Forum Settings
Forums

Why did the Seinen demographic change so much?

New
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »
Dec 11, 2019 8:51 AM

Offline
Apr 2010
3745
A series for adults doesn't necessarily need to have anything sexual or violent. Sometimes the theme is enough.


Dec 11, 2019 9:06 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Red-Berry-Vodka said:
@Daniel_Naumov @alshu @inim is this seinen? if not then idk anymore x.x
Nope, it's definitely not seinen. Seinen is not "like shounen, just with more tits and gore", that is the immature take on the term. There are countless ultra-violent OVAs from the last century. Look no further than Violence Jack, Overfiend, or Genocyber. While all of them are certainly not for kids, they are not mature at all. They are just exploitation flicks. Seinen means "adult", in that adult problems (e.g. alcoholism, marriage, non-binary sexuality, heading a family, mental health etc.) are dealt with. And of course it allows laxer presentation of sexuality and violence, but is not about them.

Dec 11, 2019 9:07 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34597
That's easy, it never changed to exclusively cute girls so don't pretend it has. Problem solved.


I love threads based on false premises, they're so easy to reply to.
I probably regret this post by now.
Dec 11, 2019 9:12 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
@inim Overfiend (Uratsukidoji) IS seinen; it's a freaking hentai series. lol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji

Apparently the anime added hentai stuff though.



Dec 11, 2019 9:16 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
Seinen be like: I shot this man, holy flip I'm so mature. I shot another man I'm even more mature. What is this? Demonic rape, and relentless torture? Say no more I'm Seinen incarnate.
Dec 11, 2019 9:16 AM
Offline
Apr 2016
4788
Red-Berry-Vodka said:
@Daniel_Naumov @alshu @inim is this seinen? if not then idk anymore x.x



Anime Vampire wars. the first minutes kick ass, i've stated that it fully reminds me of Golgo 13 but shortened, its shortness makes it inferior to the later u_u

why is considered as mystery noir?

About what that unexpected inim said. "Seinen = lose wahmen and violence" is a retarder's definition. Do not get fooled. If it does not deal with something serious and problematic, instead just being a lot of fighting, it is not "seinen". It's... regrettable.
Re:formed
Dec 11, 2019 9:24 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Chiibi said:
@inim Overfiend (Uratsukidoji) IS seinen; it's a freaking hentai series. lol
Anything gets a hentai tag when genitalia, bodily fluids, and/or penetration are shown. That's why the likes of Overfiend, A Kite, Mezzoforte and Belladonna of Sadness are technically tagged hentai. Good luck trying to fap on either, though. Otoh, soft-porn (of degrees) like Sleeping with Hinako, Eromanga-sensei, Aki-Sora, the OVAs of the mainstream ecchi francises (DxD, Sister New Devil, Love-Ru etc.), and 80s/90s OVA such as Violence Jack. The latter gets away without an ecchi tag even, while it graphically depicts rape. But: Without showing genitals and bodily fluids. Phew, so much better.

Edit: Since when Hentai implies Seinen or vice versa? It simply is not even related.
inimDec 11, 2019 9:29 AM

Dec 11, 2019 9:28 AM

Offline
Nov 2017
5678
Doesn't seinen just mean "adult men" in the sense of "we're trying to primarily sell this to adult men"? Like, it's not even a genre but a target demographic exactly like shounen, shoujo and josei? Adult men can like a wide variety of stuff, so there is a wide variety of stuff made for them. I suppose that doesn't explain the shift away from violence to cute girls - if it ever really happened in the scale implied - but that could just be a case of changing trends, just like how Hollywood had a brief love affair with gritty reboots of classic stories.
Dec 11, 2019 9:31 AM

Offline
Jan 2018
1265
I'm really confused on when seinen became CGDCT, are you referring to manga? I have barely seen anything that falls under that scope within seinen in anime.
What a beautiful Duwang
Dec 11, 2019 9:37 AM
Offline
Apr 2016
4788
Vilkku92 said:
Doesn't seinen just mean "adult men" in the sense of "we're trying to primarily sell this to adult men"? Like, it's not even a genre but a target demographic exactly like shounen, shoujo and josei? Adult men can like a wide variety of stuff, so there is a wide variety of stuff made for them. I suppose that doesn't explain the shift away from violence to cute girls - if it ever really happened in the scale implied - but that could just be a case of changing trends, just like how Hollywood had a brief love affair with gritty reboots of classic stories.

