Schlopsi said: AudioTsunami said: 21. First Part of JoJo, Hot Road, Kaze no Tani no Nausicaä 30 Most Shinkai stuff will work here(5cm per second, hoshi no koe), Summer Wars, No. 6, All you need is kill Oh Evangelion has a manga too based on the anime. Eva sucks tho. Thanks. I'll go with Hot Road for #21. Not sure about #30, 'cause I'd prefer to watch the anime/films instead. Heard about Evangelion too. Well, probably not my cup of tea anyway. All You Need Is Kill is based off a Light Novel and is a p good manga, and short. |
ClavisM said: Wondering if someone could recommend me a few things for some of the criteria?: 31. Read a manga that has inspired or been adapted to cd drama 44. Read a manga that deals with something related to Japanese culture 49. Read a manga centered around folklore or mythology and possibly one for 60? Someone did recommend me something but I can't find the complete manga. I prefer action/crime stuff but as long as their isn't a lot of romance I'll pretty much give most things a go. Thanks in advance ^^ 31: Onanie master Kurosawa is probably your best option, most of the rest are just straight yaoi. 44: Ran and The Grey World(Folklore), Densha Otoko(internet culture), Cross Game(Koshien), Lady Snowblood(Samurai) 49: Ran and The Grey World, Ghost Hunt, Mononoke Soushi, Ushio To Tora 60: Gunnm, Bokurano, Oyaji BrainpanSonata said: I have 60 in my challenge. Open to anything, but I have a penchant for horror and thrillers. Clavis, have you read Matantei Loki? It would fit 49 pretty nicely. Kokou Not Hitou, Kakukaku Shikajika |
AudioTsunamiMar 29, 2017 11:23 AM
| Went with Kokou no Hito. Thanks, Audio. I don't actually have a full count of my pre-MAL completed manga (and barely even a rough estimate), so I'm going to tag my challenge manga so they don't get lost when I add in those other manga. |
   |
Schlopsi said: @Wenli: You can go with Chikan Otoko, since you liked OMK. Otherwise: Dawn: Tsumetai Te. @Gwadzka: Shi ni Itaru Yamai. If you want something completely different, try out Kuro Kishi Monogatari. Both are Seinen. Can someone give me some underdog recs for 21. Read a manga published between the 1980s and the 1990s and 30. Read a manga adapted from a video game, original anime or light novel? I am up for everything as long as it's less than 10 Volumes and finished. For 30: This is actually quite rare that a manga adapts from another medium. Maybe you'll like Emanon. That one is based on a novel. https://myanimelist.net/manga/17465/Omoide_Emanon |
 |
AudioTsunami said: All You Need Is Kill is based off a Light Novel and is a p good manga, and short. Yeah, I've seen Live.Die.Repeat and quite liked it. Not sure if its necessary to read the manga as well.. ;) @SixFlags: I might read that one. Thanks. |
| Has to be a light novel, not an actual novel. Same reason why Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan or Vagabond wouldn't work. Satougashi no Dangan wa Uchinukenai, DRRR 1st arc, Conductor are all completed things that work, along with what I listed previously. DunMachi and The Rising of the Shield Hero are both ongoing things that work. @Schlopsi @SixFlags. |
AudioTsunamiMar 29, 2017 11:42 AM
Thanks a lot I'll check them out ^^ |
  |
It's getting trickier than I thought. *sigh* I might just go with Darker Than Black - Shikkoku no Hana. Even though the prequel didn't convince. |
Schlopsi said: It's getting trickier than I thought. *sigh* I might just go with Darker Than Black - Shikkoku no Hana. Even though the prequel didn't convince. I read that last year, it was real bad, so good luck getting through it. |
| Hello! I was looking for some reccomendations for #60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. Preferably not ecchi, mecha or sport. Thank you! ( ´¬`) |
Nadeko_ said: Hello! I was looking for some reccomendations for #60 - Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread. Preferably not ecchi, mecha or sport. Thank you! ( ´¬`) How about : Ran to Haiiro no Sekai |
aemiliuz said: Mmmh, thanks, but I already used it for another entry.（ಥ_ಥ）Other suggestions?How about : Ran to Haiiro no Sekai |
Nadeko_ said: aemiliuz said: Mmmh, thanks, but I already used it for another entry.（ಥ_ಥ）Other suggestions?How about : Ran to Haiiro no Sekai I'll try again with Natsu no Zenjitsu |
aemiliuz said: I'll try again with Natsu no Zenjitsu Woo, it looks interesting! :D Thanks~ |
| For 44 (Read a manga that deals with something related to Japanese culture), would a yakuza manga count? If not, any recommendations less than 5 volumes would be appreciated, can be on my ptr. |
| Yeah, sure. Japanese gang culture. |
| Hello~ Could I get a recommendation, please? Anything not already listed here, labelled with the Action genre, and relatively short if possible. Thanks! ^^ |
| Not those three things or just not listed and IS labelled action and relatively short? Not listed, short or action: Kokou no Hitou Not listed, but short and action: Gunnm, Oyaji, All you need is kill |
| @AudioTsunami Not listed, but short and action. I think I'll use Oyaji, and save All You Need Is Kill for the adapted from a light novel slot. Thank you! |
