SunflowerDaisho said: Wyvern22 said: ✘ 1000-nen Joou: Queen Millennia – series not listed under the Killer Rabbit Trope Galaxy Express 999 is on the list and i thought that series related to them also counts if the trope still applies Related series do count if the trope still applies; however, the trope for Galaxy Express 999 refers to Maetel who doesn't appear under the Characters section for 1000-nen Joou: Queen Millennia. If the trope does indeed apply, proof will be needed. I'm asking, just in case, but for this challenge what it says in her profile La Andromeda Promethium II about what happens in the movie, isn't it enough? (She is like Maetel since she doesn't seem to kill a fly but later in her role as the Queen Millennial she opposed to Promethium I) Is true that in other series she is the villain but not in this movie |
Wyvern22Aug 20, 2017 5:48 PM
 |
Wyvern22 said: SunflowerDaisho said: Related series do count if the trope still applies; however, the trope for Galaxy Express 999 refers to Maetel who doesn't appear under the Characters section for 1000-nen Joou: Queen Millennia. If the trope does indeed apply, proof will be needed. I'm asking, just in case, but for this challenge what it says in her profile La Andromeda Promethium II about what happens in the movie, isn't it enough? (She is like Maetel since she doesn't seem to kill a fly but later in her role as the Queen Millennial she opposed to Promethium I) Is true that in other series she is the villain but not in this movie As I haven't seen the movie and it's hard for me to tell by just reading Synopsis' and Character descriptions, I'm going to @Kreyul and see what they think. |
 |
| @Wyvern22 @SunflowerDaisho After reading things over, I will allow it. |
SunflowerDaisho said: Wyvern22 said: I'm asking, just in case, but for this challenge what it says in her profile La Andromeda Promethium II about what happens in the movie, isn't it enough? (She is like Maetel since she doesn't seem to kill a fly but later in her role as the Queen Millennial she opposed to Promethium I) Is true that in other series she is the villain but not in this movie As I haven't seen the movie and it's hard for me to tell by just reading Synopsis' and Character descriptions, I'm going to @Kreyul and see what they think. Awesome. Thanks for your help, Kreyul. @Wyvern22 As your original Turn-In has been crossed out, you will have to resubmit. Make sure you link this post in your new Turn-In, so as to not run into a problem when your challenge gets inspected again. Thank you. |
|
| @SunflowerDaisho @Kreyul Thanks a lot!!!! |
|
Eren_B said: Challenge: 52 Weeks Challenge Version: 2/4 Start Date: September 12, 2016 End Date: March 12, 2017 Post Link: #30 Upgrading From: 1/4 Upgrading To: 2/4 *according to your animelist, you have started Steins;Gate on Nov 13th; a day earlier than you were allowed to (Week 10: Nov 14th-20th). NamiLover69 said: Challenge: Mecha Version: Easy Start date: BC End date: 12/03/17 Post link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1554390#msg47817673 *Redline is not tagged with Mecha. *Code Geass: Boukoku no Akito 1 - Yokuryuu wa Maiorita has more than 80k members. *Your entry is still valid since you have enough entries that meet the requirements, but please remove / fix the ones mentioned above. TahZin said: Challenge: Reviewed Challenge Version: Hard Start Date: Nov. 01, 2016 End Date: Mar. 12, 2017 Post Link: LINK *The reviews from Ajin 2nd Season and Kara no Kyoukai 5: Mujun Rasen has been deleted. Rojo said: Challenge: Ecchi Version: Easy x1 Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before club Post Link: Post #103 Challenge: Historical Version: Easy x1 Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: Post #55 Ecchi Challenge: *Medaka Box Abnormal does not have more than 2 seasons. *HanSemi TV is rated R, not R+. Historical Challenge: *Gintama: Shiroyasha Koutan is less than 15 mins. It's valid since you have more entries then needed, but please fix / remove this entry mentioned above. Magical Challenge: *Little Witch Academia: Mahoujikake no Parade is not longer than 60 mins. Rojo said: Challenge: Horror Version: Easy x1 Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: Post #39 *Imawa no Kuni no Alice (OVA) is not tagged with horror. abystoma2 said: Challenge: Shoujo-ai Challenge Start Date: before club End Date: 15.03.2017 Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1503077#msg45705898 *according to your anime list, Nikutai Ten'i is On-Hold. Resolved Astarate said: Challenge: Military Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: +++ *according to your anime list, you haven't watched Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch yet (in PTW). Your entry is still valid since only 10 requirements are needed now, but please remove or fix the one mentioned above. AYOSHINA said: Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #15 Start Date: 03/15/17 End Date: 03/15/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1599520#msg49992807 *Kyon has a nickname ("John Smith"). You can use the supporting characters though, then you are set. Resolved renzoushi said: Challenge: The People Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Nov 21, 2016 End Date: Mar 16, 2017 Post Link: ☆☆☆ *Aika S. Granzchesta has brown eyes. Resolved Ginger_Snap said: Challenge: The Movie Timeline Challenge Version (If applicable): n/a Start Date: Jul. 3, 2016 End Date: Mar. 17, 2017 Post Link: 📅 *The Bathroom aired in 1970, not 1971. *Uchuu Enban Dai-Sensou / The Great Battle of the Flying Saucers did not air in 1976. Side Note: the link of Great Mazinger tai Getter Robo leads to Daishizen no Majuu: Bagi. KenApplepi said: Challenge: Slice of Life Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Jan 13, 2017 End Date: Mar 17, 2017 Post Link: here Challenge: Numbers Challenge Version: 1 Start Date: Jan 12, 2017 End Date: April 3, 2017 Post Link: here Slice of Life Challenge: *Natsume Yuujinchou is not ranked 800 or higher. *One More Time, One More Chance is less than 15 min total. *You've used the requirement "Watch a series with less than 25k members" twice. Numbers Challenge: *your entry is valid, but please fix your link from Owari no Seraph: Kyuuketsuki Shahar (it leads to 91 Days) and K: Missing Kings leads to Zoku Natsume Yuujinchou. Dakenfromvault1 said: Challenge: ONA Exposure Challenge Version: Hard Start Date: 25/10/2016 End Date: 17/03/2017 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1482815&show=50#msg48285893 *Only 29 entries. You left out the requirement "Watch an Adventure, Drama, or Magic ONA". *Puchitto Gargantia Special is a Special. *Curly, Bishoujo Mobage: Mobami-chan and Choujuu Giga cannot be found in your list. Resolved / Returned-in Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - The Movie Timeline Challenge - Start Date: 20.11.2016 End Date: 17.03.2017 Post Link: Link *Kataku is not 20 min or longer. Resolved AYOSHINA said: Challenge: Episodic Challenge Version: Medium Start Date: 08/24/16 End Date: 03/18/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1546018&show=0#msg47486608 *Hetalia Axis Powers is an