Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »
Jun 25, 2012 8:02 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
443
Rider >>>>>>> Archer > Saber > Lancer > Berserker > Caster >>>>>> Assassin.

Rider in the first place by far since he is directly the embodiment of awesomeness, and Berserker suffered of little to no development, that's the reason he ranks 5th, and that in itself is one of the minor flaws this series has.
Jun 25, 2012 8:04 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
-Shuda- said:


While we're at it,

Other women, no loli or servant (Rin and Saber):

Natalia > Irisviel > Aoi > Maiya > Shirley > Sola


Natalia>Sola>Iri>Maiya>Shirley>Every loli>Aoi wheelchair version>>>>>>>>>>>Aoi
Jun 25, 2012 8:09 PM
Offline
Dec 2007
4845
ssjokg said:
-Shuda- said:


While we're at it,

Other women, no loli or servant (Rin and Saber):

Natalia > Irisviel > Aoi > Maiya > Shirley > Sola


Natalia>Sola>Iri>Maiya>Shirley>Every loli>Aoi wheelchair version>>>>>>>>>>>Aoi
Lol, I actually have to agree with you on the Aoi part. She actually seemed more "motherly" in her dreams than she truly was in the whole series.

Jun 25, 2012 10:57 PM
Offline
Feb 2012
12
Archer > Rider > Caster > Saber > Berserker > Lancer > Assasin

Kiritsugu > Kirei > Kariya = Waver > Ryuunosuke > Kayneth = Tokiomi
Jun 25, 2012 11:25 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
5252
Archer > Rider > Lancer > Saber> Caster > Assassin
Kirei > Kiritsugu > Kariya > Waver > Ryuunosuke > Tokiomi > Kayneth
Jun 26, 2012 4:39 PM

Offline
Jul 2009
384
Servant:

Rider
Archer(Gilgamesh)
Saber
Lancer
Berserker
Caster
Assassin

Master:

Kiritsugu
Kariya
Waver
Kirei
Tokiomi
Kayneth
Ryuunosuke
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 26, 2012 9:17 PM

Offline
Feb 2010
914
Servants:
[LN]
1. Archer (Gil)
2. Rider
3. Saber
4. Berserker
5. Lancer
6. Assassin
7. Caster

[Anime]
1. Archer (Gil)
2. Rider/Saber
3. Lancer
4. Berserker
5. Caster/Assassin

1st choice is obvious. I originally had Rider above Saber, but my attachment to Saber grew again after watching the anime. So I put them both on par with each other.

I switched Lancer and Berserker's spots after the anime too. The anime made Lancer more interesting than he seemed in the LN. But they're both pretty close.

I originally had Caster all the way down, but the anime has made him more flashy and interesting as a character for me. So I actually like him a little more than I originally did when reading the LN. Still, I can't forgive him for his despicable acts.

Assassin, on the other hand, was the least developed and interesting character. I was going to put Assassin below Caster after watching the anime, but I have to give props to Assassin for the nice little dance performance back in episode 2 xD



Masters:
[LN]
1. Waver
2. Kariya
3. Kiritsugu
4. Kirei
5. Kayneth
6. Tokiomi
7. Ryuunosuke

[Anime]
1. Waver
2. Kiritsugu/Kirei
3. Kariya
4. Kayneth/Tokiomi
5. Ryuunosuke

Don't feel like commenting much on the masters. Though I admit Kirei's laugh in the last episode was quite epic. Props to Kirei's seiyuu for doing an excellent job.



*Edit: Tbh I felt less for the masters than I did in the LN. But I guess it can't be helped since the anime cant flesh out the characters entirely.

