TheSunLife said: ScraF said: Do you value all of the shows you've given a 7 the same? Some you consider to be close to an 8 while others close to a 6, same logic applies here. Right but a 10 is considered the highest value possible, there is no imaginary decimals (which I use). Sure there are anime that I gave 10s which I value more but, every single thing on their list? I press X to doubt. TheSunLife said: A 9.5 can be rounded up to a 10, can it not?ScraF said: Do you value all of the shows you've given a 7 the same? Some you consider to be close to an 8 while others close to a 6, same logic applies here. Right but a 10 is considered the highest value possible, there is no imaginary decimals (which I use). Sure there are anime that I gave 10s which I value more but, every single thing on their list? I press X to doubt. |
| Not just taste-shaming, but also taste-arguing is pointless. "I don't understand how you could rate X lower than Y, it's absurd!" This isn't about shaming the other party, it's just a lack of understanding that everyone's taste is different. Anime is entertainment: sometimes I'm entertained by deep and thought provoking stuff, some other times I'm not; sometimes I'm entertained by shallow but fun stuff, some other times I'm not. No point in arguing. |
| it can be funny if you use it as ajoke but if you're using it seriously thats just stupid lol. |
ScraF said: TheSunLife said: Right but a 10 is considered the highest value possible, there is no imaginary decimals (which I use). Sure there are anime that I gave 10s which I value more but, every single thing on their list? I press X to doubt. TheSunLife said: A 9.5 can be rounded up to a 10, can it not?Right but a 10 is considered the highest value possible, there is no imaginary decimals (which I use). Sure there are anime that I gave 10s which I value more but, every single thing on their list? I press X to doubt. Not in this case because a 10 by definition is perfect. You can't round up to a 10, that defeats the purpose. If it is a 9.5 or higher it is still a 9, it is missing that extra umph to make it a 10. But again you are missing the main point they gave everything a 10. Like I don't care, they can do whatever they want (it's there list/maybe they just enjoyed everything they watched). It's just they should know because of that no one will take their opinion seriously. Because they have no taste (or at least don't show it at first glance). |
| "Bro, if you set your mind to it. You can jack off to anything." ☆☆☆☆☆ |
| People like adhoms on the internet what is new? If someone does that to you ultimately you know they aren't worth engaging with any form of dialogue. |
| It is dumb imo. We seem to have forgotten opinions exists. So I say. Demon Slayer > Your favourite anime It also deserves a 10/10 score. |
Lepru said: Taste-shaming can be necessary sometimes. I'm not saying that people should go around insulting people because of their favourite anime or anything like that. I see taste-shaming necessary when someone insults an anime for a certain reason and at the same time praises another anime completely ignoring that this anime has the same flow. A primary example of this are One Piece fans insulting Fairy Tail for not having many deaths/having fake deaths while acting like One Piece is completely flawless. I don't even know how a One Piece fan can say something like this, but I've seen many examples of this...These people need to be put in their place. Its not only one piece fans Most of the fanbase insults ft for not having lots of deaths. (but you only mentioned one piece because you hate it.) Don't attack me, i love fairy tail. |
 |
| it’s so childish imo lmaooo, i remember being screamed on here bcos i rated jjk a 7 and aot a 10 whilst they had rated jjk a 10 and aot a 4. apparently that’s me being a sheep looooll,, idc what anyone rates anything bcos we’re all allowed our own opinions.. no idea why some ppl on the website take it so personally and think it’s a massive deal. who even cares?! |
Sakuta002766 said: Lepru said: Taste-shaming can be necessary sometimes. I'm not saying that people should go around insulting people because of their favourite anime or anything like that. I see taste-shaming necessary when someone insults an anime for a certain reason and at the same time praises another anime completely ignoring that this anime has the same flow. A primary example of this are One Piece fans insulting Fairy Tail for not having many deaths/having fake deaths while acting like One Piece is completely flawless. I don't even know how a One Piece fan can say something like this, but I've seen many examples of this...These people need to be put in their place. Its not only one piece fans Most of the fanbase insults ft for not having lots of deaths. (but you only mentioned one piece because you hate it.) Don't attack me, i love fairy tail. You didn't get the point of my comment. I used one piece as an example because One piece has arguably even more fake deaths. So seeing a one piece fan criticising fairy tail for fake deaths completely ignoring all the horrible fake deaths in One piece is just stupid and hypocritical. By the way, I don't hate One piece... I'm a fan of it. You may think I hate it because I gave a low score to the anime, but that's just because I can't forgive Toei for changing the Akainu vs Whitebeard fight... and I also dislike how they have been animating Wano, I absolutely hate all those Dragon ball effects, there is no point in using them with One piece. |
