HeNrYTG50 said: @yu6 Hoshi no Samidare could be what you're looking for. :) Also, I think Inuyasha should count. Oh I know that one but haven't read it yet. Thank you! |
 |
MissSweet said: Can someone recommend me a manga for #60? (˘ʃƪ˘) You've lots more Junji Ito waiting for you, like Souichi no Tanoshii Nikki or Kubi Gensou. Or more Aya Nakahara goodness like Dame na Watashi ni Koishite Kudasai. But for a mangaka you may not have read before, Warau Kanoko-sama and its sequel Koi Dano Ai Dano. Naedoko is one of my all-time favorite shoujo protagonists. |
 |
Sazerlim said: IS reading a hentai manga allowed for the challenge I-its not like I'm gonna read one... Haha, yes hentai is allowed, it's just not a requirement. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Hi! Can anyone help me with #38 Read a manga with more users listed in Plan to Read than Completed? I want something complete if possible^^ |
  |
makotoed said: Hi! Can anyone help me with #38 Read a manga with more users listed in Plan to Read than Completed? I want something complete if possible^^ Takemitsu Zamurai is the first one i found. i'm sure if you look, you can find others. |
AudioTsunami said: makotoed said: Hi! Can anyone help me with #38 Read a manga with more users listed in Plan to Read than Completed? I want something complete if possible^^ Takemitsu Zamurai is the first one i found. i'm sure if you look, you can find others. Thank you! I'll try to look first before reading this. |
| |
Selphie64 said: aslerio said: Please recommend me some manga for challenge #43, #44, #49 #43. Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in their field #44. Read a manga that deals with something related to Japanese culture #49. Read a manga centered around folklore or mythology Thank you! #43: Eternal Sabbath (scientist), Monster (doctors & detectives) #44: Ghost Hunt (japanese.... well, ghosts, Buddhist monks, Shinto priestess, etc.), Gugure Kokkuri-san (yokai) or, if you're feeling really ambitious, InuYasha (more yokai) #49: Samon the Summoner, Mahoutsukai no Yome Well, maybe you can get some more recommendations elsewhere, I've tried to find the least shoujo on my list. =) thank you very much! i think i am going to read monster first |
 |
| Hey, any recommendation for #30? And another one for #60? Preferably between 20-60 chapters and completed :3 #30 : Read a manga adapted from a video game, original anime or light novel. |
Asunii said: Hey, any recommendation for #30? And another one for #60? Preferably between 20-60 chapters and completed :3 #30 : Read a manga adapted from a video game, original anime or light novel. For #30, how about the Wolf Children manga? It just says original anime, not anime series, so manga adapted from anime films should be ok. I dunno if it's fully scanlated though, they might have dropped it after YP picked it up. I know I saw the complete omnibus at B&N yesterday though. Looked pretty nice, if a bit pricey. If I'd had the time I'd have just read it there. Failing that, The Electric Tale of Pikachu is a classic. If that's no good, maybe one of the Zelda adaptations. Edit: Breath of Fire IV got a pretty legit manga adaptation too, come to think of it. For #60... maybe Bonnouji? Seems like you read a lot of romance. |
HorkusFeb 28, 2017 3:54 PM
Horkus said: Asunii said: Hey, any recommendation for #30? And another one for #60? Preferably between 20-60 chapters and completed :3 #30 : Read a manga adapted from a video game, original anime or light novel. For #30, how about the Wolf Children manga? It just says original anime, not anime series, so manga adapted from anime films should be ok. I dunno if it's fully scanlated though, they might have dropped it after YP picked it up. I know I saw the complete omnibus at B&N yesterday though. Looked pretty nice, if a bit pricey. If I'd had the time I'd have just read it there. Failing that, The Electric Tale of Pikachu is a classic. If that's no good, maybe one of the Zelda adaptations. Edit: Breath of Fire IV got a pretty legit manga adaptation too, come to think of it. For #60... maybe Bonnouji? Seems like you read a lot of romance. Oh wow, these look great and the lengths are perfect! Pretty much interested in reading all of them :p Stupid of me to not think of Pokemon though, as I love the games and used to watch the anime all the time, should've thought of that one xDD Thanks a lot! |
| For No.30 "Something adapted from Video Game, Anime or Light Novel", Does Dragon Quest, Dai no Daibouken count, since it doesn't follow the story of Dragon Quest but has the same name and universe? |
 |