Got tempted by Thess's comment to list favorite master/servant teams:
-Rider & Waver
-Saber & Irisviel
-Kirei & Gil

Will probably add more later if I can think of any additional ones.
sallym613Jun 30, 2012 12:29 PM
Jun 27, 2012 2:54 AM

Offline
Nov 2009
289
Servants:
LN
1. Rider
2. Saber
3. Berserker
4. Archer
5. Lancer
6. Caster
7. Assassin

Anime
1. Rider
2. Saber
3. Archer
4. Caster
5. Lancer
6. Berserker
7. Assassin

Masters:
LN
1. Kariya
2. Kirei
3. Kiritsugu
4. Waver
5. Ryuu
6. Kanyeth
7. Tokiomi

Anime
1. Kirei
2. Kiritsugu
3. Waver
4. Ryuu
5. Kariya (He's such a joke in the anime)
6. Kanyeth
7. Tokiomi
Jun 27, 2012 10:22 PM

Offline
Nov 2011
755
1. Archer - unmatchable swag. Arrogant as he may be, he demonstrates he, too, is honorable at times.
2. Rider - he's the perfect compromise between the arrogant Archer and idealistic Saber
3. Lancer - the match up between him and his master is just so unfortunate. It's hard not to feel sorry for him.
4. Caster - disagree with his morals you may, but he was looking for a good time, and his long lost love interest.
5. Saber - she's just...there.
6. Berserker - we never really got to know him.
7. Assassin - what did he do, again?
Jun 27, 2012 11:18 PM

Offline
Jul 2008
114
might as well join in now that i have finished Fate/Zero
Lancer>Saber=Archer>Berserker>Rider>Assassin>Caster
and for masters
Ryuunoske>Waver>Kariya>Kiritsugu>Kirei>Tokiomi>Kayneth
Jun 28, 2012 12:37 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
1201
Taking into account novels too.

Servants:

Rider>>>Archer>Saber> Lancer = Caster = Berserker >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Assassin.

Masters:

Kirei>>>>>Waver = Kariya> Ryuunosuke >> Kiritsugu = Kayneth >>>>> Tokiomi.

Now Master/Servant teams:

1) Rider and Waver. Most enjoyable to watch on screen with their chemistry and ongoing development.
2) Kirei and Gilgamesh. YUETSU.
3) Caster and Uryuu. Entertaining pair of psychos. Made for each others.
4) Saber and Irisviel. They were so d'awwww in their lady/knight dynamics.
5) Kayneth, Sola and Lancer. I liked their tragic triangle. It made them interesting.
6) Tokiomi and Gilgamesh. The only noteworthy is how he sucked up at Gil and he hated him for it. Hilarious.
7 & 8) Kiritsugu and Saber + Kirei and Assassin: "..."
EDIT: 9) Kariya and Berserker: I forgot about it because it's so bad due to Berserker rape-blood drink and awful pain that cripples the guy.
ThessJun 28, 2012 11:52 AM
Jun 28, 2012 8:20 PM
Offline
Aug 2010
207
Rider > Gilgamesh > Lancer > Saber > Caster > Berserker > Assassin. The first three were far better than the last four, though.

Kiritsugu > Waver > Tokiomi > Kirei > Kayneth > Kariya > Ryuunosuke
Jun 28, 2012 9:00 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
999
Caster > Lancer/Rider >>> Saber/Berserker/Archer> Assassin.
Jun 29, 2012 6:42 AM

Offline
Jan 2011
649
Servants: Lancer > Rider > Saber > Berserker > Archer > Caster > Assassin

Masters: Kirei > Kariya > Waver > Kiritsugu > Tokiomi > Kayneth > Ryuunosuke
Jun 30, 2012 4:40 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
70
Servants:

Archer>Rider>Berserker>Lancer>Caster>Assassin Zayd*>>>>>>>>>>Saber

*In series-Assassin can't be ranked, they didn't get to do anything. They're just there.

Masters:

Waver>Kiritsugu>Tokiomi>Kirei>Kayneth>Kariya>Ryuunosuke
Jul 3, 2012 1:34 PM

Offline
Jan 2012
86
Saber
Lancer
Rider
Beserker
Assassin
Archer (too much of a jerk)
Caster
Jul 5, 2012 7:05 PM

Offline
Dec 2011
176
1.Saber
2.Rider
3.Lancer
4.Archer
5.Berserker
6.Caster
7,Assassin

Jul 5, 2012 7:10 PM

Offline
Jan 2011
172
Saber > Berserker > Archer > Lancer > Rider > Caster > Assassin
"You watch too much."
"I don't watch enough."

