Seiken Densetsu: Legend of Mana - The Teardrop Crystal

I liked the story. Never imagined the end of it. Now i just want to play the videogame. i guess for what i have read in the coments they were specting more because they already have played it . But to me, not knowing the story from before i would recommend.

It has a unique story and designs. The main charcater is not like the one we have always seen in toher stories. I think the charcter was pretty naive but wait isnt that the way others typicaly do without consecuences

I think many will hate and just a few will like this.

Game-based productions aren't anything new. If they're any good, they can be like Fate/stay Night or Clannad; done poorly, well, there's no shortage of terrible Hollywood movies based on popular games, which should say something about Hollywood writing.

Here's a TL;DR: People who have played the game will appreciate the expanded backstory for the Jumi, but they may be put off by some plot decisions made by the writers. For those who have not, some elements will likely be a distraction from enjoying the series. As someone who has played and enjoyed the original game, I don't regret watching this, but I do hesitate to recommend ... it.

Visually, I'm of the opinion that the staff did the best they could based on the concept art. A lot of then-Squaresoft's concept art put people (particularly boys) in some, shall we say, unique costumes, and Legend of Mana is no exception. Creating character designs that can be animated but at the same time be faithful to the original concept and game artwork is no easy task, and I think they did all right, though it may be off-putting for some people. I did like the designs for the all-new characters Sappho and Marina, and if Square Enix had any sense at all they would make them a part of Echoes and release Legend of Mana style title card art featuring them (I won't hold my breath). The animation itself "felt" a bit amateurish to me for some reason. The studios animating this aren't ones I'm super familiar with, so this isn't Kyoto or Shaft quality by any stretch, and it seems that they ran out of time to finish the final episode because there are still or blank frames used at key dramatic moments. Hopefully they'll be filled in for the Blu-ray release, even if they're probably quite graphic.

As someone who has played the original, I enjoyed the recreated environments and the nod to the world creation system, but to be honest the stuff about artifacts creating places lost to time probably would have been a lot better had there been a fair bit of context from this era of Mana games.

In terms of performance and direction, again, I think the cast and director did a pretty good job. They managed to cast Kaori Nazuka with her massive vocal range for Pearl and Saori Hayami for Serafina, and while I have no idea who did the vocal direction, they clearly know what they're doing. Hayami also sang the opening and closing credits songs, the ending being a lovely Japanese version of the Song of Mana from the original game. And while the fantastic Yoko Shimomura wrote the soundtrack for both the original game (which is rearranged for the anime) and some additional tracks, she didn't write the opener, which is a bit of a shame. The intro's all right, it makes full use of Hayami's vocal talents, but it's not something exceptional, I skipped it after the first time just like any other intro.

That brings me to the more controversial bits, which is the story. The anime's plot hews closely to the events and dialogue in the game, with a couple of key distinctions. First and most important, the Jumi backstory is greatly expanded, so the new content involving Sappho and Esmeralda is well worth it for fans of the game. Second, unlike the game where you're compelled to pick the boy or the girl (now officially named Shiloh and Serafina), both player characters are part of the story. The anime progresses as though Shiloh is the player character and Serafina is a unique NPC, and there are some decisions made in the story specifically to include Serafina in some significant fashion that will be off-putting to some viewers who have played the original game. I'm honestly of two minds about this. On the one hand, having Shiloh and Serafina both involved can be amazing if written well. Serafina's character arc incorporates things that are already firmly established in the game's story, even in the Jumi arc itself. And yet, there's a simplistic feel to it, the plot twists felt like they were straight out of a 1980s Saturday morning kids' cartoon (think DC superhero movie but dumbed down), and the justification was 2 very brief glimpses into Serafina's past in the final episode that didn't really convince me. I think this could have been 2 episodes longer: 1 episode to delve into Serafina's past, and 1 more episode or a 1-hour finale because the final episode felt like a rush job other than the still frames. I think the idea itself is interesting enough to warrant giving it the time it needs, but unfortunately, that's clearly not what happened. I also think that dropping the audience into the story without the larger context of a shattered world is doing the game's story a bit of a disservice. Marina was introduced as a new character and even got regularly shown in the credits, but in the show itself she is criminally underutilized.