ONA. Resolved Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - The Military Challenge - Version: Easy Start Date: BC End Date: BC Post Link: Link *Appleseed is not tagged with Military. Resolved AYOSHINA said: Challenge: User Ratings Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 05/12/16 End Date: 03/19/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1509858&show=0#msg46000482 *Highschool of the Dead has not been rated 5 by Sulframus. Resolved Useless_Goddess said: Challenge: The Aired 2016 Challenge Start Date: January 1st, 2016 End Date: March 19th, 2017 Post Link: Link *ReLIFE cannot be found in your list. AYOSHINA said: Challenge: TV Tropes Challenge Version: Medium Start Date: 06/08/16 End Date: 03/20/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1519412&show=0#msg46386461 *The TV trope "Alas, Poor Yoorik" was used twice. *You have only 19 entries. Resolved GNozaki said: Challenge: "Treasure" Set - SH #04 Start Date: March 17, 2017 End Date: March 21, 2017 Post Link: Link *according to your anime list, you've watched Orange: Mirai in June. Your entry is valid, but please change the end date. Resolved Akai_Shuichi said: Challenge: The Comedy Challenge Version: Hard Start Date: Before Club End Date: January 22nd, 2017 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=0#msg48118591 Note: Re-turning in after quite a while *Tsuritama is not an anime with only a Japanese title. Resolved extremeplant said: OVA Exposure Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 23.01.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Link *Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (OVA) is not tagged with action, demons or harem. Resolved Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #09 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 21.02.2017 End Date: 01.04.2017 Post Link: Link Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #10 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 16.02.2017 End Date: 21.03.2017 Post Link: Link can you send me a screenshot of the reviews? The reviews are written on the 10th (for #9 challenge) and 11th (for the #10 challenge) to me, even though I changed to your time zone. Resolved GamerDLM said: Challenge: People Challenge Version: Medium Start Date: 07/15/2016 End Date: 03/22/2017 Post Link: Link *Sanosuke Sagara does not have long hair (hair length to ears). Resolved Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - The Reviewed Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 05.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link *The reviews for Initial D Fourth Stage and Initial D Fifth Stage have been deleted. Resolved Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #01 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 15.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #06 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 15.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link #01 Challenge: *Same as mentioned above. A screenshot will be a big help, thank you. #06 Challenge: *The review for Tentai Senshi Sunred 2nd Season has been deleted. Resolved *Mira Yamana does not have golden/yellow eyes. *Erio Touwa has been used twice. (For blue hair and white/pale skin). *Your entry is valid for now though, since I've checked for the easy difficulty and you have listed more charcters than needed. But please fix the characters/entries mentioned above. Resolved haylE15 said: Challenge: March 2017 Challenge Start Date: March 1st 2017 End Date: March 26th 2017 Link: #51 *Your entry is valid, but the link does not lead to your challenge post. Romy_ said: Challenge: March 2017 Challenge Start Date: March 6th 2017 End Date: March 27th 2017 Post Link: Here *Link does not work. I found your entry though (it's valid), but fix the link please. Thank you. Lady_Nera said: Challenge: ROMANCE CHALLENGE Version: EASY (first try) Start Date: BEFORE CLUB End Date: 27 March 2017 Link: #154 -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- Challenge: SLICE OF LIFE Version: EASY x1 Stard Date: BEFORE CLUB End Date: 27 March, 2017 Link: #175 Romance Challenge: *Akagami no Shirayuki-hime does not end with the same last letter of your username. Side Note: the link of Shigatsu no Kimi wa Uso leads to Howl no Ugoku Shiro Slice of Life Challenge: *Nodame Cantabile OVA 2 is not tagged with Slice of Life and is also less than 15 min total. Resolved Animewikia said: Challenge: Comedy Challenge Version: (Easy) Start Date: Before the Club End Date: 3/28/17 Post Link: Here *The requirement "Watch a comedy anime that aired in the Fall" was used twice. Konekojo said: Challenge: Aired 2014 Challenge Version: Start Date: 10/18/2016 End Date: 03/28/2017 Post Link: here *Your entry is valid, but the link does not lead to your challenge post. Resolved acestrawbs said: Challenge: Historical Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 09/03/2017 End Date: 28/03/2017 Post Link: Historical *Drifters: Special Edition is an OVA. Resolved SebastianOrf3 said: Challenge: COMEDY CHALLENGE Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: Here *Golden Time is not adapted from a book or novel. AngelBeatsYui said: Challenge: March 2017 Challenge Start Date: March 1st 2017 End Date: March 29th 2017 Link: Here *Your entry is valid, but the link does not lead to your challenge post. Resolved ToosokaRin said: Challenge: Series-Per-2-Days Version: Hard (20 Entries) Start Date:Mar.10. 2017 End Date: Mar.30.2017 Post Link: One day, The world will realise the full potential of the universe. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Challenge: The Studios Challenge Version: Not Applicable. Start Date:Oct.10. 2016 End Date: Mar.30.2017 Post Link: One day, we will all meet our maker's end. Series-Per-2-Days-Challenge: *Doujin Work is less than 15 minutes per episode. Studios Challenge: *Your link does not lead to your challenge post. *according to your anime list, you have already completed (last updated) Elfen Lied, Kitakubu Katsudou Kiroku and Beelzebub before you started the challenge. Nordict_Teralian said: Challenge: The Series-Per-2Days Challenge Version: Conquered Start Date: Feb.05.2017 End Date: Mar.26.2017 Link: Post *according to your anime list, you have watched Mob Psycho 100 in June. homlikemom said: Challenge: March 2017 Challenge Start Date: March 1st 2017 End Date: March 29th 2017 Link: Here *Your entry is valid, but the link does not lead to your challenge post. Rojo said: Challenge: Special Per-Day Version: Medium x1 Start Date: 11/03/17 End Date: 30/03/17 Turn-In: Post #55 Challenge: Genre-Movie challenge Version: N/A Start Date: 11/03/17 End Date: 31/03/17 Turn-In: Post #115 Special-Per-Day-Challenge: *Kyoukai no Kanata: I'll be Here - Mirai-hen is a movie. Genre Movie-Challenge: *JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Phantom Blood cannot be found in your list. Rojo said: Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #01 Version: "Treasure" Set - SH #01 Start Date: 11/03/17 End Date: 31/03/17 Turn-In: Post #103 *Berserk: Ougon Jidai-hen II - Doldrey Kouryaku does not have any broadcasted info. It has to be listed on the anime page. @chitochito @Tea no access to your anime list. Please set it to public, so a validation from your turn-ins are possible. All Entries Completed #3251 ― #3500 |
