Farewell, My Dear Cramer
| Blame the animation. That seems to be what's holding the story back |
 |
| You haven't even attempted to watch the anime but just took the score at face value? Yes the anime is not amazing (it's the animations that really suck) but to start a thread complaining about an anime you haven't even watched is weird. |
 |
| Good manga, bad adaptation. |
| A superb Manga with a OK adaptation I believe that people that are actually very into fotball will love it because its honestly one of the only manga I've seen where the author actually understands the sport Most characters are endearing and that has been conveyed well enough in the adaptation in my opinion. The only "bad" things is the very limited animation, which is understandable. But from a football fans perspective, this is a really good Anime/manga And you really should really stop judging an Anime based of the score of a community that has become very tocix and it frankly doesn't represnt the larger Anime community anymore. MAL has become a place filled with people that believe that they understand the industry and that they're critics that can rightfully judge Anime that are not even catered towards them |
FireFistYKMay 2, 2021 4:18 PM
 |
| I don’t know personally I enjoy it, but then again animation isn’t a priority for me to in terms of anime as long as I find it funny/amusing |
 |
| haven't read the manga but animation is definitely the biggest problem here. looks like ass. especially since its a sports anime where animation takes huge part in the viewing experience the studio can definitely do better so idk why they aren't. |
| I don't know man. But I really enjoyed it so far. Maybe because I love sports anime and soccer. Everything seems okay, I love the character, the music, and the pace really good, not felt rushed. The only problems that everyone seems to be complaining is the animation, though it still enjoyable imo. |
| I mean I rarely write on forums outside of my Club. But some of the takes here on this show really leave me stunned. Like yes the animation is not that exciting and the sound doesn't add much either, but I don't think that are like the major issues. Probably my biggest issue is this so called "comedy" especially in the forms of the trainer of the boys team and Shiratori or like that one part about healthy cooking. Like it is super annoying. Still if it would only that I could live with that, but the rest is not much better. From minute 1 the show hammers in that this is one of those "chosen one" stories with a big fat swollen monologue on how our MC is supposed to revitalize women's football (whatever that means). Honestly I could say more negative things here, but I don't want to be too toxic. There are some things that are alright. Like I think Soshizaki's character is probably the one thing that still keeps me somewhat interested in the show, but the rest is just a snoozefest, which wouldn't be too bad, if this wasn't a season stacked to the brim with quality shows like Odd Taxi, Megalo Box S2 or Fumetsu no anata e. |
| one of the worst sports anime I've ever seen. |
| Just found out the manga is finished (which means the anime TV series and movie will probably adapt all of the manga_ and was written by the same mangaka for Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso aka You Lie in April. However, this incredibly low rating and judging from some of the comments it's to do with the poor quality animation as well as community bias. FireFistYK said: And you really should really stop judging an Anime based of the score of a community that has become very tocix and it frankly doesn't represnt the larger Anime community anymore. MAL has become a place filled with people that believe that they understand the industry and that they're critics that can rightfully judge Anime that are not even catered towards them This is definitely true and it makes it infinitely harder to choose what anime to watch. |
| It's like real life Women Soccer - bad with funny bits. Really, there is no point in watching. |
bastek66May 11, 2021 3:44 PM
 |
| It's a sports anime buy featuring girls playing soccer in Japan. I don't know what more people were expecting? It's cute and lovely, and just not the same story as Your Lie in April. Not sure why folks have shot the rating down to a 5 ☠ |
  |
| It's the adaptations fault, the manga's great. |
 |
| I don't think the anime is particularly well made. For one there are far too many characters so they all blend together since none are given enough time to stand out (a massive problem with a lot of 1-cour shows). But there's definitely a good manga here, the author knows his football and captures a lot of the determination of making a good team out of nothing. I'll be reading it after the anime wraps up. I also think some of the material is way too "insider" for people. You really need to have some knowledge of football strategy and famous players to get the most out of the show since they breeze over references assuming the audience knows. Lots of sports anime avoids that by leaning on lack of realism, but this tries to be extremely realistic in its portrayal of the sport. But overall what really makes it suffer is the anime adaptation just feels lazy and rushed. It's far from the only example of a modern anime that I call "colorized manga". It just feels like they're going through the manga, taking panels they think need to be animated, and animating them. But they're avoiding the work done to translate something you read into something you watch. |
| Great football series like Captain Tsubasa or Area no Kishi are like Pastore in Huracán. Cramer is like Juanfi Garro in Huracán |
| Buenos Aires, Argentina Check my latest web novel on Our Greatest Comeback🦊⛩️ and please drop a like or comment if you liked it! |
Sharry_Gami said: As someone watching almost all good airing anime...I dont think its bad..I d say its 6.7...Light hearted story..Good to watch while eating a meal Really? The comments I feel are more objective make it sound like a trashie anime. I'm also watching many simulcast, but I would rate most of them around 6. Adding another meh anime isn't on my priority list. |
| It's the animation and the pacing. This story has a lot of potential of done right. The prequel movie proves that. Honestly, if the show had been adapted by A1 or someone else, this could've been pretty decent. |
| Though people are saying the animation is holding it back, there was really not much to hold back to begin with. This is taking into account the characters, which are dysfunctional, and the plot, which seems to hinge on random actions by characters (like the uniform bit or kicking a baseball????). If it was just written with a little more care it would have been a well-received show about women's soccer, but instead we are left with this. |
 |
