiwaraPatrick

Offline

Jul 2013

One of my all time favorites. Can't wait to buy the Blu Ray when it comes out.

Mar 7, 2023 10:58 PM

#185

CondemneDio

Offline

Jan 2013

6446

This movie is everything that's wrong with new One Piece movies. Filled to the brim with nonsense cameos, movie original characters retroactively and clumsily written into existing backstories, and the villain has one of the most broken abilities that would change the balance of power in the world if it were actually canon.

Mar 8, 2023 1:00 AM

#186

_cjessop19_

Offline

Nov 2018

5725

Really good movie.

What surprised me the most was actually

MAL EMOJIS - Get your specially formatted emojis for MAL forums.

Mar 8, 2023 3:24 AM

#187

GosuDRM

Offline

Dec 2012

2953

Good overall. But why they show the Gear 5 Luffy?

Mar 8, 2023 5:44 AM

#188

ryzxgum

Offline

Apr 2022

6358

amazing movie, every single song was fire. ado snapped!

the peak animation was crazy too, i had to pause so many times just to appreciate it. whole crew was suffering from peak sakuga. even issho's fight scene.
man, i love fights with music so much and this movie delivered absolutely that.

shanks and his crew looked as good as ever, yasopp too. glad to see more familiar faces like katakuri, CP0 and bleuno, issho and the marines. more characters like boa during the ED.
gear 5 tho LMAO toei said screw it, you anime-onlys get a spoiler! as a manga reader, i laughed.
also, all the females looked divine, strong 9/10 for me. will definitely rewatch this movie sometime soon.

Mar 8, 2023 8:14 AM

#189

Jamk_

Offline

Jan 2021

1759

Usopp and Uasopp using their observation Haki was an amazing father son moment and the animation was fire asf I didn’t care about the music but the rest was great

Mar 8, 2023 9:36 AM

#190

Hatul

Offline

Oct 2008

1007

Dreadful waste of time.
This movie was so clumsily paced, jumping from one thing to the next with no downtime and rapidfire exposition, no time to let anything register. Overcrowded with cameos for the sake of either fanservice or at best, a dues ex machina (Bartolomeo and Law).
Nice performances from Uta, but the way it segways into her songs is quite jarring and unnatural a lot of the time, and so is the characterization for everyone in this movie in general for that matter. Everything just felt slightly off.
Overall probably not as bad as Stampede, but still incredibly disappointing imo. I was bored out of my mind during the third act.

Mar 8, 2023 11:19 AM

#191

Rexnihilo

Offline

Oct 2020

3537

Overall it was an ok movie with some great songs from Ado. The story was weak to say it nicely. Shanks just shows up to show some haki and moves but we don't actually learn more about him. 6/10 movie.

Mar 8, 2023 11:26 AM

#192

Madonis

Offline

Dec 2008

Rexnihilo said:
Overall it was an ok movie with some great songs from Ado. The story was weak to say it nicely. Shanks just shows up to show some haki and moves but we don't actually learn more about him. 6/10 movie.

Open to debate, because there are various implications, but I guess it doesn't matter since the manga will be more explicit. Still, I found that aspect interesting in the movie.

Hatul said:
Dreadful waste of time.
This movie was so clumsily paced, jumping from one thing to the next with no downtime and rapidfire exposition, no time to let anything register. Overcrowded with cameos for the sake of either fanservice or at best, a dues ex machina (Bartolomeo and Law).
Nice performances from Uta, but the way it segways into her songs is quite jarring and unnatural a lot of the time, and so is the characterization for everyone in this movie in general for that matter. Everything just felt slightly off.
Overall probably not as bad as Stampede, but still incredibly disappointing imo. I was bored out of my mind during the third act.

I disagree, for me the transition to the songs were appropriate either contextually or emotionally. The characterization was fine under the circumstances involved.

As for the pacing, my only issue there was around the midpoint of the film yet I was fully immersed into the last act.

Nevertheless, I didn't have a ton of trouble with the exposition and getting in the moment when important events happened. This is personal, of course.

Mar 8, 2023 12:42 PM

#193

DoctorWasabi

Offline

Jan 2014

3762

BRO this was absolutely amazing. Episode 1029, 1030 and this movie is what makes One Piece so fucking good. The grand fights are great and all, but what makes this anime truly special is the characters and the living breathing world that they live in.

I think we only have 1 more movie, maybe two more, but I hope it's on the quality that is Film Red. Stampede was a big let down, and was honestly kinda forgettable. It was all action and no depth, yet it's regarded more favorably and rated higher by most people. A shame people can't appreciate true value.

EASY 9/10

Also if I'm correct, Uta died at the end :( RIP

Mar 8, 2023 12:43 PM

#194

DoctorWasabi

Offline

Jan 2014

3762

x2kill4 said:
so what happen to Uta, is she died at the end? i may miss the scene but i cannot see her anywhere after Luffy wake up..

It's HEAVILY implied that Uta died.

Mar 8, 2023 10:19 PM

#195

Zane_0

Offline

Aug 2011

566

Now my favorite OP movie out of all the OP MOVIES

https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/5LYzTBVoS196gvYvw3zjwBG6tfTPUwigsf2iPyCSvPg

Mar 8, 2023 10:25 PM

#196

Morcombe1990

Offline

Sep 2010

298

it's a fun "turn of your brain popcorn flick" movie but easily the weakest of the 5 "Films" overseen by Oda.

the songs are good and Uta's powers are interesting, the action is great, the fanservice at the end with shanks is worth watching the movie for alone.

just a couple things that bugged me, first is fujitora being ok with akainu and kizaru's plan to kill Uta and 70% of the world population makes no damn sense, based on his manga appearances there is absolutely no way he would go along with that, he even goes back to that personality at the end of the film when he refuses to fight shanks with so many sleeping civilians around, but just 30 minutes ago he was fine helping wipe out over half the world.