Jul 11, 2012 10:45 PM

Offline
May 2011
3600
Well, I feel the need to do this again now that I`ve officially completed it.
--

Servants: Rider >= Saber > Archer > Lancer > Berserker > Caster > Assassin
--

Masters: Emiya Kiritsugu > Waver > Kotomine > Tokiomi > Kariya > Ryunosuke > Kayneth
Jul 31, 2012 5:01 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
Servants:
1. Archer
2. Rider
3. Lancer
4. Caster
5. Berserker
6. Saber
7. Assassin

Masters:
1. Kirei
2. Kiritsugu
3. Kariya
4. Waver
5. Ryuunosuke
6. Tokiomi
7. Kayneth
Aug 5, 2012 8:45 PM

Offline
Aug 2011
429
Servants:
Rider
Archer
Saber
Lancer
Caster
Berserker

Masters (Might as well...):
Waver = Kariya = Kiritsugu
Kirei
Ryuunosuke
Tokiomi
Kayneth
Soge_king999Aug 5, 2012 8:48 PM
Jul 7, 2013 3:55 AM
Offline
Jul 2013
1
Saber > Lancer > Assassin > Berserker > Archer > Rider > Caster XD
Jul 17, 2013 10:20 AM

Offline
Sep 2012
536
Servants:

Saber
Rider
Archer
Lancer
Caster
Berserker
Assassin


Masters:

Kiritsugu
Kotomine
Tokiomi
Waver
Kariya
Kayneth
Ryuunosuke
Jul 19, 2013 7:45 AM
Offline
Dec 2012
71
Servants:
Lancer>Rider>Berserker>Saber>Assassin>Caster (he scares me)>Archer (he is annoying)

Masters:
Kariya>Kiritsugu>Waver>Kirei>Tokiomi>Ryuunosuke(he is scary..)>Kayneth
Jul 19, 2013 9:37 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
115
Servants:
Saber
Archer
Rider
Lancer
Berserker
Assassin
Caster

Masters:

Kiritsugu
Kotomine
Tokiomi
Waver
Kariya
Kayneth
Ryuunosuke( This guy is crazy) lol
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jul 19, 2013 9:51 AM

Offline
Apr 2013
50
Servants
Saber
Gilgamesh
Rider
Lancer
Assassin
Caster

Masters
Kiritsugu Emiya
Kotomine
Waver
Tokiome
Kayneth
Ryuunosuke
Asuna_LMNJul 19, 2013 10:05 AM
Jul 19, 2013 9:49 PM
Offline
Jul 2013
26
Servants:
Saber
Rider
Archer
Berserker
Lancer
Caster
Assassin(s)

Masters:
Kiritsugu
Waver
Kirei
Kariya
Tokiomi
Ryuunosuke
Kayneth
Aug 16, 2013 11:16 AM

Offline
Jun 2011
1568
Servants:-
Berserker
Rider
Caster
Lancer
Saber
Archer
Assassin

Masters:-
Kiritsugu
Kariya
Tokiomi
Kayneth
Ryuunosuke
Waver
Kirei
Oct 19, 2013 2:57 PM

Offline
Apr 2013
298
Rider
Berserker
Caster
Saber
Assassins
Lancer
Archer

Kariya
Kiritsugu
Kirei
Ryuunosuke
Tohsaka
Waver
Kayneth
Oct 19, 2013 11:32 PM

Offline
Nov 2012
15463
Servants:

Archer
Berserker
Lancer
Rider
Caster
Saber
Assassin

Masters:

Waver
Kiritsugu
Kariya
Ryuunosuke
Kirei
Kayneth
Tokiomi
Oct 30, 2013 7:03 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
Servants:
Saber>Archer>Rider>Lancer>Berserker>Caster>Assassin

I loved Saber in F/SN, and I continued to love her in F/Z. To people who don't like Saber because of her views on kingship: That's what this odd thing called CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT is for :P

Masters:

Kiritsugu>Waver>Kariya>Kirei>Kayneth>Ryuunosuke>Tokiomi
Oct 31, 2013 12:07 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
HikariJake said:
Servants:
Saber>Archer>Rider>Lancer>Berserker>Caster>Assassin

I loved Saber in F/SN, and I continued to love her in F/Z. To people who don't like Saber because of her views on kingship: That's what this odd thing called CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT is for :P

That she had char development doesnt mean that she will become well liked because of that.And the problem is her wish not her kiingship.SHE is the one that has problems with her kingship.