JCDRANZER said: Just found out the manga is finished (which means the anime TV series and movie will probably adapt all of the manga_ and was written by the same mangaka for Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso aka You Lie in April. However, this incredibly low rating and judging from some of the comments it's to do with the poor quality animation as well as community bias. FireFistYK said: And you really should really stop judging an Anime based of the score of a community that has become very tocix and it frankly doesn't represnt the larger Anime community anymore. MAL has become a place filled with people that believe that they understand the industry and that they're critics that can rightfully judge Anime that are not even catered towards them This is definitely true and it makes it infinitely harder to choose what anime to watch. 12 episodes is far too low to adapt it all. |
| I really enjoyed this show! In fact, I login back to MAL after months just to give the score it deserves. The pace at the beginning feels a bit rushed and just dumped the characters at us, which might be off-putting to some viewers. But going in further you'd understand that the reason for that direction is that they fleshed out the character little by little with the story, like a sculptor chiseled out the stone to make statues. The characters that seems so bland and generic at the first episode become an actual cast of unique characters. I think the director did a good job especially going past the 4th episode the show character dynamic began to show it's color, the voice actor choices also quite good, though kinda hard to shake that Aoi Yuuki voice due to her being MC in other show airing this season. The Director and the Producer seems to have worked together in the past with good records, like the Udon no Kuni no Kiniro Kemari and Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo. I really feel this anime didn't get the appreciation it deserves, especially when you see people merely complaining about the animation quality, I don't know why but I feel that a lot of newcomers in the medium are really spoiled by a lot of the big budget shows that pours sakuga scene every 5 minutes, or movies that took years to finish... I think they're really unaware on the process of making animations and the whole lot of steps and people involved around it, and put this unrealistically high bar for a budget (probably one-off) anime to those powered by million dollars franchise. |
| The most important things in life is the people that you care about |
azzuRe said: I really enjoyed this show! In fact, I login back to MAL after months just to give the score it deserves. The pace at the beginning feels a bit rushed and just dumped the characters at us, which might be off-putting to some viewers. But going in further you'd understand that the reason for that direction is that they fleshed out the character little by little with the story, like a sculptor chiseled out the stone to make statues. The characters that seems so bland and generic at the first episode become an actual cast of unique characters. I think the director did a good job especially going past the 4th episode the show character dynamic began to show it's color, the voice actor choices also quite good, though kinda hard to shake that Aoi Yuuki voice due to her being MC in other show airing this season. The Director and the Producer seems to have worked together in the past with good records, like the Udon no Kuni no Kiniro Kemari and Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo. I really feel this anime didn't get the appreciation it deserves, especially when you see people merely complaining about the animation quality, I don't know why but I feel that a lot of newcomers in the medium are really spoiled by a lot of the big budget shows that pours sakuga scene every 5 minutes, or movies that took years to finish... I think they're really unaware on the process of making animations and the whole lot of steps and people involved around it, and put this unrealistically high bar for a budget (probably one-off) anime to those powered by million dollars franchise. I think the Animation in this is very pretty. With lots of style and colour. While I don't care for the Women Coach in the story, I like all the other Characters. It is the show that giving me the most enjoyment in the spring season. Oh ya I also don't seem them as an underdog team, an unrated team might be better said. They have 4 maybe 5 "Star players" on their team that not underdog that is a potential powerhouse team. Although most them are rookies. Onda who is a prodigy as claim, not always shown physique. Midori "Sossy" Soshizaki Known as number 3 middle school soccer player in Japan. And Suou the fasted player on the field. Then there is Eriko Tase the captain who clearly was the most skilled of her old team with hard work before these rookies joined. And maybe Aya(loud girl) Maybe not as trained as the other girls she does seem Natural Sports Gifted. |
| I agree with everyone that are saying the story of this is great. Imo, it has a better story than Your Lie in April and it's one of the few sports series that has female characters and actually gives them respect as athletes(or even as people - many sports anime treat their few female characters like shit). I personally don't mind the animation, but it's definitely the biggest problem(the soundtrack is also kind of bland). The animation is definitely cheap, with a lot of repeated shots and frames with few moving pieces. I think if this looked half as good as the other female sports anime that Lidenfilms did, Hanebado, the anime would probably be ~2.5 pts higher rated. |
StarFog said: The Sound Effect And music is so… Horrible, and the Tone Color For Animated Things Like People And Other Object is so Flat, Sadly, with Same Author Like Shingatsu Wo Kimi No Uso, Its Pretty Bad KimiUso was adapted by A1 pictures... |
 |
| It's fucking shit. Don't watch this for football, for characters, for animation, for CGDCT. Believe me, everything about this sucks. If you want to watch cute girls play sports just watch Puraore! It's 100% better. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sayonara Watashi no Cramer Episode 13 DiscussionStark700 - Jun 27, 2021 |
36 |
by BigBoyAdvance
»»
Mar 1, 3:29 AM |
|
» More seasons?Sleeping_wolf_ - Jun 20, 2021 |
8 |
by Torcher_
»»
Oct 8, 2022 8:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Sayonara Watashi no Cramer Episode 6 DiscussionStark700 - May 9, 2021 |
26 |
by samsince04
»»
Aug 14, 2022 3:29 PM |
|
Poll: » Sayonara Watashi no Cramer Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Apr 4, 2021 |
125 |
by samsince04
»»
Aug 13, 2022 11:35 AM |
|
Poll: » Sayonara Watashi no Cramer Episode 11 DiscussionStark700 - Jun 13, 2021 |
24 |
by Gvendoline
»»
Apr 16, 2022 4:59 PM |