While the translation is "Young Man", the genre itself is not for men only... unless you subtly mean only men are receptive to serious, complex stories and philosophy. In this case, well... let me shake your hand. And my head.
Re:formed
Dec 11, 2019 9:38 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
inim said:
Chiibi said:
@inim Overfiend (Uratsukidoji) IS seinen; it's a freaking hentai series. lol
Anything gets a hentai tag when genitalia, bodily fluids, and/or penetration are shown. That's why the likes of Overfiend, A Kite, Mezzoforte and Belladonna of Sadness are technically tagged hentai. Good luck trying to fap on either, though. Otoh, soft-porn (of degrees) like Sleeping with Hinako, Eromanga-sensei, Aki-Sora, the OVAs of the mainstream ecchi francises (DxD, Sister New Devil, Love-Ru etc.), and 80s/90s OVA such as Violence Jack. The latter gets away without an ecchi tag even, while it graphically depicts rape. But: Without showing genitals and bodily fluids. Phew, so much better.

Edit: Since when Hentai implies Seinen or vice versa? It simply is not even related.


Because "seinen" means "adult male" and hentai is only made for adult males lol It sure as hell ain't made for the shounen demographic...immature as it is.

Anyway, the manga of Uratsukidoji is labeled 'seinen', even if you think it's not.



Dec 11, 2019 9:39 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
do you mean shounen? I dont know a single seinen with cute girls doing cute things unless you count stuff like monster musume and seikon no qwaser as "cute"
would be great if u could give examples too instead of just starting a thread without any for who knows which reason, I mean why do you even bother making threads when u obviously dont even care enough to respond to people.
the majority of seinen are still violent and the stuff with girls is usually about alcohol or sex
Dec 11, 2019 9:43 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Chiibi said:
inim said:
Anything gets a hentai tag when genitalia, bodily fluids, and/or penetration are shown. (...) Since when Hentai implies Seinen or vice versa? It simply is not even related.
Because "seinen" means "adult male" and hentai is only made for adult males lol It sure as hell ain't made for the shounen demographic...immature as it is.
Yea, we all know that teenagers never watch pornos. And all men older than twenty are raging perverts. And all of them love tits and ass, none of them is gay or asexual. Your world view is mildly amusing.
Chiibi said:

Anyway, the manga of Uratsukidoji is labeled 'seinen', even if you think it's not.
No, it is not tagged seinen on MAL. Why would it, it's just horror/exploitation. https://myanimelist.net/manga/11821/Urotsukidouji

Dec 11, 2019 9:50 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
inim said:
Chiibi said:
Because "seinen" means "adult male" and hentai is only made for adult males lol It sure as hell ain't made for the shounen demographic...immature as it is.
Yea, we all know that teenagers never watch pornos. And all men older than twenty are raging perverts. And all of them love tits and ass, none of them is gay or asexual. Your world view is mildly amusing.
Chiibi said:

Anyway, the manga of Uratsukidoji is labeled 'seinen', even if you think it's not.
No, it is not tagged seinen on MAL. Why would it, it's just horror/exploitation. https://myanimelist.net/manga/11821/Urotsukidouji


The f*ck, man? You don't need to be so condescending; I'm just telling you who it's MADE for, not who it APPEALS to.

Who cares about what MAL tags stuff as? MAL doesn't always know either. MAL didn't know that Angels of Death was josei until I said something lol

Wiki says Urotsukidoji IS seinen, see?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji

Just in case your ass is too lazy to click the link, I will quote it:

Written by Toshio Maeda
Published by Wani Magazine
English publisher
NA
Fakku
Demographic Seinen
Magazine Manga Erotopia
Original run 1 December 1986 – 1 April 1989
Volumes 6


Here's the Japanese stating "OVA aimed at adults" from its Japanese wiki page

成人向けOVA

You need to do research on more than one website lol.




Dec 11, 2019 9:52 AM
Offline
Apr 2016
4788
Girls girls calm down the first to turn the stove on wins this stupid piece of argument.
Re:formed
Dec 11, 2019 9:58 AM

Offline
Nov 2017
5678
Daniel_Naumov said:
Vilkku92 said:
Doesn't seinen just mean "adult men" in the sense of "we're trying to primarily sell this to adult men"? Like, it's not even a genre but a target demographic exactly like shounen, shoujo and josei? Adult men can like a wide variety of stuff, so there is a wide variety of stuff made for them. I suppose that doesn't explain the shift away from violence to cute girls - if it ever really happened in the scale implied - but that could just be a case of changing trends, just like how Hollywood had a brief love affair with gritty reboots of classic stories.

While the translation is "Young Man", the genre itself is not for men only... unless you subtly mean only men are receptive to serious, complex stories and philosophy. In this case, well... let me shake your hand. And my head.

