DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Pretty good episode. I like the MC, he's brave and looks pretty useful. Great OST by Sawano as always, the animation is great as well. The OP wasn't that good in my opinion, and it looks like I have to wait for another week to hear the ED. 5/5 |
mizukasaApr 7, 2016 5:03 PM
 |
Amarrez said: Honestly? Thought it was rubbish. This may just be me being jaded but I can't stand Araki's over the top, EVERYONE IS SCREAMING ALL THE TIME direction anymore. It tries for bombast but to me it's just incredibly irritating. Or maybe it's just not for you? |
mizukasa said: The ED wasn't that good in my opinion, and it looks like I have to wait for another week to hear the OP. That was the OP played in the end. The ED is by Aimer. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
| Shingeki no Zombie. |
shanimebib said: -Ducky said: Have you read the manga or something? I thought it wasn't out yet. (that's what it says on mal anyway) Well assuming it takes 1-3 days to turn, wtf was the scene with the mc all about then? He turned in like 2 minutes tops. And having more than one conductor doesn't matter, if the train was infested, it's likely that everyone inside would die, as they did. (really not sure how multiple operators is relevant tbh) The manga won't come out in Japan before May 2, 2016. I am not sure where we are getting the 24-72 hours from. I guess some people have access to Fuji TV because the anime is TV Original and not adapted from another source. DragonSlayer_19 said: Oh come on ! Who would expect zombie-like blood thirsty creature to be intelligent ? Of course they don't think so . How can they expect a kabane to operate a train and have it arrive on time ? Didn't they add that scene of the kabane sitting in the operating room for some reason ? That's the thing. How do we know that THEY don't know whether Kabane are intelligent or not? Just because they have zombie traits, it doesn't mean they are the hollywood zombies we know. edit: added spoiler tag. Well wasn't them getting caught off guard seeing a train operated by a kabane enough to make u think that they thought the kabane were unintelligent creatures ? Oh well if u insist on your point , so be it . Maybe next episode you'll get ur answer as to whether they thought of kabane as intelligent or unintelligent creatures |
 |
shanimebib said: mizukasa said: The ED wasn't that good in my opinion, and it looks like I have to wait for another week to hear the OP. That was the OP played in the end. The ED is by Aimer. You're right. I was actually about to edit my comment. |
|
| Very awesome, definitely following this. |
 |
Lararin said: ColdBreeze said: Now that you mention it, it's even more unbelievable.Our MC got infected in less than a minute. The guy on the train not. Curious if they have an explanation for it and some other stuff. Yup, I'm really curious about this. The guy on the train lasted a good one or two minutes without showing any signs of infection except for right where he was bitten. But the main character was almost gone within about the same length of time. The main character made it clear though that "this isn't a curse, it's a virus" and they made a point of showing he was gathering Kabane bits from the dirty trains to study. Then when the Bushi police/warriors came it was mentioned there being a rule that they keep people who were bitten or "might be" Kabane for three days in prison.... even in real life people can be carriers for a disease without showing signs of infection themselves, and depending on a person's overall health it may take longer/shorter for them to be affected by a disease, so perhaps this is something like that. I wanna know the science behind this XD For starters, let's watch the anime first, SHALL we. Here's the image of the train-guy 1: As you can see, the infection is evident and it did happen in a few seconds. Note the bite isn't that big, bit is a chomp-off nonetheless. Hai, kore, picture N2: This is Ikoma's bite. How does it look compared to train-guy-1? It's not only larger, it's DEEPER. So, now, the science. The deeper the wound, the more danger of causing infection. This is why protrusions are also the most dangerous wounds, because they can reach the blood flow while looking harmless on the surface. Naked-train guy - I assume, the 3-days quarantine is to verify whether small scratches on the skin are indeed infected by the virus or are random harmless injures. Namely because people would hide these types of wounds - they even might not be aware of having them until the examination. And Ikoma said he didn't know for certain if the naked guy wasn't infected. He protested not to be cornered or killed according the regulations Bushi have come up with. They killed him simply because he ran away, without any visible wound or explanation from the medics/inspectors. |
zellamiApr 7, 2016 5:08 PM
antonn said: Shingeki no Zombie. You mean Attack on Kabane. I am hoping that everything splits from episode 1. Will give the anime two more episodes to decide whether to continue watching it or give up. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
-Ducky said: jojo_kyle said: The idea is kabaneri are mindless idiots, there is more than one conductor,and it takes over 24 hours to 72(3 days exactly) for them to completely change. Which is why people that get bit are exposed during the inspection. Have you read the manga or something? I thought it wasn't out yet. (that's what it says on mal anyway) Well assuming it takes 1-3 days to turn, wtf was the scene with the mc all about then? He turned in like 2 minutes tops. And having more than one conductor doesn't matter, if the train was infested, it's likely that everyone inside would die, as they did. (really not sure how multiple operators is relevant tbh) I assume the "it takes over 24 hours to 72(3 days exactly) for them to completely change" comment is based when the main character comments to the Bushi that they have a law/rule to imprison anyone suspected of being a Kabane for 3 days (instead of just killing anyone with a wound immediately). That leads you to assume that they think anyone who has been infected will show signs of such within 3 days, although it was never worded clearly that way. The Bushi warrior/police seem really worried about figure out who is Kabane and who isn't, which makes it seem like there may be people who take more than a few minutes to change into zombies, or perhaps there are people who can be carriers of the virus without showing symptoms. None of that has been discussed outright in the show yet though, so we just have to keep watching and see what happens :D |
| Is it just me, or does the animation feel outdated? It feels like something from 2006. |
 |
Elegade said: Is it just me, or does the animation feel outdated? It feels like something from 2006. I think you're mixing up animation with art. They choose to make the art style look more like 90s anime. |
| Interesting start. Not much to say on what's going on so far, but the art's nice. Though as much as I love EGOIST I can't say that the opening is to my liking (excited for the collab with Aimer for the ending though). |
 |
| This guy's plot armor is impenetrable. |
 |
keragamming said: Elegade said: Is it just me, or does the animation feel outdated? It feels like something from 2006. I think you're mixing up animation with art. They choose to make the art style look more like 90s anime. Oh yeah the art, not animation. Why would they choose a 90s art style? Is this for the nostalgia effect? They should appeal more the SNK fans and made it look more modern. |
|
zellami said: Lararin said: Yup, I'm really curious about this. The guy on the train lasted a good one or two minutes without showing any signs of infection except for right where he was bitten. But the main character was almost gone within about the same length of time. The main character made it clear though that "this isn't a curse, it's a virus" and they made a point of showing he was gathering Kabane bits from the dirty trains to study. Then when the Bushi police/warriors came it was mentioned there being a rule that they keep people who were bitten or "might be" Kabane for three days in prison.... even in real life people can be carriers for a disease without showing signs of infection themselves, and depending on a person's overall health it may take longer/shorter for them to be affected by a disease, so perhaps this is something like that. I wanna know the science behind this XD For starters, let's watch the anime first, SHALL we. Here's the image of the train-guy 1: As you can see, the infection is evident and it did happen in a few seconds. Note the bite isn't that big, bit is a chomp-off nonetheless. Hai, kore, picture N2: This is Ikoma's bite. How does it look compared to train-guy-1? It's not only larger, it's DEEPER. So, now, the science. The deeper the wound, the more danger of causing infection. This is why protrusions are also the most dangerous wounds, because they can reach the blood flow while looking harmless on the surface. Naked-train guy - I assume, the 3-days quarantine is to verify whether small scratches on the skin are indeed infected by the virus or are random harmless injures. Namely because people would hide these types of wounds - they even might not be aware of having them until the examination. And Ikoma said he didn't know for certain if the naked guy wasn't infected. He protested not to be cornered or killed according the regulations Bushi have come up with. They killed him simply because he ran away, without any visible wound or explanation from the medics/inspectors. Thanks for the great breakdown with screenshots!! "I assume, the 3-days quarantine is to verify whether small scratches on the skin are indeed infected by the virus or are random harmless injures. Namely because people would hide these types of wounds - they even might not be aware of having them until the examination." Good and logically point. I just to the assumption that it was from a battle but it could just be a scratch from life in the daily train or bumping against someone... you are right in that they probably need to watch to see if it's infected or not. I'm going to watch this episode a second time tonight after work :) |
