| You need to move on TPN s2. And Horimiya adaption is solid, and they adapted highlighting the strong chapters of manga because Horimiya is riddled with fillers that does slow the story. WEP is original so your defination of butchered are nonsense. And they end it open ending, which is suck but its a norm for original anime because of circumstances |
 |
|
| Well I for one already loved Lain. |
| I don't think it deserves an anime adaptation. It has turned into a cosplay tutorial rather than a rom-com manga. |
 |
| I don’t think they butchered horimiya at all, to be honest. They showed almost all the important points, the rest is just slice of life. The end of the manga is just as incomplete as the end of the anime |
| Cloverworks main problem all 3 of them was episode count. Only thing they could do in this case is a anime original ending like they did with shadows house. I don't think this anime would be in trouble. On the other hand, I really don't want summertime render's studio turning out to be cloverworks as most people predicting (that would a goner,if it turned out true) |
AdampkDec 7, 2021 4:29 AM
  Click for a anime mashup! Still not gone bandwagon u, keep crying. Here u are welcome to CRINGE at my EXISTENCE |
|TanakaTarou24 said: AbelDande said: check your facts. Horimiya was promoting the manga. It was supposed to have fewer scenes that are just enough to get people into manga. It wasn't an anime that was supposed to adapt so much from the manga. There's no point in putting the whole movie in a trailer. Here horimiya anime was a trailer to the mangaThe reason why TPN and Horimiya turn out like that is mainly because both series has ended so they decide to rush it. And that’s Aniplex’s decision, not CloverWorks. WEP is the story writer fault. There are no reason to rush this. There are only 65 chapters and if there’s 12 episodes, it will only adapt like 40-50 chapters so rush it won’t result to anything. 95% of the things they didn’t adapt are slice of life, which are great but doesn’t move the story forward. The anime adapted all of the main plot points and is just as complete as the manga in terms of story, but if you still want more, there’s a lot of slice of life with the characters in the manga; I think it was a great ideia. |
DeaneDec 7, 2021 11:17 AM
TanakaTarou24 said: Deane said: the manga was supposed to be slow life slice of life series. That's why they are cut out95% of the things they didn’t adapt are slice of life, which is great but doesn’t move the story forward. The anime adapted all of the main plot points and is just as complete as the manga in terms of story, but if you still want more, there’s a lot of slice of life with the characters in the manga; I think it was a great ideia. Yeah I know, I was just defending the anime’s decision to cut most of the non-important chapters out. I really enjoyed both the manga and the anime, I just think it was wise to focus more on romance than on slice of life for a 12 episode season. |
| if they butcher it, then blame it to the staff who is responsible for it, not cloverwork as a whole :/ But I do agree that 3 of their production this year were awful. |
"......If I told you that I was a real witch, would you believe it?"  |
| I mean it depend on Aniplex their higher-ups We may get great production and faithful to the original source like 86,Demon slayer or "Fucc i'm drop this project " like The promise neverland Regardless of how you feel about their anime adaptions... you can't deny their quality visuals |
LanceKelzDec 8, 2021 12:10 PM
| Don't worry I mean this is also the studio behind Bunny Girl Senpai. so just because Horimiya and Promised Neverland S2 didn't live up to many people's expectations doesn't mean the same thing will happen again. |
 |
Snow_dropindo99 said: TPN s2 only because Horimiya is good and popular. And they adapt it by not adapting, what becoming the manga stale and boring. So good adaptionDon't worry I mean this is also the studio behind Bunny Girl Senpai. so just because Horimiya and Promised Neverland S2 didn't live up to many people's expectations doesn't mean the same thing will happen again. |
|
| Tbh only TPN S2 was ruined, the rest like Horimiya is only full of fillers SOL that does slow the story, while WEP the source is original, so it doesn't make sense if you blame the studio because the ending isn't what you expected, you should complain to the author who made the story. also don't overlook the fact that Cloverworks is the studio that worked on Bunny Girl Senpai and they adapted it well. So just because they mess up 1 or 2 of your favorite anime doesn't mean all their anime is badly adapted. |
Yukino_chan99Dec 10, 2021 7:34 PM
 |
ponygobyebye said: If they really want to do the series justice, they should only adapt 2 (at a push 3) chapters per episode. If I think of animes that pretty much adapted their source manga 1:1, then a 12 episode season contained 20-24 chapters of content (I'm thinking of things like Grand Blue and Boarding School Juliet). Some Sono Bisque Doll chapters are shorter (with multiple full page panels focusing on a certain action) so I could see maybe the first 30 chapters being adapted 100% faithfully. Again, Cloverworks is an animation studio, and the animation looks EXACTLY like the manga's art style. If there is a fuckup, blame the writer and director. I really hope that's not the case. As you said, the chapters contain around 20 pages...And in addition, some pages illustrate the same scene... 3 chapters per episode could be nice I think... If we have 13 episodes like Bunny Senpai, Shadow House or Horimiya. The last episode with chapter 37-39 could be a good ending. I'm not an "expert" but it seems reasonable to me, while allowing to cover half of the available volumes. Personally I liked most of the works of CloverWorks, and I'm happy that this studio is adapting this manga. In any case, I see no reason to rush this manga. There are several points where they can stop. However, I hope the ecchi side won't be too present. |
ponygobyebye said: I agree with your point that the late 30s are a good place to stop. As long as I see the moment Kitagawa falls in love with Gojou on the train home from their first cosplay event, I'll be very happy. I can't remember exactly which chapter that is (14 maybe?) but that's basically guaranteed to be covered, and could make a nice halfway point. Unlike your generic romcom, the ecchi in here is fairly sexy without being explicit (if that makes any sense). Another manga that is extremely erotic without shoving tits, ass and panty shots in your face is Yancha Gal no Anjou-san, which is incidentally also very good and I would like to see animated. It's like an ecchi-er high school Takagi-san. It's When I refer to the ecchi side, I hope the studio won't exaggerate. You know... with more scenes, more dialogues, more fanservices or even just zooms. The manga is well balanced on this point, so I hope it will be respected. |