She had Rider and Kiritsugu telling her why she was wrong in FZ(+Gil laughing at her) and Lancelot telling her that she did well as a king.Yet the one that changed her was Shirou because of LOVE.

So we had 1 king,her master and her best..no THE BEST knight telling her off but she only heard the teenager she fall in love with....
Nov 4, 2013 2:12 AM

Offline
Feb 2012
467
they were all lame,why ask?
but If I had to choose one,I would choose Rider.
Nov 5, 2013 1:57 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
155
Interesting question, I think the servant that I "liked" the most would have to be rider; this would be due to him just being a dynamic character. If I was to say which servant's screen time I enjoyed the most, it would have to be caster. When I saw the first scene with caster-- which I didn't expect at all-- his ability to make me go, "What the fuck?" piqued my interests.

The things he did were often more frightening then what most horror anime throw around. Add this too his inane speeches and the way his master and he interacted; he was a pure pleasure to watch.

Just because Gille de Rais was my favorite, doesn't mean that I didn't want him to be killed though. He was just an enjoyable antagonist.
Nov 5, 2013 11:43 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
aLooser said:

The things he did were often more frightening then what most horror anime throw around. Add this too his inane speeches and the way his master and he interacted; he was a pure pleasure to watch.

Just because Gille de Rais was my favorite, doesn't mean that I didn't want him to be killed though. He was just an enjoyable antagonist.

Caster Team was indeed interesting and hell we will probably never see a Master and Servant bond like theirs ever again(Maybe if the Assassin Jack the Ripper and her Master from FAte/Apocrypha get more focus in the full LN).This has nothing to do with liking their actions.
Nov 6, 2013 2:12 AM
Offline
Dec 2012
338
Servant:
Archer > Rider = Berserker > Saber > Lancer = Caster > Assassin


Master:
Kirei > Waver > Kiritsugu > Ruunosuke > Tokiomi = Kariya > Kayneth
Nov 7, 2013 10:41 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
92
Servants:
1.Saber(Love the suit and her)
2.Berserker(Just badass)
3.Archer(...He finally wore his armor instead of UBW)
4.Rider(Charisma but thats all. MEH)
5.Lancer(Cool, but not as cool a chu chuchulain imo)
6.Caster (... love his energy)
7.Assassin(....Doesn't exist)

Masters:
1.Kiritsugu(*claps* for backstory)
2.Kirei( + points for not getting stabbed, swallowed, etc just shot.)
3.Waver(One of the less cruel masters, badass later on ;))
4.Kariya(GOD SAVE THE LITTLE GIRL...! D:)
5.Tokiomi(Boring)
6.Ruunosuki(... Like Caster ^^.)
7.Kayneth(So blunt
machokanaJun 13, 2014 10:20 AM

Nov 10, 2013 8:24 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
155
ssjokg said:
aLooser said:

The things he did were often more frightening then what most horror anime throw around. Add this too his inane speeches and the way his master and he interacted; he was a pure pleasure to watch.

Just because Gille de Rais was my favorite, doesn't mean that I didn't want him to be killed though. He was just an enjoyable antagonist.

Caster Team was indeed interesting and hell we will probably never see a Master and Servant bond like theirs ever again(Maybe if the Assassin Jack the Ripper and her Master from FAte/Apocrypha get more focus in the full LN).This has nothing to do with liking their actions.