Shanks is a moron, sure it was nice that he wanted Uta to achieve her dream but you do not abandon your child under any circumstances on a lie, this entire movie and her "death" is entirely his fault. really hurt his character for me.

also no vivi in the end credit cameos, she's basically the only one left out (they could have done a little hint towards where she actually is)

Mar 9, 2023 3:38 AM

#197

Uhaklifa

Offline

Mar 2020

Film Red became my favorite One Piece movie along with the Omatsuri Danshaku. I really like how they promoted Uta as an arc princess during PV's just like Nami and Robin, while baiting us into believing that even more with sending her concert some pirates lurked among the fans planning to kidnap her mainly Big Mom pirates. At that point I geniuenly believed that this was going to be another cliche OP formula where Luffy chases down a girl and saves her from the big bad boys. When Uta turned out to be movie's main villian I was geniuenly suprised, happy and exicited. After that my main expectation was Uta getting "Talk No Jutsu" after fighting a little bit against Luffy and Shanks. But that also didn't happened. Despite getting sympathy a lot from Luffy and Shanks Uta never backed down from her desire and to be honest she was quite evil and had a really twisted personality. She only gave up and took the responsibility of the events and simply commited suicide after getting defeated.

Overall it really deserves 10/10. Animation, Art and Music was also quite good. Especially Musics of this movie definitely will be on my playlist for a while.

Mar 9, 2023 6:42 AM

#198

cpt_assassin-777

Offline

Aug 2021

Watched it on 09/03/2023 in HD, And I don't regret waiting this long to watch it. Honestly, this was really good, I have to thank the animators who a lot of time and effort into it. my rating 8.5/10 ish

Mar 9, 2023 9:48 AM

#199

Mattuzmk

Offline

May 2013

232

Just got my hand on the movie, managed to suffer through it.
What a disappointment. Holy shit...
I gave it a 4/10, but feels like it might be too generous. I've been watching anime OVAs and movies for a really long time now. I've seen pretty much every major release related to a big name medium, but this really feels like a bottom barrel movie. Best decision of my life that I didn't buy a movie ticket for this garbage. Probably would have walked out after like 30 mins.

Mar 9, 2023 7:47 PM

#200

Madonis

Offline

Dec 2008

Morcombe1990 said:
it's a fun "turn of your brain popcorn flick" movie but easily the weakest of the 5 "Films" overseen by Oda.

the songs are good and Uta's powers are interesting, the action is great, the fanservice at the end with shanks is worth watching the movie for alone.

just a couple things that bugged me, first is fujitora being ok with akainu and kizaru's plan to kill Uta and 70% of the world population makes no damn sense, based on his manga appearances there is absolutely no way he would go along with that, he even goes back to that personality at the end of the film when he refuses to fight shanks with so many sleeping civilians around, but just 30 minutes ago he was fine helping wipe out over half the world.

Then let me spell it out for you by asking a direct question: what exactly was the alternative at that point in the story?

From their point of view, doing nothing would be the worst case scenario because letting Uta continue her plan means the songs would reach more and more people across the world. Fujitora might not like it, but there was no obvious alternative.

In fact, if Uta didn't voluntarily bring all of those people back, then they would be forever trapped and as good as dead at the end of the movie.

Shanks is a moron, sure it was nice that he wanted Uta to achieve her dream but you do not abandon your child under any circumstances on a lie, this entire movie and her "death" is entirely his fault. really hurt his character for me.

You're talking about the same Shanks who lost his arm in a manner that, in retrospect, seems increasingly silly every passing year. He's not perfect and made a mistake in judgment.

If you want Shanks to be squeaky-clean and free from any sort of humanity, then I can see why you would be disappointed. I think it makes him more relatable, especially in the full context. He was also much younger than he's now.

Thankfully, your opinion isn't shared by the vast majority of people who watched this movie, including many how have similar or even greater experience.

It just shows your mind is closed off to new approaches and ways of creating a movie.

MadonisMar 9, 2023 7:51 PM

See All Discussions

» New Poster of One Piece Flim: Red TheDeadmanII - May 26, 2022	8	by VincentCannon »» Sep 24, 8:19 PM
» Is this the worst one piece movie? ( 1 2 ) EndlessMaria - Mar 10, 2023	70	by DestyPuffari »» Sep 23, 10:47 AM
» Confusion about the time line of the Movie [*spoiler from Wano] ANIk_003 - Aug 6	14	by Terry-Sensei »» Sep 13, 7:20 PM
» So where is Kyuubey??? Hitagi__Furude - Mar 11, 2023	6	by Zarutaku »» May 23, 6:22 AM
Poll: » Best Film Red Song (Since the movie is now out on streaming services) Cestlavie_ - Mar 7, 2023	18	by Itzmespooky »» Jun 7, 2023 5:45 PM

One Piece Film: Red Episode 1 Discussion

More topics from this board

» New Poster of One Piece Flim: Red

» Is this the worst one piece movie? ( 1 2 )

» Confusion about the time line of the Movie [*spoiler from Wano]

» So where is Kyuubey???

Poll: » Best Film Red Song (Since the movie is now out on streaming services)

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters