| I sort of go by gut instinct. I set 5 as average so I try to compare it to the anime I have seen before to determine where it fits. |
  |
| What makes this thread so different? |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I rate based in "everything": -Story -Characters -Art -Sound -Enjoyment (I only give extra points, it decidec if I give a 8 or a 9, not more) I think that as sound you could think about voice acting, sound effects, music and opening & ending, in the two latters if the lyrics have any meaning, I think it should increase the rating. |
 |
| Why should we tell you how to rate your anime? Are you fucking retarded? |
A stupid thread deserves a stupid answer!  |
| If I like it I give it a high rating. If the anime has a sequel I give it the same score as I did to the prequel on the first episode, but if it gets boring I decrease the score by one, and it can keep decreasing until it gets better. I don't rate all the anime the same way, for more info check my profile. |
 |
| Make a scale for music by itself, separate from sound which can be for sound effects. |
Pyravia said: Don't speak on everyone's behalf. I'm not forcing you. This optional, so, what are you, fucking retarted? I want to know what everyone thinks so I (probably) can change my thoughts on rating anime. It's nice to know what everyone thinks. It could change a lot. What I like may not be what the majority likes, but it can still help me change the way I rate things. Your thread is nothing special. One of these comes by every 1/2 months. Dig some threads up from back then and go through those instead of filling AD with cancer like this. I see people commenting shit I've already seen them commenting in other threads. |
A stupid thread deserves a stupid answer! |
| I rate based on how I felt about it in its entirety. I'm not going to rate every aspect individually and balance the final score around that. Pyravia said: Anything I can change sound with? Music? OST? |
Pyravia said: There's nothing in this life that it's perfect -_- so in that cases I rate based in enjoyment (if it deserves a 9 but I absolutely love it, I give it a 10).SuzuMine-chan said: But, say for example... You have a perfect system, and you absolutely loved one anime, but the sound quality wasn't really in check for a 10/10, but everything else was?I rate based in "everything": -Story -Characters -Art -Sound -Enjoyment (I only give extra points, it decidec if I give a 8 or a 9, not more) I think that as sound you could think about voice acting, sound effects, music and opening & ending, in the two latters if the lyrics have any meaning, I think it should increase the rating. And you want it to be 10/10 in all. |
|
Pyravia said: Prince said: Try reading the description, pifta. It's not the same, pifta. ;)Your thread is nothing special. One of these comes by every 1/2 months. Dig some threads up from back then and go through those instead of filling AD with cancer like this. I see people commenting shit I've already seen them commenting in other threads. Most people would act passive aggressive by now, but you sure are out of your shell already. I can't help it when I see cancer like this. Sorry man o/ |
A stupid thread deserves a stupid answer! |
Pyravia said: GoldNautilus said: That would mess up the whole 0-50 Average Score. Maybe originality or creativity?Make a scale for music by itself, separate from sound which can be for sound effects. Or rate Enjoyment 0/20 Why does it absolutely have to stay at a 50 point scale? You could still convert it into percentages with any number of categories, they just won't be whole numbers for the most part. But if you insist on limiting it to 5 categories, I don't think anyone can help you. |
| Sound quality? Christ, that's like the least important part of an anime. All the Japanese VAs are professionals so it's doubtful they'll sound like shit and poor music doesn't decrease the enjoyment. Good music just increases it. A good OP/ED song might make the show more memorable. Also art and animation should be 2 separate fields since the art basically means the character designs and backgrounds while animation deals with fluidity, CGI and that type of shit. Not that I care since I just rate things whatever I feel like. The more it pisses me off the lower the score. |
 |
Pyravia said: And just rate it whatever I think? I mean, I find it very hard to make such a specific rating without calculating. Why is it hard to rate without calculating? Like, if I love an anime (Fairy Tail, for example) and I know I love it. I know I'll rate it somewhere between a 8 and a 10. Then I think of things I might not have liked so much about it, like if I thought it dragged on in places. Then I knock down the score by 1 point and settle for final score of 9. It's not difficult, lol. |
| So turn those into 2 and get rid of sound, problem solved. |
|