Exactly! You, my friend "get it". Just because you don't agree with someone's actions doesn't mean you can't find them interesting. That combo was the definition of interesting.
Dec 1, 2013 10:04 AM
Offline
Jun 2013
159
Archer > Saber > Rider > Lancer > Berserker > Assassin > Caster

Waver > Kiritsugu > Kariya > Tokiomi > (Sola) > Kayneth > Ryuunosuke > Kirei
Dec 1, 2013 11:05 AM
Offline
Nov 2013
17
Servants:
1) Saber (so honorable + heroic)
2) Archer (felt like he was untouchable)
3) Rider (lights up the story)
4) Lancer (super honorable + likable)
5) Caster (humorous + perfect match)
6) Berserker (just random, no real development except at his death)
7) Assassin (irritating + little talent)

Masters:
1) Kiritsugu (amazing history, most skilled, noble intentions)
2) Waver (heartwarming ending with Rider)
3) Tokiomi (nice guy, good intentions, respected)
4) Kariya (all he wanted was to save Sakura and give her a happy life)
5) Ryunosuke (perfect for Caster, but was still evil with little development)
6) Kayneth (hated this guy: arrogant, self-absorbed prick who shows no respect to anyone)
7) Kirei (even worse than Kayneth: no intentions other than to ruin people's lives, did not care when Kayneth killed his father mercilessly, killed Tokiomi for no reason)
PivotDec 1, 2013 12:02 PM
Dec 1, 2013 11:18 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
How is Saber and Lancer any different from Berserker?Also, you confuse honor with hypocrisy.

Kiristugu is by far the least skilled between the actual magi of the series,Tokiomi,Kirei,Kayneth and him.If Rider hadnt attacked Berserker and Lancer in ep5 he would have revealed his position and most likely suffer defeat.

Tokiomi isnt a nice guy, has no noble intentions and isnt respected by anyone.You have pretty much confused Kayneth with Tokiomi.

Kirei wanted to find a reason for his birth and a reason to continue leaving and to prove to himself that he is good.How did he kill his father?Are we even watching the same show?
He killed Tokiomi so he could take Gilgamesh and win the war, so he could find his wish.
Tokiomi on the other hand caused an entire family to be destroyed, along with the one man that cared for that family more than Tokiomi ever did, all for the most unoriginal and dubious goal in history of magi.
Dec 1, 2013 11:46 AM
Offline
Oct 2010
5252
Can't remember if I commented here but

Archer > Rider > Lancer > Saber > Berserker > Caster > Assassin.

Masters

Kirei > Kiritsugu > Tokiomi > Kayneth > Kariya > Ryunosuke > Waver

Honestly, I don't consider waver to even be a master. Saber is also a pretty shitty servant despite having such ridiculous advantages (magic armour, lady of the lake blessing, invisible sword, avalon etc)
Dec 1, 2013 12:01 PM
Offline
Nov 2013
17
For the record, this is my opinion. However, I suppose I'll argue for it.

Saber and Lancer are completely different from Berserker. The fact that Lancelot was put into the Berserker class should be explanation enough. Berserker didn't fight, it rampaged. It didn't abide by chivalry; it was just a "mad dog", as Archer said. Perhaps Lancelot was at one point no different from Saber and Lancer, but it can't be denied that he is now.

Really? I disagree. Kiritsugu defeated Kayneth in a one-on-one, and would have killed him if it weren't for Lancer. Kiritsugu also defeated Kirei one-on-one. You're making false claims when it was shown explicitly who was stronger.

Incorrect. If Rider hadn't attacked Berserker, Kiritsugu would have sniped Kayneth and Maiya would have sniped Assassin. They would have been fine, especially with Saber right there. With Kayneth gone, Lancer wouldn't have to abide by the command spell to team up with Berserker. Berserker would have been the one at a loss here, not Kiritsugu.

If you want to contradict my claims about Tokiomi, at least back up your notions. Also, to say Kayneth is a nice guy and Tokiomi is evil is as backwards as it gets.

Kirei wanted nothing but destruction, as seen by his hysterical laughing at the end of the war. Furthermore, Kayneth killed his father, and he didn't even care. He killed Tokiomi to receive Archer, but he wasn't even supposed to be involved in the war per the treaty with Kiritsugu. Also, Tokiomi was nothing but nice to Kirei, and Kirei kills him with the very sword gifted to him.

