Yami no Koe
Voices in the Dark

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

"Worth finishing up but don't expect anything much"

This being my first Junji Itou manga, his artwork drew me in because it was either more Western or it had a more conservative action POV panel style than most mangas I'm used to.

It's also the first horror comic I really tried following through and finishing but most of that is due to the blessings of the internet making these types of works easier to find and finish.

This newness is probably what convinced me to rate the art this good and yet be more critical of the manga's story even if it was already touted as a set ... of short stories.

The art first off doesn't appeal to me. It's not scary and it makes these stories feel more like a children's folktale and it doesn't feel like the artist is interested so much in the horror as much as telling a cautionary fictional urban legend.

It's worth mentioning this bit because the plot highly relies on this art style and it's not a case where I'm saying this so that readers might know how the art looked to me as much as it is a warning to people planning to read this to avoid digging on if the artwork doesn't work for them because the rest of the quality of this manga highly relies on the artwork keeping you anticipated for the next page.

This is why even if the artwork didn't work for me I rate it a 9 over the story's 6 because this is the type of manga where the art elevates the interest of the story to the point that the story only works because the art is there and while an art change in my opinion could help boost the quality of this manga, I cannot deny that this specific style gives the manga a special essence that makes it memorable by virtue of being rarely done this way as an overall package.

How the essence stacks up though I have no other similar horror mangas to compare to but this is the core of why I finished this manga. The art is just eye catching enough that even if it doesn't appeal to me, it makes me want to see the whole thing through.

On the flip side though, I can almost guarantee that this is among the more mediocre horror mangas out there even without viewing anything else. The reason I say this is because the theme of the stories attempt to evoke mystery at the end but unfortunately it not only does an abrupt job of doing this but it has a bad habit of mixing the climax with the conclusion.

To expand on this flaw, the plots are so rushed that if you were more engaged with the story unlike me, you'd probably be surprised that at certain points in a story, it was extended when it could have ended and then vice versa, you'd have stories where you're surprised it ended at the point it ended.

This normally would be an issue of lowering the story's rating if not for the fact that the stories are actually interesting. Right off the bat if your experience of Asian horror stories involve more mainstream things like The Ring for movies or Fatal Frame for videogames, you'd at least recognized that all of the short stories here are far far more original, morally superior in terms of a folk tale warning and finally much much more satisfying to consume as far as general storytelling is concerned.

This doesn't mean much though when it's still not scary just like those two examples and yet it's genre and design is supposed to be horror. Compound that with the rushed conclusions then it's really more of an ambitious but poorly done set of short horror stories with good intentions.

But...again this is where the artwork and the plot hugs each other so well that despite these shortcomings, it's worth picking up and had I found this and read it from a tankobon or comic book instead of on my PC, I'd have rated it higher.

It's just the type of guilty pleasure comic that works well alongside a set of weekly American superhero comics that I couldn't afford/be interested in investing in but when judged relative to the type of quantity and information available on the internet (even if one were to assume there was no piracy/online uploading and it's just relative to other mangas being sold online) it just doesn't retain it's quality very well because of the lack of the portable feel mixed with the fact that you could have been better off checking something other than this instead and all the uniqueness of the plot and the art melding together...all it did was just crash you down to a disappointing and unanswered fictional mystery that neither horrified nor made a mark on your soul because of the lack of a certain quality of conclusion, climax or completion to the tales contained inside.

8.5/10
Pretty good collection, though I still hate Ito for Glyceride. I stand with his editor, no doubt.

1. *The Dark Drinks Blood*:
6/10
Fine, at best. The story starts off by introducing its protagonist as insecure and recovering from a bad relationship. It could have gone in a better direction if Ito decided to explore those feelings with horror elements but the story is quick to dismiss that premise and instead introduces a largely unimpressive concept, reducing the opening premise to a mere segue. That’s where the story starts going downhill, the ‘antagonist’ is not at all interesting and you guess the mystery very early on leaving ... you with nothing to hold on to. Though this short is never terrible, it’s just hugely boring and mediocre, maybe others might like it better than I did.
Sadly, this is one of the rare Junji Ito stories where the art failed to impress me, something which stories with far worse plot-lines still managed to do.

