| These 2 animes had great potentials but eventually mediocre. Eventually the Tokyo ghoul anime got even worse but Sao got a lot better in alicization. I have read the Tokyo ghoul manga and it was great. On the other hand for Sao's aincrad arc, I have read the progressive manga which I greatly enjoyed. So would you like these reboots if they are done? Edit: About Sao, I'm just talking about the anime adaptation of progressive as it expands on the story of aincrad and shows us the world building a lot better. I'm not a hater and I think my high enough rating for it confirms it. |
Biswa_29Dec 7, 2019 8:05 AM
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| Wait for reboot in 2040 or something |
MySweetLucifer said: I don't see how the Aincrad arc would need a reboot. I enjoyed that arc in the Anime quite a bit. The arc needs to be longer. The Sao world is still totally foreign to us. Lores and character developing moments are there in progressive considering floor takes up a volume. I would enjoy it being animated. Believe me, everyone would the new Kirito. 😂 |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| Tokyo Ghoul reboot could be done but under one condition. Yutaka Yamada is to take care of the soundtracks again. |
LuchseDec 7, 2019 8:39 AM
  “The most shameless thing in the world is political power that can be inherited regardless of ability or talent!” |
| whats wrong with SAO season 1? it was fine and it what made SAO popular in the first place |
| Once I see a good adaptation/reboot of the TG and TG:Re manga I'll be able to die happily |
 |
Nick-Knight said: >Implying that SAO S1 exists. Boi just don't. Bro, I'm talking about the progressive anime adaptation which is kind of a reboot and expands on the story a lot. |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| If they get reboots i will personally commit sodoku and you should too. Both are not good enough to deserve a reboot imo, i would maybe watch a TG one just cause it was the first mango i followed weekly. |
 |
| The problem with SAO for me is Kirito. He is just boring and his personality is being op. There is nothing good about Kirito. He is just super 1 sided. |
| Go check out my latest review: https://myanimelist.net/profile/YeeYeeAss/reviews |
YeeYeeAss said: The problem with SAO for me is Kirito. He is just boring and his personality is being op. There is nothing good about Kirito. He is just super 1 sided. His progressive counterpart is very different. They changed the characters a lot in the novels and manga. I mean there was one panel in the manga in which Kirito was thinking something very deeply while doing a quest with Asuna and a female npc. When she asked him, he replied "I'm thinking about whom to marry between the 2 of you". Asuna was like "wtf!" and I was going ROFL. 🤣🤣 |
Biswa_29Dec 9, 2019 5:07 AM
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| IMO SAO reboot is unnecessary but TG obviously need a good treatment. |
 |
| Sure, Sword Art Online deserves it. But a spin off would be better because that would be kinda going back in past to see the development. It's better to move forward but still a yes from me. As for tokyo ghoul the whole story was not for me. |
| Progressive is absolutely amazing, I’m loving the novels, I really want it to have an anime adaption. Considering Unital Ring is just started, to animate it is needed a lot of time, so Progressive could be the next part to have an anime adaptation in SAO franchise and it would be great! About Tokyo Ghoul, I’m not interested in, so I’ll be indifferent to an eventually remake/reboot. |
 |
HectorBlaze said: Progressive is absolutely amazing, I’m loving the novels, I really want it to have an anime adaption. Considering Unital Ring is just started, to animate it is needed a lot of time, so Progressive could be the next part to have an anime adaptation in SAO franchise and it would be great! About Tokyo Ghoul, I’m not interested in, so I’ll be indifferent to an eventually remake/reboot. Don't know, the alternative ggo is also there. It might get a new season. But I'll greatly prefer progressive over it. theDEMYSTIFier said: Don't care anything about SAO. But Tokyo Ghoul obviously requires a 'Brotherhood' treatment. Don't know it can grab an "absolute banger" opening like 'unravel', I wish. We all need another unravel. Probably that's the only good thing to come out of the anime |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| There's no way to really salvage SAO Season 1 without completely rewriting it and coming up with a new villain that doesn't feel cartoonishly evil but like an actual character. More worldbuilding and the likes would be welcome, but as long as it all goes to shit as spectacularly as it did in the current version it wouldn't make much difference to the overall quality of SAO S1. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
biswa290701 said: HectorBlaze said: Progressive is absolutely amazing, I’m loving the novels, I really want it to have an anime adaption. Considering Unital Ring is just started, to animate it is needed a lot of time, so Progressive could be the next part to have an anime adaptation in SAO franchise and it would be great! About Tokyo Ghoul, I’m not interested in, so I’ll be indifferent to an eventually remake/reboot. Don't know, the alternative ggo is also there. It might get a new season. But I'll greatly prefer progressive over it. Alternative is done by another studio, so it’s an independent project. I believe it’s not related to the other SAO series from A-1 Pictures’ point of view. |
|
| SAO is going to take a nap in the 2020s, is what I think. Tokyo Ghoul is maybe cursed and I don't think anybody's gonna approach it, let alone touch it, for a very, very long time. |
 |