I did not mean it that way nor did I mean that only adult men can like seinen. I simply meant that seinen is primarily aimed at men, just like shoujo is primarily aimed at teenaged girls and josei - whose existence this entire thread seems to have forgotten - is primarily aimed at adult women.

I do find it a bit weird, though, that many people in this thread seem to have taken "seinen" to be some kind of a value statement, where something aimed at adults must be "serious" and "complex" and if it isn't it can't be called seinen. I've always seen "seinen" as a descriptive term, meaning that something is either aimed at an adult male audience or has been published in a seinen magazine, neither of which have anything to do with the content of the work.
Dec 11, 2019 9:59 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Chiibi said:
inim said:
No, it is not tagged seinen on MAL. Why would it, it's just horror/exploitation. https://myanimelist.net/manga/11821/Urotsukidouji

Wiki says Urotsukidoji IS seinen, see? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji
You love moving goal posts, don't you? Anyway, why we keep discussing degrees of sex and violence, hentai and shounen in 90% of this thread? None of that is related to seinen.

Seinen is much more about the likes of Monster, Planetes, Hourou Musuko, and Berserk than any of those. Seinen stories are stories about adults doing adult things and having adult problems, not a more violent form of shounen or lesser form of hentai like many of the posters here use the word.

Dec 11, 2019 10:08 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
inim said:
Chiibi said:

Wiki says Urotsukidoji IS seinen, see? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji
You love moving goal posts, don't you? Anyway, why we keep discussing degrees of sex and violence, hentai and shounen in 90% of this thread? None of that is related to seinen.

Seinen is much more about the likes of Monster, Planetes, Hourou Musuko, and Berserk than any of those. Seinen stories are stories about adults doing adult things and having adult problems, not a more violent form of shounen or lesser form of hentai like many of the posters here use the word.


I don't know what you mean by "moving goal posts" but your attitude seems to be "Seinen anime can only include mature anime by MY definition of 'maturity', not official sources that state something I hate is 'seinen'.

Which is bloody ridiculous. I don't claim the crappy shoujo I hate "are no longer shoujo" just because I hate them. If the manga runs in a magazine for a certain demographic, that is what you call it.

That's how it works.



Dec 11, 2019 10:10 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34597
Chiibi said:
inim said:
Yea, we all know that teenagers never watch pornos. And all men older than twenty are raging perverts. And all of them love tits and ass, none of them is gay or asexual. Your world view is mildly amusing.
No, it is not tagged seinen on MAL. Why would it, it's just horror/exploitation. https://myanimelist.net/manga/11821/Urotsukidouji


The f*ck, man? You don't need to be so condescending; I'm just telling you who it's MADE for, not who it APPEALS to.

Who cares about what MAL tags stuff as? MAL doesn't always know either. MAL didn't know that Angels of Death was josei until I said something lol

Wiki says Urotsukidoji IS seinen, see?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji

Just in case your ass is too lazy to click the link, I will quote it:

Written by Toshio Maeda
Published by Wani Magazine
English publisher
NA
Fakku
Demographic Seinen
Magazine Manga Erotopia
Original run 1 December 1986 – 1 April 1989
Volumes 6


Here's the Japanese stating "OVA aimed at adults" from its Japanese wiki page

成人向けOVA

You need to do research on more than one website lol.



I'd trust MAL over wiki at least when it comes to stuff like this.

From what I can see there seem to be specific magazines that publish hentai stories, like this 'Manga Erotopia' magazine. They don't seem to be the same as Seinen Magazines, because those don't publish pornographic content that gets a hentai tag. I don't think you would find something as pornographic as the show in question in a random seinen magazine, only in specialized 'ero' magazines like 'Manga Erotopia'. And since the demographic tags are purely based on what magazine a series was published in you can make the argument that being from a hentai magazine and not a normal seinen magazine gives it a different target audience/demographic.

Technically that target audience would still be adult males, but a much more narrow and specific range of adult males compared to normal seinen magazines. It's not MADE for every adult male out there, only for hentai readers/watchers.

What you're saying is kinda like saying the target audience for hardcore violent porn is identical with the viewers of Breaking Bad or any other adult-targeted series or movie. But it's really much more niche to publish something in a porn-based magazine than in a regular seinen one and that's the main difference between being 'Seinen' and being 'Hentai'.

In Hentai it is 'implied' that it is aimed at adult males (so double tagging them with both is not necessary), but the tag specifies the target audience way more than 'seinen' ever could so they can't be user interchangeably. Both have their distinct meaning and there's no reason to conflate them and imply that a graphic hentai like Urotsukidouji is aimed at the entire adult male gender and has as broad of an appeal as something like Monster or Mushishi and should have the same demographic tag as those.