| Someone telling me to watch Demon Slayer is not an insult, I enjoyed it. As for Shounen, a lot of my favs are from this demographic and alongside Seinen, has done the most for anime. So I find it hard to get offended over stupid stuff like that. |
| Taste shaming is completely justified. Anyone with even slightly different interests to me is subhuman and should be socially ostracised. |
 |
| fuck them they suck on big black cock |
| That's why I'm only letting chicks with 90% affinity i to my harem Jokes aside from what I've seen people usually only say this kind of stuff when someone shit talks an Anime and then also praises something similar to no end . Basically hypocrisy |
| It's never relevant or insightful in any discussion. Totally uncalled for. |
 Life is a despicable endurance race |
Lunilah said: AlexPaulLEWZ said: To give people pause, as in they see something from you intended to make them think twice. Talking about your mean score, as you've given every anime you've completed a 10/10. I'm curious as to why.Give people what? I'm afraid I don't understand. The point of this is that there are quite some people who call-out 10-meaners as people with "no taste." It's not insulting per se, but I think it's somehow... annoying to think about. What is the meaning of "no taste" or "taste" to begin with? Exactly like that xD I feel that you cannot fully objectvely compare one anime to another since they're both so different. Coupled with how I like anime that much, I can't really decide what's bad when I FINALLY WATCH IT xD |
Roevhaal said: AlexPaulLEWZ said: What's the point of giving 10's to everything? If you give everything the same rating that rating no longer has any meaning and If you just don't want to bother there's the option to not rate at all.Give people what? I'm afraid I don't understand. The point of this is that there are quite some people who call-out 10-meaners as people with "no taste." It's not insulting per se, but I think it's somehow... annoying to think about. What is the meaning of "no taste" or "taste" to begin with? What's the point of giving a low score to X, but a higher score to Y? Objectivity? I understand that, but what is the threshold, the standard that anime you like should have? For example, you gave Bakemonogatari a 10, but Beelzebub a 1. Does that mean your standard for supernatural things is Bakemonogatari, and since Beelzebub didn't have the harem and/or romance like Bakemonogatari, it gets a low score? If it is, I don't blame you for that, but if it isn't, what are your grounds of giving Beelzebub a 1? You didn't like it? Understandable. You thought that the characters were bland? Understandable. But other people out there might view the characters as awesome. The story didn't click with you? Understandable. There are people out there who don't think Bakemonogatari is good! The point is, ratings are subjective to the one giving them. Just because they give 10 to everything doesn't automatically mean that they 10s are already meaningless. What is the meaning of rating in the first place, what do people base their ratings on? Isn't it because of pure subjectivity? Since I rate based on pure enjoyment... I can't really decide what's a 9 xD But I guess it should be something that truly disappointed me... which by far, haven't yet come. Or did it? idk can't remember |
AlexPaulLEWZMay 5, 2021 1:19 PM
TheSunLife said: You do not have any taste lol. You can't rate everything a 10 and say you have taste in anime. You obviously did it for the meme. I can see you are definitely committed to the bit. Because there is no possible way you are telling me Uzaki-chan and Attack on titan are equal. Go watch some shit anime like sword art or boku no pico. You can't tell me we can take your opinion seriously. Cause according to you, you haven't seen any bad anime to take part in a conversation. That's the problem with the premise of your argument (in my opinion). Just because I rate everything I watch a 10, doesn't mean that I'm going to watch everything and give it a 10. How are you going to equate Uzaki-chan and Attack on Titan when their genres and focuses are in totally different directions? Uzaki