NaineLIEzSep 7, 2017 7:22 AM
  "Happy Unbirthday." set by ani ♥ |
NaineLIEz said: extremeplant said: OVA Exposure Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 23.01.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Link *Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (OVA) is not tagged with action, demons or harem. *Mira Yamana does not have golden/yellow eyes. *Erio Touwa has been used twice. (For blue hair and white/pale skin). *Your entry is valid for now though, since I've checked for the easy difficulty and you have listed more charcters than needed. But please fix the characters/entries mentioned above. All Entries Completedr #3251 ― #3500 OVA Exposure Challenge: I put Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (OVA) from "Watch a action, demons or harem OVA" to "Watch a super power, comedy, or fantasy OVA." People Challange: I have changed Mira Yamana for Arin Kannazuki. I also changed Eri Touwa in "Has white/pale skin" for Yashiro Hoshimiya. |
  |
| @NaineLIEz It has a synonym, but both the english title is also Tsuritama, which is a japanese title. But anyways, I'm too tired for this, I replaced Tsuritama with Koyomimonogatari and put Tsuritama on the 11-20 episodes criteria. |
 People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
NaineLIEz said: *according to your anime list, Nikutai Ten'i is On-Hold. Whoops, I forgot to mark it complete. Fixed. |
You all need to watch Nami. |
| @Akai_Shuichi oh that I didn't know. If that's the case, you didn't have to swap, but still thank you. AngelBeatsYui said: This is the issue when people delete their posts XD Should I just change the link and resubmit or just change the link? Fixing the link should be enough, since your post hasn't been crossed out. |
"Happy Unbirthday." set by ani ♥ |
| Don't worry! And thank you for your work here! |
People need societies, but they don't necessarily need nations. - Yang Wen-li |
| @NaineLIEz I replaced with Souma Yukihira from Shokugeki no Souma: Ni no Sara (watched on Mar 13). wikia Also for some reason i didn't get your notification :/ |
 |
| @NaineLIEz Wyvern22 said: *Kataku is not 20 min or longer.Challenge: - The Movie Timeline Challenge - Start Date: 20.11.2016 End Date: 17.03.2017 Post Link: Link Changed for Tatsu no Ko Tarou so i changed the ending date of the turn-in to 24.03.2017 Wyvern22 said: *Appleseed is not tagged with Military.Challenge: - The Military Challenge - Version: Easy Start Date: BC End Date: BC Post Link: Link I just deleted the entries necessary and left only 10 Wyvern22 said: *The reviews for Initial D Fourth Stage and Initial D Fifth Stage have been deleted.Challenge: - The Reviewed Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 05.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link Added Seikai no Monshou and Panda Kopanda so i changed the ending date to 06.04.2017 Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #09 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 21.02.2017 End Date: 01.04.2017 Post Link: Link Wyvern22 said: can you send me a screenshot of the reviews? The reviews are written on the 10th (for #9 challenge) and 11th (for the #10 challenge) to me, even though I changed to your time zone.Challenge: - #10 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 16.02.2017 End Date: 21.03.2017 Post Link: Link Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - #01 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 15.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link Wyvern22 said: #01 Challenge:Challenge: - #06 Challenge x2 - Start Date: 15.02.2017 End Date: 23.03.2017 Post Link: Link *Same as mentioned above. A screenshot will be a big help, thank you. #06 Challenge: *The review for Tentai Senshi Sunred 2nd Season has been deleted. The same happens to me now so i made the following changes: Since Fetish Doll's review was on day 10 i just moved it to the #10 Challenge x2 Added Yami Shibai 4th Season as the reviewed on day 1 so i changed the ending date to 31.03.2017 Added Ookami to Koushinryou II as the reviewed on day 6 so i changed the ending date to 30.03.2017 Added Zhen Hun Jie as the reviewed on day 9 |
Wyvern22Aug 23, 2017 9:16 AM
|
NaineLIEz said: acestrawbs said: Challenge: Historical Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 09/03/2017 End Date: 28/03/2017 Post Link: Historical *Drifters: Special Edition is an OVA. Moved from Special to OVA do I need to do anything else? Tricked by the name should have checked. |
    |
The OVA I used was post timeskip Sanosuke which according to the wiki his hair is now at shoulder length. Image for Reference: |
NaineLIEz said: Lady_Nera said: Challenge: ROMANCE CHALLENGE Version: EASY (first try) Start Date: BEFORE CLUB End Date: 27 March 2017 Link: #154 -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- Challenge: SLICE OF LIFE Version: EASY x1 Stard Date: BEFORE CLUB End Date: 27 March, 2017 Link: #175 Romance Challenge: *Akagami no Shirayuki-hime does not end with the same last letter of your username. Side Note: the link of Shigatsu no Kimi wa Uso leads to Howl no Ugoku Shiro Slice of Life Challenge: *Nodame Cantabile OVA 2 is not tagged with Slice of Life and is also less than 15 min total. Romance challenge: I put Akagami in the tag "Watch a series that begins with a letter between A - L"; changed the link to shigatsu. Slice of Life Challenge: I add "Mimi wo sumaseba" in the tag "Watch a manga adaption" Now they should be ok! :) |
"AI WA QUARTET★NIGHT!" |
| @renzoushi @Wyvern22 @Lady_Nera Your entries are valid now. acestrawbs said: Moved from Special to OVA do I need to do anything else? Tricked by the name should have checked. Nope, everything is correct, so you are all set. GamerDLM said: The OVA I used was post timeskip Sanosuke which according to the wiki his hair is now at shoulder length. Image for Reference: All right, thanks for the screenshot, your entry is valid. |
NaineLIEzAug 23, 2017 2:48 PM
"Happy Unbirthday." set by ani ♥ |
NaineLIEz said: AYOSHINA said: Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #15 Start Date: 03/15/17 End Date: 03/15/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1599520#msg49992807 *Kyon has a nickname ("John Smith"). You can use the supporting characters though, then you are set. Kyon changed to Taniguchi. NaineLIEz said: AYOSHINA said: Challenge: Episodic Challenge Version: Medium Start Date: 08/24/16 End Date: 03/18/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1546018&show=0#msg47486608 *Hetalia Axis Powers is an ONA. Hetalia Axis Powers replaced with Cutey Honey. NaineLIEz said: AYOSHINA said: Challenge: User Ratings Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: 05/12/16 End Date: 03/19/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1509858&show=0#msg46000482 *Highschool of the Dead has not been rated 5 by Sulframus. Sulframus replaced by zofot. NaineLIEz said: AYOSHINA said: Challenge: TV Tropes Challenge Version: Medium Start Date: 06/08/16 End Date: 03/20/17 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1519412&show=0#msg46386461 *The TV trope "Alas, Poor Yoorik" was used twice. *You have only 19 entries. Switched Majo no Takkyuubin (Alas, Poor Yorick) from Medium with JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Stardust Crusaders (Passing Judgment) from Hard. |
