Attack on Titan
BlakexEkalb said: deg said: Animation Directors are actually Animation Supervisors they correct the drawings and animation to be consistent looking but ye too many of them means there is bad production schedule and too many of them means there are varying levels of expertise so ye inconsistency like off model drawings are expected if that happens I haven’t seen the episode yet (sadly), but I’ve seen images of the beast Titan.... what do you think of it lmao i actually like the 3DCG parts since im use to watching modern mecha anime that is full of 3DCG mecha lol at least 3DCG is always consistent with on model character designs and they do not need ADs or Animation Directors lol |
deg said: 34 key animators on episode 1 for an average animation or movement is kinda bad though dude and expect that to rise even more in later episodes when there is more crunch time They could use a 100 just as long the quality doesn't dip too much from the first episode I am good. |
keragamming said: deg said: 34 key animators on episode 1 for an average animation or movement is kinda bad though dude and expect that to rise even more in later episodes when there is more crunch time They could use a 100 just as long the quality doesn't dip too much from the first episode I am good. welp thats bad for the budget management but ye i know your exaggerating there and i get your point that you only care about the final result aka the end justify the means |
VanishingKira said: https://twitter.com/exaenae/status/1335620365335339009 Right off the bat, 7 animation directors, 34 key animators and three production assistants. Absolutely outlandish. Blou correct them I don't want to tweet much about AOT but... This is NHK bullshit credits. They group all the animation directors together and don't separate the 2nd KA. The credits for the first episode are rather normal. 3 ADs, one assistant, 2 FX ADs, 18 key animators. No disaster yet. https://twitter.com/Bloodyredstar/status/1335645906289504257 |
| I actually think that the episode looked better than the PV. If the animation stays consistent thorough the season I’ll be happy. |
cAbaddon said: It absolutely does, the PV is barely animated. People saying PV looked better is madness.I actually think that the episode looked better than the PV. If the animation stays consistent thorough the season I’ll be happy. |
 |
at best they are equal but not better, like there is barely any difference in composite which is subjective take on which one is better (i prefer the glossy look of the PV) while the character movements on the actual show is average to below average for a 1 cour show and ye the actual show do CGI titans that a lot criticize but i like that at least |
| I became too attatched to this thread, and I don't want it to be forgotten. Please guys, keep discussing about anything, maybe about the possibility of a movie sequel |
 |
HistleChif said: deg said: at best they are equal but not better, like there is barely any difference in composite which is subjective take on which one is better (i prefer the glossy look of the PV) while the character movements on the actual show is average to below average for a 1 cour show and ye the actual show do CGI titans that a lot criticize but i like that at least Another thing were panicking about was the pacing, thankfully those concerns have been put to rest. its been ages since i read the manga and i do not re-read manga but i think they added a lot of additional filler content in this episode to achieve that 2 chapter pacing so to me they could do at least 2.5 to 3 chapters per episode if they can but ye thats just me really liking a fast pace story telling |
| I need to watch the episode! Maybe later! |
| All weebs creatures of the galaxy, hear this message. Those of you who listen will not be struck by western animation. You will no longer know hunger, nor pain. Your Anime have come to lead you now. Our strength shall serve as a luminous sun toward which all intelligence may blossom. And the impervious shelter beneath which you will prosper. However, for those who refuse our offer and cling to their western animation ways… For you, there will be great wrath. |
| By the way, considering we already have a BluRay preorder, it's technically not possible for the sequel (actual finale) to be in episode format. Season 3 Bluray came with both Part 1 and 2, so they can't exactly create a part 2 for Final Season. Specially with Leakers insisting the Final Season is indeed the last Season. In another words, it's almost certain we will have a movie right? |
|
| this thread is pretty much ded now |
 |
sammy69 said: this thread is pretty much ded now Just follow my posts, I was the one gave "heat" to this thread anyway. |
SirTristram said: The thread was the most fun when you didnt post any replies tbh XDsammy69 said: this thread is pretty much ded now Just follow my posts, I was the one gave "heat" to this thread anyway. |
Rdxrchi said: The thread was the most fun when you didnt post any replies tbh XD But... I was here all along? Maybe you are talking about my occasional hiatuses. I'll be completely gone in a few days, don't worry. |
Jockeys said: SirTristram said: But... I was here all along? Maybe you are talking about my occasional hiatuses. I'll be completely gone in a few days, don't worry. you are truly a detestable person, with a negativity and arrogance that make me believe that you are alone in the world. and if you are not, I'm sorry for those around you, I don't know how they can bear you chill this is just an anime no need for ad hominems or personal attacks |
SirTristram said: he alaways been thereRdxrchi said: The thread was the most fun when you didnt post any replies tbh XD But... I was here all along? Maybe you are talking about my occasional hiatuses. I'll be completely gone in a few days, don't worry. |
|
Jockeys said: not gonna lie but thats poetic as fucc😂SirTristram said: But... I was here all along? Maybe you are talking about my occasional hiatuses. I'll be completely gone in a few days, don't worry. you are truly a detestable person, with a negativity and arrogance that make me believe that you are alone in the world. and if you are not, I'm sorry for those around you, I don't know how they can bear you |
|
SirTristram said: yas u chad.............................sammy69 said: this thread is pretty much ded now Just follow my posts, I was the one gave "heat" to this thread anyway. |
|
| @sammy69 how does it feel to be the creator of this thread. |