Do you see nothing horribly messed up about that?

Tokiomi gave his confessions to Kariya during their battle where Tokiomi sets him aflame. After that, I realized that Tokiomi wasn't all that bad, and did what he had to.
PivotDec 1, 2013 12:07 PM
Dec 1, 2013 12:33 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
Remind me what part of killing is chivalry.And you are missing the point.Both Lancer and Saber had no development except during their deaths exactly like Berserker.

If Kiritsugu had fired during ep 5,Kayneth wouldnt even be hurt thanks to the Volumen Hydragyrum.He defeated Kayneth after laying traps everywhere in the castle he was familiar with, against an opponent he had studied, while Kayneth had none of that.Oh yeah he even survived Kiritsugu's bombing some days ago.
His battle with Kirei was a draw.And he only survived thanks to powers that werent his own aka AVALON.Kirei killed Kiritsugu first with a single punch.

Assassin wouldnt even ffeel the bullets and would kill Maiya and proceed to attack Kiritsugu and/or Iri,while Berserker is still attacking a wounded Saber ,who couldnt fight against him even when she was at top form, and also has to worry about Lancer whose Master would survive Kiritsugu's attack thanks to Volumen Hydragyrum.Bye bye Team Saber.

Tokiomi gave his daughter to somebody he knew would torture and poison her to get her "stronger".All not for her but so that his family can be even more well known.A big hypocrite that even makes up reasons to prove himself right.
Kayneth was the bad teacher of Waver and didnt seem to be an ass to any other student.He is good enough to abandon the war in order to save a woman that NEVER loved him.That he was angry at Lancer and Kiritsugu and that he ridiculed Waver doesnt make him evil.
It's so easy to see who is evil and who isnt in less than a sec.

Kirei didnt know he wanted destruction until after the end of the war.Yes he didnt care,how does that make him the killer(oh you edited your post)?And it was already established that he lack the emotions to feel sorry for him.
How does not following the treaty make him evil?Tokiomi was "nice" to Kirei, so?Sakura didnt do anything to him and he sent her to a freak show and that made him as nice guy,but somehow Kirei is evil for betraying Tokiomi?

I see that your way of looking at things is all messed up.

Tokiomi sent his daughter to get tortured and poisoned, and it's possible he knew about the rape as well,so that in the future, if he failed(thats what I call being self aware), she and Rin could succeed him even if it means killing each other in order to make the family more well known and "respected".

Is there something wrong with you?How is this "not all that bad"?
ssjokgDec 1, 2013 12:37 PM
Dec 1, 2013 1:27 PM
Offline
Nov 2013
17
The entirety of the Code of Chivalry rotates around how to honorably take another's life. This was said explicitly in the anime, as well. If you're trying to tell me Lancer and Saber had no development before their deaths, you're completely wrong.

Was Kayneth even with his Volumen Hydragyrum? You're just guessing here. Plus, a bullet coming from no where that Kayneth can't even see wouldn't be guarded against, would it?

Even if it would, it wouldn't put Kiritsugu in danger if Assassin is out of the picture. Assassin might very well feel the bullet. Assassin is a bunch of different shadows, remember? Not to mention she's probably the weakest of the heroes.

Kayneth wasn't phased by any of the traps lain out for him, if you recall. To say that those "held him back" in any way is incorrect. I don't care whose powers were whose; I'm talking about which one of them was stronger. Kirei lost, don't you remember Kirei sulking on the ground in defeat, asking why Kiritsugu wouldn't give him the Grail?

Now how do you know Tokiomi knew that Matou would poison and destroy her? Again, you're going off of an estimate.

If it's "so easy" to see who is good and evil, how are you completely missing it? Kayneth forced Lancer to commit suicide, and dishonored his name, all for a woman just as evil as he. A mix of stupidity and evilness caused the concoction known as Kayneth. Kayneth brutally murdered the neutral priest, just in order to steal command spells from him. How is he not evil?

