New
Jul 12, 2013 7:31 PM
#352
Shocked said: Fai said: Raven-san said: Anyone has the PV for this? EDIT: Is this it? No that's HF opening for vita version of realta nua the pv shown today comes out tomorrow. Kami_no_Kage said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Also, people that look through this thread and see all the rather passionate hatred for Heaven's Feel. In my experience with the VN community, both this route and UBW are about equally liked. However, both routes are very different from one another as to how they handle Shirou's ideal. So, yeah, both routes are pretty divisive in opinion. Which is too bad, as I feel that the three routes of F/SN are meant to be taken as a whole. This is why I kind of wish that the entirety of the story would be adapted, especially UBW which was extremely neutered in it's adaptation. Basically this. Either adopt all routes or none at all. Now, hold on. I sure as hell didn't say that. Yeah, I'd rather have an adaptation for all of the routes but, if it has to be, I'm fine with it just being HF. But, well, let's see what they announce when the time comes. Sorry, I am not fine with UBW route and its fanbase being majorly shafted in favor of HF. I am not sure why HF fanbase wants it to be solely HF adaptation either considering HF alone would be impossible to comprehend. Let me just say this: if there is just a HF adaptation made, and people who haven't played the game complain they can't understand it: abandon them. This adaptation is for US! The VN is right there, they have their chance! And also Beasts Lair, if they want to have a week long argument about whether prana transfer through lip contact is feasible and not poisonous. That's still favoritism towards HF over UBW by both typemoon and ufotable and that is unacceptable. Why should HF get a full adaptation and UBW - not? I personally love UBW way more, with HF being second and fate - last, so the idea that HF gets a full on anime series adaptation, while all UBW has is freaking 1 hour "movie" made with flash that completely butchers the story material is pretty much a stab in the heart. Not to mention it makes no sense business-wise at all - Rin and Saber are far, far, FAR more popular than Sakura. Any high quality tv show ALSO has to have hooks to get new audience - that's why F/0 sold and worked so well for ufotable. Also you have to ensure that the new audience UNDERSTANDS ON WHAT THE HELL is happening, so it simply does NOT make any sense to adapt just HF in terms of business appeal. Either way one looks - it does not make sense to JUST adapt HF. Stuff has to sell and alienating half the fanbase while taking away the chance to attract NEW fanbase just makes no sense. That's like if Type Moon suddenly remade FSN VN and decided "oh well, we will just do HF and fate routes this time oh and at the same time we will cut out every second line of dialogue from both~" I don't think anyone is arguing against you that a full revamp and adaptation of Fate/Stay Night would be bad or unwanted. I'm assuming that anyone who's excited for Heaven's Feel would want -at least- Heaven's Feel to be animated, and a revamp of the first two routes would just be extra awesome. It's not "let's have an animated HF for only us HF fans and have everyone else piss off," it's "let's have an animated HF at least, and grab anything else that we can get our hands on." Best case scenario, we get the whole thing. Worst case scenario, at least have an animated HF. Something like that. Yeah, this pretty much how I see it. Of course I'd rather have it all, but I'll take what I can get. About Rin, I've noticed some comments about how HF focuses on Sakura and not on the two more popular characters Rin and Saber. The thing is that Rin, at least, gets a lot of focus in Heaven's Feel and her characterization there is actually a large part of why she's my favorite Fate/ character. It would be nice if Saber could still somehow receive her development in some way, if this is just a Heaven's Feel adaptation. Her and Gil were very important in /Zero, so the fact that they have very much reduced roles in HF could kind of hurt things. How could they incorporate them? No idea. I'm glad that isn't my problem |
"Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
Jul 12, 2013 7:33 PM
#353