| Hi guys Looking for a bit of guidance for the "27. Read a manga one-shot that became a prototype for a longer series" - does this manga count = Koe no Katachi Sorry if it seems dumb. I've always been more into anime and am using this challenge to get digging into manga a little more :') Thanks! |
  |
| Hey guys! So I have this: 60. Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread Anyone who is in the challenge as well, can you recommend me something? What I like are stuff that's ether more realistic, slice of life or horror, mystery, psychological. What I dislike: harem, ecchi, romance. Thank you in advance c: |
| @Caitlynlol I'd recommend Sanctuary or Kokou no hitou If you want something shorter then I'd go with Satougashi no Dangan wa Uchinukenai but beware it's quite depressing |
 |
| @MegaMan-Zero Wow, I love your recs! I'm already reading Kokou no Hitou since before, I'm a quarter through it so I can't choose that for this challenge. Therefore, I'm going to go with Sanctuary. I'm also going to read the short one just for sadness fun because it looks really good as well. Thank you very much! |
| First of all,i'm just gonna say sorry for so many questions.It is my first time reading mangas (and honestly i`m still getting used in MAL so yeah). With all of the explanation done ,here we go: For #43:read a manga with an adult mc. -Does Molester Man from Chikan Otoko count? For the bingo card:could i edit my card into this and not edit some circles on it? Edit:I've used the excel spreadsheet provided for the challenge for more easy tracking (i just basically screenshot my bingo card from the spreadsheet) Lastly i needed recommendations for #60:something that does not exceed 30 chapters and involves romance will do :) Thanks in advance! |
kuromi_hideakiApr 7, 2017 5:34 PM
 |
| @kuromi_hideaki Hi, welcome to the manga challenge! Chikan Otoko does count for #43 That's an acceptable way to edit the bingo card, sure, since I can check the original when I go over your form. As for a rec, what about Bitter Virgin? It's 32 chapters though. Nineteen Twenty-One if you're okay with a Korean comic and if you like BL, then No Color because it's awesome :) |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Hello I still need to do #60. "Read a manga recommended to you by another Manga Reading Challenge participant in the discussion thread" Can someone recommend me a finished manga with ten volumes or less? Also, can someone recommend a magazine, that I can use for #15. "Read a manga serialized in a josei magazine"? Thanks |
  |
tsuyokunaru said: @kuromi_hideaki Hi, welcome to the manga challenge! Chikan Otoko does count for #43 That's an acceptable way to edit the bingo card, sure, since I can check the original when I go over your form. As for a rec, what about Bitter Virgin? It's 32 chapters though. Nineteen Twenty-One if you're okay with a Korean comic and if you like BL, then No Color because it's awesome :) Im already wanting to read Bitter Virgin ever since i've read the synopsis (better get started in reading this one) Does manhwa count in this challenge? (i thought mangas are the only ones accepted here) Anyways thank you for your help ^_^ |
|
kuromi_hideaki said: Im already wanting to read Bitter Virgin ever since i've read the synopsis (better get started in reading this one) Does manhwa count in this challenge? (i thought mangas are the only ones accepted here) Anyways thank you for your help ^_^ Yeah, both manhwa and manhua count as well as one-shots, original english manga and light novels don't count though. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
tsuyokunaru said: kuromi_hideaki said: Im already wanting to read Bitter Virgin ever since i've read the synopsis (better get started in reading this one) Does manhwa count in this challenge? (i thought mangas are the only ones accepted here) Anyways thank you for your help ^_^ Yeah, both manhwa and manhua count as well as one-shots, original english manga and light novels don't count though. Oh ok kinda confused for a sec but thanks for the info. |
|
| Hi :D ,i'm looking for recommendations for #60...can someone do it for me? Any manga with less than 10 volumes will be welcome,thank you (: |
| @Orumaito I'd go with Spirit Circle or Hoshi no Samidare P.S Mizukami Satoshi is my favourite mangaka If you don't mind reading manhwa then the breaker works as well it's pretty good |
|
| @MegaMan-Zero thanks.I'll read Hoshi no Samidare,looks interesting,Psychological is my favorite genre,anyway,thanks again. |
Orumaito said: @MegaMan-Zero thanks.I'll read Hoshi no Samidare,looks interesting,Psychological is my favorite genre,anyway,thanks again. Hoshi no Samidare is REALLY good, so that's a really great choice. It's a slow starter tho |
| Hello! Can someone give me some rec for #60? Preferably not a rec with too many chapters and no hentai, anything else is fine! Thanks ^^ |
 |
