Alderaminn said: 3) I have 0 idea which titles I should use for (I.06), (I.10), (I.20, (I.27). It'd be perfect for very short titles but I'll appreciate any suggestion~ Also, may I ask for a manga suggestion needed for (I.25)? Any genre would do just please, smth really short, I've already packed myself with a lot of 10+ volumes titles... Thanks a lot! <3 Well, here goes 6. Sengoku Youko for something quality, Carnival Glare for speed. I always struggle with this one myself 10. Onanie Master Kurosawa, Rurouni Kenshin or Seven Days if you don't mind yaoi, which seems to be most of the titles available for this one. 20. Sekine-kun no Koi or Koroshiya 1 and Benkei in New York to get something a little different for this one 25. Kiku and Kijin Gahou seem to be fairly different from what you go for, hope they add a little spice EDIT 27. Wolfsmund I'm cheating here and just putting the rec from faq here 'cause I have no idea for this one We have a rec for every challenge on the first post by the way. Feel free to ask for recs, just mentioning it since it's not too obvious |
Ironclad_CobraFeb 12, 2019 9:20 PM
Alderaminn said: I watched Death Note anime waaaaay back in my fan begginings and recently I've tried to read manga with no much luck. I think Death Note is this kind of story that you can fully enjoy only when you have 0 idea about plot, characters and the intrigue. Otherwise you quickly loose reading/watching flow and focus on plotholes and weak points which this title is really full of. And since it's nowadays a wide-known classic, it's hard to have no spoilers before reading. For me the biggest disappointment was so far Mushishi. Everyone had been recommending it to me since I can remember, it's very highly ranted here and on other sites, it was even published in my country by a publishing house known for translating only remarkable mangas... It is, indeed, a very good title, with perfect story and character writing but... I think it was lacking of emotions. It had no main plot, characters were changing with every chapter, the main one was very distanced and had no charisma, art style wasn't helping at all since author has a habit of giving everyone the same face and facial expressions. Can't say I hated it or that I lost time for reading it but really can't undestand all the praise it gets. I did go into it pretty blind, the only thing I knew was there was a book that killed people and devils (the shinigami). I haven't seen the anime either. I'm doing this challenge as a way to introduce myself to manga really. As I said not something I hated, but just didn't understand the praise. Banana Fish looks interesting, may add that to my challenge. |
  |
| I've just read Teppu for Intermediate - Read a sports manga. I am a HUGE Hajime no Ippo fan and the 2/3rds of Teppu was so good I thought it was better then Ippo, then sadly it lowers in quality (apparently it went on a Hiatus due to authors bad health) and then ends pretty quickly. I really feel this could've been an all time classic if it'd got to continue. Also if anyone has any recommendations for an artist who can draw, or a title including, women with abs this good then I'd like to know.   Edit: Not sure what I'm doing wrong with image posting there? |
|
| All Rounder Meguru focuses on a dude for the most part but there are several supporting girls with the sick abs. Dumbbell Nan Kilo Moteru? is literally just about girls getting swole. (also is ecchi) Saotome Girl, Hitakakusu is about a chump dating a girl boxer. |
AudioTsunami said: All Rounder Meguru focuses on a dude for the most part but there are several supporting girls with the sick abs. Dumbbell Nan Kilo Moteru? is literally just about girls getting swole. (also is ecchi) Saotome Girl, Hitakakusu is about a chump dating a girl boxer. Ace, all 3 look fun. Definitely adding them to my list! Thanks |
Flash87Feb 13, 2019 3:42 AM
|
HeNrYTG50 said: 1. I'd say it counts, haven't read it tho. :P 2. Being in space would count. I'll get back to you with recs after a while. :D Thanks! Since a lot of you support the idea, I think it'll be safe to go with Banana Fish :p Ironclad_Cobra said: Alderaminn said: 3) I have 0 idea which titles I should use for (I.06), (I.10), (I.20, (I.27). It'd be perfect for very short titles but I'll appreciate any suggestion~ Also, may I ask for a manga suggestion needed for (I.25)? Any genre would do just please, smth really short, I've already packed myself with a lot of 10+ volumes titles... Thanks a lot! <3 Well, here goes 6. Sengoku Youko for something quality, Carnival Glare for speed. I always struggle with this one myself 10. Onanie Master Kurosawa, Rurouni Kenshin or Seven Days if you don't mind yaoi, which seems to be most of the titles available for this one. 20. Sekine-kun no Koi or Koroshiya 1 and Benkei in New York to get something a little different for this one 25. Kiku and Kijin Gahou seem to be fairly different from what you go for, hope they add a little spice EDIT 27. Wolfsmund I'm cheating here and just putting the rec from faq here 'cause I have no idea for this one We have a rec for every challenge on the first post by the way. Feel free to ask for recs, just mentioning it since it's not too obvious WOW! This is so helpful, thank you very much! <3 |