AYOSHINA said: Switched Majo no Takkyuubin (Alas, Poor Yorick) from Medium with JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Stardust Crusaders (Passing Judgment) from Hard. There are still 19 entries, #15 is missing. The rest looks good. |
NaineLIEzAug 24, 2017 7:46 AM
"Happy Unbirthday." set by ani ♥ |
NaineLIEz said: GNozaki said: Challenge: "Treasure" Set - SH #04 Start Date: March 17, 2017 End Date: March 21, 2017 Post Link: Link *according to your anime list, you've watched Orange: Mirai in June. Your entry is valid, but please change the end date. I've fixed the End Date. Don't know why I mixed up the dates, huh. Thanks ^^ |
 |
NaineLIEz said: Konekojo said: Challenge: Aired 2014 Challenge Version: Start Date: 10/18/2016 End Date: 03/28/2017 Post Link: here *Your entry is valid, but the link does not lead to your challenge post. oh sorry, people probably deleted their post : here is a new link |
 |
NaineLIEz said: AYOSHINA said: Switched Majo no Takkyuubin (Alas, Poor Yorick) from Medium with JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken: Stardust Crusaders (Passing Judgment) from Hard. There are still 19 entries, #15 is missing. The rest looks good. #15 now FLCL (Robot Antennae). |
done. thanks |
|
| @SunflowerDaisho I am mentioned at the bottom of post #839 (to help you find what I'm talking about). -For Shiki, you said "series aired in summer, not fall". I thought that because it aired from July through to December that it could be used for either? -As for Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Gaiden: Ami-chan no Hatsukoi, she wears glasses in the series/episode/special so wouldn't that count? -I guess I got the wrong idea about Umineko; I thought that two cours was 24 episodes, so Umineko had more because it has 26 episodes:p I see that this is wrong, and that 26 episodes counts as a 2-cour anime... On the other hand, other people appear to have turned in anime with 26 episodes for that requirement without any problem. |
ShanayaaaAug 27, 2017 2:41 PM
 |
Shanayaaa said: @SunflowerDaisho I am mentioned at the bottom of post #839 (to help you find what I'm talking about). -For Shiki, you said "series aired in summer, not fall". I thought that because it aired from July through to December that it could be used for either? -As for Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Gaiden: Ami-chan no Hatsukoi, she wears glasses in the series/episode/special so wouldn't that count? -I guess I got the wrong idea about Umineko; I thought that two cours was 24 episodes, so Umineko had more because it has 26 episodes:p I see that this is wrong, and that 26 episodes counts as a 2-cour anime... On the other hand, other people appear to have turned in anime with 26 episodes for that requirement without any problem. For Shiki, as far as I know, if a requirement asks for a series that aired during a certain season/year/etc. only the date when it began Airing counts. I will ask a senior Inspector (@AYOSHINA) for verification. For Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Gaiden: Ami-chan no Hatsukoi, as long as you can provide proof that she wears glasses for the majority of the Special, she can be accepted. A screenshot or two would suffice. As for Umineko no Naku Koro ni, a 2-cour anime would be 22 - 26 episodes in length... Though a number of challenges have been accepted with series of a similar length. Again, I will defer to @AYOSHINA for help with the issue. |
|
| @AYOSHINA IF TURN-IN POST HAS BEEN CROSSED OUT, PLEASE RESUBMIT ONCE CORRECTIONS HAVE BEEN MADE. leejongki said: Challenge: #01 Challenge Start Date: Feb 26, 2017 End Date: April 12, 2017 Link: Here ✘ Mesu Kyoushi 4: Kegasareta Kyoudan – series listed under On-Hold ✘ Koro-sensei Quest! – cannot use the same series more than once Kreyul said: Challenge: User Ratings Challenge x2 Version: Conquered Start Date: 1/8/17 End Date: 4/9/17 Post Link: Link ✘ Saiki Kusuo no Ψ-nan (TV) – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.03.17 ✘ Oniichan dakedo Ai sae Areba Kankeinai yo ne! – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.03.17 ✘ Active Raid: Kidou Kyoushuushitsu Dai Hachi Gakari – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.04.17 & cannot verify Score as user has set list to Private ✘ 12-sai.: Chicchana Mune no Tokimeki – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.06.17 ✘ Kantai Collection: KanColle – User (02_Jessica_04) no longer exists ✘ Touken Ranbu: Hanamaru – series Score listed as 3, not 2, by selected User ✘ Nanbaka – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.03.17 ✘ Nanbaka – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.05.17 ✘ Schwarzesmarken – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.05.17 ✘ Chiruran: Nibun no Ichi – User (Livann) no longer exists ✘ Occultic;Nine – series Completed prior to Start Date; shows Last Updated as 01.07.17 Punkero said: Challenge: The Special-Per-Day Challenge Second Run Version: Conquered Start Date: 05/03/2017 End Date: 13/04/2017 Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1522819#msg48799240 ✘ Little Nemo Pilot (1987) – series must be Completed on specified day (04.13.17); Start/End Date shows as 04.12.17 SomeFun said: Challenge: The Sports Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: Here ✔ Your entry is valid; however, please edit your Turn-In post and specify that you're completing Style #2 of the Challenge. Fixed Ginger_Snap said: Challenge: The Special Exposure Challenge Version (If applicable): Hard Start Date: Oct. 19, 2016 End Date: Apr. 14, 2017 Post Link: Here Note: Can not overlap with Genre Special Challenge: My Genre Special Challenge ✘ C³ Special – cannot use the Ecchi genre as it was not one of the listed "options above" in said requirement Omelettecat said: Challenge: Magical Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: April 15, 2017 Post Link: here Challenge: Horror Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: here (Magical Challenge – Easy) ✘ All anime used must appear on this list, the following (4) series do not: Tales of Symphonia The Animation: Sylvarant-hen, Bokusatsu Tenshi Dokuro-chan, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Majo no Takkyuubin (Horror Challenge – Easy) ✘ Jigoku Shoujo – series is only 2-cour long at 26 episodes; requirement states anime must be "more than 2-cours in length" ✘ Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai – series does not list Horror under Genres Vanadis said: Challenge: ☀️ The Special-Per-Day Challenge ☀️ ☀️ Version: Hard ☀️ Start Date: 15.03.2017 ☀️ End Date: 13.04.2017 ☀️ Post Link: ☀️☀️☀️ Challenge: 🎬 The Genre-Specials Challenge 🎬 🎬 Start Date: 15.03.2017 🎬 End Date: 14.04.2017 🎬 Post Link: 🎬🎬🎬 (Special-Per-Day Challenge – Hard) ✘ Hiyokoi (2012) – series Type listed as ONA (Genre-Specials Challenge) ⛔ Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Special – series started day before specified Start Date (03.15.17); change Start Date in Turn-In post to Challenge Post Date (03.14.17) to be valid ✘ Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase – series Type listed as TV & series listed under On-Hold heinrich6745 said: Challenge: Special Exposure Challenge Start date: Oct 9 2016 End date: April 15 2017 Post link: Here ✘ Accel World: Infinite∞Burst – series Type listed as Movie ✘ Miss Monochrome: The Animation - Manager – series Type listed as OVA ✘ Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu: Matsuri - Sentaku ni Yotte Tenkai ga Kawaru "LIPS Eizou" – series Type listed as ONA ✘ Bazar dé Gozarre – series listed under On-Hold moissi said: Challenge: Slice of Life Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: Before Club End Date: Before Club Post Link: Here. ✘ Clannad – series Source listed as Visual novel ✘ Free!: Eternal Summer – series not Ranked 800 or higher (#800, #801, #802, etc.); currently Ranked #685 heinrich6745 said: Challenge: Genre-Music Challenge Start date: April 16 2017 End date: April 17 2017 Post link: Here ✘ Okaasan ni Naisho – series Type listed as ONA ✘ Toute wa Sono Kotae – series not found on anime list ✔ Your entry is valid, as you still meet the necessary requirements. Astarate said: Challenge: Myth Set #13 Challenge Start Date: Feb 13 2017 End Date: April 17 2017 Post Link: +++ ✘ Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko – series has no episode videos listed Archer0596 said: Challenge: The 100 Episodes Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: March 04, 2017 End Date: March 04, 2017 Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1505105&show=50#post90 Upgrading From: Easy Upgrading To: Medium ✔ Your entry is valid; however, please edit your Turn-In post and delete the "Upgrading From/To" section, as you are just turning in the Easy Version. Fixed Archer0596 said: Challenge: The Romance Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: March 04, 2017 End Date: April 02, 2017 Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559055&show=100#post146 Upgrading From: Easy Upgrading To: Hard ✔ Your entry is valid; however, please edit your Turn-In post and delete the "Upgrading From/To" section, as you are just turning in the Easy Version. Fixed Archer0596 said: Challenge: The Mystery Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: March 04, 2017 End Date: April 18, 2017 Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1544516&show=100#post148 Upgrading From: Easy Upgrading To: Hard ✔ Your entry is valid; however, please edit your Turn-In post and delete the "Upgrading From/To" section, as you are just turning in the Easy Version. Fixed Archer0596 said: Challenge: The Slice of Life Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: April 09, 2017 End Date: April 14, 2017 Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1532581&show=150#msg50285691 Upgrading From: Easy Upgrading To: Hard ✘ Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu (2009) – the entire Main cast must have natural colored hair; Nagato Yuki has purple hair ✘ Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai. – series does not list any of the required options under Genres ✘ Dareka no Manazashi – series must be 15+ minutes total ✘ Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu – series is not 2-cour (or more) in length; must be, at least, 22 - 26 episodes ✘ Please edit your Turn-In post and delete the "Upgrading From/To" section, as you are just turning in the Easy Version. Archer0596 said: Challenge: The Comedy Challenge Version: Easy Start Date: April 02, 2017 End Date: April 14, 2017 Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=150#post164 Upgrading From: Easy Upgrading To: Hard ✘ Clannad – series does not have an all female Main cast ✘ Please edit your Turn-In post and delete the "Upgrading From/To" section, as you are just turning in the Easy Version. Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - The Mystery Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 06.01.2017 End Date: 17.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ Detective Conan vs. Wooo – series must be 15+ minutes total ✘ AD Police – series is not more than 2-cour in length Zenit said: Challenge: OVA Exposure Challenge Version: Hard Start Date: 16 June, 2016 End Date: 18 April, 2017 Post Link: Here ✘ Nayuta – series Completed before Start Date; Last Updated shows as 06.12.17 ✘ Hetalia: The Beautiful World Extra Disc – series must be 15+ minutes total heinrich6745 said: Challenge: Genre-OVAs Challenge Start date: Oct 9th 2016 End date: April 19th 2017 Post link: Here ✘ Animation! – series listed under On-Hold Wyvern22 said: Challenge: - The Sports Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 28.01.2017 End Date: 19.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ Please edit your Turn-In post and specify that you're turning in Style #2 of the Challenge. ✘ Initial D Battle Stage – series cannot contain the Drama genre ToosokaRin said: Challenge: Special-Per-Days Version: Medium (20 Specials) Start Date: Apr.1.2017 End Date: Apr.20.2017 Post Link: Blip _________________________________________________________________________________ Challenge: OVA-Per-Days Version: Medium (20 OVAs) Start Date: Apr.1.2017 End Date: Apr.20.2017 Post Link: Blip ⛔ All series must be Completed on the Specified date, and the Last Updated shows about half of your series were not. Please provide your timezone so I can properly inspect your challenges. Jhiday said: Challenge: April 2017 Challenge Start date: 2017-04-01 End date: 2017-04-21 Post link: here ✘ xxxHOLiC Rou – related series can be used if the trope applies; however, Mugetsu (who the trope references) does not appear under the Characters section. If you feel the series does in fact apply to the trope, proof will be needed. The_White_Wolf said: Challenge: 🐣🌷 April 2017 Challenge 🌷 🐣 Start Date: April 1st End Date: April 21st Post Link: My Post ✘ Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso – cannot use previously seen series; anything started before official start date is not allowed Lady_Nera said: Challenge: Shounen Ai Challenge Start Date: Before club End Date: Apr 24, 2017 Post Link: #69... ✘ Osakana wa Ami no Naka – series Studio listed as J.C.Staff Sojin said: Challenge: 1st Year Anniversary Challenge Start Date: Feb. 3rd, 17 End Date: Apr. 24th, 17 Post Link: Link ✘ Dr. Slump Movie 01: Arale-chan Hello! Fushigi Shima – series must be TV type or be more than 12 episodes at 20+ minutes per ✘ Fate/Prototype – series must be 15+ minutes total ✘ Reikenzan: Hoshikuzu-tachi no Utage – series must appear on this list ✘ Tonari no Seki-kun OVA – series must be TV type ✘ Mikakunin de Shinkoukei: Mite. Are ga Watashitachi no Tomatteiru Ryokan yo. – series must be 15+ minutes total Ginger_Snap said: Challenge: The Short Challenge x2 Version (If applicable): n/a Start Date: Nov. 26, 2016 End Date: Apr. 20, 2017 Post Link: Here Note: Can not overlap with the Genre Music Challenge or the Unrated Challenge: My Genre Music Challenge, I have not started an Unrated Challenge ✘ Heya – series does not start with the letters J, K, or L Even Entries Completed #3602 ― #3750 |