Kirei wanted nothing more than to entertain himself through the suffering of others. Don't you remember what horrible things he did to Kariya? Let me remind you. He killed Tokiomi, and framed Kariya for killing him. He also made Kariya's sister hate him because of this, and would never trust him again, when all Kariya did was try and fix the family his sister had started. What a sociopath.

Betrayal is evil. I don't see what's so hard to understand about that. Tokiomi never realized Matou would do those horrible things to Sakura. When someone is nice to you, you don't stab them in the back (LITERALLY).

Please refrain from misquoting me, by the way.
Dec 1, 2013 1:52 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
There is no right or wrong way to take someone's life.Murder is murder.
Pleases provide scenes where both of them were developed,had any epiphany or changed their mindset except during their deaths.

Kayneth would be in a battlefield without his nest trick?Makes sense.Kayneth doesnt need to know where it comes from.

Assassin,even by being the weakest Servant, is still a Servant and it cant be harmed by normal methods.Kiritsugu says that to Maiya in the same ep.

So the traps were all useless?Nope.All of them made Kayneth believe he can blcok everything kiritsugu used on him.That is why the first shot from the Contender passed through.
Waking up first from the illusion doesnt make Kiritsugu more skilled than Kirei if that is what you mean.Kirei took everything Kiritsugu thrown at him and still came after him as if nothing was happening.

Tokiomi's family along with the Einzberns and the Matou created the Wars.He knows the basics of their training JUST LIKE RIN KNEW IN FSN.

With this logic everyone including Iri and Saber is evil since they would kill everyone else to get the grail.It doesnt make sense.Sola wasnt evil.1.She never loved Kayneth even before they summoned Lancer.2.It was because of Lancer's curse that she was such a bitch towards Kayneth.The priest was never neutral if you didnt notice that in episode fucking one and several other as well and Kayneth found out about that.

He still wasnt sure that this is what he wanted.And for fucks sake.Aoi wasnt Kariya's sister.That Kirei is a sociopath is the only correct thing you said till now.Oh yeah he was also the one that healed Aoi.

So Kiritsugu is evil for betraying Saber by destroying the grail.Kariya is evil for betraying Zouken and running away from home etc etc...Again makes no fucking sense
Tokiomi KNEW the way they train themselves.They used to be allies years ago.That Tokiomi was an idiot for not understanding both Gilgamesh and Kirei doesnt make Kirei or ANYONE that would kill him evil.

I dont need to misquote you.You havent payed attention to the series,you cant distinguish good from evil and confuse screen time with development.
Dec 1, 2013 2:10 PM
Offline
Nov 2013
17
In that case, you simply don't know what chivalry is. If this is the case, it'd be best if you didn't make false claims about what is chivalrous and what isn't.

Kayneth wasn't in the battlefield, he was in the sidelines. How do you know he took all the necessary precautions? He doesn't know there will be someone about to snipe him. Also, you're guessing once more when you say his Volumen works automatically.

If Kiritusugu says that to Maiya, why was he about to order Maiya to shoot Assassin? Surely, he knew it would kill.

The first shot from the Contender hit Kayneth because Kayneth's an arrogant snob who can't feasibly understand that anyone is better than he. The traps didn't do anything.

No, that is not what I mean. Kiritsugu won the battle. It said this numerous times; Saber said it, Kirei said it... Even Kirei was surprised as to how he wasn't dead. He said "Kiritsugu spared me because he was a softy". How much more obvious do I have to make it to you that Kirei lost the battle to Kiritsugu. If you still disagree, it's useless.

The priest gave the command spell to Kayneth, even though Saber was the one who defeated Caster. If anything he was biased in Kayneth's favor. Yet, Kayneth kills him. Sola was incredibly evil. She tortured Kayneth until Kayneth released to her his command spells. Your understanding of evil is so messed up, it's kind of funny.

No, Kirei was sure this is what he wanted. Archer made it apparent.

He also healed Kariya in order to see him suffer further. Wow, what a nice guy, huh?

