| The flaws it had from the previous arcs and how ridiculous the villains are like Overhaul, and the broken power system, this is definitely not to the level of FMA or HxH. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| I wasn't aware the people were even making such an extreme comparison. |
 |
| seriously when this type of thought come into your mind |
| [font="\"lucida grande\", tahoma, verdana, arial, sans-serif"] [/font] |
Ponzerelli said: bruh havent read any but if there anime were adapted properly from manga then BNHA>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>FMAB and HxH.................I genuinely believe that My Hero Academia as a manga series should be taken as seriously as Fullmetal and Hunter Hunter. I do understand it's a HOT Take so please share your thoughts about this down below |
 "No one can rewrite the stars How can you say you'll be mine? Everything keeps us apart And I'm not the one you were meant to find It's not up to you you It's not up to me When everyone tells us what we can be How can we rewrite the stars?" |
| As much as I love MHA from the bottom of my heart. NO, it's nowhere near FMA and HxH(haven't read HxH). MHA is a manga way different from them and isn't close to them. If you believe so, it's a personal taste and I have no right to criticize about it. FMA and HxH are way older than MHA and MHA is half inspired by NARUTO. All that matters is we appreciate each mangaka for their efforts and nothing else. We don't need any comparison to prove what manga is better and what's not. Some people just don't get into the manga and drop it. Everyone has their tastes and they should be proud of it. But they should make unnecessary and stupid claims. If you think MHA is better than them, it's your choice. |
Deathlydash said: liEbeRTJoHAn21 said: i think he's talking about the manga he also said it's a hot take seriously when this type of thought come into your mind Ewmanga said: i respect your opinion but why the fuck did you rate most manga youve read a 2 or 3?My Hero Academia is one of the worst shounen. It doesn't deserve to be compared to HxH or FMA READ HIS USERNAME? |
Scordolo said: Powersystem in MHA? You can say power system only if every person in that universe can use it or have that ability like in Naruto everybody has Chakra in their bodies but in the first chapter and the first line of the first monologue and the synopsis itself says "not all men are created equal" only 80 percent have quirks and out of those 80 percent there are cases like Dabi and Aoyama whose quirks are not compatible with their bodies. So no one is equal, everyone has different quirks. Saying MHA has a broken power system is wrong.The flaws it had from the previous arcs and how ridiculous the villains are like Overhaul, and the broken power system, this is definitely not to the level of FMA or HxH. |
i_m_a_hero_too said: Scordolo said: Powersystem in MHA? You can say power system only if every person in that universe can use it or have that ability like in Naruto everybody has Chakra in their bodies but in the first chapter and the first line of the first monologue and the synopsis itself says "not all men are created equal" only 80 percent have quirks and out of those 80 percent there are cases like Dabi and Aoyama whose quirks are not compatible with their bodies. So no one is equal, everyone has different quirks. Saying MHA has a broken power system is wrong.The flaws it had from the previous arcs and how ridiculous the villains are like Overhaul, and the broken power system, this is definitely not to the level of FMA or HxH. Yeah, sorry I should've said it more like, I don't like the One for all power system instead of Power system in general. Because there is literally no one that has a quirk that can even compete with One for all. And on top of that, Deku will get 6 more quirks which honestly doesn't make sense at all. Deku was just way too op in the first place so I don't see the point of him getting more quirks. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Scordolo said: it was all explained in the "Quirks doomsday theory" by Ujiko...Deku wasn't OP...he was just in the right place in the right time to become the 9th user and was quirkless. Ujiko said that there will be a time in future where people wont be able to control their quirks and there will be a outbreak of quirks of their ancestors just like how Blackwhip emerged and since human body cant evolve faster than the quirks so their bodies will break just like All Might explained to Deku that he needs to be buffed else the force of OFA itself will break his body. So in future there will be a time where everybody will be as OP as OFA users.i_m_a_hero_too said: Powersystem in MHA? You can say power system only if every person in that universe can use it or have that ability like in Naruto everybody has Chakra in their bodies but in the first chapter and the first line of the first monologue and the synopsis itself says "not