SunflowerDaishoSep 13, 2017 6:14 AM
|
| @SunflowerDaisho Mmm, no idea how that happened, I even turned in the challenge exactly at 00:10 AM April 13. Anyway, https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1492431&show=950#msg51066150 based on this, can't I used my mistake allowed and so still have this entry be valid? |
 |
SunflowerDaisho said: Shanayaaa said: @SunflowerDaisho I am mentioned at the bottom of post #839 (to help you find what I'm talking about). -For Shiki, you said "series aired in summer, not fall". I thought that because it aired from July through to December that it could be used for either? -As for Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Gaiden: Ami-chan no Hatsukoi, she wears glasses in the series/episode/special so wouldn't that count? -I guess I got the wrong idea about Umineko; I thought that two cours was 24 episodes, so Umineko had more because it has 26 episodes:p I see that this is wrong, and that 26 episodes counts as a 2-cour anime... On the other hand, other people appear to have turned in anime with 26 episodes for that requirement without any problem. For Shiki, as far as I know, if a requirement asks for a series that aired during a certain season/year/etc. only the date when it began Airing counts. I will ask a senior Inspector (@AYOSHINA) for verification. For Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Gaiden: Ami-chan no Hatsukoi, as long as you can provide proof that she wears glasses for the majority of the Special, she can be accepted. A screenshot or two would suffice. As for Umineko no Naku Koro ni, a 2-cour anime would be 22 - 26 episodes in length... Though a number of challenges have been accepted with series of a similar length. Again, I will defer to @AYOSHINA for help with the issue. - Only the date when it began Airing counts, so unfortunately Shiki wouldn't fit in that requirement. - A 2-cour anime series would be 22 - 26 episodes in length, so for the requirement you would need to watched a series with 27+ episodes. |
Punkero said: @SunflowerDaisho Mmm, no idea how that happened, I even turned in the challenge exactly at 00:10 AM April 13. Anyway, https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1492431&show=950#msg51066150 based on this, can't I used my mistake allowed and so still have this entry be valid? Ah, yep. That'll work fine. No need to do anything, your entry is valid. |
|
SunflowerDaisho said: Vanadis said: Challenge: ☀️ The Special-Per-Day Challenge ☀️ ☀️ Version: Hard ☀️ Start Date: 15.03.2017 ☀️ End Date: 13.04.2017 ☀️ Post Link: ☀️☀️☀️ Challenge: 🎬 The Genre-Specials Challenge 🎬 🎬 Start Date: 15.03.2017 🎬 End Date: 14.04.2017 🎬 Post Link: 🎬🎬🎬 (Special-Per-Day Challenge – Hard) ✘ Hiyokoi (2012) – series Type listed as ONA (Genre-Specials Challenge) ⛔ Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Special – series started day before specified Start Date (03.15.17); change Start Date in Turn-In post to Challenge Post Date (03.14.17) to be valid ✘ Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase – series Type listed as TV & series listed under On-Hold ✘ Hiyokoi (2012) – series Type listed as ONA I'm sure these were listed as specials when I watched them. :/ What can be done about that? Is there any way to check changes that were made to the page? I've tried archive.org, but it can only prove that series type was "special" in 2016 (Screenshot). ⛔ Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Special – series started day before specified Start Date (03.15.17); change Start Date in Turn-In post to Challenge Post Date (03.14.17) to be valid Changed the date to 14.03.2017 in the turn-in post. ✘ Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase – series Type listed as TV & series listed under On-Hold Sorry about that stupid mistake. >_< It should be Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase Special, but somehow I used the TV instead. And now I see that special doesn't even have the "vampire" type! :/ Am I allowed to make some replacements between my Genre-specials and Special Exposure challenges? Thanks for your help.^^ |
| @SunflowerDaisho Wyvern22 said: ✘ Detective Conan vs. Wooo – series must be 15+ minutes totalChallenge: - The Mystery Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 06.01.2017 End Date: 17.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ AD Police – series is not more than 2-cour in length The last mystery series that i watched and was aired longer than 2-cours was City Hunter 2 and i'd finished it one week before this post so just reject the turn-in. Now i'm going to watch Blood+ but i want to know if i still can use the series that i've alredy watched for the 2nd run Wyvern22 said: ✘ Please edit your Turn-In post and specify that you're turning in Style #2 of the Challenge.Challenge: - The Sports Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 28.01.2017 End Date: 19.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ Initial D Battle Stage – series cannot contain the Drama genre Turn-in changed. And swaped Initial D Battle Stage with Grappler Baki |
Wyvern22Aug 27, 2017 9:54 PM
|
SunflowerDaisho said: Zenit said: Challenge: OVA Exposure Challenge Version: Hard Start Date: 16 June, 2016 End Date: 18 April, 2017 Post Link: Here ✘ Nayuta – series Completed before Start Date; Last Updated shows as 06.12.17 ✘ Hetalia: The Beautiful World Extra Disc – series must be 15+ minutes total My start date is in 2016 and I don't see anything about 15+ minutes in the rules (or am I just blind? ><) |
 |
Vanadis said: SunflowerDaisho said: (Special-Per-Day Challenge – Hard) ✘ Hiyokoi (2012) – series Type listed as ONA (Genre-Specials Challenge) ⛔ Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Special – series started day before specified Start Date (03.15.17); change Start Date in Turn-In post to Challenge Post Date (03.14.17) to be valid ✘ Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase – series Type listed as TV & series listed under On-Hold ✘ Hiyokoi (2012) – series Type listed as ONA I'm sure these were listed as specials when I watched them. :/ What can be done about that? Is there any way to check changes that were made to the page? I've tried archive.org, but it can only prove that series type was "special" in 2016 (Screenshot). ⛔ Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon SuperS Special – series started day before specified Start Date (03.15.17); change Start Date in Turn-In post to Challenge Post Date (03.14.17) to be valid Changed the date to 14.03.2017 in the turn-in post. ✘ Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase – series Type listed as TV & series listed under On-Hold Sorry about that stupid mistake. >_< It should be Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase Special, but somehow I used the TV instead. And now I see that special doesn't even have the "vampire" type! :/ Am I allowed to make some replacements between my Genre-specials and Special Exposure challenges? Thanks for your help.