| @makotoed https://myanimelist.net/manga/44307/Kakukaku_Shikajika/stats counts @Bagira20 If it doesn't follow the same story, at least partially, then it wouldn't count as an adaptation, so unfortunately no |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| I dont understand something. 25.Read a manga that started publishing last year (*). (*).=??? That the manga must have at least 5 volumes in length or this is only for the extra title"Prodigious "??? Or i can read a one-shot or something like that from 2016? |
  |
L0ro said: I dont understand something. 25.Read a manga that started publishing last year (*). (*).=??? That the manga must have at least 5 volumes in length or this is only for the extra title"Prodigious "??? Or i can read a one-shot or something like that from 2016? That restriction is only for the people doing it on Prodigious difficulty, and the challenges with the "*" are excluded from the 5 volume long restriction |
 |
tsuyokunaru said: @makotoed https://myanimelist.net/manga/44307/Kakukaku_Shikajika/stats counts @Bagira20 If it doesn't follow the same story, at least partially, then it wouldn't count as an adaptation, so unfortunately no Thank you for the recommendation! I'll check this out^^ |
| |
yube said: I need help for challenge #60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. Any suggestions? I'd like something completed but I'm ok with anything else otherwise. Maybe on the shorter side if possible? Holy cow I can't even load your ptr list on the mobile site it's too big. Did you just add every series you haven't read? The first thing that jumped out at me going down the list was Blue Spring Ride. That's a pretty good shortish series, maybe give that a try. |
yube said: I need help for challenge #60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. Any suggestions? I'd like something completed but I'm ok with anything else otherwise. Maybe on the shorter side if possible? I saw About Death on your PTR, it's real good. |
| I'm taking suggestions for 42, 60, 51, 64, 46, 5, 20, 28, 33, 48, 67, 19, 41, and 2 please help |
AudioTsunami said: I'm taking suggestions for 42, 60, 51, 64, 46, 5, 20, 28, 33, 48, 67, 19, 41, and 2 please help #42 Ookami to Koushinryou #60 Life For #33 it's a manhwa but it's really good in my opinion. It's called Can't See Can't Hear But Love #48 Sakamichi No Apollon or Diamond Dust For #67 since the second letter of your username is "u" I suggest you to read Umania but you can also look for other manga that you're interested in #19 Nagi no Asu kara or Hamatora #41 Love So Life For #2 is a josei manga but I hope you don't mind since I personally enjoyed it. It's called Aigan Cinderella. |
| |
| 15. Read a manga serialized in a josei magazine I don't normally seek out josei, so I'm stumped on this one. Would any magazine with at least one josei series in it count? Any recommendations? |
  |
| I still don't know what to do with #66 (Read a manga suggested by Manga+ or MyAnimeList). They only rec me things like Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso, Naruto, or Tokyo Ghoul, and I'm doing a Yuri only challenge :/ Another question, would this count as being related to Maria-sama ga Miteru for #69 (Read a manga that is related to something you previously read) purposes, even though this particular Marimite manga isn't in manga relations of the one I want to read? TambalaiAri said: 15. Read a manga serialized in a josei magazine I don't normally seek out josei, so I'm stumped on this one. Would any magazine with at least one josei series in it count? Any recommendations? I don't think it counts. I was recommended Pietà for that very item, and I liked it, you can check it out if you want. |
 |
AudioTsunami said: I'm taking suggestions for 42, 60, 51, 64, 46, 5, 20, 28, 33, 48, 67, 19, 41, and 2 please help Junji Ito's Cat Diary is a nice little read, and would count for either #42 or #51. I Don't Exist in This Firefly City should do for #41, though I don't remember any ages being given, they are clearly young kids. U wa Uchuusen no U for either #2 or #20. Frankenstein for #46 and Monster for #46 or #5. TambalaiAri said: 15. Read a manga serialized in a josei magazine I don't normally seek out josei, so I'm stumped on this one. Would any magazine with at least one josei series in it count? Any recommendations? Comic ZERO-SUM publish some pretty non-standard josei, but for almost-shoujo josei, you could try Dame na Watashi ni Koishite Kudasai, Ginban Kishi, Jumping or anything by Akiko Higashimura, all very good, fuzzy josei. |
Selphie64Mar 6, 2017 10:50 AM
|
| @Conde_Mohr @Selphie64 :: Thank you for the recommendations! I now have a long list of josei to investigate~ |
| |
