Magical Girl Raising Project (light novel)
| The first season wasn't like the worst show ever but it was kinda hard to watch, with characters getting killed off so easily before even getting to do much. The synopsis of this says there are 16 girls this time. I can't imagine they will get much development at all before being thrown into the blender. Seems like it will be a waste. |
 ☆☆☆ "There's a huge difference between one and infinity. However, compared to the difference between existence and non-existence, one and infinite are nearly the same. I am the child destined to become the best witch... no... The greatest Creator in the world...!" -Maria Ushiromiya ☆☆☆ |
| I'm still upset that they killed off the TS girl so early. D: |
EndlessMaria said: The first season wasn't like the worst show ever but it was kinda hard to watch, with characters getting killed off so easily before even getting to do much. The synopsis of this says there are 16 girls this time. I can't imagine they will get much development at all before being thrown into the blender. Seems like it will be a waste. That's what great about mgrp tho, even the strong gets mogged if they get careless |
 |
| You're asking me if I want to see PFLE in anime? Of course yes. Hell yes. Noisrev said: EndlessMaria said: The first season wasn't like the worst show ever but it was kinda hard to watch, with characters getting killed off so easily before even getting to do much. The synopsis of this says there are 16 girls this time. I can't imagine they will get much development at all before being thrown into the blender. Seems like it will be a waste. That's what great about mgrp tho, even the strong gets mogged if they get careless Which is actually a strong point of it indeed. There's no point making that kind of story if you already know that X and Y are safe because they're too strong. |
ZefyrisJan 30, 2023 4:37 AM
 |
| Yes I want it, the first season was enjoyable anyway so more season of this is always welcome :) |
 (っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
| Yes, this series is very enjoyable and worth reading and watching. I love especially the chibi illustrations of the magical girls. Each one of them is very well designed. |
| “Right is right even if no one is doing it; wrong is wrong even if everyone is doing it.” ― Saint Augustine |
| I did not watch it yet, but idea of cute magical girls killing each other for my entertainment does appeal to me. |
| Buy my awesome BDSM male domination book here https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/1174760 Visit my Discord https://discord.com/channels/1047490147794550844/1047490149161898039 I am not there most of the time but you can leave a message. Or my blog here https://BDSMAnime.blogspot.com/ Or here https://BDSMAnime18.blogspot.com/ Submit to me and become my subject here https://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=88107 |
| Consider me spiteful and it will make me look like a bad fan, but seeing this get a season 2 instead of Gakkougurashi is really disappointing to me. Considering the same studio did both and Gakkougurashi came out in around a year before season 1 of this. It truly is an industry where I pick the wrong shows to like. |
 |
Calal-Chan said: Consider me spiteful and it will make me look like a bad fan, but seeing this get a season 2 instead of Gakkougurashi is really disappointing to me. Considering the same studio did both and Gakkougurashi came out in around a year before season 1 of this. It truly is an industry where I pick the wrong shows to like. I don't think Lerche would have said no to a second season of Gakkou Gurashi, so the side that was not interested in a season 2 was most probably the publisher/sponsor side. In other words, since those two series have two completely different sponsor and publisher behind them, no choice between Gakkou Gurashi and Mahoiku was ever made. Lerche was offered to make a season 2 of Mahoiku, but never was offered to do a season 2 for Gakkou Gurashi. It's probably that simple. ...Also, if you've only seen Mahoiku's anime, you're probably underestimating Mahoiku's story and characters quite a bit tbh. |
|
| Sooooo looking forward to this. I thought it was better than Madoka Magica. |
| Yes yes we do!!!! I’m so excited!!! |
 |
| Ok so you don't like this franchise, for you it's just a waste, so no one can be excited for it. Why are you even making a post on a forum about an anime/franchise you don't care about? I swear MAL is full of people causing discussion just becuase they feel the need, the urge, of telling everyone their opinion when absolutely no one asked about it. |
Sorry if my english is bad (っ˘▽˘)っ~~~ Btw, cry about it. |
| Yes I want more seasons !!! I loved the first anime |
| Yes, looking forward to this. One of my favorite parts of this story was the play on power scaling. Some super strong magical girls getting offed in spectacular ways by seemingly weaker ones. The death order was pretty unpredictable aside from the one obvious one. Considering Restart is two volumes, I hope it receives more episodes, though... |
| omg yes OMG YES YES |
 |
Zefyris said: They would have said yes probably and yeah I agree it was the publisher/sponser side. I know there was never a choice and I don't actually hold Mahoiku or any staff responsible for it. I know how the production side works I am just a salty fanboy XDCalal-Chan said: Consider me spiteful and it will make me look like a bad fan, but seeing this get a season 2 instead of Gakkougurashi is really disappointing to me. Considering the same studio did both and Gakkougurashi came out in around a year before season 1 of this. It truly is an industry where I pick the wrong shows to like. I don't think Lerche would have said no to a second season of Gakkou Gurashi, so the side that was not interested in a season 2 was most probably the publisher/sponsor side. In other words, since those two series have two completely different sponsor and publisher behind them, no choice between Gakkou Gurashi and Mahoiku was ever made. Lerche was offered to make a season 2 of Mahoiku, but never was offered to do a season 2 for Gakkou Gurashi. It's probably that simple. ...Also, if you've only seen Mahoiku's anime, you're probably underestimating Mahoiku's story and characters quite a bit tbh. I have seen the first season and I gave it a 4/10. Granted this was a long time ago, but if season 2 improves it then that is good I might watch it then. Give Gakkougurashi a shot if you haven't. I know my toxic fanboy came out but it is still a good show. I will be trying season 2 of this show and will re-watch season 1 before so and who knows maybe my opinion will change on it. I did watch it like 7 years ago. Thanks for your response and for not being a dick about it all. :D |
|
Calal-Chan said: Zefyris said: They would have said yes probably and yeah I agree it was the publisher/sponser side. I know there was never a choice and I don't actually hold Mahoiku or any staff responsible for it. I know how the production side works I am just a salty fanboy XDI don't think Lerche would have said no to a second season of Gakkou Gurashi, so the side that was not interested in a season 2 was most probably the publisher/sponsor side. In other words, since those two series have two completely different sponsor and publisher behind them, no choice between Gakkou Gurashi and Mahoiku was ever made. Lerche was offered to make a season 2 of Mahoiku, but never was offered to do a season 2 for Gakkou Gurashi. It's probably that simple. ...Also, if you've only seen Mahoiku's anime, you're probably underestimating Mahoiku's story and characters quite a bit tbh. I have seen the first season and I gave it a 4/10. Granted this was a long time ago, but if season 2 improves it then that is good I might watch it then. Give Gakkougurashi a shot if you haven't. I know my toxic fanboy came out but it is still a good show. I will be trying season 2 of this show and will re-watch season 1 before so and who knows maybe my opinion will change on it. I did watch it like 7 years ago. Thanks for your response and for not being a dick about it all. :D Don't worry, if I took you for a simple hater I wouldn't have taken the time to answer you, so I didn't take it the wrong way :). Well, we don't know what Lerche is going to do with the original material. Simply, the first series stopped too soon, so peoples didn't understood that what they watched was just the prologue, because they didn't finish adapting said prologue to show where the story would go and why what happened was meaningful. So it was taken very wrongly as just some bad Madoka copycat even though Mahoiku's true purpose is going into a completely different direction (regardless of what peoples think of said story purpose). That was why I said that if you only saw the anime then you may misunderstand heavily said anime. This is a problem shared by any anime that only adapted the prologue of a novel (Rokka no Yuusha for example had the same problem), peoples can't see where the story intend to go from there and misjudge the story's direction. |
|
Zefyris said: Considering my low score for Rokka no Yuusha as well considering how much I hated the ending I get exactly what you are saying. I will 100% try Mahoiku again when season 2 happens that way maybe I can see what it is actually supposed to be about. Even Gakkougurashi has issues as an adaptation. This is just a problem the anime industry suffers from. A go read the source material thing. It makes shows have subpar adaptations sometimes or at the very least endings that leave you a bit sour.Calal-Chan said: They would have said yes probably and yeah I agree it was the publisher/sponser side. I know there was never a choice and I don't actually hold Mahoiku or any staff responsible for it. I know how the production side works I am just a salty fanboy XD I have seen the first season and I gave it a 4/10. Granted this was a long time ago, but if season 2 improves it then that is good I might watch it then. Give Gakkougurashi a shot if you haven't. I know my toxic fanboy came out but it is still a good show. I will be trying season 2 of this show and will re-watch season 1 before so and who knows