| tbh i never thought this one is gonna have over 6000+ comments or even come close to 100.....man . at first i was like bruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh and now idk how i actually feel abt it .... |
|
sammy69 said: tho this thread was an entire battlefield itself i swear to god😂😂and idk how yall wrote so many paragraphs 😂😂tbh i never thought this one is gonna have over 6000+ comments or even come close to 100.....man . at first i was like bruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh and now idk how i actually feel abt it .... |
|
| I hope @Hinako49 still will post the Cao translations. I'm actually interested in his opinion after the first episode is reveal and if he is seeing mostly positive opinion of the first episode or not. |
| @Hinako49 I knew this would happen and this is plain wrong. He was a sweet guy who tried to reply everyone's questions even though he was extremely busy. He doesn't deserve this. I hope it won't get worse. |
Bababazooka69 said: can't help but there are people like sir tristam who could not even appriciate the efforts of the staff they made and tried to satisfy the viewers they are everywhere on social media :( Just fuck off if your standards are low and you want to ride MAPPA's dick. I wasn't ever an advocate for harassing staffs individually and I stated this many times. Being rightfully harsh on MAPPA on a forum is something else but harassing staff is something else. I bet you'll start harassing them as soon as this turns into 7DS despite speaking like this. I'll stay true to myself until the end at the very least. |
hinako49 said: As long as CGI was involved in the big picture, it was set in stone that the community would be divided. For some, even if Disney came to do animation for AoT, it would still be a downside. So don't feel bad for something you didn't do: you shared something that many people enjoyed reading, don't forget!keragamming said: I hope @Hinako49 still will post the Cao translations. I'm actually interested in his opinion after the first episode is reveal and if he is seeing mostly positive opinion of the first episode or not. i was thinking to post it yesterday but i don't wanna stir more fights in this forum lol 😂 so many people shit posting on mappa now i already saw comments calling Cao a liar cause ep 1 is nowhere close to an awesome animation that he said before tho it is just troll comments, i am uncomfortable about this because i feel like its my fault for moving all his posts here and earn him the unnecessary hate when the outcome doesn't satisfy some people 😞 |
 |
Bababazooka69 said: so you are saying "fuck pacing, fuck story, fuck characters, fuck writing i want 2d sakuga all over my screen for whole 16 episodes" just go and watch those MAD sakuga vids on loop then drop final season from your list already. Sure man, just put words on my mouth I've never said. This shows your inability to form an argument and why you think the way you think now. You can not think there can be a gray area, it's only absolutes for you. Let me tell you something; what you are talking about isn't something mutually exclusive. You can both get great 2D animation and great storytelling. You don't have to sacrifice one in order to make the other better. In fact, they are all connected and support each other. They won't be able to do justice to this story if this level of animaton keeps going, and you'll see it too. |
Bababazooka69 said: s3p2 had wonky animations at times and cgi colossal too yet its in top 10 cause of its story and characters. If this season has average animation throughout, it will be in top 10 why? cause of its story and characters. You are an anime only i assume so wait and watch S3P2 had wonky animation, this is completely wonky animation on it's own. There is a big difference. No one would dare to say anything bad to MAPPA if they were to at least reach S3P2 levels of animation with the schedules they had. They literally filled the show with CGI lmao, what are you talking about? This is only slightly better than OPM S2 to me and it might get worse. People would see it too if they were objective and not blinded by their love for the AoT. |
Bababazooka69 said: And this cgi is OBJECTIVELY a decent cgi not the best not the worst certainly better than colossal cgi. I would suggest you to watch episode again in 1080p if you think this cgi is bad like berserk bad. You are one of those guys who would say its cgi no matter its good or bad its still cgi like its some cursed technology anime has started to implemented it recently Dude, where the hell I said problem was the CGI? I've been telling the CGI is the only decent part of the episode, not great but not too bad. Everything else is the issue. You are speaking autonomously with all these memorized lines like a robot just to defend this. Anyway, let's not argue further. |
SirTristram said: i am genuinely curious to know what your other issues are....Bababazooka69 said: And this cgi is OBJECTIVELY a decent cgi not the best not the worst certainly better than colossal cgi. I would suggest you to watch episode again in 1080p if you think this cgi is bad like berserk bad. You are one of those guys who would say its cgi no matter its good or bad its still cgi like its some cursed technology anime has started to implemented it recently Dude, where the hell I said problem was the CGI? I've been telling the CGI is the only decent part of the episode, not great but not too bad. Everything else is the issue. You are speaking autonomously with all these memorized lines like a robot just to defend this. Anyway, let's not argue further. |
TweedleDane said: i am genuinely curious to know what your other issues are.... MironBiron nailed it, these are exactly my thoughts except for the fact I already accepted the CGI: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1880211&show=50#msg61324393 |
| i wonder how the aot fandom would be if i didnt create this thread |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Koito91 - Mar 28, 2021 |
693 |
by Dakidhellsing
»»
May 25, 3:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 31, 2021 |
818 |
by SaimonIdk
»»
May 21, 9:50 AM |
|
» The one thing I dont understand now is, why WIT censored so much the violence?MAQS - Dec 20, 2020 |
26 |
by SoughtLi
»»
Apr 28, 7:26 PM |
|
Poll: » If Eren was in avatar...TASM18 - Apr 17 |
18 |
by belugaanime
»»
Apr 19, 2:12 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 7, 2021 |
513 |
by JoestarEISH_020
»»
Apr 13, 8:01 AM |