Kiritsugu is often evil during F/Z. He only changes at the very end. His intentions are good, but his methods are evil.

So you're saying, as long as he's stupid, killing an innocent person is 'ight? Yep... This is your morality at it's finest.

Screen time is development in most cases, my sense of good and evil is far greater than yours, and I have watched this anime avidly just this weekend. It's more fresh in my mind than yours.

Sola TORTURED Kayneth to make him release his command spells. You do not find this evil? In that case, this discussion is over. I can't argue with someone who cannot grasp basic logic, and whose entire argument has been based around speculation.

Also, this discussion is meaningless anyway. All of these ratings were my opinion. I couldn't give a shit as to whether you agree or not. I think we're done here.
Dec 1, 2013 2:34 PM

Offline
Aug 2009
20024
I know what chivalry is.Bullshit some kids use to justify their methods of killing.

He is like 10 meters away from where Saber is fighting.He knows that others are watching and shit were getting too dangerous to simply just stand there doing nothing.Um no I am not guessing.

Do you know what suppressive fire is?And even that would fail.You would know that if you could remember what Kirei did when they were firing at him.And"if"?He clearly said that.

The Contender is much more powerful than everything else he used against Kayneth.Kayneth had no reason to belive that he had something more powerful than mines and grenades.And that was the plan.To make Kayneth raise his defenses even more after the fist shot.

We went from most skilled to who won the war...please be consistent.
Kiritsgu didnt won the battle.It was draw.When he killed Kirei there was no battle,no fight.He was just the guy that woke up first from something none of them did.Kirei said that to Shirou while he was hiding everything else.
Shooting someone to the heart from behind isnt something a softy would do.

No he gave one command spell to him because Lancer helped Saber.
Sola had already lost it thanks to Lancer's curse.That isnt being evil.

NO he wasnt.The whole laughing scene along with his realization at the end prove that.

He wouldnt be able to see Aoi suffer.She wasnt able to suffer.

You DO realize that every single char in the war was ready to kill?What does evil method even mean?Kiritsugu evacuated an entire hotel before blowing it up,he didnt change at the end, he is still the same person.You should either call every single one of them evil including your absolute favorites Lancer and Saber or never mention that word again.

Tokiomi was never innocent.

No it isnt .You have no sense of good and evil.You just decide what is good and what is evil based on how much you like the chars.Lol you cant even remember the events or char relations correctly.

Sola had lost her mid due to Lancer's curse.I am tired of saying that.

You opinion is based solely on how you remember the series ,if you can remember it at all.For someone not giving a shit you surely gave an entire pile.
ssjokgDec 4, 2013 9:40 AM
Dec 4, 2013 9:06 AM

Offline
Jun 2013
279
Disregarding the argument above me, my favorites are.

1. Gilgamesh - Love his arrogance and you simply can't beat this guy
2. Saber - I've always loved Saber even though I just cannot agree with what she says about chivalry and battle. EXCALIBUR!!!
3. Rider - He's so hammy and awesome! His bond with Waver was amazing as well.
4. Lancer - I respect Lancer but he's in the same ballpark as Saber concerning their views on battle. His death was tragic though
5. Berserker - He was so awesome! The twist at the end involving him was rather shocking but pretty easy to guess if you know your mythology
6. Caster - His voice annoyed me but I guess he was an interesting fellow?
7. Screw Assassin, he sucked :P
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »

More topics from this board

» What's next?

infinite_Shadows - Apr 10

13 by Ain2Zwei »»
Apr 15, 4:48 PM

Poll: » Fate/Zero 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Jun 23, 2012

1325 by Joel77 »»
Mar 25, 11:30 PM

Poll: » Fate/Zero 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

tsubasalover - Jun 16, 2012

655 by Joel77 »»
Mar 25, 11:03 PM

Poll: » Fate/Zero 2nd Season Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Yumekichi11 - Jun 9, 2012

728 by damnit_tomioka »»
Mar 18, 2:06 PM

Poll: » Fate/Zero 2nd Season Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

belatkuro - Apr 28, 2012

585 by goodwake »»
Mar 9, 11:00 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login