Idk what you think of males and our relationship to porn, but I promise you most of us are not into the kind of graphic porn that Urotsukidouji provides and whoever made that anime/manga was aware of that fact and only targeted it at a niche and not the entire adult male demographic, like a seinen tag would imply.
I probably regret this post by now.
Dec 11, 2019 10:15 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
Pullman said:
Chiibi said:


The f*ck, man? You don't need to be so condescending; I'm just telling you who it's MADE for, not who it APPEALS to.

Who cares about what MAL tags stuff as? MAL doesn't always know either. MAL didn't know that Angels of Death was josei until I said something lol

Wiki says Urotsukidoji IS seinen, see?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urotsukid%C5%8Dji

Just in case your ass is too lazy to click the link, I will quote it:



Here's the Japanese stating "OVA aimed at adults" from its Japanese wiki page

成人向けOVA

You need to do research on more than one website lol.



I'd trust MAL over wiki at least when it comes to stuff like this.


The English Wiki, maybe, the Japanese version?

Definitely not. MAL doesn't even have the demographic listed for every anime in the list. Why? Cause they don't freaking know.

*bangs head against wall*

I'm not saying "ALL ADULT MALES ENJOY PORN LOL", I am saying "hentai for guys is illegal to be labeled and sold as "shounen", therefore it can only be labeled as "seinen".



Dec 11, 2019 10:17 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Chiibi said:
inim said:
Seinen is much more about the likes of Monster, Planetes, Hourou Musuko, and Berserk than any of those. Seinen stories are stories about adults doing adult things and having adult problems, not a more violent form of shounen or lesser form of hentai like many of the posters here use the word.
your attitude seems to be "Seinen anime can only include mature anime by MY definition of 'maturity', not official sources that state something I hate is 'seinen'.
My point is that in many of the postings here "seinen" is reduced to "more sex and gore". Which is not true, one can earn a R+ or Rx rating without remotely dealing with adult problems by simply having exploitaiton imagery and stories.

Adult males happen to be as diverse, if not more diverse, than teenagers. Why they buy a Seinen manga and not yet another exploitation OVA? Because as an adult, you really can't identify with those teenage heros in most anime. The problems of coming of age are many years or decades in the past. Don't get me wrong, this is not a "better" or "worse" assesment, just a "different" assesment. Exploitation is for all ages, teenage boys love their share of tits and gore as much (or as little) as any other male. But stories about problems real adults have, with real adults as MCs - that's seinen.

Dec 11, 2019 10:20 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
inim said:
My point is that in many of the postings here "seinen" is reduced to "more sex and gore". Which is not true


Yes, I am aware of that.

But stories about problems real adults have, with real adults as MCs - that's seinen.


Adults don't have to be MCs for it to be seinen though. It's safer to say "there are no rules" for what makes seinen "seinen", other than the magazine it's marketed to.



Dec 11, 2019 10:29 AM

Offline
Nov 2017
5678
inim said:
Adult males happen to be as diverse, if not more diverse, than teenagers. Why they buy a Seinen manga and not yet another exploitation OVA? Because as an adult, you really can't identify with those teenage heros in most anime, and the problems of coming to age are many years or decades in the past. Don't get me wrong, this is not a "better" or "worse" assesment, just a "different" assesment. Exploitation is for all ages, teenage boys love their share of tits and gore as much (or as little) as any other male. But stories about problems real adults have, with real adults as MCs - that's seinen.

Don't seinen series include exploitation series as well, though? I certainly remember seeing a fair amount of gratuitous violence and nudity in some seinen series. There are many different flavors of adult oriented content, almost all of which can be found within seinen stories.
Dec 11, 2019 10:34 AM
Offline
Jul 2017
8
Nostalgik said:
Breadwinnerr said:
Not adding anything to the topic💩 but could some of you give me some Seinen anime recommendations, I’m in a drought. Something that focuses on largely mature themes - I really like anime like that.
(Kenpuu Denki) Berserk, Vinland Saga, Monster, Rainbow, Houseki no Kuni.

Also, I suggest you start using the rating scale's numbers below 7

Bardees said:
Some great seinen anime
Monster
Fate zero
Vinland saga
3 gatsu no lion
Rainbow
Kaiji
While mature, Fate isn't a seinen.

But if it's not to recommend only seinen, I'd have to put Kaiba in my recommendations

Mod edit: Merged double post. Please use the edit button.
Sorry, I messed up.
You know Fate Zero is different than other fate series, I mean we have adult main characters and more complex, so it got me confused.
Dec 11, 2019 10:36 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Vilkku92 said:
inim said:
Exploitation is for all ages, teenage boys love their share of tits and gore as much (or as little) as any other male. But stories about problems real adults have, with real adults as MCs - that's seinen.