2. *Ghosts of Golden Time*:
8/10
This one works surprisingly well to be honest. It has a good horror concept and a great villainous duo, together with great art and nice atmosphere.
All aspects are well done and even the ending, which left me cold immediately after the story, has grown on me since.

3. *Roar of Ages*:
5/10
Another Ito story which ends up being disappointing wholly because it does not build upon it’s premise well enough. I feel that a good percentage of Ito’s average stories can be elevated to great ones if he learns to tell apart which premise will work better as a 10-15 page mood piece and which one deserves to be developed up to a minimum 25-30 page length, this one clearly falls in the later category.

4. *Secret of the Haunted Mansion*:
7.5/10
This story is where readers first meet Souichi, who is also a part of several other subsequent short stories and overall it’s not that bad. The story starts off as an atmospheric piece and is elevated by the night setting but then quickly moves it’s focus away from the atmosphere and to the creepily drawn eccentric villains, something which I’m not usually very fond of. But here Souichi and his son are done well enough to make that gimmick work.

5. *Glyceride*:
8.5/10
It is believed, where I live, that all things and people have God residing in them. Today I think that God in me died.
DO NOT LET MY RATING CONVINCE YOU TO READ THIS STORY.
Absolutely Revolting, Repulsive and Sickening, this Ito short is a proof that editors should include a readers’ warning for shit like this.
A decent story and mystery with the Ito’s utterly abhorrent, loathsome and detestable visual imagination brought to life (regrettably) by his undeniable skill when it comes to art.
The only reason I am rating this shit this high is because it delivers upon what readers expect from a horror manga, shit that’s so terrifying and disgusting that you have to look at it with your hand covering most of your eye lest you see any more of those drawings than the bare minimum required to get over with the story.

6. *The Earthbound*:
9/10
This short’s central theme is a spoiler so I won’t mention it but I must say that this is one of the Ito stories which is very strong at the end too. The atmosphere, art, mystery and all are undeniably good but the twist at the end elevates the story to another level, great for a change.

7. *Dead Man Calling*:
7/10
The second story in this collection to contrive horror from guilt and it does a fairly good job at it too. Great sense of mystery throughout the story but again the end left me cold, for a different reason tho, it fails at thematic conclusion rather than with the explanation of the supernatural phenomenon at hand, as with most Ito stories.
This one too is strongest in the beginning and middle.

I seem to be making a habit of marking down highly rated authors lately. I loved Uzumaki for its weirdness, and just about tolerated Gyo (maybe have to do a review of that in the near future), but Voices in the Dark didn't really do it for me, for all of Glyceride's gross-out factor.

Art 6/10
Was fairly torn on whether to rate this a six or a seven tbh. I both love and hate Junji Ito's signature style at this point. I like how it's very realistic, but at the same time, if you've seen one Ito work, you've seen literally all of them bar the ... monsters. The characters all make the same expressions and their mannerisms feel like they were almost traced from another Ito work. The environments are good enough, but there are definitely other authors out there with more striking art styles at this point. The monster stuff, like the bat-thing in the first chapter, have the stand-out page turns that Ito is known for, and the art is, as usual, consistently good there.

Story 5/10
This is an anthology, so somewhat hard to rate, but overall the stories are decently constructed, but feel very 'on the nose' for the most part. One chapter is dedicated entirely to an homage to one of his other works, so it's basically pure fanservice for those characters. Otherwise, in terms of themes, it's strictly by-the-book, with characters stumbling upon urban legend style mysteries and such. Something horrible/mysterious happens, usually with someone looking crazy, and we end on the main character either living on ominously, or (more rarely) implied death. Classic Ito short story material. It's not bad, but story-wise, it's not good either tbh.

Characters 4/10
Okay, unpopular opinion time. I've always hated the way Junji Ito writes his characters. They're bland shells, open stand-ins for the audience and their loved ones, with little to make any of them unique. They really start to blend together if you read his works back-to-back, and their samey facial expressions from story to story really start to piss me off. Junji Ito is obviously quite gifted at art, but his human characters are completely stagnant, both in terms of design, and in terms of writing. Their lines are often stilted, and nobody is particularly distinct across stories. I get that this is because they're meant to be blank slate characters for Japanese readers to project their own loved ones onto (this scary stuff could happen to you!) but as a non-Japanese reader, it falls completely flat. As a lapsed reader of Steven King, I find this writing device works poorly on me in regards to American works, too, so maybe it just isn't for me.