is a comedy while Attack on Titan is action. They are, and will never be equal. Sword Art Online? Oh. Looks like I forgot to put it in my list LMAO. I stopped watching after the second season since the gap was so long that I moved to other watching priorities and eventually forgot it. What is the most "accepted" definition of "taste" in the first place? The reason why I am doing this argument is because I believe "taste" as the inclination to watch shows of one type against other types of shows. When I was younger, I liked watching popular things like the shows at the top 3000 of MAL, but as I grew older, I felt that I am liking to find hidden gems more. Of course, I avoid certain tropes like gore, death games, and such as much as possible, but of course, there are some exceptions. So basically, preference = taste is how I define it. PS. I don't think SAO is shit within its first two seasons. I loved the Mother's Rosario Arc best, followed by the original Aincrad arc. |
AlexPaulLEWZ said: You give high scores to what you think is good and low scores to what you think is bad, do you honestly believe everything on your list is crème de la crème? To me it seems like you think very fondly of Island, should it really be placed in the same category as every other anime on your list?Roevhaal said: What's the point of giving 10's to everything? If you give everything the same rating that rating no longer has any meaning and If you just don't want to bother there's the option to not rate at all. What's the point of giving a low score to X, but a higher score to Y? Objectivity? I understand that, but what is the threshold, the standard that anime you like should have? For example, you gave Bakemonogatari a 10, but Beelzebub a 1. Does that mean your standard for supernatural things is Bakemonogatari, and since Beelzebub didn't have the harem and/or romance like Bakemonogatari, it gets a low score? If it is, I don't blame you for that, but if it isn't, what are your grounds of giving Beelzebub a 1? You didn't like it? Understandable. You thought that the characters were bland? Understandable. But other people out there might view the characters as awesome. The story didn't click with you? Understandable. There are people out there who don't think Bakemonogatari is good! The point is, ratings are subjective to the one giving them. Just because they give 10 to everything doesn't automatically mean that they 10s are already meaningless. What is the meaning of rating in the first place, what do people base their ratings on? Isn't it because of pure subjectivity? Since I rate based on pure enjoyment... I can't really decide what's a 9 xD But I guess it should be something that truly disappointed me... which by far, haven't yet come. Or did it? idk can't remember |
Roevhaal said: AlexPaulLEWZ said: You give high scores to what you think is good and low scores to what you think is bad, do you honestly believe everything on your list is crème de la crème? To me it seems like you think very fondly of Island, should it really be placed in the same category as every other anime on your list?What's the point of giving a low score to X, but a higher score to Y? Objectivity? I understand that, but what is the threshold, the standard that anime you like should have? For example, you gave Bakemonogatari a 10, but Beelzebub a 1. Does that mean your standard for supernatural things is Bakemonogatari, and since Beelzebub didn't have the harem and/or romance like Bakemonogatari, it gets a low score? If it is, I don't blame you for that, but if it isn't, what are your grounds of giving Beelzebub a 1? You didn't like it? Understandable. You thought that the characters were bland? Understandable. But other people out there might view the characters as awesome. The story didn't click with you? Understandable. There are people out there who don't think Bakemonogatari is good! The point is, ratings are subjective to the one giving them. Just because they give 10 to everything doesn't automatically mean that they 10s are already meaningless. What is the meaning of rating in the first place, what do people base their ratings on? Isn't it because of pure subjectivity? Since I rate based on pure enjoyment... I can't really decide what's a 9 xD But I guess it should be something that truly disappointed me... which by far, haven't yet come. Or did it? idk can't remember I don't think anything is the crème de la crème. I believe everything has their flaws, and thus their respective uniqueness—including Island—regrettably. Island, of course, is not in the same category! It's apart from any other 10 I have since it's the only one in my favorites xD But like what I said in my quote above, I can't really give something lower than a 10 until I figure out what constitutes a true 9 in my book—which is, for now, something that will actually disappoint me for once. |