Don't seinen series include exploitation series as well, though? I certainly remember seeing a fair amount of gratuitous violence and nudity in some seinen series. There are many different flavors of adult oriented content, almost all of which can be found within seinen stories.
According to mal-badges, I've watched more seinen shows than any other demographic genre, by far. The list posted earlier in this thread has most of them. Scanning trough it, not even 15% of the shows have increased sex and violence levels. Thus I tend to say seinen of course can use any level of exploitation, because it targets adults. But more often than not, it doesn't. If you check the shows, many of them are historical, comedy, thrillers and whatnot. What is the most common denominator, in my view, is that the protagonists are usually adults, and that there is no good-evil contrast as in shounen. Most characters have shades of gray.

Edit: 15% when not considering the "Soft Porn" block, of course, i.e. the shows which actually try to tell a story.
inimDec 11, 2019 10:44 AM

Dec 11, 2019 10:46 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
Bardees said:
Nostalgik said:
(Kenpuu Denki) Berserk, Vinland Saga, Monster, Rainbow, Houseki no Kuni.

Also, I suggest you start using the rating scale's numbers below 7

While mature, Fate isn't a seinen.

But if it's not to recommend only seinen, I'd have to put Kaiba in my recommendations

Mod edit: Merged double post. Please use the edit button.
Sorry, I messed up.
You know Fate Zero is different than other fate series, I mean we have adult main characters and more complex, so it got me confused.


Fate Zero's manga is indeed seinen audience...if that helps any. I would think the anime would be the same.

The manga runs in this magazine:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Young_Ace



Dec 11, 2019 11:05 AM

Offline
Nov 2017
5678
inim said:
Vilkku92 said:

Don't seinen series include exploitation series as well, though? I certainly remember seeing a fair amount of gratuitous violence and nudity in some seinen series. There are many different flavors of adult oriented content, almost all of which can be found within seinen stories.
According to mal-badges, I've watched more seinen shows than any other demographic genre, by far. The list posted earlier in this thread has most of them. Scanning trough it, not even 15% of the shows have increased sex and violence levels. Thus I tend to say seinen of course can use any level of exploitation, because it targets adults. But more often than not, it doesn't. If you check the shows, many of them are historical, comedy, thrillers and whatnot. What is the most common denominator, in my view, is that the protagonists are usually adults, and that there is no good-evil contrast as in shounen. Most characters have shades of gray.

Edit: 15% when not considering the "Soft Porn" block, of course, i.e. the shows which actually try to tell a story.

That 15% plus soft porn (which does count) do exist, though, and you've been kind of implying that they don't or that they shouldn't count. Of course they aren't anywhere near all that the seinen demographic has or in any way representative of the demographic as a whole, but they are part of it.
Dec 11, 2019 11:22 AM
Offline
Jul 2017
8
Daniel_Naumov said:
I would like to note that
Bardees said:


Vinland saga

is not really a "seinen". It transcends all those vague "genres" and is a story much bigger in scale than, say
Bardees said:

Fate zero

which is not even a "seinen" and centers itself around several kids in a power-fantasy. With slight twisting of myths.

For your information, Fate zero characters are adults not teenagers
Dec 11, 2019 12:26 PM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
Bardees said:
Daniel_Naumov said:
I would like to note that
is not really a "seinen". It transcends all those vague "genres" and is a story much bigger in scale than, say

which is not even a "seinen" and centers itself around several kids in a power-fantasy. With slight twisting of myths.
For your information, Fate zero characters are adults not teenagers

Let's talk about lowered expectations. Just because for a change not everybody in a show is a 15 year old highschool boy doesn't make it an adult show. Fate/Zero is not a mature show, it is a superhero wishfullfillment show in which some roles are cast with adults. Nothing in their actions is particularily adult, they could be replaced with teens without hurting the plot.

While the tin says Vinland Saga is a seinen show, every character starting with Thor{fin, s, kell} has a horrible shounen design. If it wasn't for Askeladd and King Canute, I'd long dropped. Thorfinn is the epitome of a teenage edgelord, angry, angsty, confused. He has near-superpowers, can jump 5 meters high, and so on. That said, selling to both demographics is a smart move.

Long story short, neither Fate/Zero not Vinland saga is a fully mature and adult show. They are both in a gray area between shounen and seinen, in my book.

Dec 11, 2019 12:46 PM
Tail On!

Offline
Aug 2018
2221
Jus1294 said:
I'm really confused on when seinen became CGDCT, are you referring to manga? I have barely seen anything that falls under that scope within seinen in anime.