^^ Special-Per-Day Challenge (Hard) I was able to find proof through oldweb.tody that it was indeed listed as a Special two days after you watched it, so just make a note on your challenge with a screenshot of proof or a link to this post for consistency sake. Your challenge is now valid. Genre-Specials Challenge As long as your Special Exposure Challenge hasn't been checked by an inspector and the dates still work all around, I don't see a problem with it. Wyvern22 said: @SunflowerDaisho Wyvern22 said: ✘ Detective Conan vs. Wooo – series must be 15+ minutes totalChallenge: - The Mystery Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 06.01.2017 End Date: 17.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ AD Police – series is not more than 2-cour in length The last mystery series that i watched and was aired longer than 2-cours was City Hunter 2 and i'd finished it one week before this post so just reject the turn-in. Now i'm going to watch Blood+ but i want to know if i still can use the series that i've alredy watched for the 2nd run Wyvern22 said: ✘ Please edit your Turn-In post and specify that you're turning in Style #2 of the Challenge.Challenge: - The Sports Challenge - Version: Hard Start Date: 28.01.2017 End Date: 19.04.2017 Post Link: Link ✘ Initial D Battle Stage – series cannot contain the Drama genre Turn-in changed. And swaped Initial D Battle Stage with Grappler Baki Mystery Challenge (Hard) If you haven't turned in your 2nd run yet, you should be fine to take series from it to use. Sports Challenge (Hard) Everything looks good now. Your Turn-In is now valid. Zenit said: SunflowerDaisho said: ✘ Nayuta – series Completed before Start Date; Last Updated shows as 06.12.17 ✘ Hetalia: The Beautiful World Extra Disc – series must be 15+ minutes total My start date is in 2016 and I don't see anything about 15+ minutes in the rules (or am I just blind? ><) Oh, wow. You're right, and I'm the completely blind one here. Both of those were my mistake. Your entry is valid, no need to do anything else. |
|
SunflowerDaisho said: Vanadis said: I'm sure these were listed as specials when I watched them. :/ What can be done about that? Is there any way to check changes that were made to the page? I've tried archive.org, but it can only prove that series type was "special" in 2016 (Screenshot). Changed the date to 14.03.2017 in the turn-in post. Sorry about that stupid mistake. >_< It should be Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase Special, but somehow I used the TV instead. And now I see that special doesn't even have the "vampire" type! :/ Am I allowed to make some replacements between my Genre-specials and Special Exposure challenges? Thanks for your help.^^ Special-Per-Day Challenge (Hard) I was able to find proof through oldweb.tody that it was indeed listed as a Special two days after you watched it, so just make a note on your challenge with a screenshot of proof or a link to this post for consistency sake. Your challenge is now valid. Thanks. :) I've added screenshot and links to my Special-per-day and Special Exposure challenges, where Hiyokoi was used. Genre-Specials Challenge As long as your Special Exposure Challenge hasn't been checked by an inspector and the dates still work all around, I don't see a problem with it. Added Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase Special to the Exposure challenge and Vampiyan Kids: Pilot to the Genre-specials. Do I have to turn-in these challenges again now? I'm new to this, so I'm not really sure how everything works.^^" |
Vanadis said: Special-Per-Day Challenge (Hard) I was able to find proof through oldweb.tody that it was indeed listed as a Special two days after you watched it, so just make a note on your challenge with a screenshot of proof or a link to this post for consistency sake. Your challenge is now valid. Thanks. :) I've added screenshot and links to my Special-per-day and Special Exposure challenges, where Hiyokoi was used. Genre-Specials Challenge As long as your Special Exposure Challenge hasn't been checked by an inspector and the dates still work all around, I don't see a problem with it. Added Tsukuyomi: Moon Phase Special to the Exposure challenge and Vampiyan Kids: Pilot to the Genre-specials. Do I have to turn-in these challenges again now? I'm new to this, so I'm not really sure how everything works.^^" Your Genre-Specials and Special-Per-Day Challenge both look good now. Both are valid and as your original Turn-In post has not been crossed out, there's no need to re-submit. Your Special Exposure Challenge will be checked when the inspectors get to it, no need to do anything there either. You're all set. |
|
| @SunflowerDaisho I'm not saying that you guys made sloppy work but... are you freaking serious? This was back in April... on the twenty-first. Personally, I think this a tiny weeny little bit late. Don't you? Oh, while you're at it. Please check the August Challenge before the 31st. Thanks as always for your hard work... |
The_White_WolfAug 28, 2017 10:38 AM
 |
The_White_Wolf said: I understand your frustration, but please keep in mind that the inspectors are only doing their jobs and its not a personal stab to anyone in particular. With all timed challenges, should something turn up as invalid later on when that timed challenge is inspected, we do allow some time for the user to make a correction whether you use something else you watched that month, or watch something new within the allowed time. For monthly challenges, we realize we can't ask you to jump in a time machine to April and go watch something else xD@SunflowerDaisho I'm not saying that you guys made sloppy work but... are you freaking serious? This was back in April... on the twenty-first. Personally, I think this a tiny weeny little bit late. Don't you? Oh, while you're at it. Please check the August Challenge before the 31st. Thanks as always for your hard work... I do ask that you try to keep your responses respectful to the very unappreciated inspectors. They're doing their best to recruit more help, train that new help, and get caught up with their inspections. August will not be inspected before the 31st, that would be unrealistic with the sheer number of waiting turn-ins. As the club grows we've tried asking for more inspector help which has not come easily, unfortuantely. You have 24 hours to watch something else to meet the requirement that was marked invalid. Please politely let the inspectors know when this has been completed and the challenge updated. Thank you for your understanding ^-^ |
SunflowerDaisho said: ✘ xxxHOLiC Rou – related series can be used if the trope applies; however, Mugetsu (who the trope references) does not appear under the Characters section. If you feel the series does in fact apply to the trope, proof will be needed. MAL's character sections are notoriously uncomplete for OVA sequels. Mugetsu does appear in Rou (curled up around Watanuki), and is indeed a major part of the plot of the first episode (out of two). Hopefully this is enough proof. |