psychosheep said: Hi there ! I also got the 60th challenge! please recommend me anything ( but no yaoi, ecchi, yuri or harem please >.< and also, does a manga that takes place in a imaginary/ a place that don't exist/ all around the word (i thought of Hetalia ;) work for the challenger 46 : Read a manga that takes place outside of Japan (if not, please recommend me Something because i didn't find anything yet ^^' thank you !!! *(^0^)* There's a sadly overlooked Arakawa short Raiden-18, or Liar Game for some mind games. Koi dano Ai dano and its prequel are very good, non-standard shoujo, as is the ever-popular (deservingly) Akatsuki no Yona. As for 'outside of Japan', I guess we'll need one of the admins to decide, I'd like to know as well. DQA said: Hi Guys! I also have the 60 Challange and would need a recommandation! Im totally in Survival Mangas like Battle Royal, Kamisama etc. But i guess i have read most of them. Maybe someone sees if im missing an Major one and can give me an recommandation :D Otherwise some Other Aktion Stuff would be Fine :D ... I'm not an authority on the survival manga, but the characters in Junji Ito Collection 4 or Junji Ito Collection 9 are making decent efforts towards that specific goal. Ditto in his more known work, Uzumaki, or you could try Kimi no Knife. School Mermaid is also a pretty fun horror with nice little twists. |
|
DQA said: Hi Guys! I also have the 60 Challange and would need a recommandation! Im totally in Survival Mangas like Battle Royal, Kamisama etc. But i guess i have read most of them. Maybe someone sees if im missing an Major one and can give me an recommandation :D Otherwise some Other Aktion Stuff would be Fine :D Besides this im someone is looking for something for #38"More Plan to read then completted" Imawa no Kuni Alice is almost entirely translated in English. |
HeDoesntRow said: Anybody got a recommendation for 43. Read a manga that has a main character that is a professional in his field? I'm eyeing Freesia and Tajuu Jinkaku Tantei Psycho, but I'm not sure if I'm in the mood for a story quite so dark right now. Any suggestions are welcome, thanks. Bambino!! Kakukaku Shikajika Natsu no Zenjitsu Subaru |
| I need a recommendation for "40 - Read a manga with an adult MC", I would start reading Uchuu Kyoudai, but I already have a lot of ongoing manga in the challenge. About challenge "61 - Read a manga that another user has read for this challenge", should I ask here in this thread for something or should I go and check the lists one by one to find something? Thanks for the help. |
 |
PurpleHaze said: I need a recommendation for "40 - Read a manga with an adult MC", I would start reading Uchuu Kyoudai, but I already have a lot of ongoing manga in the challenge. About challenge "61 - Read a manga that another user has read for this challenge", should I ask here in this thread for something or should I go and check the lists one by one to find something? Thanks for the help. For an adult MC: I see you enjoyed 20th Century Boys, so why not try Monster or Master Keaton? I also see Sanctuary on your ptr, that'd be good too. As for 61 I'm pretty sure you could do either, as long as you link to the challenge entry you found it on. I'll go ahead and recommend Kakukaku Shikajika, which I read last week for the "award-winning" challenge, but if that doesn't look like your cup of tea you can look through the challenge entries and see if anything jumps out at you as interesting. |
Horkus said: PurpleHaze said: I need a recommendation for "40 - Read a manga with an adult MC". For an adult MC: I see you enjoyed 20th Century Boys, so why not try Monster or Master Keaton? Strongly recomend 20th Century Boys. Mushishi also would be great i think. |
Horkus said: PurpleHaze said: I need a recommendation for "40 - Read a manga with an adult MC", I would start reading Uchuu Kyoudai, but I already have a lot of ongoing manga in the challenge. About challenge "61 - Read a manga that another user has read for this challenge", should I ask here in this thread for something or should I go and check the lists one by one to find something? Thanks for the help. For an adult MC: I see you enjoyed 20th Century Boys, so why not try Monster or Master Keaton? I also see Sanctuary on your ptr, that'd be good too. As for 61 I'm pretty sure you could do either, as long as you link to the challenge entry you found it on. I'll go ahead and recommend Kakukaku Shikajika, which I read last week for the "award-winning" challenge, but if that doesn't look like your cup of tea you can look through the challenge entries and see if anything jumps out at you as interesting. Thanks for the help. Monster I watched the anime again last year, so everything is still fresh in my memory, so I think I'll go with Sanctuary, thanks. |
|
| Can anyone recommend me a manga for 60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread |
 |
| Guys....I need help with challenge #44... Any recommendations of around ~30-40 chapters? |