Sakura Trick
Kiniro Mosaic
Non Non Biyori
Urara Meirochou
K-On!
Slow Start
Yuyushiki
Sansha Sanyou
Hidamari Sketch
A-Channel
Machikado Mazoku
New Game
Anima Yell
and next season's Koisuru Asteroid to name a few
Dec 11, 2019 12:51 PM

Offline
Nov 2007
9158
Because CGDCT is healing.

Just check this:


Unless you are an angsty/edgy shounen fan or a feminist, this will put a smile on your face without seeing the actual content.

The Japanese adult society is tired of their monotonous life and at the end of a tiring day or week of work or college, they want something soothing and non-violence. In a street interview shown in NHK World, it revealed the glaring statistics. The Japanese adult men (college students and working) said they prefer to watch/read something calming because it helps them prepare better for what they 'have to' do (emphasizing on "have to") and not 'want to' do.

And for older women (college and working), they want to see live-action adaptation of of cute shoujo manga instead of josei, the latter which deals with more mature romance making them identify with real life. But they want to experience the pure innocence of falling in love for the first time when they were younger and an idealistic romance instead of what they are experiencing or have had experienced irl.

Both male and female groups also identified themselves of enjoying fluffy stuff - the most popular being videos of kittens being kittens - if that helps understand the situation of their lives.
Stay Home and Wash Your Hands.
Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones.
Protect Your Community and Help Defeat
Coronavirus.
Dec 11, 2019 12:57 PM

Offline
Feb 2010
34597
shanimebib said:
Because CGDCT is healing.

Just check this:


Unless you are an angsty/edgy shounen fan or a feminist, this will put a smile on your face without seeing the actual content.


I love many CGDCT anime, but gochuumon was not one of them, I found it boring with characters I didn't care for and designs that didn't really appeal to me, so I'd say that's a bad example if you were going for universal appeal. K-on or Love Live would have been better choices imo.

also no idea what feminism has to do with any of that...
I probably regret this post by now.
Dec 11, 2019 1:03 PM
Tail On!

Offline
Aug 2018
2221
Pullman said:
shanimebib said:
Because CGDCT is healing.

Just check this:


Unless you are an angsty/edgy shounen fan or a feminist, this will put a smile on your face without seeing the actual content.


I love many CGDCT anime, but gochuumon was not one of them, I found it boring with characters I didn't care for and designs that didn't really appeal to me, so I'd say that's a bad example if you were going for universal appeal. K-on or Love Live would have been better choices imo.

also no idea what feminism has to do with any of that...


Didn't care too much for those, Non Non Biyori is by far the best of the popular CGDCT
Dec 11, 2019 1:10 PM

Offline
Jan 2018
1265
Roevhaal said:
Jus1294 said:
I'm really confused on when seinen became CGDCT, are you referring to manga? I have barely seen anything that falls under that scope within seinen in anime.


Sakura Trick
Kiniro Mosaic
Non Non Biyori
Urara Meirochou
K-On!
Slow Start
Yuyushiki
Sansha Sanyou
Hidamari Sketch
A-Channel
Machikado Mazoku
New Game
Anima Yell
and next season's Koisuru Asteroid to name a few


K-on being a seinen was news to me lol. Would've never guessed it was published in a seinen.
What a beautiful Duwang
Dec 11, 2019 1:10 PM

Offline
Feb 2010
34597
Roevhaal said:
Pullman said:


I love many CGDCT anime, but gochuumon was not one of them, I found it boring with characters I didn't care for and designs that didn't really appeal to me, so I'd say that's a bad example if you were going for universal appeal. K-on or Love Live would have been better choices imo.

also no idea what feminism has to do with any of that...


Didn't care too much for those, Non Non Biyori is by far the best of the popular CGDCT


well, we can at least on NNB being fantastic :>.

But K-on was the one that got me into the genre and I went into it not really expecting to like it that much but ended up a converted fan of cute girl slice of life shows. That's the power of K-On.

But mainly I named those two series because they are probably the most popular and successful ones with the most universal appeal just based on how popular they became in Japan and around the globe. As much as I love NNB, it's obscure in comparison.
I probably regret this post by now.
Dec 11, 2019 1:19 PM

Offline
Nov 2007
9158
Pullman said:
shanimebib said:
Because CGDCT is healing.

Just check this:


Unless you are an angsty/edgy shounen fan or a feminist, this will put a smile on your face without seeing the actual content.


I love many CGDCT anime, but gochuumon was not one of them, I found it boring with characters I didn't care for and designs that didn't really appeal to me, so I'd say that's a bad example if you were going for universal appeal. K-on or Love Live would have been better choices imo.

also no idea what feminism has to do with any of that...