maybe my opinion will change on it. I did watch it like 7 years ago. Thanks for your response and for not being a dick about it all. :D Don't worry, if I took you for a simple hater I wouldn't have taken the time to answer you, so I didn't take it the wrong way :). Well, we don't know what Lerche is going to do with the original material. Simply, the first series stopped too soon, so peoples didn't understood that what they watched was just the prologue, because they didn't finish adapting said prologue to show where the story would go and why what happened was meaningful. So it was taken very wrongly as just some bad Madoka copycat even though Mahoiku's true purpose is going into a completely different direction (regardless of what peoples think of said story purpose). That was why I said that if you only saw the anime then you may misunderstand heavily said anime. This is a problem shared by any anime that only adapted the prologue of a novel (Rokka no Yuusha for example had the same problem), peoples can't see where the story intend to go from there and misjudge the story's direction. Thanks for giving me a different perspective always nice to talk to someone who is reasonable. :) |
|
| Yes looking forward to another season. I read the wiki and I saw that there are a lot of them. And by a lot I mean a lot. There are so many and I've read some of their backstories and powers. Some are broken and some had interesting powers so I would love to see more of them animated. |
| I am super hyped. The original is a very solid battle royale. |
| Shoot first, think never. |
| I did and that's all that matters to the universe apparently. 💋 |
| it's pog s1 was pog and at the end of s1 it showed s2 so yes |
 |
| Yes, very much so. It's nice to have more shows that have a twist on the magical girl genre. Especially something that's outlived Madoka, and imo, far better character designs. |
| "Well, she's flatter than a pancake" -Mimi Alpacas "Woof" -Tobiichi Origami "Are you trying to turn the dormitory into a strip club!?! -Atena Saotome |
Calal-Chan said: Rokka no Yuusha is a great read. The twists in it are some of the best and the way they deduce who is lying and has ulterior motives is fantastic.Zefyris said: Considering my low score for Rokka no Yuusha as well considering how much I hated the ending I get exactly what you are saying. I will 100% try Mahoiku again when season 2 happens that way maybe I can see what it is actually supposed to be about. Even Gakkougurashi has issues as an adaptation. This is just a problem the anime industry suffers from. A go read the source material thing. It makes shows have subpar adaptations sometimes or at the very least endings that leave you a bit sour.Don't worry, if I took you for a simple hater I wouldn't have taken the time to answer you, so I didn't take it the wrong way :). Well, we don't know what Lerche is going to do with the original material. Simply, the first series stopped too soon, so peoples didn't understood that what they watched was just the prologue, because they didn't finish adapting said prologue to show where the story would go and why what happened was meaningful. So it was taken very wrongly as just some bad Madoka copycat even though Mahoiku's true purpose is going into a completely different direction (regardless of what peoples think of said story purpose). That was why I said that if you only saw the anime then you may misunderstand heavily said anime. This is a problem shared by any anime that only adapted the prologue of a novel (Rokka no Yuusha for example had the same problem), peoples can't see where the story intend to go from there and misjudge the story's direction. Thanks for giving me a different perspective always nice to talk to someone who is reasonable. :) |
| it was a pretty decent survival anime for a a medium that doesnt get it right (unlike survival manga, now thats were you get the quality stuff), so yeah, Im fine with another season even if it´s more of the same. |
| :v |
MichaelJackson said: it was a pretty decent survival anime for a a medium that doesnt get it right (unlike survival manga, now thats were you get the quality stuff), so yeah, Im fine with another season even if it´s more of the same. How did it not get it right? |
|
Noisrev said: I was talking about anime in general not getting survival right most of the time. Mahou shoujo ikusei is one of the few ones that I think it actually got it right in the last yearsMichaelJackson said: it was a pretty decent survival anime for a a medium that doesnt get it right (unlike survival manga, now thats were you get the quality stuff), so yeah, Im fine with another season even if it´s more of the same. How did it not get it right? |
| :v |
| Yes, obviously. The first season wasn't anything great, but there is not nearly enough edgy magical girl anime to be picky. |
 |
| Im curious now, I liked the anime but the LN does seem more interesting. Any idea where I can read that? |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
More topics from this board
» HYPELiddo-kun - Jan 30, 2023 |
15 |
by Comander-07
»»
Apr 21, 2:23 PM |