insan3soldiern said: Shocked said: Fai said: Raven-san said: Anyone has the PV for this? EDIT: Is this it? No that's HF opening for vita version of realta nua the pv shown today comes out tomorrow. Kami_no_Kage said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Also, people that look through this thread and see all the rather passionate hatred for Heaven's Feel. In my experience with the VN community, both this route and UBW are about equally liked. However, both routes are very different from one another as to how they handle Shirou's ideal. So, yeah, both routes are pretty divisive in opinion. Which is too bad, as I feel that the three routes of F/SN are meant to be taken as a whole. This is why I kind of wish that the entirety of the story would be adapted, especially UBW which was extremely neutered in it's adaptation. Basically this. Either adopt all routes or none at all. Now, hold on. I sure as hell didn't say that. Yeah, I'd rather have an adaptation for all of the routes but, if it has to be, I'm fine with it just being HF. But, well, let's see what they announce when the time comes. Sorry, I am not fine with UBW route and its fanbase being majorly shafted in favor of HF. I am not sure why HF fanbase wants it to be solely HF adaptation either considering HF alone would be impossible to comprehend. Let me just say this: if there is just a HF adaptation made, and people who haven't played the game complain they can't understand it: abandon them. This adaptation is for US! The VN is right there, they have their chance! And also Beasts Lair, if they want to have a week long argument about whether prana transfer through lip contact is feasible and not poisonous. That's still favoritism towards HF over UBW by both typemoon and ufotable and that is unacceptable. Why should HF get a full adaptation and UBW - not? I personally love UBW way more, with HF being second and fate - last, so the idea that HF gets a full on anime series adaptation, while all UBW has is freaking 1 hour "movie" made with flash that completely butchers the story material is pretty much a stab in the heart. Not to mention it makes no sense business-wise at all - Rin and Saber are far, far, FAR more popular than Sakura. Any high quality tv show ALSO has to have hooks to get new audience - that's why F/0 sold and worked so well for ufotable. Also you have to ensure that the new audience UNDERSTANDS ON WHAT THE HELL is happening, so it simply does NOT make any sense to adapt just HF in terms of business appeal. Either way one looks - it does not make sense to JUST adapt HF. Stuff has to sell and alienating half the fanbase while taking away the chance to attract NEW fanbase just makes no sense. That's like if Type Moon suddenly remade FSN VN and decided "oh well, we will just do HF and fate routes this time oh and at the same time we will cut out every second line of dialogue from both~" I don't think anyone is arguing against you that a full revamp and adaptation of Fate/Stay Night would be bad or unwanted. I'm assuming that anyone who's excited for Heaven's Feel would want -at least- Heaven's Feel to be animated, and a revamp of the first two routes would just be extra awesome. It's not "let's have an animated HF for only us HF fans and have everyone else piss off," it's "let's have an animated HF at least, and grab anything else that we can get our hands on." Best case scenario, we get the whole thing. Worst case scenario, at least have an animated HF. Something like that. Yeah, this pretty much how I see it. Of course I'd rather have it all, but I'll take what I can get. About Rin, I've noticed some comments about how HF focuses on Sakura and not on the two more popular characters Rin and Saber. The thing is that Rin, at least, gets a lot of focus in Heaven's Feel and her characterization there is actually a large part of why she's my favorite Fate/ character. It would be nice if Saber could still somehow receive her development in some way, if this is just a Heaven's Feel adaptation. Her and Gil were very important in /Zero, so the fact that they have very much reduced roles in HF could kind of hurt things. How could they incorporate them? No idea. I'm glad that isn't my problem Saber role was different, but still big. |
Jul 12, 2013 7:39 PM
#354
I've only watched Fate/Stay Night and haven't watched Fate/Zero...If I watch this new one before watching Fate/Zero, will I understand it or should I watch Fate/Zero first? |
Jul 12, 2013 7:46 PM
#355
i can die peacefully now.... |
Jul 12, 2013 7:49 PM
#356
Tennouji_ said: How you remake what doesn't exist?and the remake of Tsukihime anime. |
Jul 12, 2013 7:51 PM
#357
krisalice85 said: I've only watched Fate/Stay Night and haven't watched Fate/Zero...If I watch this new one before watching Fate/Zero, will I understand it or should I watch Fate/Zero first? Fate/zero is the prequel of FSN so you don't need to watch Fate/Zero to understand the new one. However, the art direction will be different since this new project will be done by Ufotable, which did Fate/Zero, instead of Studio Deen. So I guess there is value from watching Fate/Zero for FSN fans, besides that it is a great anime. |
Jul 12, 2013 7:57 PM
#358
Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel Please be Heaven's Feel |
"I left everything I own in One Piece" ~ Gol D. Roger |
Jul 12, 2013 7:57 PM
#359
Jul 12, 2013 7:59 PM
#360
Tennouji_ said: SaberRitsu said: Tennouji_ said: How you remake what doesn't exist?and the remake of Tsukihime anime. Oh my bad. I regret using the word "remake". lol. Tsukihime needs some justice done for the VN. |