Gochiusa is one of the top sellers in Japan outside the ground-breakers. The intention was not to "attract" people with an example which is why I said "without seeing the actual content". We are discussing why there's been a shift in Japan in recent decade. Picking ARIA, K-On!, GnP, LL would make little sense as they are too big names to make them into examples of overall CGDCT.

As for the second part, it seems you don't frequent many boards. I have seen feminists branding CGDCT as selling young/underage female characters as object of adoration for older men like it is something filthy. Not that they are "entirely" wrong as they got the object and the subject right, but the hate they spread for their stupid interest is ridiculous. They are people with double standards because they never say anything against a bulk of stories for Josei demographic with college/high school boy and office lady/ widowed women OR all those TL manga for young women where the guys are literally rapists and that's the whole selling point, but since those are catered for women, they never make an issue out of it as much as they make out of stuff made for men. Thanks to LL, which has the largest female fanbase, was a slap on their face and they have toned down jumping on CGDCT at every opportunity as hyenas.
shanimebibDec 11, 2019 1:22 PM
Stay Home and Wash Your Hands.
Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones.
Protect Your Community and Help Defeat
Coronavirus.
Dec 11, 2019 1:21 PM
Tail On!

Offline
Aug 2018
2221
Jus1294 said:
Roevhaal said:


Sakura Trick
Kiniro Mosaic
Non Non Biyori
Urara Meirochou
K-On!
Slow Start
Yuyushiki
Sansha Sanyou
Hidamari Sketch
A-Channel
Machikado Mazoku
New Game
Anima Yell
and next season's Koisuru Asteroid to name a few


K-on being a seinen was news to me lol. Would've never guessed it was published in a seinen.

All the Manga Time Kirara magazines are seinen and they are pretty much the go to for CGDCT
Dec 11, 2019 1:36 PM
Offline
Sep 2013
1346
Roevhaal said:


All the Manga Time Kirara magazines are seinen and they are pretty much the go to for CGDCT


Kirara doesn't have seinen definition, the publisher only call it moe-4koma magazine. If you want to know if a magazine is seinen or not, look up Japanese wikipedia. Seinen magazines are described as "seinen" while niche genre manga magazines aren't described as seinen, only mentioning they have male(or female) readers.


For example, all major seinen magazines such as young jump, young sunday, young magazine are defined as seinen magazines while wikipedia about Kirara only saying it has male readers.
umashikanekoDec 11, 2019 1:48 PM
Dec 11, 2019 1:44 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
shanimebib said:
I have seen feminists branding CGDCT as selling young/underage female characters as object of adoration for older men like it is something filthy.


That's just because they are mentally retarded SJWs who cannot seem to tell the difference between real girls and fictitious girls. :/ SJWs just love to ruin everything that is not aimed at them...and even if things are aimed at them, "they're still not accurate enough" or some shit.



Dec 11, 2019 1:45 PM

Offline
Jan 2018
1265
Roevhaal said:
Jus1294 said:


K-on being a seinen was news to me lol. Would've never guessed it was published in a seinen.

All the Manga Time Kirara magazines are seinen and they are pretty much the go to for CGDCT


Neat to know, but I still find OP's take saying seinen nowadays is exclusively CGDCT goofy
What a beautiful Duwang
Dec 11, 2019 1:50 PM

Offline
Sep 2018
1273
The reason being that anime is more mainstream now and family friendly stuff makes more money.

Even something like Vinland saga is not as dark or realistic in its adaptation compared to the manga. Some more absurd action scenes and some more cute king boi scenes.

Seinen is also a demographic and in Japan many adult people watch Cute Girls doing stuff sooo some stuff is maybe targeted at those spicy guys.
Dec 11, 2019 2:37 PM

Offline
Jul 2019
363
AkaneManiac said:
Ok, fellas, time for some real talk here!

When did the demographic that was known for extreme violence and sexual content turn into exclusively cute girls doing cute things, and why do you think that happened? Which one do you prefer? Was it a good thing?

I'm genuinely curious about this topic!


As far as I'm concerned that is a major improvement. The less toxic masculinity the better.



I would love for you to show me examples of those "Evil" feminist you keep talking about.
You do realize that shows like K-On! were very popular among girls and that it was directed by a woman.
There is no reason why girls couldn't enjoy CGDCT in fact a lot of them do, just like many Shojo and Yuri stuff is watched by boys.
Feminist generally have a problem with toxic masculinity and oversexualization and objectification of women.
AnimeFeministDec 11, 2019 2:59 PM


Never explain,
Never retract,
Never apologize
Just get the thing done
And let them howl
Dec 11, 2019 2:44 PM

Offline
Jan 2018
1265
AnimeFeminist said:
AkaneManiac said:
Ok, fellas, time for some real talk here!

