Francys said: PKDMO said: Why is the score so low? I am unable to watch it yet. Is there something wrong with the movie? It's just a recap. Does that mean it deserves a low score, though? Rating it low implies the original series was flawed in some way... |
     |
| T Francys said: I don't think so. Recaps are just a way of remembering important scenes of the anime in preparation for a sequel (In that case, the movie). They compress almost everything, so they aren't the real experience you would get from watching the anime. I actually crunched the numbers in another thread... In the case of "Made in Abyss"... Assuming each movie has a runtime of 2 hours exactly.. There would only be about 20 minutes of cut footage in total. Or 1 minute 30 seconds from each episode. Especially for someone new to the series, there isn't really much being cut or compressed... Sure, you're not getting the full 10/10 experience, as you say. But you are getting the 9.5/10 experience. Which is almost as good. Also there is the issue of people rating the series before they've even seen it. And I can guarantee that virtually no-one who has rated it has actually seen it. |
|
| And when will it be available ? |
  I'm lost in this crazy world. I'm a soul among so many other. Just a lonely ghost. ★ My profile ★ Cards Collection |
| Because the time they spent making this worthless thing should have been spent on new content. |
quercifolia said: T Francys said: I don't think so. Recaps are just a way of remembering important scenes of the anime in preparation for a sequel (In that case, the movie). They compress almost everything, so they aren't the real experience you would get from watching the anime. I actually crunched the numbers in another thread... In the case of "Made in Abyss"... Assuming each movie has a runtime of 2 hours exactly.. There would only be about 20 minutes of cut footage in total. Or 1 minute 30 seconds from each episode. Especially for someone new to the series, there isn't really much being cut or compressed... Sure, you're not getting the full 10/10 experience, as you say. But you are getting the 9.5/10 experience. Which is almost as good. Also there is the issue of people rating the series before they've even seen it. And I can guarantee that virtually no-one who has rated it has actually seen it. You would then be implying the Original deserves a 10/10, to which I would say many would wholeheartedly disagree with, especially when the episodes adapted in here don't really come close to touching the real meat(y) of the anime series content. And that will definitely feel butchered in the next movie, with the hour special finale and all. Recaps almost never as good or better than the original. |
 |
Danpmss said: quercifolia said: T I actually crunched the numbers in another thread... In the case of "Made in Abyss"... Assuming each movie has a runtime of 2 hours exactly.. There would only be about 20 minutes of cut footage in total. Or 1 minute 30 seconds from each episode. Especially for someone new to the series, there isn't really much being cut or compressed... Sure, you're not getting the full 10/10 experience, as you say. But you are getting the 9.5/10 experience. Which is almost as good. Also there is the issue of people rating the series before they've even seen it. And I can guarantee that virtually no-one who has rated it has actually seen it. You would then be implying the Original deserves a 10/10, to which I would say many would wholeheartedly disagree with, especially when the episodes adapted in here don't really come close to touching the real meat(y) of the anime series content. And that will definitely feel butchered in the next movie, with the hour special finale and all. Recaps almost never as good or better than the original. I'm using a metaphor-- the 10/10 vs 9.5/10 comparison is to show that yes, a recap is not the "complete" experience, but in this case you can barely tell. It's not an implication of whether Made in Abyss is rated a 10/10 or otherwise. Now, the Code Geass recap movies on the other hands... (They feel rushed, at least in comparison to the full series) |
|
quercifolia said: Danpmss said: You would then be implying the Original deserves a 10/10, to which I would say many would wholeheartedly disagree with, especially when the episodes adapted in here don't really come close to touching the real meat(y) of the anime series content. And that will definitely feel butchered in the next movie, with the hour special finale and all. Recaps almost never as good or better than the original. I'm using a metaphor-- the 10/10 vs 9.5/10 comparison is to show that yes, a recap is not the "complete" experience, but in this case you can barely tell. It's not an implication of whether Made in Abyss is rated a 10/10 or otherwise. Now, the Code Geass recap movies on the other hands... (They feel rushed, at least in comparison to the full series) According to the Fathom Events website for the US screening (https://www.fathomevents.com/events/made-in-abyss) The run time for the film is 2 hours and 15 minutes, so there will barely be anything cut at all. This movie should be more or less like binging the first half of the series. |
PKDMO said: I just watched it and it was great. I mean it was just all of the first 8 episodes put together with little to nothing taken out at all. There was some new stuff at the very beginning but other than that it was just like marathoning the first half of the show minus the ops and eds. The best improvement was the sound quality because instead of plan stereo they were able to make it surround sound for theater quality.Why is the score so low? I am unable to watch it yet. Is there something wrong with the movie? |
Twoscoops_Mar 21, 2019 2:45 PM
 |
| Cause it's mediocre and disbelief is huge. |
| Where were you, when everything was falling apart? |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Made in Abyss Movie 1: Tabidachi no Yoake Episode 1 DiscussionTerrestrious - Mar 20, 2019 |
24 |
by removed-user
»»
Dec 7, 2023 11:44 PM |
|
» Help me.....El-Psy__Congroo - Jan 28, 2022 |
7 |
by Xileop
»»
Oct 16, 2022 6:19 PM |
|
» Does this have new tracks?APolygons2 - Sep 9, 2022 |
1 |
by Tomek-Masiewicz
»»
Sep 9, 2022 1:56 AM |
|
» Sub or DubKonan_Edogawa_ - Mar 25, 2019 |
5 |
by WhyDontYouTurn
»»
Jan 11, 2021 10:05 PM |
|
» Discussionmoozooh - Mar 19, 2018 |
34 |
by D3viLord
»»
Dec 30, 2019 2:43 AM |