| Excellent seriously can't wait for it come on fall |
SimmianPrime said: It's not a typical shonen anime filler type arc thing. They completely changed the story and the characters eg. imagine instead of One Piece spoiler Well that would just be part of the anime story then. I couldn't care less about manga since I don't read it. |
 |
RyanSaotome said: So basically you admit its just the typical "Waaah why'd they make minor changes" whining manga nerds do right? Not that the anime itself is actually bad? The thing is, they're making an adaption. Thus, if they make huge changes from the original source material, I really doubt you can call it a good adaption. A good anime, maybe. A good adaption, not one bit. |
 |
yhunata said: RyanSaotome said: So basically you admit its just the typical "Waaah why'd they make minor changes" whining manga nerds do right? Not that the anime itself is actually bad? The thing is, they're making an adaption. Thus, if they make huge changes from the original source material, I really doubt you can call it a good adaption. A good anime, maybe. A good adaption, not one bit. K-On made huge changes from the original manga, but it far surpassed it. The problem with manga nerds is that they assume anything thats different is automatically bad... Its not. Others can write a better story than the original mangaka sometimes. |
|
RyanSaotome said: yhunata said: RyanSaotome said: So basically you admit its just the typical "Waaah why'd they make minor changes" whining manga nerds do right? Not that the anime itself is actually bad? The thing is, they're making an adaption. Thus, if they make huge changes from the original source material, I really doubt you can call it a good adaption. A good anime, maybe. A good adaption, not one bit. K-On made huge changes from the original manga, but it far surpassed it. The problem with manga nerds is that they assume anything thats different is automatically bad... Its not. Others can write a better story than the original mangaka sometimes. Did you..... even read what I said? I said it can be a good anime, but not a good adaption. I doubt anyone would want to watch an unfaithful adaption, of a fantasy-battle shonen, nonetheless. Besides, when you cram over 100 chapters into 25 episodes, just how much do you think they decided to skip? The story would be ruined. |
|
| Yay! Some good news. Hopefully more effort will be implied and I'm praying that they don't screw up any more than they have already. Otherwise I'll end up disappointed even further than I already am. I still don't get why they made such changes if they were gonna follow the manga up to Magnostadt (or possibly even further for future manga releases). I mean really?! A-1 are you trying to piss off fans? Whatever, now I feel like some information included in the adaption wasn't pointless. Like Judal listing the Kou Empire's 5 dungeon capturers or Yunan and Scheherazade in the ending sequence. >> Interested to see how A-1 is gonna fix stuff they screwed up. And here's to hopefully some better character development. |
 |
RyanSaotome said: Did you really just use K-ON as an example for a shounen manga/anime? yhunata said: RyanSaotome said: So basically you admit its just the typical "Waaah why'd they make minor changes" whining manga nerds do right? Not that the anime itself is actually bad? The thing is, they're making an adaption. Thus, if they make huge changes from the original source material, I really doubt you can call it a good adaption. A good anime, maybe. A good adaption, not one bit. K-On made huge changes from the original manga, but it far surpassed it. The problem with manga nerds is that they assume anything thats different is automatically bad... Its not. Others can write a better story than the original mangaka sometimes. =/ |
 |
| Lol WTF is going on, Im so dam confused , So its suddenly not ending but instead its gonna have a second season? Well ok then I think thats good news |
 |
| i hope they improve the fight scenes which have been average so far |
 |
| What are A1 even doing |
 Znips: When Shay is born she just crawls back in the womb to shitpost for another year |
Amaya-dono said: What are A1 even doing making money |
|
| What the fuck? What the motherfucking fuck of sorcery is this? Holy shit is this real? After what they did to the ending of season 1? After all of the criticism it received from that ridiculous bullshit animation A-1 did? This ain't even funny. Seriously, not only did they ruin the series but they will ruin it MORE. I don't even know how many times I said this in my whole life but once again, Fuck you A-1. |
-MgZ_ said: Fuck you A-1. B-but Space Brothers and AnoHana... |
-MgZ_ said: After all of the criticism it received from that ridiculous bullshit animation A-1 did? ] I'm sure they're really worried about what people say on a foreign website about their anime. People who don't even import it, mind you. |
|