"I left everything I own in One Piece" ~ Gol D. Roger |
Jul 12, 2013 8:00 PM
#361
Meruru_Arls said: Tennouji_ said: SaberRitsu said: Tennouji_ said: How you remake what doesn't exist?and the remake of Tsukihime anime. Oh my bad. I regret using the word "remake". lol. Tsukihime needs some justice done for the VN. I don't think a Tsukihime remake (yes, I fucking said it) will happen until the visual novel is remade. |
"Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
Jul 12, 2013 8:44 PM
#362
are they going to animate the ture end in realtaa nua patch where saber and emiya meets in avalon? i would die to see that |
Jul 12, 2013 8:46 PM
#363
Jul 12, 2013 8:49 PM
#364
Shih said: Heaven's Feel now?! same here. |
Jul 12, 2013 8:59 PM
#365
Holy shit! Yes! I really hope it's Heaven's Feel because it's my favorite route, but I wouldn't be mad if they decided to remake Fate or UBW. If they do adapt HF though...I just hope they somehow condense those kitchen scenes so they can take less time. I mean for the love of god there are just SO MANY of them. Only real problem I had with the route was the pacing of the latter days where they do practically nothing before the climax, so I hope ufotable does something about that. I'm actually cheering for them to improve upon the original source rather than do a straight up adaptation. I wouldn't complain if they somehow extended Gil's role in the story and implemented Sparks Liner High into the fight against Dark Saber. I mean, it could be done if they made Shirou have the capacity to do a few more projections than he did in the VN. Rider can still seriously injure Saber with her noble phantasm, but not enough to take her down, which would leave the job to Shirou to finish her off, in which case they could adapt the Sparks Liner High fight without Shirou dieing in the end. Unfortunately, it would be impossible to adapt Mind of Steel unless they do an ova or something. |
Jul 12, 2013 9:10 PM
#367
A good choice by them. Fans have been demanding it so might as well make it now instead of using it as back up cash in the future. |
Jul 12, 2013 9:11 PM
#368
012yArthur0 said: insan3soldiern said: Shocked said: Fai said: Raven-san said: Anyone has the PV for this? EDIT: Is this it? No that's HF opening for vita version of realta nua the pv shown today comes out tomorrow. Kami_no_Kage said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Fai said: insan3soldiern said: Also, people that look through this thread and see all the rather passionate hatred for Heaven's Feel. In my experience with the VN community, both this route and UBW are about equally liked. However, both routes are very different from one another as to how they handle Shirou's ideal. So, yeah, both routes are pretty divisive in opinion. Which is too bad, as I feel that the three routes of F/SN are meant to be taken as a whole. This is why I kind of wish that the entirety of the story would be adapted, especially UBW which was extremely neutered in it's adaptation. Basically this. Either adopt all routes or none at all. Now, hold on. I sure as hell didn't say that. Yeah, I'd rather have an adaptation for all of the routes but, if it has to be, I'm fine with it just being HF. But, well, let's see what they announce when the time comes. Sorry, I am not fine with UBW route and its fanbase being majorly shafted in favor of HF. I am not sure why HF fanbase wants it to be solely HF adaptation either considering HF alone would be impossible to comprehend. Let me just say this: if there is just a HF adaptation made, and people who haven't played the game complain they can't understand it: abandon them. This adaptation is for US! The VN is right there, they have their chance! And also Beasts Lair, if they want to have a week long argument about whether prana transfer through lip contact is feasible and not poisonous. That's still favoritism towards HF over UBW by both typemoon and ufotable and that is unacceptable. Why should HF get a full adaptation and UBW - not? I personally love UBW way more, with HF being second and fate - last, so the idea that HF gets a full on anime series adaptation, while all UBW has is freaking 1 hour "movie" made with flash that completely butchers the story material is pretty much a stab in the heart. Not to mention it makes no sense business-wise at all - Rin and Saber are far, far, FAR more popular than Sakura. Any high quality tv show ALSO has to have hooks to get new audience - that's why F/0 sold and worked so well for ufotable. Also you have to ensure that the new audience UNDERSTANDS ON WHAT THE HELL is happening, so it simply does NOT make any sense to adapt just HF in terms of business appeal. Either way one looks - it does not make sense to JUST adapt HF. Stuff has to sell and alienating half the fanbase while taking away the chance to attract NEW fanbase just makes no sense. That's like if Type Moon suddenly remade FSN VN and decided "oh well, we will just do HF and fate routes this time oh and at the same time we will cut out every second line of dialogue from both~" I don't think anyone is arguing against you that a full revamp and adaptation of Fate/Stay Night would be bad or unwanted. I'm assuming that anyone who's excited for Heaven's Feel would want -at least- Heaven's Feel to be animated, and a revamp of the first two routes would just be extra awesome. It's not "let's have an animated HF for only us HF fans and have everyone else piss off," it's "let's have an animated HF at least, and grab anything else that we can get our hands on." Best case scenario, we get the whole thing. Worst case scenario, at least have an animated HF. Something like that. Yeah, this pretty much how I see it. Of course I'd rather have it all, but I'll take what I can get. About Rin, I've noticed some comments about how HF focuses on Sakura and not on the two more popular characters Rin and Saber. The thing is that Rin, at least, gets a lot of focus in Heaven's Feel and her characterization there is actually a large part of why she's my favorite Fate/ character. It would be nice if Saber could still somehow receive her development in some way, if this is just a Heaven's Feel adaptation. Her and Gil were very important in /Zero, so the fact that they have very much reduced roles in HF could kind of hurt things. How could they incorporate them? No idea. I'm glad that isn't my problem Saber role was different, but still big. Maybe they'll give Gil a bigger role or even switch him with Lancer (he helps them out for awhile doesn't he?). He had such a big role in F/Z it would be disappointing if they kill him off at the very beginning of the anime. Also, Rin does have a huge part in HF. Especially her edgey relationship with Sakura. But yeah Saber.. |
bobynJul 12, 2013 9:16 PM
Jul 12, 2013 9:19 PM
#369
Dreams DO come true! |
Jul 12, 2013 10:16 PM
#373
Does this means that again shirou will be the main character again.I would like that.Loved fate stay night more than fate zero. |
Jul 12, 2013 10:21 PM
#375
ijen said: Does this means that again shirou will be the main character again.I would like that.Loved fate stay night more than fate zero. Yeah, Shirou is the protagonist of all of Fate/stay night. Aside from the prologue and epilogue, that is. Hopefully Ufotable can handle his characterization in a better way, one of the things Deen kind of failed at was giving context to his actions. |
"Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
Jul 12, 2013 10:30 PM
#376
FSN + ufotable sounds amazing, but don't let it be a movie, please. A 30+ episode Heaven's Feel Adaption and I can die a happy death. |
Jul 12, 2013 10:34 PM
#377
*prays for a HF adaption*!! Honestly though, I'm just excited for another Fate x ufotable collaboration...I don't cate if it's a remake or not...but, hey, making a Heaven's Feel adaption wouldn't be so bad at all... ;P |
☆★☆ |
Jul 12, 2013 11:19 PM
#378
Saber <3 |
Jul 12, 2013 11:35 PM
#380
Really looking forward to this, especially if Heavens Feel! |
Jul 12, 2013 11:55 PM
#381
No thanks. Why not Fate/Prototype?!! WHY NOT SOMETHING NEW |
Jul 13, 2013 12:22 AM
#382
Fate/Prototype or Fate/Hollow Ataraxia would be nice after the adaptation for Heaven's Feel. |
Jul 13, 2013 1:04 AM
#383
YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YESSSSSS! Wow I never actually thought I would see the day when this would happen, and with ufotable manning the helm I have high hopes that this is going to be fantastic. |
Harems don't exist in America. If one guy is constantly surrounded by beautiful girls, then he's probably the gay friend. |
Jul 13, 2013 1:44 AM
#384
Beaver897 said: Exactly.Progeusz said: I developed a habit of using Fateverse to avoid confusion, many Tsukihime fans like butting in to discussions which are clearly about Fate. Can't really blame them, Fate is definitely more popular and gets much more talk, it's only natural to remind people of other part of Nasuverse, especially since it's older one. But yeah, no reason to not use Nasuverse here. Can Shiki kill Servants? Shocked said: nothing956 said: Shocked said: Progeusz said: I developed a habit of using Fateverse to avoid confusion, many Tsukihime fans like butting in to discussions which are clearly about Fate. Can't really blame them, Fate is definitely more popular and gets much more talk, it's only natural to remind people of other part of Nasuverse, especially since it's older one. But yeah, no reason to not use Nasuverse here. 'Cause we need to let people know we exist too I think you should have used a picture of Satsuki. She goes well with the line "'Cause we need to let people know we exist too." I forgot about Satsuki. And she's my secondary main in Melty Blood. Wow. |
ProgeuszJul 13, 2013 1:49 AM
Jul 13, 2013 2:30 AM
#386
More saber is always a good news, at lesst i hope she appears |
Jul 13, 2013 2:35 AM
#387
Pretty cool, wil watch for sure. |