Yxng_000 said: Hello! Can someone give me some rec for #60? Preferably not a rec with too many chapters and no hentai, anything else is fine! Thanks ^^ Hello, I hope these doesn't get considered as too much chapters but I really enjoyed them! https://myanimelist.net/manga/40761/Ookami_Kodomo_no_Ame_to_Yuki https://myanimelist.net/manga/12888/Hapi_Mari__Happy_Marriage https://myanimelist.net/manga/54925 |
  |
makotoed said: Yxng_000 said: Hello! Can someone give me some rec for #60? Preferably not a rec with too many chapters and no hentai, anything else is fine! Thanks ^^ Hello, I hope these doesn't get considered as too much chapters but I really enjoyed them! https://myanimelist.net/manga/40761/Ookami_Kodomo_no_Ame_to_Yuki https://myanimelist.net/manga/12888/Hapi_Mari__Happy_Marriage https://myanimelist.net/manga/54925 Ah thank you! I will read Diamond Dust then, it looks interesting. |
Yxng_000Apr 11, 2017 7:45 AM
|
| Hello everyone! I'm looking for any suggestions for #51: Read a manga based on real event or person. Unfortunately most of the ones I thought of picking up are still being translated, and I am not sure how accurate portrayals have to be (for ex. would Osamu Tezuka's Buddha fit here?) |
  |
| Just wondering : does Feng Shen Ji count as a single entry or three separate ones ? Also, number of volumes is unknown, does that mean it wouldn't fulfill the length restriction ? Because if you take it as a single entry it is actually decently long, definitely more than 5 volumes. Finally, would you say it is centered around folklore or mythology ? |
HapHazrD said: Just wondering : does Feng Shen Ji count as a single entry or three separate ones ? Also, number of volumes is unknown, does that mean it wouldn't fulfill the length restriction ? Because if you take it as a single entry it is actually decently long, definitely more than 5 volumes. Finally, would you say it is centered around folklore or mythology ? It certainly counts as 3 entries. @tsuykunaru on the the volume length restriction, but that seems like a slippery slope. It might be close enough for folklore/mythology cause of the whole gods things, but it's not based on preexisting folklore or mythology so..grey area |
| @HapHazrD Well, it would count as 3 entries here, but I'll let you bypass that if you link to the Baka-Updates entry instead of MAL DB. That definitely makes it longer than 5 volumes. I'll also allow it for mythology since Wikipedia says the Shang dynasty is one of the time periods that mostly influenced Chinese mythology. |
| 2025 Manga Reading Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion 2025 Anime Watching Challenge: Sign Up — Discussion Discord server for MRC/AWC |
MRC_mod said: @HapHazrD Well, it would count as 3 entries here, but I'll let you bypass that if you link to the Baka-Updates entry instead of MAL DB. That definitely makes it longer than 5 volumes. I'll also allow it for mythology since Wikipedia says the Shang dynasty is one of the time periods that mostly influenced Chinese mythology. Thanks for the pointers. I haven't decided yet wether to do the length restriction or not, but good to know I can be flexible with this manhua if needed. |
lady_freyja said: I don't think it has to be particularly faithful. Buddha definitely works here. Personally, for this item, I would recommend Innocents Shounen Juujigun about the Children's Crusade from 1212. It is short, it is about a somewhat unknown historical event and it is pretty good (well, I like the author…). But a little warning : if the manga start as pretty safe, near the end, some passages are really gruesome, I mean you'll see 10 years-old children killed or tortured. And as a shōjo fan-girl, there is always Versailles no Bara which is excellent too. About the French Revolution. Thank you for the suggestions! I'll use Buddha then, but promise to read Innocents Shounen Juujigun as well o7 ---------------- I do have one more question - is it ok to use one of the items on my card for the free spot, if it falls outside of my selected pattern? |
|
| @RulenneClarissa Yeah, that's fine. You could even re-use a number that falls within your pattern, it really is a free item. |
密室殺人はなぜ美しいのか。 |
| Question! Do dancing and acting count for the "food, music or art" challenge? |
   |
Maffy said: Question! Do dancing and acting count for the "food, music or art" challenge? Since no one is answering, I'll take it as a yes since acting is part of the arts! *wooshes* |
|
More topics from this board
Sticky: » The 'Help Identifying This Manga/Character' Thread v3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 19, 2022 |
1307 |
by DMVBB
»»
50 seconds ago |
|
» Any manga related?giandambro3 - Today |
2 |
by Retro8bit
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» What are you reading right now? ( 1 2 )nirererin - Jun 24 |
78 |
by Jhinsoul
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» Have you ever droped a manga that you had been following for a long time and with great interest?RobertBobert - Sep 7 |
20 |
by ryan77999
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» The Second Manga General Election on Niconico MangaGinIonSui - Aug 11 |
3 |
by GinIonSui
»»
11 hours ago |