Starry_sky25 said: Symphonizexx said: Now i am worried, this is cloverworks right? The one who butchered horimiya, Promised neverland and wonder egg priority? This is worrying I still have high hopes for this. And I didn't really see alot wrong with horimiya and promised Neverland. Usually things that get me are when they cut out too many of the manga scenes or mess up the animations but the animations looked good in the trailer. Let's just hope they don't cut out too many manga scenes. They literally skipped 50+ chapters in Horimiya which had some fun moments in it. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Scordolo said: they literally cut the boring parts of Horimiya so being compact adaption is good.Starry_sky25 said: I still have high hopes for this. And I didn't really see alot wrong with horimiya and promised Neverland. Usually things that get me are when they cut out too many of the manga scenes or mess up the animations but the animations looked good in the trailer. Let's just hope they don't cut out too many manga scenes. They literally skipped 50+ chapters in Horimiya which had some fun moments in it. |
|
| Jesus fucking christ people, its ANIPLEX and other people in the production committee who makes an anime get messed up, not CloverWorks. CloverWorks are just told to do the story with a certain amount of time and maximum of episodes and they're just doing their damn best so stop with the doomposting about the studio itself already. |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
DatRandomDude said: People should know about this. just because one or two of Cloverworks anime didn't live up to their expectations, people jump to the conclusion that all of their anime adaptations are bad.Jesus fucking christ people, its ANIPLEX and other people in the production committee who makes an anime get messed up, not CloverWorks. CloverWorks are just told to do the story with a certain amount of time and maximum of episodes and they're just doing their damn best so stop with the doomposting about the studio itself already. |
|
| One of the advantages with this manga is that they can stop around chapter 30 to make a "slow" adaptation (volume 4)... Or adapt more chapters and continue until chapter 38 or 39 (volume 5). I don't think this manga will be rushed.... Because some chapters aren't very long and represent several shots of the same scene. It has currently 8 complete volumes... I don't think they plan to adapt more than 5. With all these options, I think Cloverwork can make a good adaptation :) |
| This will be one of the best animes, im sure about that And Marin will be the best girl from 2022! <3 She is just PERFECT |
| A romance anime that doesn’t really have any romance in it doesn’t have potential in the first place. Literally all it covers is cosplay, and I don’t see that as a genre with potential for success at least in terms of a good anime. But with all these weird new tastes coming about in modern society this will prob end up becoming very popular. Tis a shame. |
Symphonizexx said: Now i am worried, this is cloverworks right? The one who butchered horimiya, Promised neverland and wonder egg priority? This is worrying Let me set things straight. CloverWorks did NOT butcher TPN s2, the manga author instructed the studio to do so. They may have been the ones to animate it, but it wasn't up to them. If they chose not to follow her orders, they would have been sued. Horimiya wasn't that bad, they left out some chapters, and with WEP, that was a show animated by junior, overworked, animators. They didn't know how to craft the best story. Let's stop looking down on CloverWorks, they have done brilliantly in the past with the amazing adaptation of Bunny Girl Senpai, which brought the Light Novel to life. |
 |
| Wonder Egg Priority was anime original, it literally cant be butchered. The plot just became a convoluted mess later on. Blame the script writers, not animators. Horimiya has 12 episodes, they tried to do what they could with this limited time. You cant adapt hundreds of chapters in 1-cour. Cloverworks deserves criticism, specially about how it overwork it's animators, but enough, man. Promissed Neverland is over. Many other animes were produced since then, some very good, others, bad. Also this is mostly a comedic romcom with low level ecchi. It can hardly be butchered, unless they try to fit a ton of content in the first season. |
| FGO NA Code: 482.072.599 (F2P thug life of savings...) Ben-to! best nonsensical action anime. Ever. |
40Days said: okay ,I don't actually know why I wrote that lmao, cos I didn't even like the promised Neverland that much ngl 😂Starry_sky25 said: Bro, how can you not see much wrong with promised neverland?? They literally cut out Yugo and the Goldy Pond Arc… :((I still have high hopes for this. And I didn't really see alot wrong with horimiya and promised Neverland. Usually things that get me are when they cut out too many of the manga scenes or mess up the animations but the animations looked good in the trailer. Let's just hope they don't cut out too many manga scenes.  |
| Now i am hyped, this is cloverworks right? The one who brought us Bunny Girl Senpai and Horimiya. This is awesome. |
| I read the manga for this, I don't see it as worthy of as much hype as you. As for CloverWorks, they do good work, not perfect work, but good enough. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sono Bisque Doll wa Koi wo Suru Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Homura24 - Mar 26, 2022 |
486 |
by Roses14qw
»»
9 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sono Bisque Doll wa Koi wo Suru Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 8, 2022 |
395 |
by Lanz
»»
Jun 1, 2:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Sono Bisque Doll wa Koi wo Suru Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Mar 12, 2022 |
192 |
by bronzeagesungod
»»
May 5, 6:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Sono Bisque Doll wa Koi wo Suru Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 26, 2022 |
243 |
by Over1dynasty
»»
Apr 29, 9:58 PM |
|
Poll: » Sono Bisque Doll wa Koi wo Suru Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Softhenic03 - Feb 12, 2022 |
231 |
by Netbug
»»
Apr 29, 9:37 AM |