all men are created equal" only 80 percent have quirks and out of those 80 percent there are cases like Dabi and Aoyama whose quirks are not compatible with their bodies. So no one is equal, everyone has different quirks. Saying MHA has a broken power system is wrong. Yeah, sorry I should've said it more like, I don't like the One for all power system instead of Power system in general. Because there is literally no one that has a quirk that can even compete with One for all. And on top of that, Deku will get 6 more quirks which honestly doesn't make sense at all. Deku was just way too op in the first place so I don't see the point of him getting more quirks. Feelings are connected to your quirks and behave just like that, Deku was using OFA at 20 percent but was angry by the comment passed by Monoma so Blackwhip emerged. Think of it like a videogame like if u complete a certain level you get a reward or a skill and so was blackwhip. Nobody knows at which percentage which which quirk will emerge when Shigaraki possessed by AFO tried to steal OFA forcefully, the OFA spirits which were having trouble in emerging out as individual vestiges were able to do so but u cant steal OFA without the users will so it stayed with Deku. Everything is explained by Hori about individual quirks and powerful ones. I get it that the trope of OP MC is heavily overused but hey it publishes in WSJ, it should be expected and MHA already has its roots at taking tropes and using it as its fullest. But Deku has to train for it, look Deku is still at 45 percent but how cool the fight choreography has been and Hori knows it so he made other quirks simple tools and make Deku use his brain. Deku wants to make OFA his own and he does. As of now AFO and OFA are ultimate powerful characters so that's why heroes have to group up to defeat AFO and hence the power of friendship trope was used. After the MVA arc, MHA's writing has become very good and my only complaint would be that Hori needs to create his own trope so as to make MHA unique. |
| @i_m_a_hero_too wasn't my villain academia unique enough? Name one Anime/Manga where an arc solely focuses on the villains and not even giving ANY references to the main characters. So Horikoshi already created a unique trope. It's just that the Japanese hate ANY Villain focused stories even if they have masterclass writing. If they liked it, I can see many authors doing the same because of Horikoshi's influence. I heard it's a taboo to write a villain focus story and completely pushing aside the main characters and because of that, Horikoshi got a LOT of backlash from the editors, etc. The fact he went against the editors to write his own story already makes him my favorite author. Ponzerelli said: Scordolo said: THink of it in a story sense. Can we as the reader really just see Deku smash his way through everything?*pause*, OFA needs to feel fresh, it can't just be the same thing again. Also it makes sense in that it's a stockpiling quirk that has been built up for generation. That on top of the vestiges being traced in OFA, why wouldn't Deku inherit their quirks?Yeah, sorry I should've said it more like, I don't like the One for all power system instead of Power system in general. Because there is literally no one that has a quirk that can even compete with One for all. And on top of that, Deku will get 6 more quirks which honestly doesn't make sense at all. Deku was just way too op in the first place so I don't see the point of him getting more quirks. But it doesn't explain how ONLY Deku is able to use 6 quirks and not the previous users. Nana said something like, "He is the one" so I fear it is the same "Chosen one" type of generic story all over again. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Scordolo said: @i_m_a_hero_too wasn't my villain academia unique enough? Name one Anime/Manga where an arc solely focuses on the villains and not even giving ANY references to the main characters. So Horikoshi already created a unique trope. It's just that the Japanese hate ANY Villain focused stories even if they have masterclass writing. If they liked it, I can see many authors doing the same because of Horikoshi's influence. I heard it's a taboo to write a villain focus story and completely pushing aside the main characters and because of that, Horikoshi got a LOT of backlash from the editors, etc. The fact he went against the editors to write his own story already makes him my favorite author. Ponzerelli said: THink of it in a story sense. Can we as the reader really just see Deku smash his way through everything?