I can understand doing a series on part of this game's story. It can be a jumping-off point to do the other 2 arcs and even the broader story involving the Mana Goddess, or spinoffs that explore some of the one-off stories in the game or even content involving other Mana games like Trials or Secret. Clearly someone at Square Enix thinks the Mana franchise is important enough to greenlight this. But here's the thing, animation is expensive, and it wasn't important enough to Square Enix to invest in a quality production so other shows in the Mana world can happen-- if this show doesn't sell, sponsors will be more reluctant to invest in the franchise. It's a good effort, but I fear this might be the last production in the Mana world at a time when fantasy anime is a dime a dozen.

Legend of Mana is an amazing video game. However it is also a very unconventional game, where instead of following a linear story, it consists of multiple unrelated side quests that you complete in a mostly non-linear order. Eventually some of these side quests start to form into three distinct branches: the Jumi arc, the Faerie arc and the Dragon arc, and these three arcs form the core of the game's story.

When the anime was announced I couldn't help but wonder, how on earth are they going to turn such a non-linear game into an anime? I love Legend of Mana's story for its non-linearity ... and seeing how everything eventually connects to each other, so turning it into an anime with a linear story would completely remove a huge part of what made the game so special for me.

Not only that, but anime and video games are very different mediums, and even for a linear video game story, adapting it into an anime is extremely difficult. If you simply adapt a video game directly to anime you are going to end up with a complete mess, a good adaptation of a video game needs to take as many liberties as possible to fit into the different medium. The solution the anime's staff came up with was to only adapt the Jumi storyline (hence the subtitle The Teardrop Crystal) and ignore every quest that's not directly related to it. Cutting out huge portions of a game's story and only adapting one arc of it sounds like it would be a bad idea, but as I said, it's important for video game adaptations to take as many liberties as possible, and maybe only adapting the Jumi arc is the best way to go if you want to turn Legend of Mana into an anime. If the anime staff knows what they're doing then this could turn into something really special.

The anime staff didn't know what they're doing.

Even after cutting out the vast majority of the game's story and characters, The Teardrop Crystal's attempt at turning this into a linear story is mediocre at best. I liked the story of the Jumi arc a lot in the game, but when you remove all the other smaller stories surrounding it and turn the Jumi arc into the central story of a 12 episode anime, it really starts to show its weakness. The beauty of Legend of Mana is how alive the world feels, no singular story is the main focus of the game and instead there is always something small going on for you to discover. And by only focusing on one of those stories, The Teardrop Crystal fails to make the world feel so alive. The magic that made Legend of Mana feel so special is completely gone, and in its place is simply another fantasy story that has nothing unique to offer.

Though one thing I will praise the anime for is that it does turn the game's two silent protagonists (Shiloh and Seraphina) into actual characters, and has quite a lot of anime original scenes to give the main characters some backstory and development. In the game you select one of two different protagonists at the start, and the one you didn't choose simply won't exist in the story, so the anime actually having both characters in the story interacting with each other is a nice addition I wasn't expecting. They could've done it the easy way and simply had Shiloh as the only protagonist, but they did some pretty interesting things with the anime original scenes involving Seraphina (especially at the end of the series) and it helps the anime stand out on its own a little bit compared to the original game.

I do honestly feel my score might be a little harsh because it's not like The Teardrop Crystal is straight up bad, if you know nothing about the original game then you might enjoy this anime a lot more than I did, but I simply don't think it's worth watching when the game exists and is so much better in almost every regard (the one point I will give the anime over the game is Shiloh's and Seraphina's character arcs). The Teardrop Crystal takes a really interesting and unique game, but doesn't really try to do anything with the game's interesting and unique aspects when adapting it into a different medium. And that really makes me wonder, out of every possible game Square has ever made, why on earth did they choose to adapt Legend of Mana? There's so many other games in Square's huge library that would've been much easier to adapt, but instead they chose to adapt Legend of Mana. It's such a bizarre choice that you'd think they must have some kind of master plan for turning the game into an anime, but they didn't. I really can't help but wonder how this project was ever even greenlit.

But if anything at all about Legend of Mana sounds interesting to you, the original game was remastered in 2021 for PC, PS4 and Nintendo Switch, and I highly recommend you give that a try. It's a very unconventional game and its mechanics might take some time to get used to, but it is a very special game and I promise you it's much more worth your time than this anime.

Though one last point I think is worth noting is that the anime doesn't cover the actual ending of the game, which makes me believe the anime staff also has plans to eventually adapt the Faerie and Dragon arcs too. And I think there's some potential in the idea of adapting all three arcs as separate seasons of anime, but with the way the Jumi arc turned out here, I am not looking forward to seeing how they're going to handle the other two arcs.