The only thing you can rely on is that you can't rely on anything. |
Jul 13, 2013 2:50 AM
#388
So the dude who claimed its "heavens feel" on twitter took back his/her words and is saying that its not clear. CurrentUsername said: Any idea when we'll hear more news about this? PV on 13th, so within next 24 hours, |
Jul 13, 2013 3:14 AM
#389
At this point, I'm hoping they're making something completely new, new "route". |
Jul 13, 2013 3:24 AM
#390
Great. Leave it to ufotable to do a masterpiece adaption. Fuck DEEN. |
Jul 13, 2013 3:27 AM
#391
i hope this wont be a crappy version like the first one |
Jul 13, 2013 3:42 AM
#392
CurrentUsername said: It wouldn't be adaptation then...At this point, I'm hoping they're making something completely new, new "route". I'd love to see Ilya route but it's unrealistic. |
Jul 13, 2013 3:56 AM
#393
I'm curious. Did Studio Deen write the story of FSN? Were they responsible for the development of of the FSN characters? Were they instrumental in making the plot changes and truncations? Or did they just make the animation? So much Studio Deen hate is justified IF they wrote the story. Otherwise, it's lame to blame them for how FSN turned out (barring the 'quality' animation). |
TsukikageRanJul 13, 2013 4:01 AM
Jul 13, 2013 4:06 AM
#395
TsukikageRan said: They butchered the story.I'm curious. Did Studio Deen write the story of FSN? Were they responsible for the development of of the FSN characters? Were they instrumental in making the plot changes and truncations? Or did they just make the animation? So much Studio Deen hate is justified IF they wrote the story. Otherwise, it's lame to blame them for how FSN turned out (barring the 'quality' animation). |
Jul 13, 2013 4:09 AM
#396
They made a crappy anime. That's why. Ilya route is unlikely, that's if people wants to see a lolicon Shirou *laughs* (though she is technically older or the same age as him.) |
Jul 13, 2013 4:13 AM
#397
TsukikageRan said: I'm curious. Did Studio Deen write the story of FSN? Were they responsible for the development of of the FSN characters? Were they instrumental in making the plot changes and truncations? Or did they just make the animation? So much Studio Deen hate is justified IF they wrote the story. Otherwise, it's lame to blame them for how FSN turned out (barring the 'quality' animation). I understand how you feel but it's useless. People give Deen a hard time because they take on things that people really want to see and most studios don't even dare to take up. However the don't have the resources to fulfill the unrealistic expectations of the fanbase. The most complaints I hear about the Deen adaption is about the CG dragon, Shiros wrong characterization and merging the routes. The CG dragon complaint I find hilarious because it suggests that people thought that was more ridiclous that the actual event in the VN. Which can be surmised as "Saber, let me fill you with my mana!" On the whole I peg the anime adaption as decent. Even after reading the visual novel. |
Jul 13, 2013 4:15 AM
#398
I will watch, though I am a huge Rin fan and not really one of sakura. |
Jul 13, 2013 4:29 AM
#399
Venneria said: I will watch, though I am a huge Rin fan and not really one of sakura. Its okay, the best girl still remains the lead in HF route, even. Sakura, even in her own route is nothing more than a plot device. TsukikageRan said: I'm curious. Did Studio Deen write the story of FSN? Were they responsible for the development of of the FSN characters? Were they instrumental in making the plot changes and truncations? Or did they just make the animation? So much Studio Deen hate is justified IF they wrote the story. Otherwise, it's lame to blame them for how FSN turned out (barring the 'quality' animation). Considering they also butchered Umineko and Higurashi, i'd say its very safe to blame DEEN for it. |
Jul 13, 2013 4:35 AM
#400
Fai said: Considering they also butchered Umineko and Higurashi, i'd say its very safe to blame DEEN for it. Higurashi wasn't butchered and Umineko was unadaptable from the get go. Anyone who read Umineko should have known that. Also why all the hate on Sakura? Hell, shes the only one who's good in bed. |
AidanAK47Jul 13, 2013 4:39 AM
More topics from this board
» Video Game 'Tensui no Sakuna-hime' Gets TV Anime in 2024DatRandomDude - Mar 9 |
17 |
by Synrax
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» 'Kono Sekai wa Fukanzen Sugiru' Reveals Additional Cast, Theme SongsNioxys - Yesterday |
1 |
by Sleabedybarb
»»
54 minutes ago |
|
» 'Senpai wa Otokonoko' Announces Additional Staff, Theme SongsDatRandomDude - 2 hours ago |
0 |
by DatRandomDude
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» 'Mononoke: Karakasa' Reveals Supporting Cast, Theme Song, TrailerDatRandomDude - May 1 |
8 |
by DARM11
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» 'Kaijuu 8-gou' Unveils Supporting CastHyperion_PS - Yesterday |
2 |
by deg
»»
5 hours ago |