*pause*, OFA needs to feel fresh, it can't just be the same thing again. Also it makes sense in that it's a stockpiling quirk that has been built up for generation. That on top of the vestiges being traced in OFA, why wouldn't Deku inherit their quirks? But it doesn't explain how ONLY Deku is able to use 6 quirks and not the previous users. Nana said something like, "He is the one" so I fear it is the same "Chosen one" type of generic story all over again. You are somewhat right..it's pretty much in every story. But have you forgotten about OFA and the cup theory by the fourth user. OFA is a stockpiling quirk. It keeps growing as its passed down from user to user. Now since Deku is the ninth user, and the fact that he is quirkless gives him more potential. Now you would argue regarding All Might too, even he was quirkless. Why not him? That's coz OFA was still in its growth. Deku's version of OFA also had the same principle. It keeps stockpiling. But the problem is, he can't pass it down to anyone because, the power is way too much now, that even a quirkless person can't handle it. OFA stockpiles everytime when it's passed and grows at a rapid rate. Same can said about other quirks, but their growth is gradual. If you think Deku is some chosen sort of person, actually no. He had to toil for it and not just get it like that. Hopefully that answered it |
FakeNeko said: Scordolo said: @i_m_a_hero_too wasn't my villain academia unique enough? Name one Anime/Manga where an arc solely focuses on the villains and not even giving ANY references to the main characters. So Horikoshi already created a unique trope. It's just that the Japanese hate ANY Villain focused stories even if they have masterclass writing. If they liked it, I can see many authors doing the same because of Horikoshi's influence. I heard it's a taboo to write a villain focus story and completely pushing aside the main characters and because of that, Horikoshi got a LOT of backlash from the editors, etc. The fact he went against the editors to write his own story already makes him my favorite author. But it doesn't explain how ONLY Deku is able to use 6 quirks and not the previous users. Nana said something like, "He is the one" so I fear it is the same "Chosen one" type of generic story all over again. You are somewhat right..it's pretty much in every story. But have you forgotten about OFA and the cup theory by the fourth user. OFA is a stockpiling quirk. It keeps growing as its passed down from user to user. Now since Deku is the ninth user, and the fact that he is quirkless gives him more potential. Now you would argue regarding All Might too, even he was quirkless. Why not him? That's coz OFA was still in its growth. Deku's version of OFA also had the same principle. It keeps stockpiling. But the problem is, he can't pass it down to anyone because, the power is way too much now, that even a quirkless person can't handle it. OFA stockpiles everytime when it's passed and grows at a rapid rate. Same can said about other quirks, but their growth is gradual. If you think Deku is some chosen sort of person, actually no. He had to toil for it and not just get it like that. Hopefully that answered it Yeah, seems like it's another situation where he was just in the right place at the right time. |
Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
Scordolo said: FakeNeko said: You are somewhat right..it's pretty much in every story. But have you forgotten about OFA and the cup theory by the fourth user. OFA is a stockpiling quirk. It keeps growing as its passed down from user to user. Now since Deku is the ninth user, and the fact that he is quirkless gives him more potential. Now you would argue regarding All Might too, even he was quirkless. Why not him? That's coz OFA was still in its growth. Deku's version of OFA also had the same principle. It keeps stockpiling. But the problem is, he can't pass it down to anyone because, the power is way too much now, that even a quirkless person can't handle it. OFA stockpiles everytime when it's passed and grows at a rapid rate. Same can said about other quirks, but their growth is gradual. If you think Deku is some chosen sort of person, actually no. He had to toil for it and not just get it like that. Hopefully that answered it Yeah, seems like it's another situation where he was just in the right place at the right time. Well, what's a story without coincidence |
| I personnaly enjoyed reading boku no hero academia but IMO I still prefer jojo's :) |
| I agree but objectively hxh is better than mha but I enjoyed mha more than hxh |
| i find it to be far below the level of hunter x hunter but yeah its definitly on the tier of fma |
| Being on Huntrash x Garbage tier is not something to be proud of. |
| I mean if you like it thats good and all...but seriously fma and hxh tier????Its waaay to ridiculous to even take account for. Comparison with black clover is good though.. However in terms of enjoyability, it is on that level |
 |
| a few chapters of Deki being badass won't get the series into s tier |
  “The first requirement of being a hero isn’t being right. It’s being strong. That’s why the hero always wins.” – Koyomi Araragi |
| LOL! No because deku has 7 quirks which makes him another op protagonist. |
| HACKs! 🤢🤮 |