  |
| Hello, I'm planning to read 2 manga with more than 20 volumes each in Novice level, can I begin Apprentice level before I finish them ? |
  Signature By Nate |
SukiiFu said: Hello, I'm planning to read 2 manga with more than 20 volumes each in Novice level, can I begin Apprentice level before I finish them ? Don't think so It's stated that it is required that you complete all Novice entries before you start reading Apprentice tier stuff. Also, written in bold "This means you can only read manga for one section at a time.", which I understand as being able to start 20+ anytime, but only being able to use them in the tier you're currently working on. I mean, if it worked your Novice tier's finish date could potentially be later than your Apprentice tier's finish date, which doesn't really make sense. Then again, I'm no mod, so let's wait for their take on this. |
  |
SukiiFu said: Hello, I'm planning to read 2 manga with more than 20 volumes each in Novice level, can I begin Apprentice level before I finish them ? Hi! Unfortunately, you need to finish a tier completely before passing to the next, as Aemnesias said. You can start 20+ volume manga at any time, but it's intended for you to be able to use them for higher tiers, so you finish them once you get there. |
| @Aemnesias @HeNrYTG50 Thank you both for answering, I see :( |
Signature By Nate |
You still can read them now and use them for later, though! Just find a replacement for the two you've wanted to use in the novice-tier. ;) |
Schlopsi said: You still can read them now and use them for later, though! Just find a replacement for the two you've wanted to use in the novice-tier. ;) Yeah I'm gonna do that :), while I'm at it can I have a manga for this item please (I want to plan ahead) (Ad.19) Read a random manga assigned to you by a challenge staff member & from anyone else for this too please (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread |
Signature By Nate |
SukiiFu said: Yeah I'm gonna do that :), while I'm at it can I have a manga for this item please (I want to plan ahead) (Ad.19) Read a random manga assigned to you by a challenge staff member Sure! Here you go: Yoshiwara Hana Oboro |
| ^ Thank you so much :) |
Signature By Nate |
SukiiFu said: (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Since your list isn't all that similar to mine and there aren't any scores I just went with a few vaguely connected to what you've read/watched and one based on your ptr. Out Kokou no Hito YuYuHakusho |
Ironclad_Cobra said: SukiiFu said: (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread Since your list isn't all that similar to mine and there aren't any scores I just went with a few vaguely connected to what you've read/watched and one based on your ptr. Out Kokou no Hito YuYuHakusho lol even though we both read a lot, there isn't much shared manga between us, but it's fine, it's good to read something I didn't have my eyes on, mhmmm I'm more into Out, but it's ongoing, so maybe The Climber .... I will see till then, thank you for the recommendation :) |
Signature By Nate |
| "Read a collection of short stories. - They can be a compilation by the same author or by different authors" Anyone recommends a manga for this requisite? |
Partizanki said: "Read a collection of short stories. - They can be a compilation by the same author or by different authors" Anyone recommends a manga for this requisite? Goggles nickelodeon love letter Kikimimi Zukan |
AudioTsunami said: Partizanki said: "Read a collection of short stories. - They can be a compilation by the same author or by different authors" Anyone recommends a manga for this requisite? Goggles nickelodeon love letter Kikimimi Zukan Thank you very much! :) |
| When posting for turn in do the challenge list numbers need to be sequential? As I have it now, they are all 1- the amount needed for the level. Novice being numbered 1-10 and Apprentice numbered 1-15 and so on. Is that alright? Or, should it be changed so that the numbers go from 1-65 (including Expert)?? |
 LINKS ☆:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::☆ Members Cards Clubs Challenges Favorites ☆:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::☆ Forum by Evil Club - snowman 2023 |
RachelPanda said: When posting for turn in do the challenge list numbers need to be sequential? As I have it now, they are all 1- the amount needed for the level. Novice being numbered 1-10 and Apprentice numbered 1-15 and so on. Is that alright? Or, should it be changed so that the numbers go from 1-65 (including Expert)?? Whichever way is fine. :) |
| So I've got a question about a challenge entry. Read a completed manga scored highest by the user that posted directly above/below you. What happens if the person above/below you withdraws from the challenge? Does the manga they scored still count? |
   |
BrainpanSonata said: So I've got a question about a challenge entry. Read a completed manga scored highest by the user that posted directly above/below you. What happens if the person above/below you withdraws from the challenge? Does the manga they scored still count? Sure. :) We should still be able to check their score for the manga. |