Lararin said: zellami said: For starters, let's watch the anime first, SHALL we. Here's the image of the train-guy 1: As you can see, the infection is evident and it did happen in a few seconds. Note the bite isn't that big, bit is a chomp-off nonetheless. Hai, kore, picture N2: This is Ikoma's bite. How does it look compared to train-guy-1? It's not only larger, it's DEEPER. So, now, the science. The deeper the wound, the more danger of causing infection. This is why protrusions are also the most dangerous wounds, because they can reach the blood flow while looking harmless on the surface. Naked-train guy - I assume, the 3-days quarantine is to verify whether small scratches on the skin are indeed infected by the virus or are random harmless injures. Namely because people would hide these types of wounds - they even might not be aware of having them until the examination. And Ikoma said he didn't know for certain if the naked guy wasn't infected. He protested not to be cornered or killed according the regulations Bushi have come up with. They killed him simply because he ran away, without any visible wound or explanation from the medics/inspectors. Thanks for the great breakdown with screenshots!! "I assume, the 3-days quarantine is to verify whether small scratches on the skin are indeed infected by the virus or are random harmless injures. Namely because people would hide these types of wounds - they even might not be aware of having them until the examination." Good and logically point. I just to the assumption that it was from a battle but it could just be a scratch from life in the daily train or bumping against someone... you are right in that they probably need to watch to see if it's infected or not. I'm going to watch this episode a second time tonight after work :) Well, the guys on the trains are in a close contact with the Kabane anyways. The examination seemed to me rather humiliating, but given how fast the virus could spread, even a small peck on the skin probably infects the blood sooner than later. And there aren't really hazmats around aside some gloves and masks for protection. By all means, enjoy your rest :) |
| I thought the infection reaching across his body would be permanent, got pretty worried when it got to his torso I like the main guy's VA. He has a different throaty voice, I like it. I also like the main guy's eyewear. The single tinted lens look is really cool. Looking forward to more of this show |
 |
| inb4 the MC gains powers to transform into a Kabane. Seriously though, not too bad an episode, wasn't expecting much from this, and I pretty much got what I wanted from it - a nonsensical action show. If it ends up being something more than that, then I'll be happy, if it doesn't though, I'll still be happy. It wouldn't surprise me if the green crystal/rock in his hand had something to do with him not turning. Maybe it's got some special properties or something. |
"Hurry up with my damn croissants." |
| Story seems interesting, but kinda AoT, but we already knew that. Art and animation were gorgeous, great use of CGI, and the character designs aren't simple cutouts which is nice too. |
 |
| Kinda reminded me of this too! |
|
| Thought the pacing was a bit rushed, but the directing was on point. Interesting characters, good dialogues and nice animation. I liked the setting and tthe action. It DOES give a huge SnK vibe, but who cares. That was fucking fun to watch. |
| Je trempe mes cookies dans tes larmes. |
antonn said: Shingeki no Zombie. Pretty much this. Which, again, was fucking fun to watch. |
| Je trempe mes cookies dans tes larmes. |
| EGOISTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT OMG THAT WAS SUCH A GREAT EP AMG THAT KICK AT THE END |
 |
bastek66 said: What plot holes? Not everything must be explained in first episode. Do you have attention span of a squirrel? Yeah like not having the midnight train to stop before letting the bridge down, that will totally get explained later right? s/ |
| befriend (v.): To violently attack someone with very dangerous and extremely powerful blasts of magical pink light until your target sees the validity of your viewpoint. |
TYxTxYT said: bastek66 said: What plot holes? Not everything must be explained in first episode. Do you have attention span of a squirrel? Yeah like not having the midnight train to stop before letting the bridge down, that will totally get explained later right? s/ If the train doesn't slow down, it makes no difference either way. Right? Right? |