Jhiday said: SunflowerDaisho said: ✘ xxxHOLiC Rou – related series can be used if the trope applies; however, Mugetsu (who the trope references) does not appear under the Characters section. If you feel the series does in fact apply to the trope, proof will be needed. MAL's character sections are notoriously uncomplete for OVA sequels. Mugetsu does appear in Rou (curled up around Watanuki), and is indeed a major part of the plot of the first episode (out of two). Hopefully this is enough proof. Yes and thank you, those screenshots work as proof. Your Turn-In is now valid. |
|
riho88riho said: The_White_Wolf said: I understand your frustration, but please keep in mind that the inspectors are only doing their jobs and its not a personal stab to anyone in particular. With all timed challenges, should something turn up as invalid later on when that timed challenge is inspected, we do allow some time for the user to make a correction whether you use something else you watched that month, or watch something new within the allowed time. For monthly challenges, we realize we can't ask you to jump in a time machine to April and go watch something else xD@SunflowerDaisho I'm not saying that you guys made sloppy work but... are you freaking serious? This was back in April... on the twenty-first. Personally, I think this a tiny weeny little bit late. Don't you? Oh, while you're at it. Please check the August Challenge before the 31st. Thanks as always for your hard work... I do ask that you try to keep your responses respectful to the very unappreciated inspectors. They're doing their best to recruit more help, train that new help, and get caught up with their inspections. August will not be inspected before the 31st, that would be unrealistic with the sheer number of waiting turn-ins. As the club grows we've tried asking for more inspector help which has not come easily, unfortunately. You have 24 hours to watch something else to meet the requirement that was marked invalid. Please politely let the inspectors know when this has been completed and the challenge updated. Thank you for your understanding ^-^ This was never meant to be a personal attack, sorry if it came out this way. (I sorta have a sharp tongue when it comes to things like this.) (ﾉ≧ڡ≦) I do appreciate your work and never knew you guys were looking for Inspectors. I did look for an application form once but found nothing of this sort (given that was somewhere in December...). Anyway, if you don't mind me asking would you still look for an Inspector or did I blow my chance with this faux pas already? And thanks for the chance to fix it, I truly appreciate it. -Wolf |
|
SunflowerDaisho said: The_White_Wolf said: Challenge: 🐣🌷 April 2017 Challenge 🌷 🐣 Start Date: April 1st End Date: April 21st Post Link: My Post ✘ Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso – cannot use previously seen series; anything started before official start date is not allowed Dear Instructor SunflowerDaisho, I hope I do not inconvenience you any more than I already have, but I do believe that I have done right my wrong of the past. Hopefully, this is said to be the truth. I wish you the best of days and may our next encounter be a reason for joy and lush full festivities. Yours truly Wolf |
The_White_WolfAug 28, 2017 1:30 PM
|
The_White_Wolf said: Anyway, if you don't mind me asking would you still look for an Inspector or did I blow my chance with this faux pas already? Unfortunately, at this time, we've already finished our Inspector Exam and are no longer accepting applicants. However, the Inspector Exam will open from time to time. When the time comes and if you're still interested, feel free to send me an application (which can be found on the staff page). |
Kreyul said: From time to time Is quite vague, isn't it? Do you have a little hint when the next Exam starts? Anyway, I'll keep looking forward to it and thanks for the information. |
|
The_White_Wolf said: SunflowerDaisho said: ✘ Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso – cannot use previously seen series; anything started before official start date is not allowed Dear Instructor SunflowerDaisho, I hope I do not inconvenience you any more than I already have, but I do believe that I have done right my wrong of the past. Hopefully, this is said to be the truth. I wish you the best of days and may our next encounter be a reason for joy and lush full festivities. Yours truly Wolf As per riho88riho's post here, in allowing the invalid entry to be made up by watching a new series within 24 hours, your Turn-In is now valid. I am unsure if this will affect your Challenge End Date and will have to ask a senior Inspector (@AYOSHINA). Your Turn-In has not been crossed out yet though, so there will be no need to re-submit. No need to sound so formal, but I appreciate the well wishes. If you're ever unsure on how to go about fixing an invalid entry in the future, just ask what can be done and the respective Inspector can let you know how to go about correcting any mistakes. Thank you, and have a great day! |
|
The_White_Wolf said: Is quite vague, isn't it? Do you have a little hint when the next Exam starts? Anyway, I'll keep looking forward to it and thanks for the information. The next exam opening will depend on the amount of turn-ins in the future. We will be posting staff recruitment (such as the inspector position) in the newsletter, so feel free to follow that. |
SunflowerDaisho said: The_White_Wolf said: Dear Instructor SunflowerDaisho, I hope I do not inconvenience you any more than I already have, but I do believe that I have done right my wrong of the past. Hopefully, this is said to be the truth. I wish you the best of days and may our next encounter be a reason for joy and lush full festivities. Yours truly Wolf As per riho88riho's post here, in allowing the invalid entry to be made up by watching a new series within 24 hours, your Turn-In is now valid. I am unsure if this will affect your Challenge End Date and will have to ask a senior Inspector (@AYOSHINA). Your Turn-In has not been crossed out yet though, so there will be no need to re-submit. No need to sound so formal, but I appreciate the well wishes. If you're ever unsure on how to go about fixing an invalid entry in the future, just ask what can be done and the respective Inspector can let you know how to go about correcting any mistakes. Thank you, and have a great day! Change your challenge end date and link this post to your turn-in. |
| @AYOSHINA Done. |
|
More topics from this board
» 🍂 November 2024 Challenge [101st Monthiversary] ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )AWCC_admin - Oct 31 |
463 |
by TheFlyingOrange
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» 🌾 2024 AWCc Open House (Part 4 Sign Ups Open Until NOV 24) ( 1 2 )SheyCroix - Nov 16 |
55 |
by Bri
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Sticky: » 🏆 Challenges Turn-Ins (v.4) ( 1 2 3 4 )AWCC_admin - Oct 28 |
157 |
by ScarletDevil666
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Live Action Challenge ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SheyCroix - Feb 1, 2023 |
323 |
by ScarletDevil666
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Award Winning (TV) Challenge ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SheyCroix - Feb 27, 2020 |
358 |
by ScarletDevil666
»»
2 hours ago |