| Not sure if this thread is serious or not but I'll give a serious answer. Imo you should weight all the elements because it doesn't make sense to use 0/10 for everything if not everything is equally important for you. For me personally characters and story are most important factors while visuals is the least important one, so my scores divide like this: 30% story 30% characters 20% enjoyment 15% sound (ost, op&ed, voice acting) 5% visuals (art and animation) So if sound is not an important factor for you, then it should be like 5% of a score so that an anime can still be 10/10 even if you think the sound sucked. |
 |
| Enjoyment, nothing more, nothing less. Now, what is what i enjoy? I'm not sure but is something like this: Story 60% Characters 30% Everything else 10% |
| was it good?: Score in top half of scale (6-10) Was it bad?: Score in bottom half of scale (1-5) To determine specific score: 1. Story: Was the story well written and Entertaining? Yes/no 2. Characters: Were the characters likable? Did they they develop? Yes/no 3. Emotional Impact: Did the show make me feel something? Did I care about the characters and what was happening to them? Yes/no 4. The Ending: Did the show even end? If so was it was it conclusive and did it fit the show? Yes/no 5. Technical Specs: Was the show made well? Did it have good animation, music, etc? Yes/no Yes Answers (even if only partially true) = +1 No Answers = 0 Add accumulated points to determine specific score. Example: You answered yes 3 times. If you thought this show was good your rating will be an 8 If you thought the show was bad your rating will be a 3 |
KruszerMar 5, 2017 3:45 PM
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
Pyravia said: That's a bit too confusing for little me. I like using decimals so I don't get the same all the time. Also, the emotional impact can't be used for all anime. Thanks though! Sure it can, if a show doesn't have it, you just answer, no, and it doesn't get a point for that field. |
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97" |
| Set systems always seemed flawed to me. Using OP's starting post-system with the example of Gag manga Biyori: Story: 0/10 - Basicly non-existend Art: 2/10 - Fairly basic Sound: 4/10 - Basic, but catchy OP Character: 1/10 - only a few returning characters, nearly no development Enjoyment 10/10 - Funniest show in ages Overall: 17/50 So a gag/comedy-anime show does what it's supposed to do: Being funny and entertaining the audiance, but is basically a 3/10 because it doesn't deliver in aspects that are nowhere relevant. I prefer just rating my enjoyment and maybe in some rare cases adding/removing some points, for being innovative, provoking, silly etc.pp. |
| Personal enjoyment. Does it make me feel like a kid again. Does it put me in deep thought about its themes and motifs. Does it apeal to me conceptually How badly do I want to own the Blu Ray, if not already owned Rewatch value |
  |
Pyravia said: Amazing anime doesn't need to have an "emotional" impact. Kino no Tabi didn't really get me "emotional," unless in complete awe over the masterpiece it is counts. Well, I guess we'll just have to disagree on that, Kino's Journey had plenty of emotional impact for me but wouldn't call it a masterpiece. I did give it a 9 though which isn't far off. |
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97" |
| I just pick a number based on the guidelines mal already set if its good 7 , etc :] |
 |
| This is literally like other threads. Anyway, rating one anime specifically is kind of silly, considering ratings are only there for the purpose of comparison. Just rate comparatively. |
| a very complex formula based on the objective plot and character of the anime |
 |
| Simple. Go to the series' page in MAL. Look for the score. Click 0. Then submit. It's not that hard. |
| I rate based off story & characters while taking my personal appeal, and enjoyment into account. Music, art, sound, etc. are extra points in my book. |
 |
| I rate very few anime. The ones I have rated I just look at 3 things: characters, plot and overall enjoyment. If there is a factor that blows me away that is not one of those 3 it will probably be factored into my rating. |
More topics from this board
» Which anime from your past is the hardest for you criticize?Rally- - 11 hours ago |
10 |
by Rally-
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Anime which you need to watch more than just anime to like?thewiru - Yesterday |
17 |
by dazedcowcow62
»»
17 minutes ago |
|
» are there anime fan in your classroom when you are a student?Ymir_The_Viking - Yesterday |
14 |
by Maou_heika
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Who's your favorite albino waifu?Catalano - Nov 3 |
27 |
by RainyEvenings
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
Sticky: » AWC 2025 Anime Watching Challenge - Sign-Up (Open Until December 10th) ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )AWC_mod - Jan 1 |
941 |
by Phedro
»»
29 minutes ago |