biswa290701 said: YeeYeeAss said: The problem with SAO for me is Kirito. He is just boring and his personality is being op. There is nothing good about Kirito. He is just super 1 sided. His progressive counterpart is very different. They changed the characters a lot in the novels and manga. I mean there was one panel in the manga in which Kirito was thinking something very deeply while doing a quest with Asuna and a female npc. When she asked him, he replied "I'm thinking about whom to marry between the 2 of you". Asuna was like "wtf!" and I was going ROFL. 🤣🤣 So, Kirito is still building a harem and wanting to fuck a npc. Progress indeed. |
| Go check out my latest review: https://myanimelist.net/profile/YeeYeeAss/reviews |
| idk about sao since the problem of the anime is the characters, rebooting would be just a complete diferent series, but tg is a must, all the seasons were terrible, one of the examples of horrible adaptation I have in mind always |
blumenbaltDec 10, 2019 4:02 AM
YeeYeeAss said: biswa290701 said: His progressive counterpart is very different. They changed the characters a lot in the novels and manga. I mean there was one panel in the manga in which Kirito was thinking something very deeply while doing a quest with Asuna and a female npc. When she asked him, he replied "I'm thinking about whom to marry between the 2 of you". Asuna was like "wtf!" and I was going ROFL. 🤣🤣 So, Kirito is still building a harem and wanting to fuck a npc. Progress indeed. It's not a harem. He also has a lot of male friends who gets a lot of screentime. That panel was just for comedy and still Asuna does not like him. So he doesn't have any girl who likes him yet. Kirito is shown to be a fun loving dork and always ruining serious moments. The manga does have a lot of fan service though, which is not in the novel. I would like to read it but I'm more of a manga person. That's why I want an anime. The first and second boss fights are more epic than anything Sao season 1 produced. Moreover, everyone has been given an interesting twist in personality. Asuna is shown as a clean freak and can do anything to get a bath done. Whenever someone addresses them as a couple they will shout out that they aren't. Agil has a lot of screentime. There's a new character, Argo who always teases kirito as she is the info broker. Most importantly she doesn't jump on kirito's dick and sees him as a little brother. Not to mention the development of each character so far has been great. |
Biswa_29Dec 10, 2019 4:11 AM
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
blumenbalt said: idk about sao since the problem of the anime is the characters, rebooting would be just a complete diferent series, but tg is a must, all the season were terrible one of the examples of horrible adaptation I have in mind always Terrible examples you say. I believe it was the most terrible adaptation of something ever done. |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| I don't GAF about TG but we need SAO Progressive to be adapted ASAP. It's so much more interesting...AND FUNNY. I want to see the 'Kiriemon' episode. xD |
  |
Chiibi said: I don't GAF about TG but we need SAO Progressive to be adapted ASAP. It's so much more interesting...AND FUNNY. I want to see the 'Kiriemon' episode. xD Definitely man. They made Kirito so interesting and likeable. Even his haters will love him if they watch progressive. Still kazuma will stay my favourite anime protagonist though. |
Biswa_29Dec 10, 2019 9:29 AM
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| I've been wanting a SAO Aincrad reboot for forever now. The fact that the arc was so short made zero sense, and with the mediocre writing and character development, I only thirsted for a better version of it. I don't care if they nearly completely changed what happens in the reboot (if it were to be made), but if they can just go back to their roots and actually make the Aincrad arc at least a full 24 episode season, instead of the perplexing 14 in the original Aincrad arc, and improve the writing and character development, it could possibly be one of my favorite shows of all time. An Aincrad reboot has unbelievable potential if executed correctly. |
| professional women respecter |
yxckson said: I've been wanting a SAO Aincrad reboot for forever now. The fact that the arc was so short made zero sense, and with the mediocre writing and character development, I only thirsted for a better version of it. I don't care if they nearly completely changed what happens in the reboot (if it were to be made), but if they can just go back to their roots and actually make the Aincrad arc at least a full 24 episode season, instead of the perplexing 14 in the original Aincrad arc, and improve the writing and character development, it could possibly be one of my favorite shows of all time. An Aincrad reboot has unbelievable potential if executed correctly. The progressive is basically what you want. Given that unital ring has just started, it'll quite some time before season 4 releases. So they might actually release it in the next couple of years. It'll not be a 24 ep anime. Given that the novel takes up a volume for each floor, it's easily gonna be a 300 episode anime with many seasons. |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
More topics from this board
» Why male characters tend to have more interesting personalities than female characters?Alpha_1_Zero - 14 minutes ago |
2 |
by deg
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » do you consider hate on your favorites an attack on you personally?deg - Apr 23 |
40 |
by deg
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» ❄️ Anime Winter 2024 Male Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 4 5 )ISeeLifePeople - Apr 14 |
228 |
by KeyiOs
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » whats the severity of social stigma for anime and its fans now a days?deg - 23 minutes ago |
2 |
by deg
»»
11 minutes ago |
|
» Advertise your favorite animeTannenbusch - 53 minutes ago |
3 |
by NubFix
»»
15 minutes ago |