| They are ranging from 7 to 10. Most of them are either 8 or 9. |
 |
| yes all my favourites are 10/10. I have 22 10/10's so it isn't hard to put 10 of them in my favs. |
   Has a 8.60 mean score Akasaka > Other Mangakas  |
| 10 is the score I give to anime I consider my favorites so yes. Though I do have given lower scores to some of my favorites sequels. |
 |
| It should be rated 10, since it's an Favorite Anime... 10 can only be given to an Anime Series that is considered a "MASTERPIECE" |
| If everyone had their favourites as 10s, the top favourite and top scored animes would be the same, but that's not the case so no, they aren't. |
 |
| I don't have that many 10s so I have some 9s in my favorite I had an 8 for a while. But I only gave I think 6 or 7 series a 10 Vivy might be my next 10 I am really enjoying that anime. |
| My top 8 are all 10's and the last 2 are 9's. |
 |
|
| No. Actually, animes that I gave 7/8 will end up higher than the ones I gave 10. My favorites are based on my enjoyment ONLY, while my scores are based on more things. |
 |
| Yes, my 10s are only reserved for favorites. |
* |
| No, I haven't rated any of my anime and there is only one manga I rated a 10. |
 |
| I haven't scored anything 10 yet... So my favourite doesn't contain any 10... |
 |
| no, mostly 9/10 i'm too lazy to sort things out, especially the 10s |
 |
| That's a no. My favourites are based on how much I'm entertained while watching the shows and also how they resonated with me. I have some favourites that are 7's because critically speaking, they have flaws and I acknowledge that. Still doesn't stop me from loving them though. |
| I put my favourite anime from the previous decade 2010s in my favourites. And my favourite from last year 2020, both are 9/10s. I haven't placed my two 10/10s in my favourites, since they're extremely subjective. |
 |
| No 3 of them are 10s and the rest are 9 (30 character limit) |
| Usually highest rating correlates with favorites but not the other way, all of my 10's and high ratings I love but not all of my favorites are high rated. |
| I only have 4 10's, 2 animes and 2 mangas I even have 2 8's in my favorites That's becouse i'm too strict giving my 10's, but not giving my favorites |
| Nah they are mostly 9 and only one 10 in my favourites. |
| lmao no. Slightly unrelated but I remember coming across a dumbass who says "the correct rating system is anything above a 5 is above average to masterpiece, and below is subpar to appalling. Any interpretation of a rating system is only for schizos, autists..." Imagine how retarded. No, interpretations for a rating system is probably more normal than a rigid arbitrary rule that you want it be imposed upon. If you value the good more, make your system lower. If you want to make it clear how bad certain things are, make it higher. Of course there's a degree of agreeability to this. Make it either too high or too low devalues pretty much everything. For instance, there are people who mostly give out 1s and rarely anything above a 6. By then an 8 and a 9 don't make that whole lot of differences while a slightly bad show and an absolutely disgusting piece of garbage both receive a 1. Anyway, the reason why I'm saying all this is because a lot of people can't seem to understand why anything from a 7 and above is already my favorite. And that's just how I rate it. |
| . . . |
| All my favorites are 10/10. If they make it to my favorites then It meets my highest expectations leading me to give it the highest score. |
 |
Preachee said: lmao no. Slightly unrelated but I remember coming across a dumbass who says "the correct rating system is anything above a 5 is above average to masterpiece, and below is subpar to appalling. Any interpretation of a rating system is only for schizos, autists..." Imagine how retarded. No, interpretations for a rating system is probably more normal than a rigid arbitrary rule that you want it be imposed upon. If you value the good more, make your system lower. If you want to make it clear how bad certain things are, make it higher. Of course there's a degree of agreeability to this. Make it either too high or too low devalues pretty much everything. For instance, there are people who mostly give out 1s and rarely anything above a 6. By then an 8 and a 9 don't make that whole lot of differences while a slightly bad show and an absolutely disgusting piece of garbage both receive a 1. Anyway, the reason why I'm saying all this is because a lot of people can't seem to understand why anything from a 7 and above is already my favorite. And that's just how I rate it. That's not how maths work tho. 1+1+1 = 3, not 0.5+0.5+0.5= 3 I mean I understand where people who rate 3= average are coming from... but from a mathematical pov he's not wrong. And on a site that aggregates ratings, obviously snowflakes hijacking the rating system to use a snowflake scale are fudging up the final scores. |
Prophetess of the Golden Era  |
| Now that this has revived, I gotta say that my favs are no longer 10s, I have some 9s and left out some 10s at the same time because I enjoyed them more, but I don't feel that they are perfect either |
  ππ¦π°π±π’π« π±π¬ ππ«π¦πͺπ’ π’π‘π°! |
| Nah they aren't. ................ |
 |