| so true oomfie keep spittin |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Everything after Shigaraki's backstory is a masterpiece to me, especially the War Arc which is one of my favorite arcs of all time, but we can't just ignore the rest of the story which is just "good" |
| >Start with a hard work premise >Gain the quirk of the top 1 hero >Actually there are more quirks >Start training arc >Villain attacks >Hero wins >Start another training arc but it is a tournament arc >Stain >Hero wins >Start another training arc but now is camp >Guess who is back? >Hero wins >Start another training arc but now is provisional hero license > :surprised pikachu: >Hero wins >Heroes attack first >Powerpoint animation >Hero wins (?) >Start a high school musical arc >Best villain attack >Hero too >Start another training arc but now 1A vs 1B >Ok this was so bad that nothing actually happened >Lol >Endeavor, can't complain >MVA powerpoint >bruh actually starts getting good again 113 episodes worth content and they are still in the first school year This Manga is FMA & HxH Tier eh... no |
  |
| lmao I don't usually reply on bait threads. People are mostly just slinging and FMA and HxH just have so high of a reputation. But as someone whose consumed all 3. Manga / Anime the shebang. I think the balance out is. Yeah. I do think it's creeping up to that level. It is really going to depend on that ending and conclusions. Nobody will say it because of how much of a cultivated bad fanbase and mainstream on merit of likability versus critically but. Horikoshi art and flow in my opinion out speed past the other two. And a lot of the time people who hate certain arcs, from reading it weekly never revisit them; I'm not particularly a big fan of internship/overhaul pace wise but I get the point of them. I know people are gonna shoot shots at everything not being up to 100, I think that's because Hori will grow into this if he ever makes a second long running series like this. But I think the social world commentary and world building are some of my favorite aspects of the series. It only keeps getting better. His characters are some of my favorites of all time, not just Deku but the villain's actually are fun to learn about and not just power domineering fucks. People hated Shigiraki for the longest time but his parallels to Deku and build up / manipulation from AFO really feel so much better to read a second time if you're caught up. Bakugou Katsuki might be one of the best written rival/friends of all time and how he plays off Deku and their blossoming rekindling of friendship is the most satisfying relationships in a series I've ever witnessed. I can't even say anything like that about One Piece or any other mass high tier series. I could speculate more. I think it's all gonna depend on what you're judging. In my opinion I think FMA has a lot of core praise because it's a not a very long series; that works so much in it's favor to hone in key events and growth that, BNHA and any other series is doing a lot more and exploring a lot more in 300-500 chapters (again this isn't a bad/good thing). HxH on the other hand. Tho I do think Togashi had a lot of experience from his other two main shounen series, I do think HxH has flaws. I think it escapes a lot of tropes that normal shounen get tripped on, which is WHY I suspect it's so popular (lack of women being the key biggie). But it's much more streamlined of a story, with a rock of a power system, and not a big cast. These three series are doing different work and I think that's the issue comparing them. Anyways this is just my assessment. |
 |
Ponzerelli said: I genuinely believe that My Hero Academia as a manga series should be taken as seriously as Fullmetal and Hunter Hunter. I do understand it's a HOT Take so please share your thoughts about this down below I can't say it's better than those two but recent arcs of mha made this series very special for me and they were really great arcs,mha is not better than those two series but it's special in it own way . |
| As much as I love MHA, no, it's not FMA & HxH tier, if I'm being objective. But subjective-wise, I enjoy MHA more than those two. Also, it's okay to disagree with OP but respect their opinions. |
Daryllkun said: lol I forgot, I've already message in this threadI agree but objectively hxh is better than mha but I enjoyed mha more than hxh |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Boku no Hero Academia Chapter 29 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 5, 2015 |
20 |
by mkyid10t
»»
Oct 14, 12:53 PM |
|
» How do y’all feel about the ending now?The-Irreverend - Aug 5 |
10 |
by BenR98045
»»
Sep 24, 10:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku no Hero Academia Chapter 431 DiscussionARK-13 - Nov 29, 2024 |
44 |
by pranss0_0
»»
Jul 8, 8:02 AM |
|
» MHA Exhibition Leaksgrim - Jun 26 |
0 |
by grim
»»
Jun 26, 10:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku no Hero Academia Chapter 424 Discussion ( 1 2 )deg - May 29, 2024 |
52 |
by Traotora
»»
Jun 14, 3:01 AM |