Gash_V-D_Hetchum said: RyanSaotome said: -MgZ_ said: After all of the criticism it received from that ridiculous bullshit animation A-1 did? ] I'm sure they're really worried about what people say on a foreign website about their anime. People who don't even import it, mind you. It received criticism in moonland too. Maybe, but people still bought it and the manga sales increased significantly, so it did its job. Anime is a niche medium that only really needs the hardcore fans to support it to be successful, even if the rest complain. |
|
Shirube said: -MgZ_ said: Fuck you A-1. B-but Space Brothers and AnoHana... Then they made SAO and burned to shit. |
 |
Shirube said: -MgZ_ said: Fuck you A-1. B-but Space Brothers and AnoHana... AnoHana is before A-1 fucked up. They were decent before. Space Brothers doesn't need exceptional animation to be good, besides I don't even know if they are following the original material since I don't read it. RyanSaotome said: -MgZ_ said: After all of the criticism it received from that ridiculous bullshit animation A-1 did? ] I'm sure they're really worried about what people say on a foreign website about their anime. People who don't even import it, mind you. I don't even know if they care about any person's opinion at all. Magi's manga is popular, their just at it for the money. |
ihateeveryone said: Shirube said: -MgZ_ said: Fuck you A-1. B-but Space Brothers and AnoHana... Then they made SAO and burned to shit. Lol. Can't argue with that. |
| Wont watch this . Will probably pick up the manga and start from chapter 1 |
 |
-MgZ_ said: I don't even know if they care about any person's opinion at all. Magi's manga is popular, their just at it for the money. I'm sure they care more about that one random Japanese person whos bought every volume so far, the Sinbad and Alibaba body pillows and other misc merchandise more than the entirety of this website. At least people like that are helping to support the anime. |
|
-MgZ_ said: Shirube said: -MgZ_ said: Fuck you A-1. B-but Space Brothers and AnoHana... Space Brothers doesn't need exceptional animation to be good, besides I don't even know if they are following the original material since I don't read it. Yes, they're following the Space Brothers manga very closely. I'm pretty sure if they tried to change some things, they'd quickly find a way to fuck it up. |
 |
| Wow, I am legitimately upset about this. The pacing of the entire anime makes absolutely no sense now if they were probably planning a second season from the beginning. Sincerely wish they just slowed everything down and ended on Balbadd, considering the changes to the ending were made to be more "finale-ish". Less Alibaba assassination. Ugh. At least the Adventures of Sinbad is being serialized. I think. |
MeepyMar 31, 2013 8:47 AM
Avatar art by redjuice. Profile art by もひ @ pixiv. |
| lol.... I am surprised their doing a second season, I thought the Magi's BD+DVD sales plummeted to obscurity after the first two volumes (not to mention the original ending). Whatever the case I am not gonna get anywhere near this. |
[url=http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Num1dad_Asura] [/url] Click Here for Sig source |
Sophilia said: Meruru_Arls said: Your signature is entirely too large for this forums.RyanSaotome said: Well I don't give a crap about the manga, but the anime is a fun show and I want more Morgiana. Please stay away from my waifu. I think I'll let the mods make that decision, my amigo. lol. |
| "I left everything I own in One Piece" ~ Gol D. Roger |
| don't get how A-1 fucked up Magi when FT anime Followed the manga pretty well, i hope for a better adaption in fall hopefully not much rushing >.< |
| I actually enjoyed AnoHana, Space Brothers and SAO(go on, shoot me), so I haven't given up on A-1 completely. Despite that, I do agree with some of the hardcore purist fans of the manga, as I've read Magi's source material, too. They really went and fucked shit up with this adaptation, especially in the later half of this season... I was addicted to Magi's first few episodes, but once Alibaba started to fight Cassim things went downhill from there. I'm still putting this second season on my To Watch list, as I hope A-1 will wake up and animate this series properly considering the large amount of source material they'll have this fall. |
Ahmer said: don't get how A-1 fucked up Magi when FT anime Followed the manga pretty well, i hope for a better adaption in fall hopefully not much rushing >.< This is strange to me too they could have followed the manga perfectly and took a break after the Zagan arc without any changes the original plot. Oh well I'll still watch it I loved the anime even if it went its own way after Balbadd. |
"What has two arms, two legs, and is alive? Not your favorite character lol! xD" |
| Oh. My. Lord. I'm so EXCITED my hands are shaking~!! Bring it on, baby!! |
   |