Enjoyment 5/10
Gotta say, for a horror manga, next to nothing got to me in this work. There's maybe one panel in the first story, and not one of the 'shock' page turners, just a vaguely creepy look on a guy. Otherwise, Glyceride is gross-out material, and nothing else was notably scary. Ghosts of Golden Time is an absolute mess of a story, and the fact that it got past the concept stage honestly amazes me. One of the worst Ito stories I've ever seen. This was, in all, an okay bunch of 'urban legend' horror stories. I hate to say it, but it felt more like something Junji Ito put out to make a chunk of pocket change. Deeeefinitely not his best work, by a long shot.

Overall 6/10
If Ito's work usually scares you, this might scare you. If it doesn't usually scare you, this definitely won't, and you'll probably want the half hour you spend reading it back. That's a pretty narrow niche.

Yami no Koe is a goru manga collection by renowned author and artist Junji Ito. Known for his gruesome and psychological horror with a career that spans many years. The first collection I read by him was Mimi's Ghost Stories, known in romanised Japanese as Mimi no Kaiden. I wasn't too keen on the story itself and so was hesitant to go into this collection. However, after hearing great things from my friend on the story Glyceride from my friend and finding it was present in this collection, I decided to throw caution to the wind.

This collection is hard to review. The stories are disjointed ... and only join together in their collection of strange artwork and horror themes. Demons, ghosts, criminals, and disconcerting plots are found throughout this story. Each story has its good points, and others weaken in comparison to others. Each story alone is a four or five stars rated story but together, I almost rated it three and a half stars. Stories such as Earthbound don't correlate and pale in comparison to stories such as Secret of the Haunted Mansion which then pales in comparison to others. It's the only issue I find with collections such as this - within Mimi no Kaiden, it was a snapshot of the same girl's life so it was less comparable.

I enjoyed this, I truly enjoyed this. However, I didn't enjoy it as much as I would have liked. A collection like this would have done better with stories at least connected, for instance, paranormal stories in one collection. The horror level for each story would be the same, rather than one being scarier for the content than others. Mentioned before, Earthbound itself felt more like science fiction or crime rather than horror of some form despite the existence of the paranormal.

With qualms out of the way, however, this is a strong collection, despite the disjointed feeling. Ito proves himself in this collection to have a talent of mastering horror from the paranormal to the confusing, hairraising and stomach churning. The artwork is stunning throughout, and I even flinched back from the manga a few times upon turning the page. His artwork in this collection once more proves his skills at not only writing a horrifying image but his ability to draw something that makes readers flinch or nervously bite their lips. A talent that not all artists and authors of the same piece can manage, it's something to truly be cherished, and this collection only allows his skills to shine.

Yami no Koe is a set of short stories or one-shots. It's a bit difficult to score as a whole since each one left different impressions with me. I suppose it all was good. I enjoyed reading some of these well enough.

The best thing about this was the art. There's a definite unsettling style that Ito has that pairs so nicely with the stories he's conveying to a visual medium here. But, my main issues with this whole thing comes down to a couple specific stories. There was one in particular that felt grotesque for the sake of being grotesque without having much of a ... story to really back it for me.

Overall, I'd say that if you're looking for some short horror stories, this is worth looking at. But, if you're squeamish at all, be aware it can get a bit, not gory but... There's a gross factor to some scenes.

Not exactly Ito's strongest output, but not without merit. While the anthology consisting of 7 short stories does feature some of the author's best work, it's not the go-to volume to get acquainted with him. The main issue I had is not, that the stories were bad, but that compared to other Ito's work the shock and horror factor was at a much smaller rate in this book.

