 When I checked earliar in the morning after I heard the news the counter till the next chapter was still there, now its completely gone but still there for the other manga. R.I.P. to an incredible series, to bad the author had to be such a scumbag. Even though I love the series, I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10. Edit 8/10: I've decided to make my final score a 7/10 after careful consideration |
DillonAAug 10, 2020 5:33 PM
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
| You know it's possible to like the series while also condemning his actions right? |
 |
| Why can't people judge a work solely based on its own merits and demerits? Even if my favorite work was penned by Hitler, it would still be my favorite work. |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
| "I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10" -OMG how valiant. I think you get the point, I second #3 |
 |
ElneFasto said: "I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10" -OMG how valiant. I think you get the point, I second #3 KoyomiShinobu said: "Even though I love the series, I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10" Why? Don’t mistake me for some twitter warrior, act age was my only 10/10 manga. I’m giving act-age a 1/10 because the journey and the sum of its parts lead to absolutely nothing. It’s like you climb Mount Everest, you’re one day of climbing from the peak and one day you just decide to have a chopper pick you up. What was the point of everything up till now then, aside from that I also like thinking about what the manga could’ve been. The guy earlier said something like “even if hitler wrote my favorite work, I’d still consider it my favorite work”. cchigu said: Why can't people judge a work solely based on its own merits and demerits? Even if my favorite work was penned by Hitler, it would still be my favorite work. Well the problem here is that the journey is incomplete, Yonagi never truly conquered her flames, we never saw the completion of her journey nor anybody else’s in the show. Alone that would make my score a 4/10 but considering how the author betrayed the story he built up until now had to make me lower it. This is just how I feel, as I said earlier I ain’t some stupid bandwagon |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
| Do what you want and justify it how you like, but giving it a 1/10 because it got axed when your experience prior to this was a 10/10 is simply dumb. Even an incomplete work can be judged for what’s already available of it. It’s a disappointment and a shame what the author did, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that he had produced a genuinely good manga up till this point. |
Judgment526 said: Absolutely true.Do what you want and justify it how you like, but giving it a 1/10 because it got axed when your experience prior to this was a 10/10 is simply dumb. |
 |
Judgment526 said: Do what you want and justify it how you like, but giving it a 1/10 because it got axed when your experience prior to this was a 10/10 is simply dumb. Even an incomplete work can be judged for what’s already available of it. It’s a disappointment and a shame what the author did, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that he had produced a genuinely good manga up till this point. I mean for me the ending is the whole cake, if the ending isn’t good then the anime/manga isn’t good. I loved the first 15 eps of darling in the franxx, but those last 9 eps dropped it down to a 3. For me ending/cutting off an anime or ending it is like baking half a cake, what’s the point of the cake then? I will never forget Galactic Railroad arc or best girl Chiyoko. But at the end of the day what was it all for, the cake was never fully baked. |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
DillonA said: Judgment526 said: Do what you want and justify it how you like, but giving it a 1/10 because it got axed when your experience prior to this was a 10/10 is simply dumb. Even an incomplete work can be judged for what’s already available of it. It’s a disappointment and a shame what the author did, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that he had produced a genuinely good manga up till this point. I mean for me the ending is the whole cake, if the ending isn’t good then the anime/manga isn’t good. I loved the first 15 eps of darling in the franxx, but those last 9 eps dropped it down to a 3. For me ending/cutting off an anime or ending it is like baking half a cake, what’s the point of the cake then? I will never forget Galactic Railroad arc or best girl Chiyoko. But at the end of the day what was it all for, the cake was never fully baked. So basically the journey worth nothing if the ending is bad? I get that to an extend but I still think the Journey is worth more than the ending. I guess it's preference though if I was giving a manga a 10/10 and the ending was mad depending on how bad it is I would drop the score but the lowest I would go is a 5/10 the journey was too good to call the overall content bad. The journey is where majority of the content comes from, 95% of the journey was great the last 5% was bad equal extremely bad score for you don't make sense logically to me. An ending makes it break a series yes, but I feel we must remember how good the journey was which was the majority of your experience. In the end you are not being logical and making your emotions take over. |
| The author shouldn't really matter when judging an art. |
 |
DillonA said: Judgment526 said: Do what you want and justify it how you like, but giving it a 1/10 because it got axed when your experience prior to this was a 10/10 is simply dumb. Even an incomplete work can be judged for what’s already available of it. It’s a disappointment and a shame what the author did, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that he had produced a genuinely good manga up till this point. I mean for me the ending is the whole cake, if the ending isn’t good then the anime/manga isn’t good. I loved the first 15 eps of darling in the franxx, but those last 9 eps dropped it down to a 3. For me ending/cutting off an anime or ending it is like baking half a cake, what’s the point of the cake then? I will never forget Galactic Railroad arc or best girl Chiyoko. But at the end of the day what was it all for, the cake was never fully baked. You’re contradicting yourself. If there are parts of the story you loved that’s already not a 1/10. That score is reserved for something you consider to be irredeemable garbage. I rest my case though. In the end, I really don’t care what you rate it. Just pointing out your logical fallacy. |