| @Mellowmancer You can try RELife, Nazo no Kanojo,Ore Monogatari... For shorter ones try Another or Cross Manage. If you like no nonsense SoL you can try Goggles. |
Mellowmancer said: Can anyone recommend me a manga for 60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread Slam Dunk Vagabond Kuroko no Basket All on your PTR and all very highly rated on my list. Although you gave Kakukaku Shikajika a 7...boooo |
ThenextOBITO said: Guys....I need help with challenge #44... Any recommendations of around ~30-40 chapters? Densha Otoko(2 ch, train molestation stuff) Ran and The grey World(folklore) Crows....might work? Idk if japanese high school deliquents/yakuza/bike gangs is "japanese culture" enough. |
| Hi guys, I would love to get a recommendation for the following challenge "Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread". Preferable a mix of adventure, action and supernatural, any lenght (pretty standard I know XD), however true masterpieces of any genre would work to as I'd love to read anything good, thank you very much in advance <3 |
 |
Lyfa said: Hi guys, I would love to get a recommendation for the following challenge "Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread". Preferable a mix of adventure, action and supernatural, any lenght (pretty standard I know XD), however true masterpieces of any genre would work to as I'd love to read anything good, thank you very much in advance <3 Berserk Kakukaku Shikajika Ran and the grey world. |
AudioTsunami said: Lyfa said: Hi guys, I would love to get a recommendation for the following challenge "Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread". Preferable a mix of adventure, action and supernatural, any lenght (pretty standard I know XD), however true masterpieces of any genre would work to as I'd love to read anything good, thank you very much in advance <3 Berserk Kakukaku Shikajika Ran and the grey world. Thank you, I'll definitly check them out :D |
|
ThenextOBITO said: @Mellowmancer You can try RELife, Nazo no Kanojo,Ore Monogatari... For shorter ones try Another or Cross Manage. If you like no nonsense SoL you can try Goggles. Ty for the rec, I'll check them all out. AudioTsunami said: Mellowmancer said: Can anyone recommend me a manga for 60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread Slam Dunk Vagabond Kuroko no Basket All on your PTR and all very highly rated on my list. Although you gave Kakukaku Shikajika a 7...boooo Lol ty for the rec, I'll make sure to get to them soon. |
|
AudioTsunami said: ThenextOBITO said: Guys....I need help with challenge #44... Any recommendations of around ~30-40 chapters? Densha Otoko(2 ch, train molestation stuff) Ran and The grey World(folklore) Crows....might work? Idk if japanese high school deliquents/yakuza/bike gangs is "japanese culture" enough. Densha Otoko sounds nice...But I am supposed to say what aspect of Japanese culture it represents....what should I do about that? I am pretty sure that Train molestation doesn't count as an integral part of Japanese culture. Anyway,thanks for the recommendations....You were a big help. |
ThenextOBITO said: Densha Otoko sounds nice...But I am supposed to say what aspect of Japanese culture it represents....what should I do about that? I am pretty sure that Train molestation doesn't count as an integral part of Japanese culture. Anyway,thanks for the recommendations....You were a big help. I'd say this category is fairly hard to deal with as well. For example, an workplace/office comedy or drama doesn't necessarily count as a discussion of Japanese workplace culture, but it definitely could count. Seems kinda subjective tbh. Honestly as long as you think you can make some kind of case for a series you're probably OK. Either that or take the easy way out and do something folklore-related. |
| Can anyone help me with these? Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama Read a one-shot (*) - It must be a one chapter story, not one volume |
More topics from this board
» What is your favorite manga that got axes (not a rush ending )mistguy23 - Jul 10 |
14 |
by mistguy23
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Sticky: » The 'Help Identifying This Manga/Character' Thread v3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 19, 2022 |
1301 |
by Lukas_Burg
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» How to deal with having to wait for manga?thewiru - Yesterday |
1 |
by Retro8bit
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» Have you ever droped a manga that you had been following for a long time and with great interest?RobertBobert - Sep 7 |
17 |
by RobertBobert
»»
Yesterday, 12:19 PM |
|
» Occasional manga reader, what's stopping you from reading more of them?fleurbleue - Aug 18 |
15 |
by Spiffy_Official
»»
Yesterday, 5:37 AM |