The volume starts with "Blood Slurping Darkness", which as the title suggests is an alternative spin on vampirism. While the ideas Ito has are interesting and there is a twisted touch of romance to the story, it's not ... exactly the most terrifying story Ito put out. This is followed by "The Ghost of Golden Time", which is quite frankly one of his weakest stories I read/seen adapted; bland villain idea, forced conflict and a main character, who just happens to have the right supernatural ability to explain to the reader what's happening for some reason. Luckily this is the lowest point the volume reaches. "Roar of Ages" as story #3 is titled brings back Ito's ability to take long existing horror concepts and twist them in a way, that feels fresh. While the writing definetly is in the right place, Ito's intention seems off, as the story seems to play more with the emotion of sympathy than with fear. "Secret of the Haunted Mansion" is another story, that plays with my horror-fan expectation, but doesn't quite satisfy it. To be fair, the build-up is great, but the pay off is basically (if I may allow myself a bit of a indirect spoiler) mostly just fan service for the Ito fan and probably a mess to the outside-manga-reader. Story #5 "Glyceride" is one of Ito's most memorable stories. Partwise for the broken-home setting, but mostly for the creative and wonderfully explicit portrayal of the effects puberty has on the human's body. "Earthbound" is similair in nature to story #3 in that it's more of a mix of supernatural with drama and mystery than being a horror story. Once again, interesting concept, but not exactly packing much of a horror-punch. The book concludes with "Dead Man Calling", which I liked for its ambiguity and some of its art, unfortunately it's once again not much of a shocker.

So to summarize; it was a fun read and a competent addition to Ito's vast collection of horror stories, but as far as horror goes, it does lack some big guns. I do recommend it to those, who are already Ito fans,as for those who aren't: try Uzumaki or Fragments of Horror first and if you liked either of those, here's a bonus.

This review has been structurally a bit different from my other reviews, though I'm sure most readers won't catch up on that. The reason behind it, is that this was a 20 minute slap-together for Goodreads, that I wrote spontaneously, since the site immediately gives you the text box after setting a novel as finished and I felt like writing at the moment. In order to compensate for the different structure, here's the run-through of different categories I otherwise cover:

Story (☆):
This category, I covered relatively well in my original review, so read above if you for some reason haven't yet.

Art (☆☆☆):
I guess this one is a no-brainer to everyone familiar with Ito's art. The man is a master of turning ink lines into horrific and unsettling imagery. Though I must admit, that I almost felt compelled to take a star away. As mentioned the book lacks some big schockers. Most of the stories are lacking in visual horror. Exception is the gruesome "Glyceride". "Secret of the Haunted Mansion" also has some fascinating visuals, but those are mostly staples in Ito's artistry and therefore only have a limited impact.

Characters (☆):
It's a horror anthology, therefore characters play a limited role and only serve as the devices to make you relate to the horror of the situation. None are particularly well characterized, but they don't really need to be. I guess, you can alway be a monster-fanboy and critique the creativity of the villains, those are however a mixed bag. On one side you have the acne-ridden weird kid in story #5, which had a great backstory and intriguing excentricites and on the other you have the completely unfunny comedy duo in story #2 with their unappealing character design and bland super powers.

Rating system:

As seen above, I use a star system (symbols I have stolen from Yu-Gi-Oh!'s entries here on MAL) to rate the series/movies in terms of the significant categories, which can indicate its quality. Those ratings do affect the final score I give the series/movie, but I do not use a strict mathematical method to assign the final score. Ultimately I weigh the final ratings by considering the stars given. I do not consider the categories to be equivalent and value a good story and characters over good art or a cathcy soundtrack. As far as the stars given go, I use a four stage scale:
(-) - bad, a series/movie is terrible in this category
(☆) - okay, it's fine, tolerable, but likely nothing special
(☆☆) - good, it's good, but may have flaws or isn't quite among the best I've seen in the category
(☆☆☆) - great, the best rating I can give, when it's truely remarkable in the category

Final score: 6/10

well that was good collection not the best that made by the author but still good tho , im huge ito junji fan so i know other ones better than this like tomie , and if you coming here you to be ready for the depression and darkness and facing the weirdest things you can find regardless the art is so dope i love it , what bothered me here that some stories has an open ending and that was kinda sucks in the other hand all the stories were interesting enough to puch me to reach the end

I enjoyed this, I truly ... enjoyed this. However, I didn't enjoy it as much as I would have liked. A collection like this would have done better with stories at least connected, for instance, paranormal stories in one collection. The horror level for each story would be the same, rather than one being scarier for the content than others. Mentioned before,Earthbound itself felt more like science fiction or crime rather than horror of some form despite the existence of the paranormal.