hypercowbell said: So, you support the author molesting underaged girls?I support the author. |
 |
hypercowbell said: I support the author. YIKES, if you are not on red notice, police didn't do his job. |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
| This is why i judge a work based on overall enjoyment and how good the journey it gives through the entire story.. I mean don't get me wrong i've been there a lot where great manga/anime being butchered when it almost reach the climax of the story, i hate incomplete story and pretty sure everyone do, but giving the lowest rating possible just because the current situation and ignore the rest of great journey you've experienced till this point doesn't really sound logical at all to me.. But again it's your rating and none of my business, but just like other people here i only wanted to give my opinion about this as well.. |
 |
DillonA said: When I checked earliar in the morning after I heard the news the counter till the next chapter was still there, now its completely gone but still there for the other manga. R.I.P. to an incredible series, to bad the author had to be such a scumbag. Even though I love the series, I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10. Sorry for off topic but what app is that? |
KoyomiShinobu said: why not? It's ending prematurely and it will never have a conclusive ending"Even though I love the series, I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10" Why? |
| Twitter and it's consequences had been a disaster for the human race |
triton6783 said: Well, if any of those values do reflect in his/her work then that work would be criticized because of the values it has however if an author is an absolute scum but if his art is still all good stuff then it just doesn't matter what face wrote it.cythraul said: The author shouldn't really matter when judging an art. It depends on how ingrained an author's views are in his art works. If somebody is a racist/homophobe/abuser or any other type of scum, then it is likely that there will be some reflection of that in their work, even if it is subtle. |
|
Andromedaxy said: DillonA said: When I checked earliar in the morning after I heard the news the counter till the next chapter was still there, now its completely gone but still there for the other manga. R.I.P. to an incredible series, to bad the author had to be such a scumbag. Even though I love the series, I'm planning on making my final score a 1/10. Sorry for off topic but what app is that? its the shounen jump app, its a licensed app for most shounen jump series. You need a membership of $2 a month but you can read the first 3 chps and the latest 3 chps for free. For everything else you have to have a membership. The app is so good, if u got some spare cash and wanna read SJ chps in the best quality i reccomend it |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
I_am_sad_man said: Diginarcissa said: why not? It's ending prematurely and it will never have a conclusive ending Berserk, Hunter x Hunter, Vagabond... I rest my case. berserk and hxh are on hiatus, not cancelled |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
I_am_sad_man said: Miissed the point. People give those 3 scores of 9 - 10, based on what's been presented. The fact that the story itself may never have a conclusive ending or continuation is irrevelent because what they have experienced from such works thus far are equivalent to that a 9 or 10. A lack of ending doesn't suddenly make it a 1 lol. I think you're making a contradiction as well, hxh hasnt ended so people yearn to learn more, therefore the ratings are based on whats currently there. With act age you rate it as a whole, its over, canceled, finished. Therefore its completley different, its basically like comparing mha (a currently publishing manga) with something like FMA (a completed manga) |
| Aria is the greatest manga of all time |
DillonA said: its the shounen jump app, its a licensed app for most shounen jump series. You need a membership of $2 a month but you can read the first 3 chps and the latest 3 chps for free. For everything else you have to have a membership. The app is so good, if u got some spare cash and wanna read SJ chps in the best quality i reccomend it ty king I found it after a while but it's not available in my country |
Andromedaxy said: The "Shonen Jump" app is only available in the US but there is a global alternative named "mangaplus". It's the same thing but available Globally (or atleast in a lot of places)DillonA said: its the shounen jump app, its a licensed app for most shounen jump series. You need a membership of $2 a month but you can read the first 3 chps and the latest 3 chps for free. For everything else you have to have a membership. The app is so good, if u got some spare cash and wanna read SJ chps in the best quality i reccomend it ty king I found it after a while but it's not available in my country |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Afloo said: The "Shonen Jump" app is only available in the US but there is a global alternative named "mangaplus". It's the same thing but available Globally (or atleast in a lot of places) Ik I've had mangaplus for a while but ty man |
More topics from this board
» Fanmade epilogue ending of Act-agejohnknight649 - Nov 22, 2023 |
8 |
by Haigen
»»
Feb 22, 5:53 PM |
|
» It's been two years...zkl_ - Aug 10, 2022 |
14 |
by kfmc
»»
Aug 16, 2023 11:51 PM |
|
Poll: » Act-age Chapter 123 DiscussionKuma - Aug 11, 2020 |
35 |
by TheFalconZ21
»»
Jul 20, 2023 11:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Act-age Chapter 40 DiscussionStark700 - Nov 29, 2018 |
4 |
by TheFalconZ21
»»
Jul 19, 2023 2:42 PM |
|
» Do you think this manga can be revived/continued?Shafwan_Dito - May 28, 2023 |
4 |
by Swagernator
»»
Jun 20, 2023 8:40 AM |