| Loved it, show was intense and had me entertained to the end. Obviously some things were not perfect or explained, but it's the FIRST episode of a fictional anime. On a side note.... A fictional anime character that doesn't act the way you wanted them to (i.e. in a 'realistic' way) is a terrible reason to consider a show bad, especially on the first episode. |
| Not gonna lie, I'm only here for the music, Chelly is muh life but really, they had to go "it's been five years" on us, taht was just unnecessary. For some reason the character design reminds me of hentai, but anyway this can't be dumber than phantom world so I'll be watching it and probably gonna enjoy it. |
| Baby, daijobanai... |
| The train breakthrough and the MC stoping the virus were really bad done. This isn't even like SnK where they were at peace for 100 years, they literally said that another station was just destroyed, it makes no fucking sense for them to not be careful. |
| I had high expectations for this and I gotta say this first episode mostly met them. I knew it was going to be beautiful and it definitely delivered on that front, but what I'm most pleased about is that it seems the story will be more than just mindless zombie fighting. The only thing is the characters haven't really caught my interest just yet, but I guess there's plenty of time for that later. This has got a lot of potential to be great. |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
ButtSlapper said: only things worth to watch are the art style and the character design. big thanks to the character designer. This.. The sound its meh. Animation its good (i guest) but there are to many stupid happening in only one Episode, like the gate, the MC cutting his arm, the 3 day rule...etc etc... |
zellami said: TYxTxYT said: Yeah like not having the midnight train to stop before letting the bridge down, that will totally get explained later right? s/ If the train doesn't slow down, it makes no difference either way. Right? Right? If a driving train doesn't fall into the river but instead bulge right into the city, it will only prove bigger plot hole. |
| befriend (v.): To violently attack someone with very dangerous and extremely powerful blasts of magical pink light until your target sees the validity of your viewpoint. |
-Ducky said: jojo_kyle said: The idea is kabaneri are mindless idiots, there is more than one conductor,and it takes over 24 hours to 72(3 days exactly) for them to completely change. Which is why people that get bit are exposed during the inspection. Have you read the manga or something? I thought it wasn't out yet. (that's what it says on mal anyway) Well assuming it takes 1-3 days to turn, wtf was the scene with the mc all about then? He turned in like 2 minutes tops. And having more than one conductor doesn't matter, if the train was infested, it's likely that everyone inside would die, as they did. (really not sure how multiple operators is relevant tbh) The MC didn't turn the virus was just entering his body, it takes a while for them to fully turn. And we just saw what happens when a member of the train gets effected, they kill themselves to prevent any problems, and the other workers are quick to turn on them. |
Elegade said: keragamming said: I think you're mixing up animation with art. They choose to make the art style look more like 90s anime. Oh yeah the art, not animation. Why would they choose a 90s art style? Is this for the nostalgia effect? They should appeal more the SNK fans and made it look more modern. they did a more traditional artstyle in a modernistic way. I think it worked well, but not all artstyles appeal to everyone though. SnK was the same. |
|
| That was great! Really got me pumped up and I really like the MC. Plus this series is dark af. Reminds me of Snowpiercer. |
| Big Order (TV):great anime or greatest anime? |
| Has the potential to be the most overrated thing of the season and maybe of 2016. Nice looking frames though, will probably be filled with fucktons of stills later on. Attack on Steampunk Ghouls, though. Will give 3 episode rule. |
| >User since 2008 Please god help me quit this website. Such great community that doesn't even know how demographics work, AND gives """detailed"""" reviews after first episodes. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Koutetsujou no Kabaneri Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 30, 2016 |
620 |
by Vistha
»»
Oct 25, 3:51 PM |
|
» First time watcherthelavaleffel - Oct 22 |
9 |
by thelavaleffel
»»
Oct 22, 5:02 PM |
|
Poll: » Koutetsujou no Kabaneri Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 16, 2016 |
395 |
by kirA_-_
»»
Oct 21, 10:16 AM |
|
Poll: » Koutetsujou no Kabaneri Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 23, 2016 |
408 |
by Ricky16
»»
Sep 16, 9:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Koutetsujou no Kabaneri Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 9, 2016 |
525 |
by Ricky16
»»
Sep 15, 11:16 AM |