| Quick Question: for apprentice level task 27:. Read a GAR manga... Does this count? https://myanimelist.net/manga/14121/Oyaji |
|
Flash87 said: Quick Question: for apprentice level task 27:. Read a GAR manga... Does this count? https://myanimelist.net/manga/14121/Oyaji Yeah, let's count it. :P |
LemonBaskets said: Question. I'm looking for a 4-koma/web manga for the Apprentice level task 1. I was wondering if this one counts? https://myanimelist.net/manga/75749/ If not, is there any other manga for this task? I'm looking for completed ones, not publishing. Yes, it does count. You could also use one of these: https://myanimelist.net/manga/14504/Yandere_Kanojo https://myanimelist.net/manga/58027/Tsurezure_Children https://myanimelist.net/manga/11294/Mangaka-san_to_Assistant-san_to Or use this list (pretty much all of them should be completed): more 4-Koma titles |
SchlopsiFeb 21, 2019 7:23 AM
| Densha Otoko Natsu no Zenjitsu Oyaji @Frostbytes |
| Hi again (Ap.13) Read a manga based on a one-shot that got serialized. Is Hungry Joker valid for this? this is the one-shot which I see it was published before the series > Hungry Joker |
Signature By Nate |
SukiiFu said: Hi again (Ap.13) Read a manga based on a one-shot that got serialized. Is Hungry Joker valid for this? this is the one-shot which I see it was published before the series > Hungry Joker Yupp, it is valid. |
Frostbytes said: This version right? https://myanimelist.net/manga/1158/Densha_Otoko__Net_Hatsu_Kakueki_Teisha_no_Love_Story anyway thanks, will probably read that or Oyaji Yeah that's the one. |
Frostbytes said: This version right? https://myanimelist.net/manga/1158/Densha_Otoko__Net_Hatsu_Kakueki_Teisha_no_Love_Story anyway thanks, will probably read that or Oyaji Oyaji is great and a super quick read, Also valid as GAR manga so could read both. |
|
| For the MRC staff related ones (eg. Read one of their favourites...). That's the 4 friends of the mod that runs this thread right? |
|
Flash87 said: For the MRC staff related ones (eg. Read one of their favourites...). That's the 4 friends of the mod that runs this thread right? Any users listed under "MRC STAFF MEMBERS" in the description here : https://myanimelist.net/profile/MRC_mod |
|
| (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. As long as it's finished and not yaoi i'm fine. |
Armandoriel said: (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. As long as it's finished and not yaoi i'm fine. I recommend you some titles, choose the one you want so you can read: Teppuu (~36chaps), Ushio and Tora (~300chaps), Shooting girl (a single chapter), Jojo no kimyou na bouken (any part but if you begin, go on the 1st part, is 44 chaps) and another one, Rainbow (235 chaps). If you need others, tell me. |
Kanji-chama said: Armandoriel said: (I.25) Read a manga recommended to you by another participant in the discussion thread. As long as it's finished and not yaoi i'm fine. I recommend you some titles, choose the one you want so you can read: Teppuu (~36chaps), Ushio and Tora (~300chaps), Shooting girl (a single chapter), Jojo no kimyou na bouken (any part but if you begin, go on the 1st part, is 44 chaps) and another one, Rainbow (235 chaps). If you need others, tell me. Thanks, Teppu it is. |
Armandoriel said: Kanji-chama said: I recommend you some titles, choose the one you want so you can read: Teppuu (~36chaps), Ushio and Tora (~300chaps), Shooting girl (a single chapter), Jojo no kimyou na bouken (any part but if you begin, go on the 1st part, is 44 chaps) and another one, Rainbow (235 chaps). If you need others, tell me. Thanks, Teppu it is. Good call, just read it also for another challenge. Loved it. |
|
Aemnesias said: Flash87 said: For the MRC staff related ones (eg. Read one of their favourites...). That's the 4 friends of the mod that runs this thread right? Any users listed under "MRC STAFF MEMBERS" in the description here : https://myanimelist.net/profile/MRC_mod Thanks, sorry was using mobile and often things don't show up. |
|
Frostbytes said: Can anyone confirm whether this manga https://myanimelist.net/manga/28075/Zerozaki_Soushiki_no_Ningen_Shiken?q=Zerozaki qualifies for "Read a manga that with cover art that is primarily one color"? Thanks in advance. Yeah, you can use it. |
kiv7 said: Hi @MRC_mod ( Read a random manga assigned to you by a challenge staff member) 3_12 ch plz 🙏 You get Okujou-hime. Hope it turns out okay |
More topics from this board
» 2024 Manga Reading Challenge - Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )MRC_mod - Jan 20 |
156 |
by Saobenoit
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Sticky: » 2024 Manga Reading Challenge - Sign Up ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MRC_mod - Jan 18 |
385 |
by PurpleViola
»»
Today, 5:12 AM |
|
» Most obscure titles in your list.Otakupervert890 - Feb 24 |
29 |
by Synrax
»»
Yesterday, 1:49 PM |
|
» Western Studio Adaptation of Berserk (Thoughts?)FlydayEthan - Yesterday |
0 |
by FlydayEthan
»»
Yesterday, 11:08 AM |
|
» Thoughts on long manga?Chuckiemuffin - Feb 29 |
28 |
by Azuchi
»»
Yesterday, 7:33 AM |