| This is the exact of the reason why I used to put my list on private |
AlexPaulLEWZ said: What is the most "accepted" definition of "taste" in the first place? The reason why I am doing this argument is because I believe "taste" as the inclination to watch shows of one type against other types of shows. When I was younger, I liked watching popular things like the shows at the top 3000 of MAL, but as I grew older, I felt that I am liking to find hidden gems more. Of course, I avoid certain tropes like gore, death games, and such as much as possible, but of course, there are some exceptions. So basically, preference = taste is how I define it. PS. I don't think SAO is shit within its first two seasons. I loved the Mother's Rosario Arc best, followed by the original Aincrad arc. I mean, taste would be "what distinguishes that which you like from that which you dislike". If you're giving the same rating to everything you've seen, that difference is 0. For instance, if someone were to ride 299 different cars with different color, engine, tires, suspension, spoilers etc. and didn't feel more or less strongly on any of them, I don't think anyone who knows him would say that he has a specific taste on cars. I'm not trying to guilt you or anything, it just intuitively seems that way to me that you'd need to be making some sort of distinction between what you consume in terms of your personal connection for the forming of a taste. |
 |
| Just let people like what they want to like. It’s not the end of the world if someone doesn’t like this anime/manga that you really enjoy. |
| just lurking around |
| The quicker you stop caring about what others say about the anime you watch, the better it is for you. Watch what you want, rate it however you want, enjoy it however you want. Stop allowing opinions of other people to influence you. In the end it is YOU who decide to watch what you want to watch, not them. |
 |
It just shows how inmature people can be. I try to respect everyones opinions, even when they trash my favorite shows for no reason. I respect it, because they have the right of disliking something. What I do not respect, is this, taste-shamming. If you are going to make fun of someone just because of their likes, you shouldn't be giving away your opinion, because you are not onlty proving that you are inmature, but also that you are extremely annoying and egocentric.  |
slaidayMay 5, 2021 4:21 PM
| Its super dumb but sadly its not rare in mal . Those dumb azz always thought that they rule the world and people shud like what they like. "Ur taste is shit" "Ur 10 score is sucks" ? <---Dumb shut in who thought they rule the world |
| Taste-shaming is actually the only argument that matters. Why would I waste my time discussing anything with anyone when I can just laugh at them for giving Naruto a 10 |
Auron_ said: AlexPaulLEWZ said: What is the most "accepted" definition of "taste" in the first place? The reason why I am doing this argument is because I believe "taste" as the inclination to watch shows of one type against other types of shows. When I was younger, I liked watching popular things like the shows at the top 3000 of MAL, but as I grew older, I felt that I am liking to find hidden gems more. Of course, I avoid certain tropes like gore, death games, and such as much as possible, but of course, there are some exceptions. So basically, preference = taste is how I define it. PS. I don't think SAO is shit within its first two seasons. I loved the Mother's Rosario Arc best, followed by the original Aincrad arc. I mean, taste would be "what distinguishes that which you like from that which you dislike". If you're giving the same rating to everything you've seen, that difference is 0. For instance, if someone were to ride 299 different cars with different color, engine, tires, suspension, spoilers etc. and didn't feel more or less strongly on any of them, I don't think anyone who knows him would say that he has a specific taste on cars. I'm not trying to guilt you or anything, it just intuitively seems that way to me that you'd need to be making some sort of distinction between what you consume in terms of your personal connection for the forming of a taste. Ah. Now I get it. But then again, by that logic, merely basing my mean score as the essence for taste would be lacking, in my opinion. There are shows that I avoid to watch since the synopses, reviews, and general community feedback will undoubtedly affect my first impressions on it. For example, I like harem and romantic comedies. I would watch Gotoubun no Hanayome since a tutor-tutee relationships sounds appealing to me, but not Rent-A-Girfriend since the premise feels some sort of a please don't cancel me for this pseudo-pr*stitution, making me steer clear from it. PS. I know that this makes me judge the book