tigeress02 said: I just noticed this was added to the database. I don't see any information on it online though (at least not in English). Sinbad no Bouken OMG OMG!! OVA of Adventures of Sinbad coming May 8, 2013 !! *o* Thanks tigeress02! |
| I see many people here blame A-1 for deciding to make a 2nd season for whatever reason. I just want to repeat what I said before: For adaptation work, the decision of whether there is a 2nd season almost always rests with the publisher, and in this case it is Shogakukan (which publishes the Weekly Shounen Sunday in which Magi is serialized). In fact, the editor of Magi from Shounen Sunday tweeted in the official Magi twitter that the decision to make a 2nd season was made quite recently ( https://twitter.com/project_magi/status/318280302558588929 ). This would explain why they had an anime original ending but yet at the end there is still a 2nd season. In another tweet, perhaps by some other person, it said that they shipped 10 million copies of the manga ( https://twitter.com/project_magi/status/318328247794425856 ). I can see this is more than sufficient reason to continue the anime. |
symbvMar 31, 2013 11:15 AM
| So MAL finally starts locking news threads that are only a few weeks old? I wonder where was the announcement of this change? Or we are seeing yet another case of changes made that impacted users but not communicated to them? I wonder how long people would put up with this. As much as I have a bunch of information to share about anime announced recently I cannot share it in news board, and the anime series is too disorganized and chaotic to share information except with people already interested in the particular series. |
mikado34 said: I don't know who made that entry (as I understand regular MAL member can also create an entry in MAL database). However, according to the official website ( http://www.project-magi.com/news/news_detail.html?p=1&id=17478 ) the serialization of "Sinbad no Bouken" is about the manga included in the BD/DVD vol.1 being serialized in Weekly Shounen Sunday starting from the May 08th issue. I do not see any news about it being made into OVA.tigeress02 said: I just noticed this was added to the database. I don't see any information on it online though (at least not in English). Sinbad no Bouken OMG OMG!! OVA of Adventures of Sinbad coming May 8, 2013 !! *o* Thanks tigeress02! |
| So MAL finally starts locking news threads that are only a few weeks old? I wonder where was the announcement of this change? Or we are seeing yet another case of changes made that impacted users but not communicated to them? I wonder how long people would put up with this. As much as I have a bunch of information to share about anime announced recently I cannot share it in news board, and the anime series is too disorganized and chaotic to share information except with people already interested in the particular series. |
| oh god! i just hope they make the animation consistent this time! it was really disappointing for the recent series. |
symbv said: I don't know who made that entry (as I understand regular MAL member can also create an entry in MAL database). However, according to the official website ( http://www.project-magi.com/news/news_detail.html?p=1&id=17478 ) the serialization of "Sinbad no Bouken" is about the manga included in the BD/DVD vol.1 being serialized in Weekly Shounen Sunday starting from the May 08th issue. I do not see any news about it being made into OVA. Ah I see, no OVA then. Well that explains a lot. But a MAGI spinoff with Sinbad no Bouken is very welcome, I'm glad they will go with the idea :D Eight Generals <3 |
| WTF I thought this was dead... |
| It was to be expected 8DDDD yay~~~ |
| If they were gonna do a second season why the hell did they burn through all of the manga and fuck it all up? They could have just done a proper adaptation and it woulda been awesome. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Great news! Looks like its time to start watching :D |
| I guess I will finish SO1 now... Even though people say the adaptation sucks. |
| This anime is only "bad" if you read the manga, otherwise I'm pretty sure most people like it, judging by the rating it has here. I thought it was pretty damn entertaining. Unless you're a manga stickler, give this a shot, don't listen to bitter reviewers. |
More topics from this board
» Manga 'Ikoku Nikki' Receives TV AnimeDatRandomDude - Today |
16 |
by Chouninatte
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» 'Mononoke: Karakasa' Reveals Supporting Cast, Theme Song, TrailerDatRandomDude - May 1 |
7 |
by Rhae
»»
6 hours ago |
|
» GoHands Produces Original TV Anime 'Momentary Lily' for Winter 2025DatRandomDude - Apr 25 |
22 |
by Kaikaidou
»»
8 hours ago |
|
» 'Kakuriyo no Yadomeshi' Gets Second Season in Fall 2025DatRandomDude - Apr 30 |
17 |
by RobertBobert
»»
10 hours ago |
|
» North American Anime & Manga Releases for JulyAiimee - Jul 6, 2022 |
7 |
by miipsy
»»
Yesterday, 3:43 PM |