Ghemotoc said: Preachee said: lmao no. Slightly unrelated but I remember coming across a dumbass who says "the correct rating system is anything above a 5 is above average to masterpiece, and below is subpar to appalling. Any interpretation of a rating system is only for schizos, autists..." Imagine how retarded. No, interpretations for a rating system is probably more normal than a rigid arbitrary rule that you want it be imposed upon. If you value the good more, make your system lower. If you want to make it clear how bad certain things are, make it higher. Of course there's a degree of agreeability to this. Make it either too high or too low devalues pretty much everything. For instance, there are people who mostly give out 1s and rarely anything above a 6. By then an 8 and a 9 don't make that whole lot of differences while a slightly bad show and an absolutely disgusting piece of garbage both receive a 1. Anyway, the reason why I'm saying all this is because a lot of people can't seem to understand why anything from a 7 and above is already my favorite. And that's just how I rate it. That's not how maths work tho. 1+1+1 = 3, not 0.5+0.5+0.5= 3 I mean I understand where people who rate 3= average are coming from... but from a mathematical pov he's not wrong. And on a site that aggregates ratings, obviously snowflakes hijacking the rating system to use a snowflake scale are fudging up the final scores. 3 as average is already too low for my liking, but not that I'm vehemently against or anything. Which I know doesn't sound reasonable. I think there are few reasons I said what I said. Firstly I have no care about average user score for any show. I realize how incongruent this might seem, because an 8-rated show is more convincing to check out than a 6-rated show. That's generally how it is. But on the whole, if you use the 3-7 as average kind of rating system, I'd argue that it wouldn't affect the average score as much as you think. There are stats on one website that tracks MAL scores, and it shows that 7 is the most rated score. I do think it doesn't matter if you rate a 3 as average. Nothing about rating system is really a trend I think. So if it doesn't affect anything and only shows how the dude rates stuffs, then no prob? I mean it sounds fine to me. Of course as I said, there's a degree of acceptability to this. Making a system too imbalanced is inexplicably annoying. But whatever, I've come to not care. Second reason is I just don't like being objectively correct about a rating system? There's not much to be reasoned. Not that I can't take it when people want it the other way, but the dude I came across demeaned anyone who interprets a rating system differently. Whether this matter is subjective or not is up to debate, but no need to wage a war (which I will gladly partake if happens). I'm sure I wouldn't have a problem if he brought it up the way you did. edit: shit I think I misread your post, but anyway my point still stands |
PreacheeJun 3, 2021 7:42 AM
| . . . |
| There are two types of 10s for me: - The first type is one that actually has almost no flaws and actually is a 10 out of 10 For example, Attack on Titan, Code Geass, Vinland Saga - The second type is when I absolutely loved watching it to the point where I gave it a 10 For example, No Game No Life, Death Note, Jujutsu Kaisen 6/10 of my favourites are 10s, half of them are because I'm bias |
     |
| Nope. They are mostly 9. -30characterlimit- |
 |
| regarding anime yes all my favorites are 10s and the only 10s regarding manga no i think the only 10s are kagerou daze and tsubasa and the rest are 9s |
 |
| Nope, because, even though it will forever be my favorite anime, I can't bring myself to give a 10 to GuP because there are some things that happen that are poorly written and could've been handled way better in many easy ways. The others are 10, though. |
  ββββββββββββγ΅γγ΅γγβββββββββββ βββββββββββγ΅γγ΅γγββββββββββββ βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ |
| Yes My favourite are all 10s. Then my second wave of favourites are all 9s, then the next wave of favourites are all 8s... |
krukrooo said: At the moment, not really. Couldn't give NHK ni Youkoso! a perfect score. I gave it, even with the design problems |
  |
| My top 5 is all 10s. I have 20 animes in my fav list, there's 7s, 8 and 9s but only the ones which marked me are 10s. |
|
| No, my favourites are the shows that have caught my attention recently and the ones I want to promote to other people; ie "look this is good, check out the page & maybe give it a go". So the scores vary, but they are all usually 8 or above, something i found very good or better. I can't count the number of series I've found looking through other peoples' favourites, so i try and change it up so I can advertise/recommend a bunch of different shows that I'm into, and these change over time as I constantly watch more anime. There's a couple of shows that i do keep in my favourites, Gintama and Nichijou, i can't recommend them strongly enough. |
 |
| Nah it may be my favorite but doesn't mean it was a complete masterpiece lol |
 |
| yes of course, it doesnt make sense if you give a show less than a 10 and put it in your favourite, but i think sequals are excluded |
 |
More topics from this board
» Anime Dopplegangersslimeco - 41 minutes ago |
4 |
by SoumyaUkil73
»»
34 seconds ago |
|
» Are otaku like a third gender?thewiru - 44 minutes ago |
3 |
by RainyEvenings
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Has using MAL made you enjoy anime less?Dragevard - 8 hours ago |
17 |
by Ricchan__
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
» Will only watching anime will make your taste in anime worse?thewiru - 4 hours ago |
12 |
by Sensual_Yuri_69
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Best anime of 2025?RealClutch - Oct 6 |
29 |
by thewiru
»»
25 minutes ago |