by its cover, but in my opinion, that isn't different from people dropping a show after 2 episodes and giving it a 1. Using your car argument, a person might like those 299 cars equally from different brands and models (although that guy must be so rich to own cars) but he could have brands that he doesn't want to touch! I think that also constitutes to taste. Same for anime, which would require a person who genuinely likes all anime that he watches, which I believe I am! If I actually had the time, I can write reviews for each and every entry in my list explaining why they deserve a 10 in my book xD What I want to say is, while an evenly-distributed mean makes it easier (and simpler) for people to gauge taste, having a mean of 10 doesn't necessarily mean that he has "no taste," since they have shows that they refuse to watch. They rate everything a 10, yes, but I believe that even for them, not everything deserves a 10. |
AlexPaulLEWZMay 5, 2021 7:27 PM
| what's the matter,just fucking enjoy it,this is when i meet a person who always shits on taste,especially when we both a casual,i always rage quitted |
 |
KaiserHamuel said: Everyone who dislikes what I like and vice versa are mentally ill. Sounds wrong but most of the time most of us think like that |
"no one really laughs on the internet, they just go 'hM' and type '𝕃𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸𝕆𝕄𝔸𝕆𝔸'." I'm Level 69 on Mal Badges. View My Badges.  |
Hate to be that guy, but this one is kinda true most of the time. I wouldn't call someone a "shounen retard", but there are countless instances of people (who only watch the most mainstream battle shounen) popping up in discussion threads of other genres and complaining about the show being "too confusing" or "not enough action". And in those cases, the reason why they don't enjoy these other anime is because they literally only enjoy shounen :x It's still not a nice way to say it tho. |
StormxNightmareMay 5, 2021 10:27 PM
There's no possible way you can steal my heart    I want to drown in this sweet Melancholy |
| IMO, worst of all is when they attack you with "your english suck", "go learn English", etc. |
| Signature removed. Check your inbox |
| it always be the elitist who refused to accept that people dislikes what they likes and forced their opinion, they also likes to start a fight and arguments. and ooops they're so salty for no reason. |
  ♡hyena zzZzzZ♡ |
| stupid shit, everyone can give the rating they want to anything. no judging |
i fucking hate manga (keeps reading manga discord | o_ganji |
| I mostly don't care, love what you love. Though I think it's sad to limit yourself to only a few genres, whichever they are. And men watching only magical girl and loli stuff are cringe. |
| I like seeing them get called out for shaming others for liking what they like. It's just so stupid to think you have a "superior taste" and use that to make fun of people. |
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
MilkShakeT said: KaiserHamuel said: Everyone who dislikes what I like and vice versa are mentally ill. Sounds wrong but most of the time most of us think like that Yeah and that's the main reason why I try to tell myself that shows I dislike do have certain qualities that someone else may value more than I do. Same as how people who dislike the show that I like give more weightage to other qualities of the show lol |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I mostly just agree with what everyone here says, calling someone out for their "trash taste" is the most overused and unoriginal insult possible and at that point you're only embarrassing yourself if anything. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Taste different with personality, taste talk about ur favorite whereas personality talk about ur attitude / behaviour It is ok to prohibite appearance but prohibite mock other taste, is that world u gonna live in without conflict n discord ? Where is fun point of all these ? Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted posts |
NoLiferSoulMay 15, 2021 6:20 AM
 |
More topics from this board
» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 4 )nirererin - Oct 9 |
160 |
by Nefregar
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» 🍷 AD Summer 2025 Best Girl Contest ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Shizuna - Sep 28 |
320 |
by Nefregar
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Waifu War V5 (Anniversary-Edition!) (Round 1) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Minkalex - Sep 28 |
343 |
by Sensual_Yuri_69
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Do you actually want to marry your favorite VA?Dragevard - 9 hours ago |
12 |
by Catalano
»»
27 minutes ago |
|
» What MMORPGs are VRMMO/Isekai anime based on?thewiru - 8 hours ago |
10 |
by thewiru
»»
45 minutes ago |