I must be very late to the party but planning to ready some of Osamu Dazai's books. I figured you would know about it, is it ok to read No Longer Human first?
Hi Zerg, Fullmetal here it's been a long time. Would be nice to talk soon a lot has changed.
Also wanted to ask if you are familiar with the films of Kenji Mizoguchi. I think they might fit your taste/preferences well, Ugetsu (1953) in particular.
I've got absolutely no clue if you will ever read this and let's be honest I'm like seven years late to the party but I don't think that you can judge a music video by the standards of a TV-Show or even feature length movie. I mean, you do realize how dumb it is to say that "The story of the music video is bad and thus it is the worst thing ever". Firstly, it is a music video and even if you don't like the music, it is still at least fine. Secondly, the story did everything it needed to do and it using it's medium to give itself some emotional weight can be called cheap but the reality is, that it worked for a lot of people. You can't expect a great story from a music video, which on the basis of it's medium can only deliver it's story through music and visuals (I know that there are like five sentences spoken at the beginning and end but let's be honest that doesn't matter). Apart from that, the story, while simplistic also is better then the arguably low standard of "music video story-telling" so you would need to call out every single video of it's kind, that also tries to have a story.
Here's a better Shelter Review, one written with an actual modicum of understanding: 2000+ people are wrong for giving you a helpful, and if you want people to stop commenting on things, go edit it and ditch the second-rate, pretentious pseudo-academic jargon. You can still keep the tone, but it's the hackneyed attempt at sounding smart that gets to people.
I am someone who rates anime rather a high score. I was checking my animelist and noticed if im correct, Shelter being the only anime i gave a lower score than its average score. I wanted to know what others think about this anime and decided to look at the reviews and i came upon yours.
Your point is that the story is bad because the main character is a pretty girl? We cant sympathy with the character because no one else is pretty? Is this the reason you didnt like the anime and over 2000 people agreed with you or i couldnt understand it because of the many difficult words you used?
came from shelter review, don't wanna hate or anything, I'm just wondering why the hell did you need to spend so much time to write a massive review with such verbose and language that's difficult to understand. Having large vocabulary doesn't make you smart my dude.
All Comments (2226) Comments
Also wanted to ask if you are familiar with the films of Kenji Mizoguchi. I think they might fit your taste/preferences well, Ugetsu (1953) in particular.
Your point is that the story is bad because the main character is a pretty girl? We cant sympathy with the character because no one else is pretty? Is this the reason you didnt like the anime and over 2000 people agreed with you or i couldnt understand it because of the many difficult words you used?
Thought people moved on from that.