When did the demographic that was known for extreme violence and sexual content turn into exclusively cute girls doing cute things, and why do you think that happened? Which one do you prefer? Was it a good thing?

I'm genuinely curious about this topic!


As far as I'm concerned that is a major improvement. The less toxic masculinity the better.


Oh jolly, the top tier troll account has joined the thread
What a beautiful Duwang
Dec 11, 2019 2:46 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
inim said:


Edit: Since when Hentai implies Seinen or vice versa? It simply is not even related.


Surrealist humor and hentai go often together

Watch Cream Lemon, episode "To Moriyama Best Hit - It May Be So"

inim said:
Chiibi said:
your attitude seems to be "Seinen anime can only include mature anime by MY definition of 'maturity', not official sources that state something I hate is 'seinen'.
My point is that in many of the postings here "seinen" is reduced to "more sex and gore". Which is not true, one can earn a R+ or Rx rating without remotely dealing with adult problems by simply having exploitaiton imagery and stories.

Adult males happen to be as diverse, if not more diverse, than teenagers. Why they buy a Seinen manga and not yet another exploitation OVA? Because as an adult, you really can't identify with those teenage heros in most anime. The problems of coming of age are many years or decades in the past. Don't get me wrong, this is not a "better" or "worse" assesment, just a "different" assesment. Exploitation is for all ages, teenage boys love their share of tits and gore as much (or as little) as any other male. But stories about problems real adults have, with real adults as MCs - that's seinen.


Sometimes MAL is not accurate, same for other sites. Eg this series is adapted from a seinen manga, yet anime is labelled as drama and slice of life

https://myanimelist.net/anime/1083/Human_Crossing?q=Human%20cross

Unfortunately the manga author is ignored in the West. His work explore the business world of Japan like no other manga
https://myanimelist.net/people/5813/Kenshi_Hirokane
Dec 12, 2019 12:45 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
I think you need to show examples and statistics. I can't think of any seinen anime off the top of my head that is cute girls doing cute things from this decade, but I can think of plenty of seinen anime that aren't that:

One Punch Man
Tokyo Ghoul
Parasyte Maximum
Erased
Btooom!
Prison School
Bungou Stray Dogs
Blood Lad

And plenty more. I don't think a majority of seinen anime are focused on bloody action and sexual content:

Blood Lad
Erased
Monster
Sakamoto Desu Ga?
Kaguya-Sama
Scum's Wish
Dec 12, 2019 12:49 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
4466
RealTheAbsurdist said:
I can't think of any seinen anime off the top of my head that is cute girls doing cute things from this decade
I used anime+ to compile a list of seinen's I watched, and it had three CGDCT with that MAL tag: Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou, Konohana Kitan, and the Non Non Biyori francise.

Dec 12, 2019 3:23 AM
Offline
Sep 2018
136
AkaneManiac said:
Ok, fellas, time for some real talk here!

When did the demographic that was known for extreme violence and sexual content turn into exclusively cute girls doing cute things, and why do you think that happened? Which one do you prefer? Was it a good thing?

I'm genuinely curious about this topic!


I feel like the "old school Seinen" is making a come back. Vinland Saga for example had been killing it this year.
Dec 12, 2019 4:30 AM

Offline
May 2018
10523
GroovySensei said:
Vinland Saga for example had been killing it this year.

Which is surprisingly...or maybe not so much surprisingly...very shounen-ish.
Dec 12, 2019 4:51 AM
Offline
Sep 2018
136
alshu said:
GroovySensei said:
Vinland Saga for example had been killing it this year.

Which is surprisingly...or maybe not so much surprisingly...very shounen-ish.


I mean, a little bit. Only because as a viewer you're watching Thorfinn grow up. Other than that, hes a child thrown into adult situations and having to kill in order to survive.
Dec 12, 2019 5:19 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564612
Don't us grown male adults like women? Assuming that heterosexuals count
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »

More topics from this board

» Criticism You Don't Understand.

Alpha_1_Zero - 5 hours ago

4 by TRC_Randy »»
7 minutes ago

» Have you ever divorced your waifu? (ex-waifu)

EndlessMaria - Aug 12, 2022

41 by Maou_heika »»
9 minutes ago

Poll: » Have y'all seen Rainbow?

MillerEvans23 - 1 hour ago

5 by TRC_Randy »»
13 minutes ago

Poll: » What's with all the hate from the MAL community towards Anitubers? ( 1 2 )

Alpha_1_Zero - Apr 25

66 by PlasticRobot »»
13 minutes ago

» What anime brought you to watch more anime? :)

Rinrinka - Yesterday

26 by luckyrune »»
17 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login